So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Before you do I suggest you watch this 20/20 show on a woman in a nice hotel in Miami who got in the elevator at 3:30 in the morning with a large 6 foot 3, 330 pound man alone. He made small talk with her and she agreed to go to his room for a drink and ended up getting beaten nearly to death and raped then carried out of the hotel in a suitcase and left for dead in a field. This same man was eventually found to have raped three others after meeting them late at night in a place where they were alone and after getting them isolated. There is video tape of the lady and this man getting on the elevator at 3:30 in the morning alone. Too bad she didn't have a little more awareness of the potential for crime in such a situation, and decided to take the next elevator. Better safe then sorry is the rational principle in such a situation. Watch the elevator video and decide how you would truly feel and do. Really, this is no joke.

watch here: http://www.hulu.com/watch/274688/abc-2020-the-sixth-sense-sun-sep-4-2011


Is this what network TV is really like these days?

That was unbelievably horrible, pandering reportage. I couldn't even watch it all the way through. How can you trust anything promoted through a sensationalistic bull **** program like that?
 
Is this what network TV is really like these days?

That was unbelievably horrible, pandering reportage. I couldn't even watch it all the way through. How can you trust anything promoted through a sensationalistic bull **** program like that?
Fear sells and the ones who swallow it whole are now the "skeptics"... go figure.
 
Before you do I suggest you watch this 20/20 show on a woman in a nice hotel in Miami who got in the elevator at 3:30 in the morning with a large 6 foot 3, 330 pound man alone. He made small talk with her and she agreed to go to his room for a drink and ended up getting beaten nearly to death and raped then carried out of the hotel in a suitcase and left for dead in a field. This same man was eventually found to have raped three others after meeting them late at night in a place where they were alone and after getting them isolated. There is video tape of the lady and this man getting on the elevator at 3:30 in the morning alone. Too bad she didn't have a little more awareness of the potential for crime in such a situation, and decided to take the next elevator. Better safe then sorry is the rational principle in such a situation. Watch the elevator video and decide how you would truly feel and do. Really, this is no joke.

watch here: http://www.hulu.com/watch/274688/abc-2020-the-sixth-sense-sun-sep-4-2011


You can't let a few rascals who are evil prohibit you from flirting with women on the elevator. Do you want the terrorists to win?

I didn't think so.
 
Sigh. Can't believe somebody tried to drag doorlocks into this thread as a valid validation of their own point.

Almost looks like some kind of logicall fallacy...

And what the hell is this thread being alive anyway???
 
Sigh. Can't believe somebody tried to drag doorlocks into this thread as a valid validation of their own point.

Almost looks like some kind of logicall fallacy...

And what the hell is this thread being alive anyway???

Perhaps you're right. Perhaps this thread needs to end. Summation.

If there was a god, he would approve of elevator flirting.

Since there isn't let's just be respectful of each other.

And hey, the elevator thread should continue until it doesn't.
 
Well, I'm a pretty fair thread killer, so I'll give it a shot.
Endit.
Over.
Done.
Dusted.
Discussed to death.
All move on.
 
Oh c'mon. Seriously? Skeptical of intuition until we know what the potential risks are? Doesn't that defeat the point? Intuition is a sense of something. When it is the sense that something is wrong, we become a bit more alert and (hopefully) avoid a bad situation.

For example - recently I was buying a summer dress. The dressing rooms had chairs in front of them. I noticed without paying attention that a man sitting in one of the chairs seemed tense, sitting far forward on the chair. Because I'd already picked up that something was a little off, I heard the chair creak when he got up and I paused. 10 seconds later, a cell phone was slipped halfway under the door. Unfortunately, fiddling with the lock took too long. I wasn't able to get the door open fast and hard enough to bash him in his pervy face but I did have the satisfaction of seeing him race from the store.

Very little of this was conscious. Had I shrugged it off as being irrational, my privacy would have been violated. If I were to google "cell phone camera upskirt dressing room" I'd get a gazillion hits but very few police reports about arrests from that exact scenario. It's laughable to think of doing some research then and there to discover potential risk.

There are no hard and fast rules about when to feel uncomfortable, or when to use intuition to judge a situation. The next few times I use a dressing room, I may be a little more cautious. This is natural and it is helpful. The reason I was already aware of weirdness was because I've had enough bizarre or potentially dangerous stuff happen.

(confirmation bias)
 
Oh c'mon. Seriously? Skeptical of intuition until we know what the potential risks are? Doesn't that defeat the point? Intuition is a sense of something. When it is the sense that something is wrong, we become a bit more alert and (hopefully) avoid a bad situation.

For example - recently I was buying a summer dress. The dressing rooms had chairs in front of them. I noticed without paying attention that a man sitting in one of the chairs seemed tense, sitting far forward on the chair. Because I'd already picked up that something was a little off, I heard the chair creak when he got up and I paused. 10 seconds later, a cell phone was slipped halfway under the door. Unfortunately, fiddling with the lock took too long. I wasn't able to get the door open fast and hard enough to bash him in his pervy face but I did have the satisfaction of seeing him race from the store.

Very little of this was conscious. Had I shrugged it off as being irrational, my privacy would have been violated. If I were to google "cell phone camera upskirt dressing room" I'd get a gazillion hits but very few police reports about arrests from that exact scenario. It's laughable to think of doing some research then and there to discover potential risk.

There are no hard and fast rules about when to feel uncomfortable, or when to use intuition to judge a situation. The next few times I use a dressing room, I may be a little more cautious. This is natural and it is helpful. The reason I was already aware of weirdness was because I've had enough bizarre or potentially dangerous stuff happen.

Upskirts You're preaching to the choir now ;)
 
Oh c'mon. Seriously? Skeptical of intuition until we know what the potential risks are? Doesn't that defeat the point? Intuition is a sense of something. When it is the sense that something is wrong, we become a bit more alert and (hopefully) avoid a bad situation.

For example - recently I was buying a summer dress. The dressing rooms had chairs in front of them. I noticed without paying attention that a man sitting in one of the chairs seemed tense, sitting far forward on the chair. Because I'd already picked up that something was a little off, I heard the chair creak when he got up and I paused. 10 seconds later, a cell phone was slipped halfway under the door. Unfortunately, fiddling with the lock took too long. I wasn't able to get the door open fast and hard enough to bash him in his pervy face but I did have the satisfaction of seeing him race from the store.

Very little of this was conscious. Had I shrugged it off as being irrational, my privacy would have been violated. If I were to google "cell phone camera upskirt dressing room" I'd get a gazillion hits but very few police reports about arrests from that exact scenario. It's laughable to think of doing some research then and there to discover potential risk.

There are no hard and fast rules about when to feel uncomfortable, or when to use intuition to judge a situation. The next few times I use a dressing room, I may be a little more cautious. This is natural and it is helpful. The reason I was already aware of weirdness was because I've had enough bizarre or potentially dangerous stuff happen.

All fine and dandy but you don't try, convict and execute someone on intuition. Intuition is often wrong. Useful for protecting ourselves but very likely to ****-up an innocent person's life if too much stock is put into it.
 
case:

The case your offered up as an example included a lady, alone, accepting an invite to a hotel room by a stranger. Her failure in judgment was tragic.

Of course, Stevie Wonder would have seen that one coming, don't you think?
 
case:

The case your offered up as an example included a lady, alone, accepting an invite to a hotel room by a stranger. Her failure in judgment was tragic.

Of course, Stevie Wonder would have seen that one coming, don't you think?

So Watson is to be commended for her good judgment? Excellent. That's been my point all along. And really the only point I want to make. Thanks.
 
That will be overflowing by nominations and half+ of them will be disputed to the end of time.(and winners will be disputing it after poll closes...)

I have to admit it will be hard to judge a common everyday straw man from ones that stand out. Clearly case#46cw39's was a real stand out.
 
So Watson is to be commended for her good judgment? Excellent. That's been my point all along. And really the only point I want to make. Thanks.
Had she not denigrated and stereotyped I might have agreed with you, Had she not not been so presumptive and narcissistic her message might have had some weight. As it is, it was polemic and caused more harm than good. Too bad she felt her ego was more important than the message.
 
Had she not denigrated and stereotyped I might have agreed with you, Had she not not been so presumptive and narcissistic her message might have had some weight. As it is, it was polemic and caused more harm than good. Too bad she felt her ego was more important than the message.

Well that doesn't have anything to do with her judgment that night which was either good or poor right? So is that just setting up an off-my-point straw man for fun for me as a refutation to something I never said (post about her blog response quality)? lol Also I never replaced anyone's position on Watson with another (straw man) and then refuted that. I simply stated my own opinion on the goodness of her judgment that night and why.

A straw man is a component of an argument and is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position.[1] To "attack a straw man" is to create the illusion of having refuted a proposition by replacing it with a superficially similar yet unequivalent proposition (the "straw man"), and refuting it, without ever having actually refuted the original position.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man


But the rest of your post I agree with. So no arguments there about that.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom