So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
You said more mature. What do you mean by mature
I'm sorry, are you actually asking me what maturity is?

, and can you show that it's not just your opinion ?
I'm not sure what you mean. I specifically stated that it was my experience. Are you asking if I administered some sort of maturity test to the people I've met so that I can objectively prove that this is what my experience is? No, I didn't do that.
 
You said more mature. What do you mean by mature, and can you show that it's not just your opinion ?

Perhaps you shouldn't snip quotes. ;)

The beginning of the statement, which you didn't quote fully, said 'in my personal experience'. Therefore it is an opinion, and you're going on about nothing.
 
Maybe I listed to too many installments of Loveline, but it sounds to me like these young women were acting out either against their own fathers or someone else in the family that had mistreated or abused them.

No doubt some of them had issues...really deep seeded issues.
 
We're pretty much to the 'hug and kiss and make up' phase. Don't worry, all it takes is one comment to plunge us back into darkness.

EG is obviously a misogynyst, sexist, pig, who stalks elevators to rape women. If you disagree, you are either a sexist pretending to be a woman online, a man who partakes in the same activities as EG, or an old white man just trying to keep the woman down... :D
 
EG is obviously a misogynyst, sexist, pig, who stalks elevators to rape women. If you disagree, you are either a sexist pretending to be a woman online, a man who partakes in the same activities as EG, or an old white man just trying to keep the woman down... :D

You forgot *rich* white man. And most probably mysoginist...
 
EG is obviously a misogynyst, sexist, pig, who stalks elevators to rape women. If you disagree, you are either a sexist pretending to be a woman online, a man who partakes in the same activities as EG, or an old white man just trying to keep the woman down... :D

Or a parrot. A colorful, squawky, parrot. If I remember correctly anyway.
 
The police have released one of those new 3D photofits of EG:

JasonU19UinchUfigureUl.jpg


Sorry I know I'm bad but really could help myself.
 
The police have released one of those new 3D photofits of EG:

[qimg]http://images.kaneva.com/filestore1/2259861/2850221/JasonU19UinchUfigureUl.jpg[/qimg]

Sorry I know I'm bad but really could help myself.

Okay, I've seen some funny comments, pics, and videos making fun of this whole incident, but this one is, so far, the best!
 
The police have released one of those new 3D photofits of EG:

[qimg]http://images.kaneva.com/filestore1/2259861/2850221/JasonU19UinchUfigureUl.jpg[/qimg]

Sorry I know I'm bad but really could help myself.

You see? He's harmless! No need to worry... He's just goalman!

:D
 
I'm sorry, are you actually asking me what maturity is?

In order to have a meaningful conversation it may be useful to define our terms. Is that problematic for you ?

I'm not sure what you mean. I specifically stated that it was my experience. Are you asking if I administered some sort of maturity test to the people I've met so that I can objectively prove that this is what my experience is? No, I didn't do that.

I'd like to know how you determined that they are more mature, because from my experience both sexes are pretty much equally immature.
 
The police have released one of those new 3D photofits of EG:

[qimg]http://images.kaneva.com/filestore1/2259861/2850221/JasonU19UinchUfigureUl.jpg[/qimg]

Sorry I know I'm bad but really could help myself.

I'm reporting this to the administrator for being off-topic !

Oh, wait...
 
In order to have a meaningful conversation it may be useful to define our terms. Is that problematic for you ?
More amusing than problematic.

Mature people have a greater awareness of the world around them - rather than being concerned exclusively with themselves and their circle of immediate friends and family they have an awareness of the wider issues in their society and the world - politics, social issues, etc.

They also have more of a sense of the changing nature of the world; that the issues which confront us today are not necessarily the ones that confronted us in the past, and that the future will bring different problems again.

Related to the above, they tend to begin thinking about the future of their own lives in realistic terms; they lose the "I wanna be a rock star because it's cool!" type of ambition and start to contemplate actual careers, thinking about what it will take to achieve it, earning potential, etc. They also start thinking about whether they want a family and what that might look like, etc.

They have a sense of responsibility and duty; the idea that life isn't wholly about what they get for themselves but also about what they give to and for others.

I'd like to know how you determined that they are more mature
I have conversations with the people I know and form opinions about their character. I had the impression that this was pretty standard behaviour amongst human beings.

because from my experience both sexes are pretty much equally immature.
If I had a mind to be ridiculous, I would demand that you prove that this is your experience. But since I'm not, I'll just say that this is my experience of adults over 25 or so, too, but that in the teen years there is an imbalance. And accept that your experience may differ.
 
More amusing than problematic.

Mature people have a greater awareness of the world around them - rather than being concerned exclusively with themselves and their circle of immediate friends and family they have an awareness of the wider issues in their society and the world - politics, social issues, etc.

They also have more of a sense of the changing nature of the world; that the issues which confront us today are not necessarily the ones that confronted us in the past, and that the future will bring different problems again.

Related to the above, they tend to begin thinking about the future of their own lives in realistic terms; they lose the "I wanna be a rock star because it's cool!" type of ambition and start to contemplate actual careers, thinking about what it will take to achieve it, earning potential, etc. They also start thinking about whether they want a family and what that might look like, etc.

They have a sense of responsibility and duty; the idea that life isn't wholly about what they get for themselves but also about what they give to and for others.

Taking this into account, then, I have to maintain my disagreement with you on female vs male maturity.

I have conversations with the people I know and form opinions about their character. I had the impression that this was pretty standard behaviour amongst human beings.

Sarcasm noted. Discussing with people is not a method of determining truth. It's a method of gathering data.
 
:p Yowza! Having to go back five pages to requote this:
Is there a source? I'd like to put this, or at least something about TAM 9 in the timeline.

At this point, just TAM scuttlebutt. I'll look into it.

Ok. Rechecked with attendee. According to him, it was fairly common knowledge around TAM that the Skepchicks as a community (with a couple of exceptions) made a big push via email to urge each speaker at TAM to speak out about Dawkins's comments. One speaker in particular he talked to, Carol Tavris, really didn't appreciate said push. Apparently, the speakers all got together pre-TAM to agree as a group that it was NOT a topic they felt would add anything to TAM, so they weren't going to bring it up.

I realize this is just "hearsay", however. Fwiw, I consider my sceptic source (whom I shall henceforth refer to as "Deep Doubt") very reliable. For an onymous source: If you want direct confirmation from one of the push targets, Carol TavrisWP probably your best bet (though one at a time, please, lest we inundate her with more shrill emails re elevator-gate). ;)

Another update: took my own advice and exchanged a couple of emails with Dr Tavris, and she's been very helpful, gracious and patient with me in clarifying what went on with the emails to the TAM presenters.

The emails were not, as rumored, sent by the Skepchicks (apologies for having suggested they were). They were sent by a fellow named Sasha Pixlee, on behalf of a group calling itself (from the email Dr Tavris and other TAM presenters were sent) "More Than Men, a new project run by and for concerned men in cooperation with the Women Thinking Free Foundation". His concerns about Elevatorgate et al, and motives for his email, can be discerned from this post at his website, "Sasha's Den of Iniquity".

While the Skepchicks' polemic against "straight white male privilege" in the atheist and skeptic movement clearly struck a chord with Sasha, they're not responsible for his overenthusiam; the emailing of TAM presenters was undertaken by him alone on his own more-than-manly initiative, it appears. My guess is talk of the emails was conflated with talk of the Skepchick letter-writing campaign vs Dawkins, leading to the TAM scuttlebutt I reported earlier, and which I mentioned in passing as if fact; whatever, my bad: a good lesson in going to the sources before passing on hearsay.

Thanks very much to Dr Tavris, whom I very much enjoyed corresponding with, for clearing up my confusion in the matter; and for any misinformation spread, sorry again. Mistakes were made, and, as usual, by me.


:solved1 P.S. Just a final way late follow-up to the letter-writing campaign tidbit above (for all zero of you who must care at this point :p, but better late than never): there does appear to have been a Skepchick connection after all, as Skepchick Elyse Anders is founder* of the Women Thinking Free Foundation, which as noted above works in cooperation with the More Than Men Project of Sasha Pixlee, the fellow who emailed the TAM presenters.

*assuming that's what "bad ass behind" means
 
Last edited:
:solved1 P.S. Just a final way late follow-up to the letter-writing campaign tidbit above (for all zero of you who must care at this point :p, but better late than never): there does appear to have been a Skepchick connection after all, as Skepchick Elyse Anders is founder* of the Women Thinking Free Foundation, which as noted above works in cooperation with the More Than Men Project of Sasha Pixlee, the fellow who emailed the TAM presenters.

*assuming that's what "bad ass behind" means

Excellent work!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom