So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
So I can sort of relate to someone RW's age's reaction to a guy a couple decades older. I have a stereotype in my mind of a guy attracted to women 20 years or more younger. It's not a pretty stereotype. Can a man 20+ years older than a woman be interested in her as a person, or is the interest most likely going to be sex and not much more? I'm not saying it is not possible for an older man to find a younger woman "interesting", but I am saying it is less likely.

I disagree. I think it's completely natural for older people to be interested in younger people intellectually, and vice versa. That impulse is at the basis of all of academia, which I think is one of the most noble professions and avocations there is. The appeal is so strong that they can get people to do it with very little pay.

The appeal is mutual, I think. The older person provides, if not wisdom, then at least a longer memory. The younger person provides fresh approaches to problems. The young Einstein took a fresh, childlike approach to relativity and solved it. The old Einstein didn't solve much but inspired younger people. It's a good thing.

There are, of course, sexual undertones, as there are in everything, but almost always they are more Freudian in nature than effective sexual interest. For a popular fictional example, the gay Dumbledore had a strong interest in Harry Potter, but I doubt that it was because he wanted to plook him.

Also, I think that young people overestimate their hotness factor. It works on their peers, but not so much on older people, who know better. I can see the occasional older man wanting arm candy, but for casual sex, younger people aren't as great as they think they are.

So, the age difference, to my mind, makes it more plausible that the interest was, as stated, to talk and not plook.
 
I disagree. I think it's completely natural for older people to be interested in younger people intellectually, and vice versa. That impulse is at the basis of all of academia, which I think is one of the most noble professions and avocations there is. The appeal is so strong that they can get people to do it with very little pay.
That's not the kind of interest I had in mind. If teachers are sexually attracted to young students, it isn't the most ideal in the eyes of society.

I'm talking about the guy who sees a younger woman as his mate or potential mate. How many of those men just enjoy the company of young women as opposed to you women's bodies? And again, I did not say it never happens.

....Also, I think that young people overestimate their hotness factor. It works on their peers, but not so much on older people, who know better. I can see the occasional older man wanting arm candy, but for casual sex, younger people aren't as great as they think they are.
It's the men attracted to the young women, not the young women claiming the men lust after them.

And, I don't know how big this subset of men is. I wouldn't want to venture a guess. I doubt it is a majority unless every older married man is really lusting after young women under the facade of being content.

So, the age difference, to my mind, makes it more plausible that the interest was, as stated, to talk and not plook.
Depends on the circumstances. In the case of EG, I said I would consider it differently had RW said something like, "He was an old guy leering at my tits." But she didn't say that. This avenue of discussion is only hypothetical.
 
That's not the kind of interest I had in mind. If teachers are sexually attracted to young students, it isn't the most ideal in the eyes of society.

In the case of EG, we simply don't know how he was attracted to her, so I think the question is open.

You can presuppose one kind of interest, but then you'll just get out of it what you have presupposed.

I'm talking about the guy who sees a younger woman as his mate or potential mate. How many of those men just enjoy the company of young women as opposed to you women's bodies? And again, I did not say it never happens.

It's the men attracted to the young women, not the young women claiming the men lust after them.

I'm pretty sure that in Watson's case, she was the one claiming that he lusted after her or, as she put it, sexualized her. I'm saying that there are other forms of interest that an old person might have in a young person, and that knowledge of the age gap makes me think it more likely that his interest was not sexual per se.
 
In the case of EG, we simply don't know how he was attracted to her, so I think the question is open.

You can presuppose one kind of interest, but then you'll just get out of it what you have presupposed.
Yes. The perceived meaning of my post seems to have drifted a tad. I merely said, "Had RW said [X] ... but she didn't."
 
I honestly have no idea why they flocked to my dad; by no means was he wealthy (my kids know him as the grandpa that lived on our couch). He was pretty transient, going between temporary apartments to living in the actual office of his workplace. What ever he did with them behind closed doors was more than I wanted to know. What we did know was some of them weren't even old enough to legally drink, they all knew about each other and would playfully compete, and he idolized them.

Actually, I just remembered one detail that suggests that he was having sex; he used to give me his unused Viagra at the end of the month. Who he was using his Rx with, though, is something I can't answer.

Maybe I listed to too many installments of Loveline, but it sounds to me like these young women were acting out either against their own fathers or someone else in the family that had mistreated or abused them.
 
There is no shortage of younger women who like older men. My personal experience is that it's likely a maturity thing; young women are more mature than young men on average, and for some of them an older man offers a refreshing change in that respect.
 
I just wanted to post to say that I read the whole thread. Took a few days :)

Since I got this far I might as well throw some wood into this fire and give some personal opinions.

tl;dr (blah blah blah...just ignore)

I first got in inkling of this so called "issue" when I saw PZ giving advice on how to approach people at conventions. My initial response was...ok thanks now why the **** are you giving advice on this crap? If I needed advice on biology you are the person I would listen to, but when it comes to getting laid I would need to see your Casanova credentials.

At some later point I saw RDs response and wondered why he was laying it on so thick. Obviously being hit on was not a big deal. Why was he throwing a sledgehammer out there?

Then I ran into this thread and started reading it and identified the issue pretty early on as this:

RW reflected on a situation. She then drew some conclusions from this situation and basically told guys what they ought not to do.

Ok. Great. I am not her audience so I don't care. I will act in any way that I please and her opinion on any matter is useless on me.

I then noticed that all of the sudden her ought was made universal. I am not sure at which point but then it all clicked in. She and others like her were asking all guys to act a certain way. My reaction was simply. No. **** YOU! If you want me to change my behavior then create a law, otherwise piss off.

I am kind of an abrasive person in real life. I try to be very straight forward and not to beat around the bush. With this manner I turn off the people that would be turned off by that behavior and it saves me a lot of time in not getting to know people I would not like anyway. So it works for me. RWs advice really goes against that grain. Any woman that was intimidated by a polite request is a woman I would rather not get to know any more anyway. The easiest way to eliminate such women would be to maybe say something that would turn them off and focus on the ones that are not bothered by it.

The amount of empathy being asked from me is such that I am unwilling to give it. So to Phill Plaitt attitude of "don't be a dick". Dude I'm fine being a dick and associate with people that understand that and don't get hung up on it. I don't have the time and energy to worry about the rest. If you have a problem with that...guess what. It's your problem.
[/rant]

Sorry I didn't put something more logical up. I had a decision tree diagram prepared in my head but the points have already been made by others.
 
I just wanted to post to say that I read the whole thread. Took a few days :)

Quick, get this man some water!

There should be a ribbon for 'surviving the elevator thread' or something.
 
Quick, get this man some water!

There should be a ribbon for 'surviving the elevator thread' or something.

Wonder how many of us would be there...

at the end all I could think of would be Hot coffee (Mod).

What was sad was to see otherwise intelligent posters engaged in too many logical fallacies.

Is it slowing down finally?
 
Wonder how many of us would be there...

at the end all I could think of would be Hot coffee (Mod).

What was sad was to see otherwise intelligent posters engaged in too many logical fallacies.

Is it slowing down finally?

We're pretty much to the 'hug and kiss and make up' phase. Don't worry, all it takes is one comment to plunge us back into darkness.
 
We're pretty much to the 'hug and kiss and make up' phase. Don't worry, all it takes is one comment to plunge us back into darkness.

Hm...

Elevators/lifts are not dangerous places.No need to be scared...

:redface1

Coffee is just coffe,not sex...

What is unwanted proposition when no proposition intended?

:whistling
So not here.
:runaway

BTW: I couldn't be that guy. He spoke.
 
Hm...

Elevators/lifts are not dangerous places.No need to be scared...

:redface1

Coffee is just coffe,not sex...

What is unwanted proposition when no proposition intended?

:whistling
So not here.
:runaway

BTW: I couldn't be that guy. He spoke.
Nice summary. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom