So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
To keep things honest, can you please research and learn what a straw man actually is. The accusation is getting very old.
It is a verifiable fact and it has been noted half a dozen times in this thread that the kerfuffle over elevatorgate is about what happened at the atheist youth conference after RW's video blog. The only connection to the initial video blog is the reason RW said stupid things at the atheist youth conference was because a couple people criticized her initial video.

It is a straw man to continue to defend RW's initial reaction to EG and RW's initial video and or her feelings about or reaction to EG when no one is taking the position you are defending. Specifically: "to keep things honest, her original statement on it was a two minute blurp in an 8 minute video, it was hardly a big deal. She made her point, moved on, and while this is just my interpretation of her presentation of the incident, I doubt she intended on it becoming this much of a deal."

We all agree on that point. All of it. The gripe people had with RW was that from there she blew the thing out of proportion because a couple people did not make the same assessment of the elevator incident. RW had a cow that people had a different opinion. RW called that different opinion misogynist.
 
The fact that the two went separate ways and the altercation caused no harm leads me to believe that she was being ridiculous.

So as Monday morning quarterback, after the situation turned out to be nothing, you can draw a conclusion that nothing happened and she over reacted. However, when you are living in the moment and have no idea what the next second is going to bring and zero history of this individual to predict what his next action is going to be, it's hard to be so confident. She experienced something that she didn't care for and made mention of it, in a blog...cue internet explosion.

ETA: Again she did not give enough information about the event to draw any proper conclusions. But from what I heard her say, and from my personal experience, I gather she was being over dramatic.

You are entitled to your opinion but with all the steps you take to ensure a woman's comfort and possibly your success with them; why would you take them if making it clear that you don't like them is over reacting?
 
So Watson is to be commended for her good judgment? Excellent. That's been my point all along. And really the only point I want to make. Thanks.

Good judgment in not going up for coffee, yes. IMO bad judgment for heading into snarkville via the almighty "interwebs" ... unless the aim is to attract attention as primary goal, in which case that aim has been achieved.

How many pages, how many posts?

The winner of this thread is RW, since people are talking about her, and it appears that she prefers that to the alternative.
 
We all agree on that point. All of it. The gripe people had with RW was that from there she blew the thing out of proportion because a couple people did not make the same assessment of the elevator incident. RW had a cow that people had a different opinion. RW called that different opinion misogynist.

Interesting, I am left wondering why there were so many pages justifying and criticizing RW for not appreciating that approach. That must have been my imagination. However, RW posts a short personal anecdote, which incites a few people to post comments of their own, the one that stands out in my opinion is McGraw's hyperbole, which deserved to be challenged. I fail to see how:
Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and--don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner..."
...equates to demonizing men for being sexual beings? What exactly is it about her stating a specific way she does not like being approached that inspired anyone to not only blog about it, but to call her out on things she didn't express. It was other people making a big deal over it that caused it to snowball.
 
She experienced something that she didn't care for and made mention of it, in a blog...cue internet explosion.
This is wrong. That's not how it went down and no one I know of feels that RW doesn't have the right to her perceptions of the event. It was the presumption that the behavior was wrong and then speaking categorically about white male privilege and patriarchy and telling another female skeptic that she (the other skeptic) "did not get it" and then proceeding to engage in polemics.

If it were as innocent as you maintain I sure as hell would not be here.

You are entitled to your opinion but with all the steps you take to ensure a woman's comfort and possibly your success with them; why would you take them if making it clear that you don't like them is over reacting?
I can't parse this but then it wasn't directed at me.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, I am left wondering why there were so many pages justifying and criticizing RW for not appreciating that approach. That must have been my imagination. However, RW posts a short personal anecdote, which incites a few people to post comments of their own, the one that stands out in my opinion is McGraw's hyperbole, which deserved to be challenged. I fail to see how:
Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and--don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner..."
...equates to demonizing men for being sexual beings? What exactly is it about her stating a specific way she does not like being approached that inspired anyone to not only blog about it, but to call her out on things she didn't express. It was other people making a big deal over it that caused it to snowball.
For one thing she presumes to speak for every woman. She presumes that because she perceived sexualization that it was de facto sexualiztion. She doesn't say, "look, I would recommend that men not do that". She says "don't do that". A bit of humility would be nice. Many of us don;t think EG did anything wrong. Some of us think we might want to consider changing our etiquette and that it is worth discussing the issues in order to advance the zeitgeist and raise awareness that some women find a lot of male behavior boorish and/or harassing. We don't feel that RW's views are all that is to be said on the matter.
 
Last edited:
This is wrong. That's not how it went down and no one I know of feels that RW doesn't have the right to her perceptions of the event. It was the presumption that the behavior was wrong and then speaking categorically about white male privilege and patriarchy and telling another female skeptic that she (the other skeptic) did not get it and then proceeding to engage in polemics.

That was the entirety of events but don't negate the fact that the video and twitter/facebook (?) responses were to her saying that she didn't like being approached like that.

If it were as innocent as you maintain I sure as hell would not be here.

That's really not supportable by anything.
 
For one thing she presumes to speak for every woman. She presumes that because she perceived sexualization that it was de facto sexualiztion. She doesn't say, "look, I would recommend that men not do that". She says "don't do that". A bit of humility would be nice. Many of us don;t think EG did anything wrong. Some of us think we might want to consider changing our etiquette and that it is worth discussing the issues in order to advance the zeitgeist and raise awareness that some women find a lot of male behavior boorish and/or harassing. We don't feel that RW's views are all that is to be said on the matter.

The first vblog was all I and me. It wasn't until the multiple responses agreeing that it was a lousy, that she seemed to gain the impression that it was universally wrong.
 
The first vblog was all I and me. It wasn't until the multiple responses agreeing that it was a lousy, that she seemed to gain the impression that it was universally wrong.
It could be argued that she was only asking men not to do that to her.

...when men sexualize me in that manner...
I think this was the start.
 
I went through the timeline, multiple times. That all did not happen in the first day.
I don't claim it did. I claim that she (and her opponents) escalated it.

Amazing that after all of these pages we are still doing this.
 
You are entitled to your opinion but with all the steps you take to ensure a woman's comfort and possibly your success with them; why would you take them if making it clear that you don't like them is over reacting?

Please restate the question. I've fail to understand your point here.
 
It could be argued that she was only asking men not to do that to her.

...when men sexualize me in that manner...
I think this was the start

I know when you put your opinion out on the internet, there's always going to be someone who disagrees with you. I just found that the responses to her saying, in short, don't make a pass at me after I just got done saying that I don't like to be sexualized, to be less rational than her assuming that he was sexualizing her. Even you agree that she has the right to set her own boundaries, so what exactly is the point of the responses?

I don't claim it did. I claim that she (and her opponents) escalated it.

Amazing that after all of these pages we are still doing this.

Now if you had originally stated that she and her opponents escalated it, I would have had nothing to say. The statement I had issue with was that she made such a big deal. She wasn't alone and it wasn't as if she just kept harping on it until someone engaged.
 
Please restate the question. I've fail to understand your point here.

Sorry, that was very difficult to word. You made a list of steps that you take to prevent scaring, intimidating, or failing with, the ladies.

A few rules I personally follow is: don't talk to women you don't know in parking lots, elevators (at night or during times that many people aren't around). Don't follow her around or stare at her for more than 10 seconds without establishing eye contacting, waving, smiling, and having the courage to introduce yourself. Don’t wait till the last minute to talk to a woman (ask for her number, ask for a date, ask for other things..). Have the courage to talk to a woman and be flirtatious right in front of her or your friends.

My disclaimer is that I don't think all that is necessary but it is a consideration you give to women. It's very thoughtful of you. Why would you do all that, though?
 
Sorry, that was very difficult to word. You made a list of steps that you take to prevent scaring, intimidating, or failing with, the ladies.



My disclaimer is that I don't think all that is necessary but it is a consideration you give to women. It's very thoughtful of you. Why would you do all that, though?

Generally it’s best if you avoid certain situations where women have to flat out tell you no or lie, you get rejected way more often that way. This also helps me to eliminate time wasters like, "oh sorry no thanks I have to go to "x" with my boyfriend who truly doesn't exist." :D


It reduces the "creep" factor when you are more confident and direct with her. Now, I will also note that something’s do require privacy and isolation. But that only happens after you two have a decent rapport based conversation (things like your name, who you are, why you’re talking to her, etc.)


Could you honestly tell me you'd follow a woman you don't know into a parking lot at night? Would you follow her to her room? Would you wait last minute until she was alone to pull a stunt? These are all no no’s. They all scream thirsty, and they all scream coward. It makes women think, "What’s this guy really up to? What does he really want? He said that he wanted to be my friend and now he's doing "x", strange..." In short women like consistency. Guys women aren't stupid, it’s best to be upfront (in a decent manner) about what you want. All this nonsense would've been avoided had he had the courage to have a conversation and flirt with her while in public. She would’ve shut him down but he would’ve moved on and had a good time with his friends.



Hope this helps.

Cheers

/threadderail
 
Last edited:
I know when you put your opinion out on the internet, there's always going to be someone who disagrees with you. I just found that the responses to her saying, in short, don't make a pass at me after I just got done saying that I don't like to be sexualized, to be less rational than her assuming that he was sexualizing her. Even you agree that she has the right to set her own boundaries, so what exactly is the point of the responses?
So, I think we are on track that this incident alone was not the reason for all the hoopla. And yes, I most certainly believe that RW has every right to her feelings and perceptions and certainly the right to ask others to respect her boundaries.

The problem arises, IMO, with the presumptions as to EG's intent and whether or not he sexualized her. That was the beginning of the problems. Many people felt that what EG did was not per se bad or per se creepy. However, I think that without any escalation there would at most have been some discussion and some unwanted attention.

Instead RW had to fire back with "patriarchy" and "white male privilege" rhetoric and claiming that some women didn't get it because of their privilege. Those were incendiary comments. Now, look, I understand that RW was receiving some pretty disgusting comments and I think Dawkins and others who should have known better erred in their responses. But that doesn't excuse many of the comments made by RW about McGrath and others who had legitimate points. "You don't get it" and "you are a white male" or "you are arguing from privilege" are not going to help.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom