This is the straw that never ends.
Just to keep things honest, the brouhaha was about RW's subsequent actions, not about RW's initial video blog which was merely self serving.
No the original post of this thread
was about her original behavior that night. That's why its title and content was:
So there was this female speaker on an elevator
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2...name_names.php
"You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4 AM, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and - don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner..."
Rebecca Watson, founder of Skepchick, spoke in Dublin at the World Atheist Convention a month ago.
Afterwards, in a video post, she discussed an incident that occurred there. She received some dismissive responses. The above link to PZ Myers is supportive (and has links to the above) with Richard Dawkins being dismissive within the comments. PZ Myers weighs in again. Dawkins still doesn't get it...not a total surprise with his rep, but still.
As someone who has read Rebecca on these boards over the years - seeing some of the comments, when she's being straightforward and is not, to my knowledge, being hysterical (in the pejorative sense), has me shaking my head. Not sure if this has been posted elsewhere, and thought it would be of interest."
Underlining, bolding mine. What's underlined are the elements of her position about the events of that night. What's bolded is what made her uncomfortable: alone, late at night, isolated in elevator, asked to go to his room. Now if you change her point to being in any elevator, with other people in it too, in miday, and refute that, then you have used a straw man. I've seen that happen in this thread: "She's against all flirting in elevators! That's irrational. I refute that and claim her proposition false." That's a Classic Straw Man. One clear and classic example:
You can't let a few rascals who are evil prohibit you from flirting with women on the elevator.
See what you did there? You dropped
the manner of what happened being all the elements of that night she listed, and changed her proposition to the simpler "flirting in an elevator" (the straw man) and then you refuted that.
I've proven that these elements plus one more, going to the guys room, has resulted in rape before. Her spidy sense was working well, and she felt uncomfortable about this and was skeptical (dubious) about this guy and so turned the guy's invitation to his room down. In the 2020 show the lady did not turn this invitation down in this exact same situation and the result was she was beaten nearly to death and raped.
In reference to this OP topic Darth Rotor said to me:
case:
"The case your offered up as an example included a lady, alone, accepting an invite to a hotel room by a stranger. Her failure in judgment was tragic.
Of course, Stevie Wonder would have seen that one coming, don't you think?"
Meaning anyone should have been skeptical (dubious) about this, even Stevie Wonder (blind) and showed good judgment as opposed to the poor judgment of the other example of a situation like this.
I didn't change his position (into a straw man) and then try to
refute it. I didn't refute anything. I agreed with his position, and drew a conclusion from it. Since their was no refutation, there was no straw man fallacy.
My response was:
So Watson is to be commended for her good judgment? Excellent. That's been my point all along. And really the only point I want to make. Thanks.
Then the original post went on to say she was receiving some dismissive comments about her behavior that night, which he didn't agree with, meaning dismissing her behavior that night.
So this thread was/is about her behavior that night. It's fls who want's to change the topic to her response to the people demeaning her behavior that night. Then others added to its topic (went off-topic) to say she was rude, sexist, ego maniacal, in her blog responses to these people dismissing her behavior that night. This is indeed changing from the original point being discussed, but even this is not a straw man. It is just moving on to another topic: "I don't want to discuss her point about her behavior that night; I want to discuss how hard, wrong she came down on those who dimissed her point about that night."
Anatomy of a straw man.
Debater 1. I have a proposition X which I believe.
Debater 2. Your proposition ~X (the straw man) is false, and I
refute it via Y. Therefore your proposition is false.
A straw man is a component of an argument and is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position.[1] To "attack a straw man" is to create the illusion of having refuted a proposition by replacing it with a superficially similar yet unequivalent proposition (the "straw man"), and refuting it, without ever having actually refuted the original position."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man