So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it's hilarious that a thread about somebody's reaction to somebody's reaction to a clumsy pass in an elevator has got to 92 pages while a thread about siblings actually having sex in an elevator has already lost steam.

The lesson to be learned in all this is to simply use the stairs from now on.

Seriously? The reason this thread is so popular is because it's about a well-known personality of the community represented by this forum. And not only is it about her suggestion, it's about the reaction by well-known 'stars' of this forum community, reaction to these reactions of these stars, feminism in general, and female representation in the community represented by this forum. That would take a lot of pages. Also stairs are not the answer. The answer ironically is to be skeptical and play it safe over sorry when you a female, late at night, isolated, alone, and approached by a stranger.
 
Last edited:
Not really
"Not really", what?

...it is having common sense when it is late in the night and a woman is alone in an isolated place. It is manifesting a simple better safe then sorry principle.
No one argues otherwise. I said theres nothing wrong with understanding risk.

That's not the situation I'm talking about
It's not what I'm talking about. Please don't start with the straw men.


Conclusion. These stats should be eye opening and dismaying to you and confirm that teaching my beautiful daughter that it's better to be safe then sorry
Straw man and appeal to fear. No one is telling you not to teach your children to be safe. I'm just not impressed with your network news fear mongering.

If you are a critical thinker and skeptic and you want your beautiful daughter to have a realistic understanding of risks then get your beautiful daughter the following book and perhaps your beautiful daughter won't grow up with irrational fear.

The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things

Best of luck to you and your beautiful daughter.
 
"Not really", what?

No one argues otherwise. I said theres nothing wrong with understanding risk.

It's not what I'm talking about. Please don't start with the straw men.


Straw man and appeal to fear. No one is telling you not to teach your children to be safe. I'm just not impressed with your network news fear mongering.

If you are a critical thinker and skeptic and you want your beautiful daughter to have a realistic understanding of risks then get your beautiful daughter the following book and perhaps your beautiful daughter won't grow up with irrational fear.

The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things

Best of luck to you and your beautiful daughter.

No thanks I will just teach her to be careful when late at night, alone, isolated and approached by a stranger. You go your way and I will go mine. Your best of luck comes off as sarcastic.
 
The reason this thread is so popular is because it's about a well-known personality of the community represented by this forum. And not only is it about her suggestion, it's about the reaction by well-known stars of this forum, reaction to these reactions of these stars, feminism in general, and female representation in the community represented by this forum. That would take a lot of pages.

(emphasis mine)

I would think celebrity wouldn't count for much on a skeptic's forum.
 
(emphasis mine)

I would think celebrity wouldn't count for much on a skeptic's forum.

The popularity of this thread proves otherwise. The big thrill was that it was Watson who made the suggestion, and what's his name and pj (sic) who were reacting as they were. Without that I bet it would not have even been a thread.
 
"Not really", what?

You can't tell what this refers to? I said

"Not really; it is having common sense ..."

If you were a critical thinker you would know instantly what part of your quoted post this refers to.

If you were a skeptic you would know that being a female, being alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a stranger is a perfect time to be a skeptic.

I'm not impressed.
 
No thanks I will just teach her to be careful when late at night, alone, isolated and approached by a stranger.
Why tell us? We aren't stupid. This is something we all know and the potential for risk has been discussed to death in the thread. Next time tell us water is wet.

You go your way and I will go mine. Your best of luck comes off as sarcastic.
Your presumptions and all the appeals to irrational fear and you telling us repeatedly about your daughter (think of the children) was a bit much.
 
If you were a critical thinker you would know instantly what part of your quoted post this refers to.
What are you talking about? I never said anything that was opposed to common sense.

I'm not impressed.
:rolleyes:

You come here to try and scare everyone and garner kudos for telling us all what we already know then you go off into irrational nonsense and YOU are not impressed?
 
Last edited:
Why tell us? We aren't stupid. This is something we all know and the potential for risk has been discussed to death in the thread. Next time tell us water is wet.

Your presumptions and all the appeals to irrational fear and you telling us repeatedly about your daughter (think of the children) was a bit much.

I said it first because people obviously thought it all was a joke and there was no potential for risk. I told you because you too denied this and poo pood the potential for risk, calling what I said not a statement about risk, but an act of irrational fear, thus showing you don't care or understand the potential for risk. Here's what you said:

"Life is inherently risky. There's nothing wrong with understanding risk but this is the kind of cautionary tales told on the 6 o'clock news to exploit irrational fear to sell news."

There is nothing irrational about being a female and being skeptical and careful when alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a stranger. This is the only case I am talking about so don't build a strawman and talk about elevators during the day with lots of people around as many have done in this thread.

Yeah I hate thinking about my children. Who gives a crap. I'm not impressed.
 
I'm not reading 92 pages to ensure I'm not repeating a joke. I'm way too busy hanging around in elevators, hoping to get lucky. I thought bars were hopping, but apparently elevators are the new place to be. I wonder what would happen if they put an elevator in my favorite bar? Hundreds dead of exhaustion within a week, I bet.

Between you and Senex, I'm going to have to re-think my usual means of vertical transportation. I'm starting to think I'm going to miss out on something.*

Linda

*(for various considerations of "something")
 
I said it first because people obviously thought it all was a joke and there was no potential for risk. I told you because you too denied this and poo pood the potential for risk, calling what I said not a statement about risk, but an act of irrational fear, thus showing you don't care or understand the potential for risk. Here's what you said:
Ahhh.... NO!

No one thinks it is a joke. People are also killed and raped in their homes. They are also raped and killed in nightclubs. That's no joke either. Life is inherently risky. There's nothing wrong with understanding risk but this is the kind of cautionary tales told on the 6 o'clock news to exploit irrational fear to sell news. There is no evidence that RW was in danger of being raped or killed.
I've already asked you. Please don't make straw men.
 
What are you talking about? I never said anything that was opposed to common sense.

It was clear in my post what I was talking about. Your comment and my response and the fact that you couldn't use common sense to see what it was obviously referring to.

You come here to try and scare everyone and garner kudos for telling us all what we already know then you go off into irrational nonsense and YOU are not impressed?

Showing you the actual facts that are in fact appalling, and saying that it is rational and skeptical for a female to be skeptical and careful when being alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a stranger is neither trying to scare anyone (these are facts) nor irrational nonsense.

You yourself above said you weren't so stupid as to not understand this potential for risk. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
It was clear in my post what I was talking about. Your comment and my response and the fact that you couldn't use common sense to see what it was obviously referring to.
Stop with the personal stuff. Stick to the argument or I will report you.

Showing you the actual facts that are in fact appalling
Those facts don't tell us what the relative risks are for riding in an elevator at any time. Can you tell us what the relative risks are?

...and saying that it is rational and skeptical for a female to be skeptical and careful when being alone, isolated, late at night and approached by a stranger is neither trying to scare anyone (these are facts) nor irrational nonsense.
That's NOT what I'm talking about. I'm talking about relative risks of this particular event (riding in an elevator). You don't even know.

You yourself above said you weren't so stupid as to not understand the potential for risk.
:rolleyes: But to be in fear of potential risk when you don't even know what that risk is, is irrational.

Get the book. The author, a skeptic and critical thinker agrees with me. I'm not saying it's wrong to be careful. I'm saying that to claim riding in an elevator at night is dangerous when you don't even know what the relative risk is, is irrational and fear mongering.
 
Last edited:
Then you don't know what "irrational fear" is.

I would strongly advise you to get the book.
The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things

Now you are talking out of two sides of your mouth. In your above quote you said:

"No one thinks it is a joke. ... There's nothing wrong with understanding risk"

And you said it is "stupid" not to understand this potential for risk.

So which one is it by your own words:

[ ] You are stupid and don't understand this potential of risk, but think this is merely irrational fear

[ ] You are not stupid and understand this potential for risk
 
Now you are talking out of two sides of your mouth. In your above quote you said:

"No one thinks it is a joke. ... There's nothing wrong with understanding risk"
Yes and?

And you said it is "stupid" not to understand this potential for risk.
Yes and?

[ ] You are stupid and don't understand this potential of risk, but think this is merely irrational fear
Understanding risk is very different from what YOU are doing. You can't even tell us what the relative risk is. Can you? Do you even know what "relative risk" means?

[ ] You are not stupid and understand this potential for risk
A potential for risk does not equate to dangerous.
 
You are the one who brought up not being a critical thinker or skeptic, so report yourself first. You simply, by doing so, made me wonder about you.
 
Accusing me of not using common sense is a personal attack.

Actually I only used what YOU used on me: not being a "critical thinker". Then you somehow wandered off this concept to use "common sense" in place of critical thinker in your response to this. And this implied you think critical thinking and common sense are the same thing. But if not then please consider it replaced with the original critical thinker as YOU first brought up. And I apologize for the misunderstanding.
 
Actually I only used what YOU used on me: not being a "critical thinker". Then you somehow wandered off this concept to use "common sense" in place of critical thinker in your response to this. And this implied you think critical thinking and common sense are the same thing. But if not then please consider it replaced with the original critical thinker as YOU first brought up. And I apologize for the misunderstanding.
Thanks. I appreciate it and I'll tone down my posts. I think you do have a point and I should have acknowledged that from the start. I just think you played your hand too strongly. Sorry.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom