So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
You were the guy who linked to The Culture of Fear, right? Because we all need to get over all of our irrational fears. You know, like elevators...

  • I never claimed that RW acted irrationally.
  • I never claimed that RW was not entitled to her feelings.
  • I do claim that to come onto a forum and cite rape statistics and propagate fear about elevators IS irrational and irresponsible.
Let's get something crystal clear. I don't begrudge RW her feelings and I don't begrudge her the right to express her opinion about those feelings. I've stated over and over that I think she has that right and I don't malign or belittle her for that. I resent you for suggesting I do.

That said, there is nothing wrong with encouraging others to find the facts about related risks so we as a people don't live in fear and I will not apologize for that.

And if you're asking me to go back over 97 pages for exact quotes, no. Jumping through hoops is icky.
Then I will accept that as concession that I never maligned RW for her feelings nor did I malign her for expressing her feelings. I will say that I took issues with the "creepy" aspect but I've never made categorical statements about that.
 
Yes, you do go on.

And, if I were so included, I could bullet point your diatribe but I ask you, with absolutely zero sarcasm, why should I?

It will be a departure from your current position -- 97 pages that, according to you, center on arguments that, as best I can tell, hardly fill 5 of them.

Your level of accuracy would be equaled were I to describe the thread as "97 pages of privileged white feminists ridiculing an awkward guy in an elevator".
 
Please forgive me because I know this wasn't directed at me and I know I run the risk of creating a straw man and for that I apologize in advance. But I think we often talk past each other and some important points are missed. Again, I do not claim that you agree or disagree with the following but I would like your opinion.

  • Was she justified in her initial reaction? (from her perspective and others) Yes.
  • Was it justified on behalf of everyone? No.
  • Was she justified in making a polite recommendation? Yes.
  • Was saying "guys don't do that" helpful? No. "Guys, please consider your actions as some of us might find that objectionable" would have been.
  • Did her comments about objectification, white privilege and her assertions that it was creepy, conducive to a discussion about appropriate conduct? No.
  • Has she acknowledge that there are valid criticisms and complaints (assuming there are valid criticisms)?
A post that does represent my position. July 30th.
 
Bookitty, it would do you good personally to find the quotes you think said what you think they said. Maybe if you re-read them a second time, you might see that you misread them the first time. If the claim you made is true: "You guys have served up over 90 freaking pages about how elevators are safe and therefore Watson had no reason to feel discomforted by EG. With a heaping side of "It doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother Watson," then it should be relatively easy to find a couple examples.

Here's what I predict you will really find:
  • We have said repeatedly it was RW's actions AFTER the initial video blog that bother those of us not in camp RW
  • RW had a right to her own personal feelings about the EG encounter
  • Not everyone would have had the same reaction
  • Advising, "guys, don't to do that", is OK if one applies it to oneself
  • But once you make the claim that, "guys, don't do that", is universal advice, your advice is a fail
  • Risk assessment is frequently irrational and a critical thinker should look at the evidence of real risk compared to perceived risk
  • Using the perceived risk to justify RW's reaction to the EG incident is OK if one notes the reaction is based on perception, not on evidence
  • Once you start trying to support RW's response based on evidence of real risk, the argument is a fail
 
Last edited:
A post that does represent my position. July 30th.
Was saying "guys don't do that" helpful? No. "Guys, please consider your actions as some of us might find that objectionable" would have been.

More than you know. In the above, you tell us how she should have phrased a throwaway line in a very short story set in a much longer video. If she had made her feelings known in that fashion, then it might not have been as objectionable. This sets up an impossible situation in which Watson is somehow supposed to magically know that this video, out of her hundreds of videos, blog posts, podcasts would be the one that would be most analyzed. You are judging her by the specific words instead of the intent which leaves everyone free to ignore the intent.
 
More than you know. In the above, you tell us how she should have phrased a throwaway line in a very short story set in a much longer video. If she had made her feelings known in that fashion, then it might not have been as objectionable. This sets up an impossible situation in which Watson is somehow supposed to magically know that this video, out of her hundreds of videos, blog posts, podcasts would be the one that would be most analyzed. You are judging her by the specific words instead of the intent which leaves everyone free to ignore the intent.
As it relates to that single phrase, I'm voicing an opinion about a very small matter. I stand by that, I don't think it's helpful.

That said, I've noted in this thread on more than one occasion that I was a long time fan of RW. I listened to her nearly every week for years. I don't know when I first tarted listening to Skeptics Guide but I know it's years. I started long before Perry passed away. And I followed Skepchick for about a year and I've seen each and every video I could get my hands on when she has been on a panel for TAM or any other event. I judge her by the body of her work. Had "guys don't do that" been the totality of this little event I wouldn't have bothered to respond. No, it was the subsequent "white male privilege" nonsense, the ad hominem and the poor form she demonstrated subsequently. Her arrogance and refusal to acknowledge that it was even possible that there could be reasoned dissent.

I don't hate RW and I honestly understand that the hateful invective she received is largely the impetus for her actions and I'm willing to cut her a bit of slack but I'd be a liar if I said I wasn't deeply disappointed.

Please, take a deep breath and stop making unfounded accusations. Please?
 
Last edited:
It is interesting to find a discussion of this matter that isn't full of profanity and insults.

Personally I found Watson's initial comment fine, if imperfect, but imperfection is to be expected in any sort of human activity (generally speaking, anyhow). It's snowballed into something that's gotten ugly on both sides.

I have to wonder if part of this is from the idea that it is ok to be extremely vitriolic when criticizing people. Some New Atheists and Freethinkers seem to think this is alright. I have to say it just makes them (and the rest of us) look bad. It also encourages ad hominem thinking, when you think of someone as an insult first and person second. It also puts other people much more on the defensive than a calm discussion using evidence and reason. Lastly it also encourages groupthink, which is something we should try hard to avoid.

We should remember that reasonable people can disagree on things.
 
More than you know. In the above, you tell us how she should have phrased a throwaway line in a very short story set in a much longer video. If she had made her feelings known in that fashion, then it might not have been as objectionable. This sets up an impossible situation in which Watson is somehow supposed to magically know that this video, out of her hundreds of videos, blog posts, podcasts would be the one that would be most analyzed. You are judging her by the specific words instead of the intent which leaves everyone free to ignore the intent.

OK, time to remember once again what happened here. RW made a comment on a video blog with words implying 'all' guys don't do that with 'any' girl. Maybe had she thought more about it she'd have worded it differently, maybe not. Who cares? I don't.

However, a couple people responded, one also in her own video blog, and said, gee, I don't think RW was correct to speak for all of the females of our species.

And that is when RW had a tizzy fit claiming in a keynote address at a conference that one of the bloggers was at, pointed to the blogger's words on RW's PowerPoint slide, used the blogger's name and then claimed that the blogger's comments contributed to misogyny and gave moral support to horrible misogynist men.

Then RW defenders and RW herself, asserted that the elevator, a foreign country and the hour meant RW was at special risk of assault. Those comments were also addressed during this kerfuffle as unsupportable by the evidence. Perceiving a special risk is defensible, but defending that perception on the basis of a 'real' special risk was not. No special risk occurred in a 5 star hotel elevator in Dublin at 4 am.

My personal interest is in conveying the relative safety of women traveling alone in most foreign countries. It's my opinion that RW in this case did a disservice to feminism, not a favor, by expecting special treatment from men, and by conveying perceived fear that was not based on evidence of real risk.
 
Last edited:
It is interesting to find a discussion of this matter that isn't full of profanity and insults.

If they were allowed here, I'm sure they'd be here.

I have to wonder if part of this is from the idea that it is ok to be extremely vitriolic when criticizing people. Some New Atheists and Freethinkers seem to think this is alright. I have to say it just makes them (and the rest of us) look bad. It also encourages ad hominem thinking, when you think of someone as an insult first and person second. It also puts other people much more on the defensive than a calm discussion using evidence and reason. Lastly it also encourages groupthink, which is something we should try hard to avoid.

This is approximately the conclusion that Gurdur reached in his excellent blog about the affair.

So now for the conclusion: exactly what's going on here all over? Is it all just misogynism as alleged by Watson and some? Is it general stupidity? No; something else. There's perhaps a clue in an important post @JoshRosenau made. Josh pointed out that the flame-war consuming the atheist net had been largely fueled by the promoted tactics of certain people before this incident. Jerry Coyne now complains of the flame-war on his blog and on the net on this subject; but flaming and name-calling were perfectly OK with Coyne before. Same with PZ Myers, who once boasted how proud he was of his rudeness. The point is that certain people have been encouraging an atmosphere of habitual scorn, never treating people as people, being as abusive as possible. Richard Dawkins is himself very guilty of this, as shown in the RDF forum board affair. And now it's come back to bite them in the arse on a subject where they can't easily blame the Usual Suspects, and they can't simply flame.

More at http://heathen-hub.com/blog.php?bt=5857
 
You are judging her by the specific words instead of the intent which leaves everyone free to ignore the intent.

Hmm.... Intent.

Well, Watson's intent with the original video seems to have been little more than to tell anecdotes about what she had been doing lately.

Watson's intent with her subsequent behavior seems to be as follows:

1) To scare as many women as possible away from skeptic conferences for fear they might find themselves on an elevator with a guy they find creepy.

2) To scare as many women as possible away from skeptic conferences for fear they might get trashed by Watson onstage.
 
If they were allowed here, I'm sure they'd be here.

No doubt, but it is nice to see a place where decent civility is enforced. I tried talking about it just a little bit on Myer's blog when the recent USA Today article was discussed. Since I didn't agree with them 100% I got shouted down and called a bunch of names by almost everyone. When I made a last post there saying I didn't see the point in continuing the discussion if they were going toss vulgarities at me left and right, they acted like I must not of been serious otherwise I would have put up with it.

Weird.

This is approximately the conclusion that Gurdur reached in his excellent blog about the affair.

More at http://heathen-hub.com/blog.php?bt=5857

That was indeed an excellent post. It pretty much matches my thoughts as you said. I largely agree on his views on the individual events as well.

I like Richard Dawkins more than Gurdur does though, but on the other hand I haven't been following Dawkins closely the last few years. I do agree Dawkins didn't handle the situation very well.
 
No doubt, but it is nice to see a place where decent civility is enforced. I tried talking about it just a little bit on Myer's blog when the recent USA Today article was discussed.

Frankly, they're partisan, so that kind of behavior is reasonably expected.

In fairly neutral corners, such as here and rationalskepticism.org, there's less bias, though it still gets argumentative from time to time. The arguments work, though, and people's opinions change. Mine did. I don't think anything short of brain surgery would change the minds of the PZ Meyers crowd.

That was indeed an excellent post. It pretty much matches my thoughts as you said. I largely agree on his views on the individual events as well.

I like Richard Dawkins more than Gurdur does though, but on the other hand I haven't been following Dawkins closely the last few years. I do agree Dawkins didn't handle the situation very well.

I think that one has to have been involved for a couple of decades to have seen how the skeptical and atheist "communities" have changed for the worse and how Dawkins has been part of that. The honey-to-vinegar ratio was once a lot higher.
 
Frankly, they're partisan, so that kind of behavior is reasonably expected.

In fairly neutral corners, such as here and rationalskepticism.org, there's less bias, though it still gets argumentative from time to time. The arguments work, though, and people's opinions change. Mine did. I don't think anything short of brain surgery would change the minds of the PZ Meyers crowd.

Yes, I did not realize that at the time.

Nothing bad about some heated debate, as long as it doesn't get out of hand.

I think that one has to have been involved for a couple of decades to have seen how the skeptical and atheist "communities" have changed for the worse and how Dawkins has been part of that. The honey-to-vinegar ratio was once a lot higher.

I guess I've only been involved since High School (helped run an atheist chat room on Talk City...that was about 14 or so years ago. Gah, too long. Things were pretty clean there, though I made a big deal about dealing with anyone in a civil manner, including being open to debate and discussion. And on Fridays we had Talk Like a Pirate Night. The room ended up getting shut down though (long story).

I kind of got my fill of such discussions back then, since you see a couple years of religious arguments and then you've pretty much seen them all. So I didn't pay a lot of attention to things until Dawkin's book came out (which I liked). In agree in principle with the idea that there's nothing wrong about being vocal about rationality (and hence atheism). You can do that and still be civil though.
 
"the admin and moderators knew about for a year or two before they suspended me for it"

Now as for the subject, I think Rebecca made way to much about it.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom