So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Seriously? The reason this thread is so popular is because it's about a well-known personality of the community represented by this forum. And not only is it about her suggestion, it's about the reaction by well-known 'stars' of this forum community, reaction to these reactions of these stars, feminism in general, and female representation in the community represented by this forum. That would take a lot of pages. Also stairs are not the answer. The answer ironically is to be skeptical and play it safe over sorry when you a female, late at night, isolated, alone, and approached by a stranger.
Amanda Knox is not a forum personality and that thread is longer.

I think you are correct that familiarity with RW is one variable. But I don't think it is the only one. I think the not so universal feminist outrage also struck a chord with some people, as did the attack on Dawkins.
 
Last edited:
Before you do I suggest you watch this 20/20 show on a woman in a nice hotel in Miami who got in the elevator at 3:30 in the morning with a large 6 foot 3, 330 pound man alone. He made small talk with her and she agreed to go to his room for a drink and ended up getting beaten nearly to death and raped then carried out of the hotel in a suitcase and left for dead in a field. This same man was eventually found to have raped three others after meeting them late at night in a place where they were alone and after getting them isolated. There is video tape of the lady and this man getting on the elevator at 3:30 in the morning alone. Too bad she didn't have a little more awareness of the potential for crime in such a situation, and decided to take the next elevator. Better safe then sorry is the rational principle in such a situation. Watch the elevator video and decide how you would truly feel and do. Really, this is no joke.

watch here: http://www.hulu.com/watch/274688/abc-2020-the-sixth-sense-sun-sep-4-2011
Sad story, but I would note that it was after she went to his room that she was attacked, not while she was in the lift. What relevance do you think it has to this thread?
 
Sad story, but I would note that it was after she went to his room that she was attacked, not while she was in the lift. What relevance do you think it has to this thread?

It is relevant because both stories are on the same event timeline of rape in 4/5 elements. And the 20/20 story is direct evidence that she was on a rape event timeline, her spidy senses or skepticism were working and she got off this timeline. I'm not saying that she would have been raped, but I am saying that she was on a known timeline of rape as proven by the 3 rape cases in the 2020 show, and that this timeline is probably the most common one.

In my life I've found that prose is not condusive to critical thinking because concepts and relations can get jumbled up and unnecessary information and strawdogs creep in. So I use the symbolism found in Susan K Langer's Intro to Symbolic Logic to keep my thinking clear.

(=int means "is to be interpreted as")

Universe of discourse (K):
K(e1,e2,e3,e4,e5)
K =int as "risk factors in a rape timeline"
Elements of K
e1 =int "stranger approaches" (* not a sufficient factor, but a necessary factor: needs to be there along with others

e2 =int "female is alone"

e3 =int "female is isolated (*on an elevator as in Watson and 20/20 case, on a stretch of road where people or cops were not around as in 20/20 other 2 cases

e4 =int "late at night: after 2:30 in morning" (*true in Watson case and all 3 2020 cases. In 2020 case raper just came out of strip club drunk. This late night drunkenness increases the risk in the late night. Alcohol is a factor in 41% of rape cases. Also not many cops or people witnesses around.*)

e5 =int (goes to secluded place Room, woods, car, park with the stranger) (* true in all 3 cases not in Watson's case*)

It's not about being raped in the elevator that is at issue; it's about the event timeline that leads to a rape. Watson was on that timeline for four of the risk factors. The 20/20 rapes are direct evidence that this timeline has lead to rape, with the first one under question being an elevator exactly as in her case. This is the relevance. It proves that she was on a known rape timeline even specifically with an elevator being used in the evidentiary 2020 rape case. It proves that she was indeed on the rape timeline (as shown in all 3 2020 cases) though the e5 was not manifested by her and she got off it there. So it is directly relevant to Watson in that she experienced 4 of the 5 elements of a known rape timeline. The fifth element is necessary because there needs to be a secluded place for the rape to occur. The elevator is a risky manifestation of this required secluded place, though it could be, but probably much less often.

So this proven three times in the 20/20 show rape timeline is:

{e4, e2, e3, e1, e5} ==> rape, as is evidenced three times in 2020 show.

So Watson and the 3 rape victims all shared the first four elements of this known rape timeline as evidenced by the 3 cases of the 20/20 show. And that is why it is relevant. It is direct evidence that Watson was on a known rape timeline.

This time line is clearly more likely then its opposite time line:

{~4 (during the day, ~2 (surrounded by friends, others,) ~e3 (in a public restaurant etc with people and cops around, meaning not isolated)}

Clearly for a skeptic the first time line would be the more dangerous one, and likely the more oft used one in rapes.

So this shows that there is nothing irrational about being a female and being skeptical and careful when alone (e2), isolated (e3), late at night(e4) and approached by a stranger (e1). So these are the most important factors or elements to be aware of and skeptical about and watch your back, given this evidence. So it boils down to, as I said, teaching my daughter that

if she is ever alone, late at night, in an isolated place, and approached by a stranger, be very skeptical and cautious.

Do not get in his car as the 2nd and third rape in the 2020 show did. And do not go to a secluded place with him (room, woods, etc). That's my parenting lesson and based on those appalling rape statistics and this being the probable most common MO of a rapist, I'm going to stick with it.

You know back in the 60's/early 70s we poor young had as our main means of transportation hitch hiking. I often hitched from college in Roanoke Va to Philadelphia. Did this for a number of times until reports came in of kids getting robbed, murdered, raped, beaten up. The probability may have been relatively low say 30 out of 100,000 like in rapes, but we became skeptical enough to stop hitch hiking and I don't think any parent would suggest today to their daughter to hitch hike the 11 hours from Roanoke to Philadelphia. Most are skeptical and caution never to hitch hike and it has completely fallen out of favor and is now hardly seen, and only by the most desperate and naive (nonskeptics). This message is the same kind of thing.
 
Last edited:
It is relevant because both stories are on the same event timeline of rape in 4/5 elements. And the 20/20 story is direct evidence that she was on a rape event timeline, her spidy senses or skepticism were working and she got off this timeline. I'm not saying that she would have been raped, but I am saying that she was on a known timeline of rape as proven by the 3 rape cases in the 2020 show, and that this timeline is probably the most common one.

I'm sorry, but your reasoning here is faulty. And it's because this is a textbook example of a confirmation bias. That is, you are looking for what you would find if your idea is correct ("she is on a known timeline of rape"), instead of considering what you would find if your idea is incorrect. Unfortunately, as we know from this very example (Elevatorgate), the same things that are present on a known timeline of rape are the same things that are present when women aren't raped. In fact, you are much, much, much more likely not to have been raped when all those elements are present than you are likely to have been raped. You can't look at whether the elements of risk were present in retrospect. Of course they were present. They are present regardless. And they are present with a whole bunch of other elements whose importance to the timeline aren't known in advance.

And this is very important because you have a daughter you are trying to educate, and you may be teaching her to focus on the wrong things. Women don't get raped because they go off with men who creep them out. Ivor the Engineer made a good point earlier in this thread. Women are mostly raped by men they know, men who aren't creeping them out. If you go by your "spidey senses", you fail to identify the vast majority of times you are at risk. And how is your daughter supposed to identify, in advance, which of the dozens or hundreds of times a stranger approaches her, she is somewhat isolated, or it is very late (or very early) is part of a rape timeline and which is part of the normal course of events?

I related a story earlier in this thread about how I was alone in an elevator with a man, very early in the morning, and he asked me back to his room. If I had told this story under other circumstances, nobody would have have suggested that I would have been in danger had I gone to his room. Yet when it occurred to me to think about the incident in the context of this thread, this situation was probably much riskier than Rebecca's because there was actually a good chance I may have gone to his room.

This is the story. I was staying at a nice hotel. I was up before 4 in the morning because I was in a more western time zone and I get up at 5 as it is. I went down to the hotel lobby for something or other. When I went back up a man (about my age, average size, probably gay, pleasant smile) got onto the elevator with me, going to the same floor as mine. Right there I've already got 4/5 elements in your timeline of rape. He told me he had been at the front desk looking to borrow a screwdriver because his rolling suitcase had a broken wheel. I made a comment about how it's awkward to carry your luggage now that rolling cases are so ubiquitous. Then I mentioned that I usually have a screwdriver and pliers with me because I carry around a multi-tool. Just then, we arrived at our floor and he said, "if you have that tool with you, I'm in room 1234 if you want to bring it by." I made a non-committal reply...not because I was worried, but because I wasn't sure I had the tool with me.

It's foolish to make Elevatorgate about rape just because she found him creepy. "Creepy" put her on guard and made her less likely to go off alone with him. And had the story been identical except the guy never gets up enough nerve to say anything to her (i.e. a man happened to be in the elevator with Rebecca when she went up to her room), it wouldn't have been told as nobody would have found it remarkable.

Linda
 
if she is ever alone, late at night, in an isolated place, and approached by a stranger, be very skeptical and cautious.
And that's fine but if that's all she knows about risk then I'm afraid you've left some important information out. To truly understand risk we need to go beyond our intuitions and news stories. We need to be skeptical of our intuitions and reporting. Which is why I keep hawking that book.

  • What is irrational fear?
  • What is relative risk?
  • What are the relative risks of various activities?
If we as citizens cannot answer those questions then we are subject to irrational fear.

The probability may have been relatively low say 30 out of 100,000 like in rapes, but we became skeptical enough to stop hitch hiking...
I apologize, and with all due respect, I'm not sure what you mean by "skeptical" and I suspect that your use of the word in this context is not appropriate.

  • Are you skeptical of flying in a plane?
  • Are you skeptical of riding or driving in a car?
If you know the relative risk then there is nothing to be "skeptical" about. You need only make an informed choice. If you are afraid of hitchhiking and know the relative risks and those are relatively low in comparison to the risk of driving then the fear could be said to be irrational.

Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to hitchhike and there is little or no benefit to justify the risks then choosing not to do so is wise.

Finally, skepticism means to be skeptical of our intuitions and fears. It's not enough to know that something is potentially dangerous, we need to know what the relative risks are.
 
And that's fine but if that's all she knows about risk then I'm afraid you've left some important information out. To truly understand risk we need to go beyond our intuitions and news stories. We need to be skeptical of our intuitions and reporting. Which is why I keep hawking that book.

  • What is irrational fear?
  • What is relative risk?
  • What are the relative risks of various activities?
If we as citizens cannot answer those questions then we are subject to irrational fear.

I apologize, and with all due respect, I'm not sure what you mean by "skeptical" and I suspect that your use of the word in this context is not appropriate.

  • Are you skeptical of flying in a plane?
  • Are you skeptical of riding or driving in a car?
If you know the relative risk then there is nothing to be "skeptical" about. You need only make an informed choice. If you are afraid of hitchhiking and know the relative risks and those are relatively low in comparison to the risk of driving then the fear could be said to be irrational.

Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to hitchhike and there is little or no benefit to justify the risks then choosing not to do so is wise.

Finally, skepticism means to be skeptical of our intuitions and fears. It's not enough to know that something is potentially dangerous, we need to know what the relative risks are.

Oh c'mon. Seriously? Skeptical of intuition until we know what the potential risks are? Doesn't that defeat the point? Intuition is a sense of something. When it is the sense that something is wrong, we become a bit more alert and (hopefully) avoid a bad situation.

For example - recently I was buying a summer dress. The dressing rooms had chairs in front of them. I noticed without paying attention that a man sitting in one of the chairs seemed tense, sitting far forward on the chair. Because I'd already picked up that something was a little off, I heard the chair creak when he got up and I paused. 10 seconds later, a cell phone was slipped halfway under the door. Unfortunately, fiddling with the lock took too long. I wasn't able to get the door open fast and hard enough to bash him in his pervy face but I did have the satisfaction of seeing him race from the store.

Very little of this was conscious. Had I shrugged it off as being irrational, my privacy would have been violated. If I were to google "cell phone camera upskirt dressing room" I'd get a gazillion hits but very few police reports about arrests from that exact scenario. It's laughable to think of doing some research then and there to discover potential risk.

There are no hard and fast rules about when to feel uncomfortable, or when to use intuition to judge a situation. The next few times I use a dressing room, I may be a little more cautious. This is natural and it is helpful. The reason I was already aware of weirdness was because I've had enough bizarre or potentially dangerous stuff happen.
 
Oh c'mon. Seriously? Skeptical of intuition until we know what the potential risks are? Doesn't that defeat the point? Intuition is a sense of something. When it is the sense that something is wrong, we become a bit more alert and (hopefully) avoid a bad situation.

For example - recently I was buying a summer dress. The dressing rooms had chairs in front of them. I noticed without paying attention that a man sitting in one of the chairs seemed tense, sitting far forward on the chair. Because I'd already picked up that something was a little off, I heard the chair creak when he got up and I paused. 10 seconds later, a cell phone was slipped halfway under the door. Unfortunately, fiddling with the lock took too long. I wasn't able to get the door open fast and hard enough to bash him in his pervy face but I did have the satisfaction of seeing him race from the store.

Very little of this was conscious. Had I shrugged it off as being irrational, my privacy would have been violated. If I were to google "cell phone camera upskirt dressing room" I'd get a gazillion hits but very few police reports about arrests from that exact scenario. It's laughable to think of doing some research then and there to discover potential risk.

There are no hard and fast rules about when to feel uncomfortable, or when to use intuition to judge a situation. The next few times I use a dressing room, I may be a little more cautious. This is natural and it is helpful. The reason I was already aware of weirdness was because I've had enough bizarre or potentially dangerous stuff happen.
I'm skeptical of your story*. ;)

Rand was talking about risk assessment of certain circumstances. You added more to the assessment in your story. You added that the guy looked out of place and nervous. That's very different from fearing dressing roms or elevators.



*BTW, I think grabbing the phone or stepping on the guy's hand would have been my first thought.
 
Last edited:
And that's fine but if that's all she knows about risk then I'm afraid you've left some important information out. To truly understand risk we need to go beyond our intuitions and news stories. We need to be skeptical of our intuitions and reporting. Which is why I keep hawking that book.

  • What is irrational fear?
  • What is relative risk?
  • What are the relative risks of various activities?
If we as citizens cannot answer those questions then we are subject to irrational fear.

I apologize, and with all due respect, I'm not sure what you mean by "skeptical" and I suspect that your use of the word in this context is not appropriate.

  • Are you skeptical of flying in a plane?
  • Are you skeptical of riding or driving in a car?
If you know the relative risk then there is nothing to be "skeptical" about. You need only make an informed choice. If you are afraid of hitchhiking and know the relative risks and those are relatively low in comparison to the risk of driving then the fear could be said to be irrational.

Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to hitchhike and there is little or no benefit to justify the risks then choosing not to do so is wise.

Finally, skepticism means to be skeptical of our intuitions and fears. It's not enough to know that something is potentially dangerous, we need to know what the relative risks are.


Skeptism is a state of mind or thinking attitude, that doesn't change with the subject matter. It's a way for thinking about things. Three definitions:

skepticism - definition of skepticism by the Free Online Dictionary ...
www.thefreedictionary.com/skepticism skep·ti·cism also scep·ti·cism (sk p t -s z m). n. 1. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety.

dictionary.reference.com/browse/skepticism
scepticism n. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety.

Definition of Skepticism - BrainyQuote
www.brainyquote.com/words/sk/skepticism220198.html
Skepticism. Skepticism. An undecided, inquiring state of mind; doubt; uncertainty.

You also seem to sometimes imply that you need 100 % of situation cases to be on the very dangerous side to apply the principle of prudency or better safe then sorry. This isn't true. A low probability of a very dangerous situation is enough to apply the principle and avoid the situation if it is easy enough to do. For example I ask you to drive for now on consistently on wet, empty highways at 130 miles an hour. There is a low probability that you will crash, maybe even 30 in 100,000 as in rape (on ave.). But I'm pretty sure you won't decide to do this but will be "prudent" or better safe then sorry and say you refuse to do this. Should I then say oh you are so wrong; you have not done a proper risk assessment and are just acting on irrational fear. Now get out there and drive it hard! But maybe you are "dubious" or skeptical about the sanity of doing such a thing and refuse. That's skepticism and I'm sure you would refuse. It's just not smart and you are heading toward implementing Darwin's Law. If you disagree with this please upload videos of you doing so over the next 30 days.

You said:

"Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to hitchhike and there is little or no benefit to justify the risks then choosing not to do so is wise."

Exactly. Thank you. You have stated my case well for me. We are finally in agreement. You call it prudent and I call it better safe then sorry. I said only the desperate would use such means and you said "little or no benefit to justify such means." Same thing as only being desperate could justify it.

And the exact same thing applies using the simple principle for this case and females:

if she is ever alone, late at night, in an isolated place, and approached by a stranger, be skeptical (dubious) and cautious.

"Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to [place oneself in a known dangerous situation] and there is little or no benefit to justify the risks [and there is an easy alternative] then choosing not to do so is wise."

So you wouldn't really advise the ladies on this forum that it is a perfectly rational and skeptical response to get isolated by getting into a car of a stranger alone at 2:30 in the morning on an empty highway (as was the case in the 2nd rape of the 2020 show)? You would you say be skeptical (dubious) and prudent; don't be dumb and naive? You would say do the prudent thing.

Conclusion Your definition of skepticism is wrong, but you have stated well my case for me.

PS I didn't use "news stories" so please stop twisting what I said. I used examples of actual documented cases of rapes (3) and state rape statistics.
 
Last edited:
I'm skeptical of your story*. ;)

Rand was talking about risk assessment of certain circumstances. You added more to the assessment in your story. You added that the guy looked out of place and nervous. That's very different from fearing dressing roms or elevators.



*BTW, I think grabbing the phone or stepping on the guy's hand would have been my first thought.

Of course it is very different from fearing dressing rooms or elevators. I think I may have made that point myself about...oh I dunno, maybe 47 bazillion times.

You, specifically, have been pimping out that false dichotomy so freaking hard. Someone says "uncomfortable" and your consistent response is "OMG! how do you leave the house with all that fear!!!!!" As if human beings are really that binary.

Rand is going on about "risk assessment' as if we have the luxury of pre-checking each and every situation. We don't. The world is incredibly random and new variables get tossed at us even in fairly typical situations. It is possible for someone to ride an elevator a million times and be creeped out only once. No amount of elevator risk assessment will prevent that one time from happening because that situation will have unique factors. Ignoring our own instincts about a specific situation in favor of generalities is frankly, stupid.

In this bizarre world that you and Rand have created, I should have ignored my feelings because dressing rooms are generally safe, or if I felt that they were not, to have whipped out my own phone, googled dressing rooms and then made some sort of statistical assessment. In the world I live in, something weird makes me pay slightly more attention and then I am ready in case an anomaly happens. And no, I'm not scared all the time.
 
You also seem to sometimes imply that you need 100 % of situation cases to be on the very dangerous side to apply the principle of prudency...
No. Clearly not. I've stated so over and over that I think it wise to be careful. It's irrational to be fearful of things that are not relatively harmful

"Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent.
I never said otherwise. In fact I said it is good to be prudent.

Exactly. Thank you. You have stated my case well for me.
You did not provide a risk assessment for elevators at night and implied that they are dangerous (what is the relative risk?). Therein lies our difference.

if she is ever alone, late at night, in an isolated place, and approached by a stranger, be skeptical (dubious) and cautious.
Please go back and read my posts. I NEVER said this was wrong. I took issue with the fact that you implied that elevators are dangerous without providing a risk assessment (what is the relative risk?).

"Let me hasten to add, it's not irrational to be prudent. If one does not need to [place oneself in a known dangerous situation]
Here's where we have a problem. Life is, itself, risky. If you go back to my first post you will see that people are killed and raped in their own homes. It's risky, not dangerous. By your logic the home is simply a dangerous place. I don't think so and I don't think hitchhiking is dangerous. It's risky. But then riding in your own car by yourself to go to the movies is risky.

What are the relative risks
of getting in an elevator at 4;00 am and a stranger's car at 2:30 am? That's what you are not addressing.

So you wouldn't really advise the ladies on this forum that it is a perfectly rational and skeptical response to get isolated by getting into a car of a stranger alone at 2:30 in the morning on an empty highway (as was the case in the 2nd rape of the 2020 show)? You would you say be skeptical (dubious) and prudent; don't be dumb and naive? You would say do the prudent thing.
"Skeptical"? No, I wouldn't use that word. Getting into a strangers car at 2:30 is a bit different than an elevator but if these ladies didn't need to get in the car then it would be prudent not to. What IS the relative risk? Are you basing your view on intuition or do you know the relative risk. Being prudent doesn't mean a behavior is dangerous.

Conclusion Your definition of skepticism is wrong
:( That's very disappointing. I've not even given a definition. I've challenged your use and I stand by that. You are misusing the word. Swimming is risky but I wouldn't be skeptical of swimming. That makes no sense and doesn't fit any of your definitions. Now, I might be skeptical of a stranger's claim that it's safe to go to his room or get in his car. Big difference.

PS I didn't use "news stories" so please stop twisting what I said. I used examples of actual documented cases of rapes (3) and state rape statistics.
  1. The news uses actual stories to scare people.
  2. They do that by failing to provide relative risk assessment.
  3. That, IMO, is what you are doing even if you don't intend to.
  4. Your statistics are not contextualized and are therefore meaningless in this discussion.
  5. You do not provide a risk assessment for elevators (what is the relative risk?)
  6. By your logic I could use your statistics to prove that staying home is dangerous.
 
Last edited:
Please, understand my point here.

Rand is going on about "risk assessment' as if we have the luxury of pre-checking each and every situation.
No. I believe you should be Be careful. Be prudent. Don't try to scare others about elevators if YOU don't know what the relative risks are.

In this bizarre world that you and Rand have created, I should have ignored my feelings because dressing rooms are generally safe
No. I'm saying don't scare people to think dressing rooms or elevators are dangerous.

This is real simple If you don't have the facts then follow your intuitions. OF COURSE. Just don't get on an internet forum citing rape statistics without context and spewing rhetoric that implies that elevators are dangerous when you don't even know what the relative risks are. That's all.Please don't read more into this than is warranted.
 
Last edited:
....
In this bizarre world that you and Rand have created, ...
:id:

Bookitty, the most bizarre thing here is the odd way you interpret what people post. I do believe you are going for the record of the most straw men in a single thread. We (plural) tell you again and again that you are frequently changing what we've posted somewhere between the page and your conscious interpretation, yet you make no effort to stop and consider a post before you once again make another straw man argument to reply to.
 
You did not provide a risk assessment for elevators at night and implied that they are dangerous (what is the relative risk?). Therein lies our difference.

I took issue with the fact that you implied that elevators are dangerous without providing a risk assessment (what is the relative risk?).

Here's where we have a problem. Life is, itself, risky. If you go back to my first post you will see that people are killed and raped in their own homes. It's risky, not dangerous.

What IS the relative risk? Are you basing your view on intuition or do you know the relative risk. Being prudent doesn't mean a behavior is dangerous.

:( That's very disappointing. This shows you don't understand that the root issue is danger, and that in the method of being prudent what is required is an on the spot assessment of the possibility of danger occurring in the case with little time and information.

Danger is something causing extreme harm to health and well-being. So getting killed or raped in the home is a danger. And if one applies the method of being prudent and determines there is a risk of this happening (due to bad neighborhood, isolated place etc.) they do the prudent thing and get locks and dogs and sometimes guns. That's precisely why locks are so popular. What they haven't done is assess the relative risk of things to come to this conclusion because it isn't necessary, just the simple risk of the possibility of this one thing happening.

Maybe this will help you see that danger is the issue when being prudent, and simple risk assessment of case possibility is all that is needed:

In martial arts there is something called "walking the dog". Get a very sharp, long, un-serrated knife and hold it in front of you blade up. Now put your index finger in contact with the blade, and "walk the dog" meaning slide your finger down the blade without losing contact with the blade. You will slice your finger but there is no danger involved. Now as you quickly assess the risk of this do you do a relative risk of things? Of course not. You simply assess the risk of cutting your finger if you do this act, and see that it is virtually 100% certain. No need to assess the relative risk of things LOL. If you called this dangerous the martial artists would laugh at you. And if you said you want to do the prudent thing and not do it they would call you a wimp precisely because there is no danger, and so no need to apply the method of being prudent. You simply don't want to do it because your simple assessment of the possibility of this single act slicing your finger is virtually 100% and you want to avoid the moderate pain of slicing your finger. And the relative risk of things doesn't even cross your mind, because it's not the relative risk of things that matters; it's your sense of the possibility of cutting your finger from doing this act that matters. You are simply avoiding things you don't like, just as Bookitty made a simple assessment of the situation at hand with few resources and decided it could lead to something she wants to avoid, and responded accordingly. That I would call guarding your wishes. So the act of being prudent technically does always involve the issue of danger. You don't need to be "prudent" if you are only worried about a hangnail coming from something. And it does involve the act of on-the-spot simple assessment of possibility of danger from some time line of behavior, with little time and few resources.

Also, saying "Finally, skepticism means ..." is considered to be offering a definition in critical thinking.
 
Last edited:
This shows you don't understand that the root issue is danger, and that in the method of being prudent what is required is an on the spot assessment of the possibility of danger occurring in the case with little time and information.
Perhaps the most dangerous thing you can do, relatively, is ride in a car. You could fear the car or you could take precautions, drive safely and make an informed choice. Acting like the news and using rhetoric like "dangerous" only breeds irrational fear.

Danger is something causing extreme harm to health and well-being. So getting killed or raped in the home is a danger. And if one applies the method of being prudent and determines there is a risk of this happening (due to bad neighborhood, isolated place etc.) they do the prudent thing and get locks and dogs and sometimes guns. That's precisely why locks are so popular. What they haven't done is assess the relative risk of things to come to this conclusion because it isn't necessary, just the simple risk of the possibility of this one thing happening.
None of those will eliminate risk, only reduce it. Homes are not "dangerous". That just breeds fear. No need to live your life in fear. The risk is lower than riding in the car to the movies. You could choose to not go to the movies or you could make an informed choice, accept and mitigate the risk by driving safely and prudently servicing your car regularly and not driving under the influence.

Maybe this will help you see that danger is the issue when being prudent, and simple risk assessment of case possibility is all that is needed:
That's pointless as I don't disagree.

My argument that you ignored:

  1. The news uses actual stories to scare people.
  2. They do that by failing to provide relative risk assessment.
  3. That, IMO, is what you are doing even if you don't intend to.
  4. Your statistics are not contextualized and are therefore meaningless in this discussion.
  5. You do not provide a risk assessment for elevators (what is the relative risk?) Without knowing the relative risk we should not be fearful of elevators.
  6. By your logic I could use your statistics to scare people about just living in their homes.
 
Last edited:
case#46cw39,

Seriously, get this book. I don't know if at this point you are receptive to what I'm saying. We didn't get off to a good start. Glassner, a skeptic and critical thinker is more likely to convince you of what I'm telling you,

The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things Barry Glassner

There has never been another era in modern history, even during wartime or the Great Depression, when so many people have feared so much. Three out of four Americans say they feel more fearful today then they did twenty years ago. The Culture of Fear describes the high costs of living in a fear-ridden environment where realism has become rarer than doors without deadbolts.

Why do we have so many fears these days? Are we living in exceptionally dangerous times? To watch the news, you’d certainly think so, but Glassner demonstrates that it is our perception of danger that has increased, not the actual level of risk. The Culture of Fear is an expose of the people and organizations that manipulate our perceptions and profit from our fears: politicians who win elections by heightening concerns about crime and drug use even as rates for both are declining; advocacy groups that raise money by exaggerating the prevalence of particular diseases; TV newsmagazines that monger a new scare every week to garner ratings.Glassner spells out the prices we pay for social panics: the huge sums of money that go to waste on unnecessary programs and products as well as time and energy spent worrying about our fears.
 
Last edited:
Do you have locks on your doors? Case closed. I guess the rest we agree on.

Quote from me:
"Maybe this will help you see that danger is the issue when being prudent, and simple risk assessment of case possibility is all that is needed:"

Your response to this:
That's pointless as I don't disagree.
 
Last edited:
Do you have locks on your doors?
They were here when I moved in. I only lock my doors when I leave. I turned down the landlords offer of an alarm system for a discount on the rent instead. I leave my windows open at night which worries my mother in law.

I do not live in fear. I rest my case.

Maybe this will help you see that danger is the issue when being prudent, and simple risk assessment of case possibility is all that is needed:"
Your example was pointless as it did not address anything relevant to the discussion that has not already been conceded.
 
Exactly. Case closed. I am glad we are in agreement now on everything. Thank you for making my case. Have a great night.
Cool. I assume you will now refrain from making alarmist claims about danger. I assume you will now leave your doors unlocked and windows open at night in the summer so you can turn off the AC and save money on electricity.

Isn't life better when you don't live in fear?

:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom