So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
:solved1 P.S. Just a final way late follow-up to the letter-writing campaign tidbit above (for all zero of you who must care at this point :p, but better late than never): there does appear to have been a Skepchick connection after all, as Skepchick Elyse Anders is founder* of the Women Thinking Free Foundation, which as noted above works in cooperation with the More Than Men Project of Sasha Pixlee, the fellow who emailed the TAM presenters.

*assuming that's what "bad ass behind" means

Considering that Women Thinking Free has been too busy with their "Hug Me, I'm Vaccinated" campaign at various cons to update their website, Ander's involvement with the apparently deserted More Than Men Project seems to be minimal.
 
Considering that Women Thinking Free has been too busy with their "Hug Me, I'm Vaccinated" campaign at various cons to update their website, Ander's involvement with the apparently deserted More Than Men Project seems to be minimal.

Mmm... maybe, maybe not. It is involvement, though. I'm just pointing out a connection I wasn't aware of previously, and which doesn't seem to have been widely known by the concerned parties, if at all. For example, responding to my initial inquiry about the source of the emails to TAM presenters requesting they devote part of their presentations to commentary on Elevatorgate, Dr Tavris replied:
TAM presenter Carol Tavris in her email to me said:
(I)t was not the skepchicks who wrote to the presenters asking us to comment on this issue. It was an outside group, something called the "More than Men" project, which DJ told me was not remotely involved in the meeting or speaking there. DJ quite correctly immediately circulated a reply saying that it was completely inappropriate for this group to be contacting the speakers.

So, DJ Grothe felt the emails were "completely inappropriate"; while under the impression they were from "an outside group... not remotely involved in the meeting or speaking there." (I'm guessing he specifies this because were the emails in fact from a group involved with TAM, his judgment about their inappropriateness would have been considerably more harsh; one imagines some sort of public censure at least.)

Dr Tavris continues:
Here is how the man in question, Sasha Pixlee, ended his message:

"I am sending this request on behalf of myself and of More Than Men, a new project run by and for concerned men in cooperation with the Women Thinking Free Foundation. More Than Men is about diversity awareness and is a call to action... Thank you." [my ellipsis -- trust me]

So, here's Mr Pixlee, in his sign-off, making sure to emphasize the connection between the More Than Men project, whom he's writing on behalf of, and the Women Thinking Free Foundation, whom they are "in cooperation with". What that means in the real world is hard to say: obviously some significant affiliation for him to have mentioned it in identifying his own group; I don't think it's unreasonable to assume consultation between the two on important decisions, which in the More Than Men project's scheme of things writing the TAM presenters would be, or on matters affecting both groups, which again writing the TAM presenters on this diversity issue would be. Indeed, it would be very strange if Mr Pixlee, having stressed the cooperation between the two groups in the email, hadn't consulted his sister org about the email. And just as incredible if Mr Pixlee was unaware of the connection between the Women Thinking Free Foundation and the Skepchicks, given that the woman identified as "the bad ass behind" the one is a writer for the other.

It's not much of a leap at this point to imagine the Skepchicks, or at least one Skepchick, using More Than Men as a proxy to try to rally the TAM speakers to their cause and have a portion of each presentation devoted to discussing their grievance with Prof Dawkins. It is, however, still a leap. What I think we should challenge, though, based on the above is DJ Grothe's impression that More Than Men was "an outside group... not remotely involved in the meeting or speaking there." I think Elyse Anders's Skepchick bio, identifying her as "the bad ass behind" the Women Thinking Free Foundation, and Sasha Pixlee's emphasis of the cooperation between her group and his, makes it very hard to see them as an "outside group".

And if that's the case, well... who knows. I think everyone's pretty much had it up to the gills with this whole business by now (aren'tcha just thrilled to be discussing it again?). :D Nonetheless, and with apologies to all those who are sick of it (includes me), I had to post this to set the record straight, about the source-of-the-emails' obvious connection to the Skepchicks, which seems to have been overlooked by everyone, including DJ Grothe. People, of course, are free to think of it (or not) and what, if anything, should be or have been done about it what they will.

(P.S. How's the book biz, bk? And would this be a best-seller, 'specially if we got all the main players to sign and pose for a group hug and/or flamenco dance-off for the dust jacket glossy?) :c1: ;)
 
Last edited:
So, here's Mr Pixlee, in his sign-off, making sure to emphasize the connection between the More Than Men project, whom he's writing on behalf of, and the Women Thinking Free Foundation, whom they are "in cooperation with". What that means in the real world is hard to say: obviously some significant affiliation for him to have mentioned it in identifying his own group;

Certainly he wanted to convey the impression that there was cooperation between his group and Women Thinking Free.

I don't think it's unreasonable to assume consultation between the two on important decisions,

I have to disagree there. Do we even have confirmation that WTFF considers themselves to be "in cooperation with" Pixlee's group?

which in the More Than Men project's scheme of things writing the TAM presenters would be, or on matters affecting both groups, which again writing the TAM presenters on this diversity issue would be. Indeed, it would be very strange if Mr Pixlee, having stressed the cooperation between the two groups in the email, hadn't consulted his sister org about the email.

Again, the fact that Pixlee mentioned WTFF doesn't mean that they really are cooperating. And even if they consulted, we don't know that WTFF agreed with this campaign. For all we know, they were appalled at the suggestion.

And just as incredible if Mr Pixlee was unaware of the connection between the Women Thinking Free Foundation and the Skepchicks, given that the woman identified as "the bad ass behind" the one is a writer for the other.

Concur that Pixlee probably knew the connection betwe Skepchicks and WTFF.

It's not much of a leap at this point to imagine the Skepchicks, or at least one Skepchick, using More Than Men as a proxy to try to rally the TAM speakers to their cause and have a portion of each presentation devoted to discussing their grievance with Prof Dawkins. It is, however, still a leap.
What I think we should challenge, though, based on the above is DJ Grothe's impression that More Than Men was "an outside group... not remotely involved in the meeting or speaking there." I think Elyse Anders's Skepchick bio, identifying her as "the bad ass behind" the Women Thinking Free Foundation, and Sasha Pixlee's emphasis of the cooperation between her group and his, makes it very hard to see them as an "outside group".

Again, I disagree, for the reasons stated above.

I don't have a dog in this fight, I just think you're building too much on inferences and speculations.

More data, particularly from, say, Anders, could quickly change my mind.
 
Last edited:
---- Again, I disagree, for the reasons stated above.

I don't have a dog in this fight, I just think you're building too much on inferences and speculations.

More data, particularly from, say, Anders, could quickly change my mind.


Excellent points, dasmiller; thanks for raising them. :)

I have to say I'm at a loss for a motive for Pixlee's having stressed the connection in his email to the TAM-speakers if there weren't some significant affiliation between them and, one would think, prior consultation on the message; however, just because I can't think of a motive doesn't mean much (he may be a 'loose cannon' for all I know, given to making things up for reasons known only to him, if that) and isn't much reason, skeptically-speaking, to accept his claim of a connection as is, without further research.

Better evidence, as you say, should decide the matter (not what I can or can't imagine). Which for this skeptic means - bleh - more digging... :dig:
 
I have to say I'm at a loss for a motive for Pixlee's having stressed the connection in his email to the TAM-speakers if there weren't some significant affiliation between them and, one would think, prior consultation on the message; however, just because I can't think of a motive doesn't mean much (he may be a 'loose cannon' for all I know, given to making things up for reasons known only to him, if that) and isn't much reason, skeptically-speaking, to accept his claim of a connection as is, without further research.


While he emphasized the connection, he also worded the email very carefully to make it clear the request came on behalf of himself and More Than Men.

Having said that, Pixlee does appear to be friends with at least some of the Skepchicks--his name comes up a number of times on their site: http://www.google.com/search?q=pixlee+site:skepchick.org

It would appear likely, IMO, that the email campaign was discussed with at least some of them.
 
I have to say I'm at a loss for a motive for Pixlee's having stressed the connection in his email to the TAM-speakers if there weren't some significant affiliation between them and, one would think, prior consultation on the message

I think Pixlee's motive was to give his letter more credibility, and that would apply whether or not there really was a significant affiliation. I don't know Pixlee (either in person or by reputation) so I've no idea whether he's the sort of person that would exaggerate any such connection.

Better evidence, as you say, should decide the matter (not what I can or can't imagine). Which for this skeptic means - bleh - more digging... :dig:

unfortunately true.
 
I think Pixlee's motive was to give his letter more credibility, and that would apply whether or not there really was a significant affiliation. I don't know Pixlee (either in person or by reputation) so I've no idea whether he's the sort of person that would exaggerate any such connection.

You're right, that could be a motive. I'd never heard of either More Than Men or Women Thinking Free ("Women Thinking Free": can't type that without giggling; the acronym's almost as lulzy), so didn't see how the connection might boost his cred; but Google shows some links between WTF Foundation and JREF (the vaccination drive), and almost nothing for MTM project, so there you go.


While he emphasized the connection, he also worded the email very carefully to make it clear the request came on behalf of himself and More Than Men.

Yes.

Having said that, Pixlee does appear to be friends with at least some of the Skepchicks--his name comes up a number of times on their site: http://www.google.com/search?q=pixlee+site:skepchick.org

Well that's a juicy spadeful, as digging goes. Nice bit of google-fu, Adman!

It would appear likely, IMO, that the email campaign was discussed with at least some of them.

Makes the circumstantial case much stronger, doesn't it. (Though thinking this over, am wondering now how much it even matters. Kind of old news; there's peace in the virtual community again; let sheeping blogs lie, if they want to. Maybe my assumption DJ Grothe doesn't know about the Pixlee-Skepchick affiliation is wrong; maybe it's well-known and has already been dealt with, privately. Easy to see why he as organizer would have thought interfering with the TAM speakers' programme "completely inappropriate"; and the breathtaking presumption of one group of presenters, whether openly or through a proxy, actually expecting others to take time out from their talks to talk about them would, I've got to think for an organizer, be completely inappropriate to the zillionth power; if you could make the case that's what happened, require some sort of public acknowledgement and reprimand; but what do I know: maybe it's all water under the bridge at this point, or already taken care of. If the evidence were a little stronger, I'd have half a mind to PM DJ about it; half to just let it slide. Ho-hum...) :stone032:
 
Because of this thread I have recently decided to flirt with women on elevators so I could report back on this thread those women's reactions. hehehe...

I'm now ready to start a new thread called picking women up in elevators ;)
 
Because of this thread I have recently decided to flirt with women on elevators so I could report back on this thread those women's reactions. hehehe...

I'm now ready to start a new thread called picking women up in elevators ;)
Sounds like you had a positive experience.
 
Because of this thread I have recently decided to flirt with women on elevators so I could report back on this thread those women's reactions. hehehe...

I'm now ready to start a new thread called picking women up in elevators ;)
Better than The Naked Man?
 
Because of this thread I have recently decided to flirt with women on elevators so I could report back on this thread those women's reactions. hehehe...

I'm now ready to start a new thread called picking women up in elevators ;)

Before you do I suggest you watch this 20/20 show on a woman in a nice hotel in Miami who got in the elevator at 3:30 in the morning with a large 6 foot 3, 330 pound man alone. He made small talk with her and she agreed to go to his room for a drink and ended up getting beaten nearly to death and raped then carried out of the hotel in a suitcase and left for dead in a field. This same man was eventually found to have raped three others after meeting them late at night in a place where they were alone and after getting them isolated. There is video tape of the lady and this man getting on the elevator at 3:30 in the morning alone. Too bad she didn't have a little more awareness of the potential for crime in such a situation, and decided to take the next elevator. Better safe then sorry is the rational principle in such a situation. Watch the elevator video and decide how you would truly feel and do. Really, this is no joke.

watch here: http://www.hulu.com/watch/274688/abc-2020-the-sixth-sense-sun-sep-4-2011
 
Before you do I suggest you watch this 20/20 show on a woman in a nice hotel in Miami who got in the elevator at 3:30 in the morning with a large 6 foot 3, 330 pound man alone. He made small talk with her and she agreed to go to his room for a drink and ended up getting beaten nearly to death and raped then carried out of the hotel in a suitcase and left for dead in a field. This same man was eventually found to have raped three others after meeting them late at night in a place where they were alone and after getting them isolated. There is video tape of the lady and this man getting on the elevator at 3:30 in the morning alone. Too bad she didn't have a little more awareness of the potential for crime in such a situation, and decided to take the next elevator. Better safe then sorry is the rational principle in such a situation. Watch the elevator video and decide how you would truly feel and do. Really, this is no joke.

watch here: http://www.hulu.com/watch/274688/abc-2020-the-sixth-sense-sun-sep-4-2011
No one thinks it is a joke. People are also killed and raped in their homes. They are also raped and killed in nightclubs. That's no joke either. Life is inherently risky. There's nothing wrong with understanding risk but this is the kind of cautionary tales told on the 6 o'clock news to exploit irrational fear to sell news. There is no evidence that RW was in danger of being raped or killed.
 
Last edited:
No one thinks it is a joke. People are also killed and raped in their homes. They are also raped and killed in nightclubs. That's no joke either. Life is inherently risky. There's nothing wrong with understanding risk but this is the kind of cautionary tales told on the 6 o'clock news to exploit irrational fear to sell news. There is no evidence that RW was in danger of being raped or killed.

Not really; it is having common sense when it is late in the night and a woman is alone in an isolated place. It is manifesting a simple better safe then sorry principle. And I will teach my beautiful daughter to be safe over sorry in this situation. Please don't go off topic and talk about daytime elevators with people around. That's not the situation I'm talking about

If you want to talk risk, then let's use facts.

Crime Rate by State, 2007
(rate per 100,000 inhabitants)

http://www.infoplease.com/us/statistics/crime-rate-state.html

Murder1 Forcible rape

Ala. 448.0 8.9 33.4 159.9 3,971.6
Alaska661.2 6.4 77.4 85.3 3,379.5
Ariz. 482.7 7.4 29.23 151.7 4,414.0
Ark. 529.4 6.7 44.7 106.7 3,953.1
Calif. 522.6 6.2 24.7 193.0 3,033.0
Colo. 347.8 3.1 41.1 71.0 3,006.1
Conn. 256.0 3.0 18.8 103.0 2,399.9
Del. 689.2 4.3 38.9 197.3 3,370.1
DC 2 1,41 4.3 30.8 32.6 724.3 4,913.9
Fla. 722.6 6.6 33.7 209.1 4,089.3
Ga. 493.2 7.5 22.8 181.7 3,901.0
Hawaii272.8 1.7 25.4 86.1 4,225.4
Idaho 239.4 3.3 38.5 15.5 2,246.6
Ill. 533.2 5.9 31.9 179.7 2,935.8
Ind. 333.6 5.6 27.5 124.1 3,396.6
Iowa 294.7 1.2 30.3 43.9 2,615.6
Kans. 452.7 3.9 44.3 72.6 3,678.7
Ky. 295.0 4.8 32.6 95.9 2,518.3
La. 729.5 14.2 32.4 141.7 4,076.0
Maine 118.0 1.6 29.7 26.5 2,428.8
Md. 641.9 9.8 21.0 236.0 3,431.5
Mass. 431.5 2.9 25.3 108.6 2,391.5
Mich. 536.0 6.7 45.5 133.2 3,065.7
Minn. 288.7 2.2 36.0 91.8 3,036.6
Miss. 291.3 7.1 35.6 98.2 3,200.8
Mo. 504.9 6.5 29.2 121.9 3,738.4
Mont. 287.5 1.5 30.3 19.9 2,765.4
Nebr. 302.4 3.8 29.7 62.4 3,161.4
Nev. 750.6 7.5 42.7 270.2 3,777.8
N.H. 137.3 1.1 25.3 32.8 1,892.0
N.J. 329.3 4.4 12.1 144.5 2,213.1
N.M. 664.2 8.2 52.4 117.8 3,725.7
N.Y. 414.1 4.2 15.2 161.1 1,978.6
N.C. 466.4 6.5 26.3 149.5 4,087.3
N.D. 142.4 1.9 32.4 10.9 1,889.6
Ohio 343.2 4.5 38.8 159.2 3,455.2
Okla. 499.6 6.1 43.1 93.2 3,526.4
Ore. 287.6 1.9 33.5 76.4 3,526.2
Pa. 416.5 5.8 27.7 156.5 2,361.3
R.I. 227.3 1.8 24.2 71.0 2,622.6
S.C. 788.3 8.0 39.5 144.0 4,271.7
S.D. 169.2 2.1 38.7 114.3 1,652.3
Tenn. 753.3 6.4 35.3 179.0 4,088.6
Tex. 510.6 5.9 35.3 162.2 4,121.2
Utah 234.8 2.2 34.3 53.7 3,500.3
Vt. 124.3 1.9 19.8 12.9 2,322.7
Va. 269.7 5.3 22.6 99.2 2,466.4
Wash.333.1 2.7 40.6 93.6 4,030.8
W. Va.27 5.2 3.5 20.4 47.0 2,525.0
Wis. 290.9 3.3 21.8 97.7 2,837.7
Wyo. 239.3 3.1 30.6 16.1 2,865.9

Many people say how awful the murder is in the US. The worst murder rate is in DC at 30.8 per 100,000. Then 14.2 for Louisiana. Calif is 6.2 New York is 4.2 Majority of states are below 9.

The worst state for forcible rape is 77.4 in Alaska. then 45.5 in Mich. 44.7 in Arkansas 44.3 in Kansas. 43.1 in Oklahoma 42.7 in Nevada. 41.1 in Colorado 39.5 in S.Carolina 38.5 in Idaho 36.0 in Mich 35.6 in Miss. The majority are in the 30s. New York is 15.2 Calif is 24.7. And Florida where the rape mentioned above happened is 33.7

Conclusion. These stats should be eye opening and dismaying to you and confirm that teaching my beautiful daughter that it's better to be safe then sorry and watch her back in dangerous (late at night, alone, approached by stranger) is the right and responsible thing to do. And I will. You will probably find something to argue about, but I won't be changing my parenting message on this.
 
Last edited:
I think it's hilarious that a thread about somebody's reaction to somebody's reaction to a clumsy pass in an elevator has got to 92 pages while a thread about siblings actually having sex in an elevator has already lost steam.

The lesson to be learned in all this is to simply use the stairs from now on.
 
I think it's hilarious that a thread about somebody's reaction to somebody's reaction to a clumsy pass in an elevator has got to 92 pages while a thread about siblings actually having sex in an elevator has already lost steam.

The lesson to be learned in all this is to simply use the stairs from now on.

I said that AGES ago.

Linda
 
I said that AGES ago.

I'm not reading 92 pages to ensure I'm not repeating a joke. I'm way too busy hanging around in elevators, hoping to get lucky. I thought bars were hopping, but apparently elevators are the new place to be. I wonder what would happen if they put an elevator in my favorite bar? Hundreds dead of exhaustion within a week, I bet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom