So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well at least something has finally been resolved.
If that's the level of RW's best repartee then we know for a fact that EG wanted sex rather than conversation.
 
Not buying it, really. A lot of those "Summaries" seem like blatant straw men. Too much straw in this discussion already.

I'm perfectly willing to believe that general opinion might be a little off base somewhere. I just have trouble taking your comments literally--hence, perceiving exaggeration.
What is it you are not buying? Because I've seen the Dawkins straw man repeatedly despite the fact he clarified his meaning and the straw man has been discussed repeatedly.

One of RandFan's recent youtube links had the same Dawkins straw man in it, for example.
 
Of course. Originally, it was meant to fight abuse against women.

Now that this is more-or-less settled, it's meant to whine about things that annoy women.
There are still worthwhile battles to fight. The conduct of EG isn't one of them in my book. But women's false fears about elevators in nice hotels in foreign countries is. ;)
 
Well at least something has finally been resolved.
If that's the level of RW's best repartee then we know for a fact that EG wanted sex rather than conversation.

And granted I have never met the woman, but based on audio, video and photographic records, I still have a problem with that conclusion. Maybe just not my type.
 
This issue has been the challenge to me as a skeptic. It's one of those things that, sure, is a false claim. But I think the discomfort any person feels about being "cornered" is a real one that I would try to always be conscious of.

That's not even the major issue; it's a minor one.

To me a much bigger issue is the fear-mongering about this: the constant comments about how terrifying it is for a woman to get into an elevator at a good hotel, despite the fact that an elevator at a good hotel is safer than almost all environments I can think of.

I can only think of two explanations for this behavior:

1) That they are trying to convince women to be terrified, and therefore keep them away from conventions in hotels.

2) That they are unbelievably stupid.

There is certainly evidence that many women, and some men, do not see how making women as paranoid as possible disempowers them.
 
Ooh...ick. Glad I didn't notice! :)
Sorry, I was jotting notes as the video rolled. I didn't mean it was relevant to anything. ;)

This issue has been the challenge to me as a skeptic. It's one of those things that, sure, is a false claim. But I think the discomfort any person feels about being "cornered" is a real one that I would try to always be conscious of.
I like Linda's point here. Did EG talking to RW increase RW's danger? Or was getting on the elevator with her the issue?

It's likely had he rode the elevator not saying anything that RW would not have blogged that a man got on the elevator with her, guys don't do that.

Are women asking men to not enter an elevator a woman alone is on lest he make her uncomfortable? Should a man get off and offer the car to the woman? Can you see where I'm going with this?

The problem was not talking to RW who felt "cornered". Because if that was the case, then we should expect men not to get on elevators if a woman is alone on them. One would logically feel just as "cornered" had the man spoken or not.



We only have what RW described to go on and she hasn't said the guy's body language was intimidating. She's had plenty of opportunity to add whatever else she based her conclusion about EG on and she's not adding anything except the location, time and words spoken.

IE, if someone is intimidating, there are many locations and times that would make a person uncomfortable and that really is a different debate.
 
Last edited:
One thing that needs to be pointed out is that the elevator incident does not qualify as sexual objectification under the criteria given in her slide. One of the points is that it has to focus primarily on the physical, which EG clearly did not do.

I don't disagree with you. :)
 
I'm really confused. epepke is making the same point. I might be laboring under a misconception of my own. It's kinda blind sided me. Hey, I'm human. Not sold yet but I'll keep at it.

I will forgive you this time but really, it's hard to get into a heated debate with such a charming avatar. It's not fair and tempting me to make my avatar cuddly puppies, in response. :D
 
I will forgive you this time but really, it's hard to get into a heated debate with such a charming avatar. It's not fair and tempting me to make my avatar cuddly puppies, in response. :D

Agreed. I laugh or at least smile every time I look at John Candy's face. Makes me wonder why I chose Roy Cohn (a horrible person) for my avatar. Somehow, to have a likable avatar would be...too easy, too nice, too pleasant.
 
Agreed. I laugh or at least smile every time I look at John Candy's face. Makes me wonder why I chose Roy Cohn (a horrible person) for my avatar. Somehow, to have a likable avatar would be...too easy, too nice, too pleasant.
Sorry for being OT. I find Cohn a very interesting individual. I noticed that Angels in America and Citizen Cohn both used the same conceit of him dying and using Ethel Rosenberg's ghost to haunt him. I suppose that he is to be another of our essence of evil. A man with no redeeming qualities. It's nice to have iconic evil and iconic goodness. I wonder how close reality meets the avatar.

But if I had to chose to spend a day with either. Candy would win hands down. :)
 
Sorry for being OT. I find Cohn a very interesting individual. I noticed that Angels in America and Citizen Cohn both used the same conceit of him dying and using Ethel Rosenberg's ghost to haunt him. I suppose that he is to be another of our essence of evil. A man with no redeeming qualities. It's nice to have iconic evil and iconic goodness. I wonder how close reality meets the avatar.

But if I had to chose to spend a day with either. Candy would win hands down. :)

And my avatars are demons and devils. Go figure !
 
Oh, ****. I saw "1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,51,101,Last". It wasn't until I clicked on "Last" that I realized the "101" was misleadingly paltry.

Now I don't feel so bad.

Linda

Pah! Lightweights...

One of the infamous Amanda Knox continuation threads is 627 pages long and added together they come to something like 1400 pages.
 
Oh, ****. I saw "1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,51,101,Last". It wasn't until I clicked on "Last" that I realized the "101" was misleadingly paltry.

Now I don't feel so bad.

Linda

I give you.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,

Deeper than primes

405 pages. 3 years. 16,181 posts. 401,271 viwes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom