So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Generally it’s best if you avoid certain situations where women have to flat out tell you no or lie, you get rejected way more often that way. This also helps me to eliminate time wasters like, "oh sorry no thanks I have to go to "x" with my boyfriend who truly doesn't exist." :D


It reduces the "creep" factor when you are more confident and direct with her. Now, I will also note that something’s do require privacy and isolation. But that only happens after you two have a decent rapport based conversation (things like your name, who you are, why you’re talking to her, etc.)


Could you honestly tell me you'd follow a woman you don't know into a parking lot at night? Would you follow her to her room? Would you wait last minute until she was alone to pull a stunt? These are all no no’s. They all scream thirsty, and they all scream coward. It makes women think, "What’s this guy really up to? What does he really want? He said that he wanted to be my friend and now he's doing "x", strange..." In short women like consistency. Guys women aren't stupid, it’s best to be upfront (in a decent manner) about what you want. All this nonsense would've been avoided had he had the courage to have a conversation and flirt with her while in public. She would’ve shut him down but he would’ve moved on and had a good time with his friends.



Hope this helps.

Cheers

/threadderail

So you do it to greater your chances of success. Nothing you need to defend, it makes perfect sense. I just didn't understand why you would make it a point not to proposition a woman in an elevator but when a woman flat out states that she didn't like the approach in an elevator, she was over reacting.

In response to your last paragraph, I probably won't be following women anywhere because I am a heterosexual woman.
 
So this thread was/is about her behavior that night. It's fls who want's to change the topic to her response to the people demeaning her behavior that night.

Well, I have been participating in this thread since the beginning, so perhaps I can be excused for thinking I know what has been discussed on the thread. :)

Of course, you are not alone. We seem to regularly get passerbys who come in to tell us that they don't see why anyone is making such a fuss over her actions that night, or over her video blog on the matter. And we patiently explain that none of the complaints or discussion here centred around those actions, which we all seem to agree weren't particularly remarkable. It does get a tad tedious to have to do this over and over again.

Linda
 
So, I think we are on track that this incident alone was not the reason for all the hoopla. And yes, I most certainly believe that RW has every right to her feelings and perceptions and certainly the right to ask others to respect her boundaries.

I know you've said it before. I just didn't want you to think I was asking you personally, what the big deal was.

The problem arises, IMO, with the presumptions as to EG's intent and whether or not he sexualized her. That was the beginning of the problems. Many people felt that what EG did was not per se bad or per se creepy. However, I think that without any escalation there would at most have been some discussion and some unwanted attention.

The only reason why I could see why she might have jumped to that conclusion is the term "back to my hotel room." I am not wagging my finger in his face, saying he should have suggested something else because this is a foreign country, it's likely the same meanings don't carry across the borders. I've said it before but it seems the words that stuck out in her mind was back to my room which, in a bar hook up, "back to your place," "back to my place," "someplace a little more private where we can talk," is typically an invite for sex. I've agreed that it requires some assuming, on her part, to conclude that he was after sex but I just don't think that it's that far of a leap.

Instead RW had to fire back with "patriarchy" and "white male privilege" rhetoric and claiming that some women didn't get it because of their privilege. Those were incendiary comments. Now, look, I understand that RW was receiving some pretty disgusting comments and I think Dawkins and others who should have known better erred in their responses. But that doesn't excuse many of the comments made by RW about McGrath and others who had legitimate points. "You don't get it" and "you are a white male" or "you are arguing from privilege" are not going to help.

That's why I agree that it snowballed. Despite the fact that I don't think McGraw made any valid points, I don't think RW was fair in accusing her of "parroting..." that was uncalled for. I do, however think she had a point with her "privileged" accusation. It is easy for RD to be dismissive because he will probably never have that type of experience. I doubt he has to worry much, about being overpowered and sexually assaulted. A strange proposition to him is nothing more than an annoyance, where as a strange proposition for some women, especially when they are in a position that they can't immediately walk away from, might end up spending that time wondering if things will end after she just says, "No." It may only be 4 floors but it's 4 floors of heightened alertness. It may not happen to all women but I would imagine it's not uncommon for women who are told that they deserve to get raped.
 
Well, I have been participating in this thread since the beginning, so perhaps I can be excused for thinking I know what has been discussed on the thread. :)

Of course, you are not alone. We seem to regularly get passerbys who come in to tell us that they don't see why anyone is making such a fuss over her actions that night, or over her video blog on the matter. And we patiently explain that none of the complaints or discussion here centred around those actions, which we all seem to agree weren't particularly remarkable. It does get a tad tedious to have to do this over and over again.

Linda

Bold mine. That's strange because I remember you yourself wondering about her actions, using straw men, and how it might affect your sons ability to get dates. There is plenty of discussion about her behavior and reaction (it was creepy; made me feel uncomfortable) and many complaints and discussion about why it should not have made her feel creepy or uncomfortable. I hope I don't have to dig them all up for you.

I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?) STRAW MAN

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?) STRAW MAN

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar? STRAW MAN

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date. STRAW MAN

Linda

But I agree, it does get a tad tedious to have to do this over and over again. :)
 
Last edited:
That's why I agree that it snowballed. Despite the fact that I don't think McGraw made any valid points...
Well, we can certainly disagree.

I do, however think she had a point with her "privileged" accusation. It is easy for RD to be dismissive because he will probably never have that type of experience. I doubt he has to worry much, about being overpowered and sexually assaulted.
Why all the detail? Do you really imagine it's compelling? Or are you appealing to emotion? I think this is a problem with the "privilege" ad hominem. Dawkins doesn't need to experience fear to logically evaluate an argument

The male privilege stuff is nonsense. That's simply attacking Dawkins and not his argument. Hardly good form for a skeptic and critical thinker. Turn it around, would RW be happy to be told, you wouldn't understand, you're a woman? The best attack against Dawkins was his use of false consolation. Dawkins deserves criticism for a poorly formulated argument but attacking him for being a white male is as cringe worthy as Dawkins' false consultation.
 
Last edited:
What I think is funny now, and forgive me if someone has already mentioned this, RW's concerned was never ( never voiced about anyway ) about the risk of being assaulted, it was about being hit on, in an elevator ...

case#46cw39, if you feel there is a need in these forums for ' Risk Awareness ' , perhaps you should start a new thread about " ...the need for females to be skeptical and careful when being alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a strangers ... "

May I say they should start by not finding themselves alone and isolated late at night...
 
What I think is funny now, and forgive me if someone has already mentioned this, RW's concerned was never ( never voiced about anyway ) about the risk of being assaulted, it was about being hit on, in an elevator ...

case#46cw39, if you feel there is a need in these forums for ' Risk Awareness ' , perhaps you should start a new thread about " ...the need for females to be skeptical and careful when being alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a strangers ... "

May I say they should start by not finding themselves alone and isolated late at night...

Hi, yeah I agree with you on the 'don't find yourself alone and isolated late at night' point.

I think she was experiencing discomfort about the possibility of getting assaulted if she would say yes to the room invite, and that was the issue (one of the issues anyway) in this account. My reason for saying this is because she was getting emails saying she deserved to get raped and so of course she was at a heightened awareness about the risk of being assaulted if she went to his room. I think that's why she reacted to the incident the way she did, and she said as much in a comment. I think she could have done a better job of explaining her behavior and the guy in the elevator, and how she felt about the reactions she was getting.

On those issues I agree: she could of done all that better. I guess she's not a genius or Mensa candidate lol.
 
Last edited:
Why all the detail? Do you really imagine it's compelling? Or are you appealing to emotion? I think this is a problem with the "privilege" ad hominem. Dawkins doesn't need to experience fear to logically evaluate an argument

I didn't mean to appeal, I just see a difference between someone's oblivious existence being annoying and someone directing attention at you, which makes you uncomfortable. Saying that he does not understand because he does not have experience is not the same as attacking RD, it's still attacking his position not his person. No, one doesn't always have to experience a particular situation to sympathize, but sometimes, when a complaint seems small and insignificant to an individual until they actually do experience it. Then they say, "Oh, now I get it, this sucks."

The male privilege stuff is nonsense. That's simply attacking Dawkins and not his argument. Hardly good form for a skeptic and critical thinker. Turn it around, would RW be happy to be told, you wouldn't understand, you're a woman? The best attack against Dawkins was his use of false consolation. Dawkins deserves criticism for a poorly formulated argument but attacking him for being a white male is as cringe worthy as Dawkins' false consultation.

There are things I can't possibly understand because I am a woman. There's no shame in admitting that. If I were to say that the laws regarding domestic violence were perfectly fair to both genders, you would tell me I make that claim because I have no idea what it's like to be a man being abused by his wife. In that sense I am looking from a privileged position.
 
Hi, yeah I agree with you on the 'don't find yourself alone and isolated late at night' point.

I think she was experiencing discomfort about the possibility of getting assaulted if she would say yes to the room invite, and that was the issue (one of the issues anyway) in this account

You may think that if you like, but there is no evidence for it. Watson, amongst all her fatuities, has never asserted for this. She's never suggested even that she didn't think that she could avoid everything by saying "no" (which is, of course, what happened: she said "no," and that was the end of it.

This is actually to her credit. Of course, it's possible that she knew that her sycophants would do that for her and so she didn't have to, calculating that she wouldn't get nailed as a whiner, I prefer to give her the benefit of the doubt and not consider her that cynical.
 
You may think that if you like, but there is no evidence for it. Watson, amongst all her fatuities, has never asserted for this. She's never suggested even that she didn't think that she could avoid everything by saying "no" (which is, of course, what happened: she said "no," and that was the end of it.

This is actually to her credit. Of course, it's possible that she knew that her sycophants would do that for her and so she didn't have to, calculating that she wouldn't get nailed as a whiner, I prefer to give her the benefit of the doubt and not consider her that cynical.

Wrong. It's just as I said, she stated this point in a comment.

"But regardless, the point I was making was that people need to be aware of how their comments might make someone feel extraordinarily uncomfortable and even feel as though they are in danger."

Rebecca Watson
06.20.2011
http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-mythbusters-robot-eyes-feminism-and-jokes/
 
Bold mine. That's strange because I remember you yourself wondering about her actions, using straw men, and how it might affect your sons ability to get dates. There is plenty of discussion about her behavior and reaction (it was creepy; made me feel uncomfortable) and many complaints and discussion about why it should not have made her feel creepy or uncomfortable. I hope I don't have to dig them all up for you.

I'm sorry that you managed to misunderstand my first post in this thread so badly (maybe it will cheer you up to know that you are the first to have done so :)). How you could possibly think I was referring to her actions on that night when I mention P Z Myers' or Watsons' statements made days or weeks later, is beyond my ken.

I agree that there has been plenty of discussion on whether her personal feelings could be generalized to reflect the feelings of most or all women.

Linda
 
I'm sorry that you managed to misunderstand my first post in this thread so badly (maybe it will cheer you up to know that you are the first to have done so :)).

Linda

Your sarcasm is boring. Your post topic is quite clear. :)
 
Your sarcasm is boring. Your post topic is quite clear. :)

Okay. So now, not only am I unfamiliar with what has been discussed in a thread I have been actively participating in, I also do not know what I intended to say in my own posts in this thread.

Linda
 
The fact that the two went separate ways and the altercation caused no harm leads me to believe that she was being ridiculous. She was trumpeting about how he sexualized her, and based on the small context clues she gave in her vlog, I am skeptical if the man came off as anything more than a coward.

People will probably be confused that I am defending Watson, but so be it.

The original vlog statement, in its original context, was hardly trumpeting. It was a little "fly in the ointment" story in the context of saying that otherwise, everyone was great. This was in a bigger context of a casual discussion of what she had been doing, for anybody who cared. She made some bad word choices, which have been picked apart endlessly, but it's common to make bad word choices in such a conversational medium.

Later, she started trumpeting and presenting the incident as evidence of insidious sexism, which of course directly contradicted her original presentation.

Any time a man starts out with "don't take this the wrong way," it means he knows you'll take it the wrong way.

Yeah, but what of it? People have projected so much into this it's comical. Some people (well, to be honest, some women) have argued that, well, because he said that, he must have wanted sex with her, and he thought that by making her fearful would increase the probability of sex. (This seems silly, and what I get out of it is that some women really don't understand how men work.)

I'll point out once again that men at conferences say exactly the same thing to other men, and there's usually something like "don't take this the wrong way." Sometimes they say "I'm not gay or anything, but..." which seems to me problematic, because what if they are gay, and it doesn't matter. What this leads to is discussion in the wee hours and maybe business and employment and academic contacts.

Based on his actions of waiting until she was getting ready to go into the elevator to go to her room, I'd say the man was shy and lacked confidence. Based on these two principle ideas alone I'm pretty sure the guy is a half-baked coward who was standing in the corner making these statements from the opposite end of the elevator making almost no eye contact, with the soft squeaky voice of a pre-pubescent boy.

This argument has been tried and didn't manage to convince a lot of people.

Frankly, the later revelation that EG was in his mid-50s makes me think that he really did just want to talk. Young men can get confused or be shy or awkward or whatever, but by the time of the half century mark, most men either:

1) Have really figured out how to interact with women, in which case they don't do such clumsy approaches in the first place and also know that they can do a lot better than Rebecca Watson, or

2) Really haven't figured out how to interact with women, in which case they'd probably be too scared to follow Watson into the elevator in the first place.

Plus, if a man did have non-sexual attentions, then he wouldn't think of such a behavior as creepy.
 
Well if you insist ... I was not the first or only one to take your post as it was written. So now you are just making things up to insult me. But don't worry, I don't care. :)

Here are some posts that quoted this post of yours directly:

If your son sees a speaker at a conference his club goes to. And a good chunk of that speaker's talk is "Don't hit on me at a conference, I'm here as a professional, and I don't like it". Then your son follows her into an elevator at 4 in the morning and asks her to his room, right then in the middle of the night, he has just made it clear that he desires sex with this woman and he is either incapable or unwilling to understand her very clearly stated boundaries.

That's likely to make her pretty uncomfortable.

Just a pro-tip.


You're right. You don't grasp it.



Ready, aim, kill it with fire, people! :D

The time and circumstances do matter though; drunk is not the best time to hit on a person, nor drunk-and-alone-in-elevator...



Then this is your response to the response above to your post, by Monketey Ghost:
I totally get the part where she felt uncomfortable.

It didn't seem to form the basis for her complaint, though. Maybe I'm wrong. I just got the impression that it was something about hitting on her which was objectionable. The time and place just made it a bit creepy. Otherwise, why bring all the stuff about sexual attraction vs. objectification? Linda

Yes you are wrong. Her comment I posted below shows danger was on her mind. Maybe she didn't explain her feelings perfectly with perfect words in the video. It was not just about hitting on her STRAW MAN as the comment post of hers below shows and the video where she says"in that manner." Yes it was creepy and she says why in clearer terms in the comment post of hers I posted below, and in the video where she says "in that manner".

She did give a talk about sexism and misogamy BEFORE the elevator incident happened, so it was NOT in relation to the elevator incident. In her elevator video she does say she "doesn't like being sexualized in that manner." This might be an obscuring, poor word choice. But what was the manner she is referring to? The time and place conditions you yourself acknowledge are a bit creepy. You see now? She was not saying I don't like being sexualized in any manner as you seem to assume. STRAW MAN. She was not, in relation to the elevator incident, talking about "sexual objectification in general" as you say. STRAW MAN. She said IN THAT MANNER: alone, 4am, isolated in an elevator.

Watch the video again where she mentions the elevator incident, and read her comment on it in the comment section:

"But regardless, the point I was making was that people need to be aware of how their comments might make someone feel extraordinarily uncomfortable and even feel as though they are in danger."


Rebecca Watson
06.20.2011
http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-m...ism-and-jokes/ Video and comment here.


I hope you understand this Watson incident better. I will send you a bill. :)
 
Last edited:
Sometimes they say "I'm not gay or anything, but..." which seems to me problematic, because what if they are gay, and it doesn't matter.

A couple of days ago at work, this woman walked by and my eyes followed her almost the entire time she was in view. A male co-worker did the same. He walked over to me right after and I just blurted out, "Did you see those shoes? Those were really neat!"

He stares at me for a second and dryly retorts, "Yeah, I was looking at the shoes."

It then hit me that the woman herself was probably pretty great looking as well. As he was walking away I yelled after him, "Hey! Don't make me feel gay!"

Ever say something, and instantly wish you hadn't said that?
 
I didn't mean to appeal, I just see a difference between someone's oblivious existence being annoying and someone directing attention at you, which makes you uncomfortable. Saying that he does not understand because he does not have experience is not the same as attacking RD, it's still attacking his position not his person. No, one doesn't always have to experience a particular situation to sympathize, but sometimes, when a complaint seems small and insignificant to an individual until they actually do experience it. Then they say, "Oh, now I get it, this sucks."
In the end it doesn't wash. I could simply dismiss the opinions of women because, well, they are women. Only theists could analyse the arguments and claims of theists and non Mormon's would have to keep silent about issues related to Mormonism. Either an argument is logically valid or it is not. Otherwise you are special pleading.

There are things I can't possibly understand because I am a woman.
Do you have the capacity to evaluate the validity of an argument or does your gender prevent that?
 
Yes you are wrong. Her comment I posted below shows danger was on her mind. Maybe she didn't explain her feelings perfectly with perfect words in the video. It was not just about hitting on her STRAW MAN as the comment post of hers below shows and the video where she says"in that manner." Yes it was creepy and she says why in clearer terms in the comment post of hers I posted below, and in the video where she says "in that manner".

A lot of people have decided that what she said later clarified what she really had meant earlier. Even people I've agreed with have done it.

This might work, but only given the assumption that Watson has a great deal of integrity and honesty as well as a great memory.

I don't do this for a couple of reasons. One of these is an opinion, albeit I think as reasonable as any and better than many. The other is a plain fact.

Opinion: I do not think that Watson has shown much integrity and honesty. I think the idea that her tale grew in the telling, probably because she wanted attention (which she has admitted to), is at least as probable as the idea that what she said later was really what she meant earlier.

Fact: The concern for almost everybody, started with Watson's calling out of McGraw, which was after McGraw made her blog entry. At the time McGraw made her blog entry, none of the subsequent statements had been made yet. Therefore, what Watson originally said is essential to understanding what happened. If Watson had said something different, then perhaps McGraw would have reacted differently. Perhaps this whole brouhaha would not have happened at all, and at least it would have played out very differently.

You can come up with some sort of gestalt idea of what she really meant, and while it might make some sense in retrospect, it does not affect what people were dealing with at the time, and all of the history is based on what people were dealing with at the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom