So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
As admin: As these things tend to be subject to Chinese whispers so to try and to ensure the facts don't get obscured by the whispers, my post from the time (the link will also take you to an archived thread that dealt with the matter):
If you don't mind we would rather stick to chinese whispers. I heard Rebecca was banned for planting thermite at 9/11 along with Amanda Knox.
 
Things I learned from the PZ Myers discussion board.

Saying that women in a bar full of drunks should probably expect to have the occasional pass made from guys they don't like = they deserve to get raped for being there. Same with parties where they are dressed like whores.

Hitting on a woman who isn't interested makes you a misogynist.

Making an unwanted pass at a woman is sexual objectification. Nude pin ups are not sexual objectification (that's sexual expression).

I don't agree. Am I crazy? Is it me?

I'd have to look to be sure, but as similar summaries have been made here of content that is far more nuanced than that, I am forced to wonder if there might be some exaggeration in your statement.
 
What is it you define as sexism? I'm not sure where you are coming from here.

What I am getting at is; you copied my post, bolded the part where I said I would have to look back to see if she actually called the incident sexism, and then suggested that it's been cited and quoted many times in this thread, then presented with a link that doesn't actually show anywhere that RW called the Elevator incident and example of sexism.

tyr_13 is correct. I am not trying to define or redifine sexism, nor am I defending her definition of sexism, sexualization, and objectification. I would like to know if you can you actually point out where Rebecca Watson has called EG sexist or his proposition an example of sexism?
 
I'd have to look to be sure, but as similar summaries have been made here of content that is far more nuanced than that, I am forced to wonder if there might be some exaggeration in your statement.

Nah, that's how they roll over there. Remember when Dawkins tried to get them to realize how ridiculous the whole thing is by pointing out what real misogyny looks like. They somehow turned that around into "Dawkins doesn't think we should fix problems here because worse things are happening in other countries".
 
One more. A bit more emotional but some good points.


Okay, emotional? That was pure hyperbole. She did not relay the story as an emotionally traumatic event.

1) She never claimed that the incident did harm her. As an individual and a recognizable public figure, she has the right to say don't do that to me.

2) She didn't call the incident sexism, and has stated many times that she and other women who have emailed her, do not like the unsolicited advances they recieve at skeptic events. She did not say it's harming society, she said that there is a gender imbalance at skeptic events and this is one of the reasons. Feel free to question whether or not that is the case but don't put words in her mouth.

3) She stated flirt, have fun, have sex, etc, she is not ignoring her biology, she just has the right to state when and where, like any other individual...and calling her a stuck up prude is not conducive to anything.

4) On to the no true feminist fallacy (which RW has made as well). Saying, "don't hit on me in an elevator, after I just stated that I wanted to go to sleep," is not exactly being a proponent of sexual oppression. Where did she condemn casual sex? Where did she say anything about people needing to be in a relationship in order to have sex?
 
"do not like the unsolicited advances they recieve at skeptic events"

What's it like when they solicit an advance? How do people go about soliciting an advance?

Is there a way to tell for certain when someone wants an advance?
 
He pronounces superfluous incorrectly.
Ooh...ick. Glad I didn't notice! :)

He repeats the false claim there is a 'special' risk of rape in an elevator.
This issue has been the challenge to me as a skeptic. It's one of those things that, sure, is a false claim. But I think the discomfort any person feels about being "cornered" is a real one that I would try to always be conscious of. I remember following an umpire after a game that consisted of controversial calls against my team. I wanted to tell him it's OK, not everyone on my team is a jerk, and that I thought he actually handled the big blow-up that occurred appropriately. As I got near, I heard him say on his cell phone, "I think one of them is after me!" or words to that effect. I couldn't tell if he was at all speaking tongue-in-cheek.

So I was behaving normally and trying to be the good guy. It was dark, as he was nearing his car where it was parked, and I was a bit larger than he in size, following after him, without sending any signals to put him at ease prior to talking with him. The lesson I took away is that even though I don't think I could have made it any easier on him, any initial concern or fear was understandable, even if there is evidence to the contrary that he might be at extra risk under the circumstances. I see a "woman with a stranger in an elevator" in the same light.

I found it interesting that he brought up the need for guys to sometimes take the risk of making a woman uncomfortable if they ever want to make a move. I haven't seen that issue brought up in the same way in these discussions.
It is interesting, and I think true. As someone who was painfully shy of asking women out on a date, let alone a one-night stand, I can tell you the key problem for me was always that I did not want to put the female in an uncomfortable position. And I'm not just talking about where she is concerned for her safety, I mean even just putting a nice person in the uncomfortable position of letting the geek down gently with a "no." But if one is unable to potentially make another feel uncomfortable, that person might be alone for a long time.
 
Last edited:
1) She never claimed that the incident did harm her. As an individual and a recognizable public figure, she has the right to say don't do that to me.
First off let me say I think criticism of the video is perfectly fine. I'm not here to defend HIS opinion. That said.

Absolutely she has that right. However, when she said, "guys don't do that", in the context of her speech ,I'm not certain that "me" (RW) was her purpose. Arguable I know but it's a fair argument either way and I think given the context it goes to "don't do that to all women".

2) She didn't call the incident sexism...
Do you mean ever? Or just her first vlog? In any event, yes, she did. Start at @12:00



...and has stated many times that she and other women who have emailed her, do not like the unsolicited advances they recieve at skeptic events.
I'm really not sure what point this is supposed to make. This is the kind of stuff driving this whole thing over the edge. What are we to do with that kind of information? It's been oft said that the devil lies in the details and this is may very well be one of those big details.

3) She stated flirt, have fun, have sex, etc, she is not ignoring her biology, she just has the right to state when and where, like any other individual...and calling her a stuck up prude is not conducive to anything.
Perhaps but then she certainly isn't helping anything. "Take a risk, except when you shouldn't." (see the previous video)

4) On to the no true feminist fallacy (which RW has made as well). Saying, "don't hit on me in an elevator, after I just stated that I wanted to go to sleep," is not exactly being a proponent of sexual oppression. Where did she condemn casual sex? Where did she say anything about people needing to be in a relationship in order to have sex?
Seems reasonable....

...and has stated many times that she and other women who have emailed her, do not like the unsolicited advances they recieve at skeptic events.
You are going to need to reconcile these two. If a guy wants to have casual sex with someone how will they do that without making an unsolicited advance? Or are you saying an unsolicited advance is copacetic if the woman makes it? Or is it just skeptics events that RW and these other women have a problem with?

It's these kinds of incongruity that I find frustrating.
 
Last edited:
"do not like the unsolicited advances they recieve at skeptic events"

What's it like when they solicit an advance? How do people go about soliciting an advance?

Is there a way to tell for certain when someone wants an advance?


I think this video on the science of flirting techniques breaks it down nicely. If she's 'soliciting' an advance, she will:

  1. begin with a bright smile, one that comes from her eyes as well as her lips.
  2. say hello and then ask a question that requires more than a yes or no answer.
  3. keep the conversation light (her object is to banter, not get bogged down in a serious discussion).
  4. fiddle a little: with her hair, her jewelry, her clothing (nb: major solicitation tip-off! people do this subconsciously when they're attracted to someone; her doing it intentionally excites you by subliminally telegraphing her interest).
  5. put a "fun" spin on whatever she says; and not break eye contact, unless you're showing her something (hmm).
  6. lean in as she talks (also, if she's really 'soliciting', her feet will be pointed towards you).
  7. touch you lightly on you arm or hand to create a little sexual tension (if it's above the belt; below the belt, a lot of sexual tension: congratulations, muchacho, your advance has just been solicited).
  8. when it's time to go, give you a brief hug or peck on the cheek to convey warmth and reinforce her interest.
So there you have it: the eight telltale signs of solicitation test. Probably not necessary to score a perfect eight out of eight to score; but be warned, the lower the grade, the higher the risk your pass will fail.


:flirt: :groom: :cupid: :eusa_pray:
 
Last edited:
Do you mean ever? Or just her first vlog? In any event, yes, she did. Start at @12:00

I looked from 12' 00" to about 17' 00", and I didn't see it. I saw her talk about "sexual objectification" and linking that to EG, and I saw her refer to McGraw about parroting misogynistic thought, but I didn't see where she referred to what EG was doing as sexism per se.
 
Nah, that's how they roll over there. Remember when Dawkins tried to get them to realize how ridiculous the whole thing is by pointing out what real misogyny looks like. They somehow turned that around into "Dawkins doesn't think we should fix problems here because worse things are happening in other countries".

Not buying it, really. A lot of those "Summaries" seem like blatant straw men. Too much straw in this discussion already.

I'm perfectly willing to believe that general opinion might be a little off base somewhere. I just have trouble taking your comments literally--hence, perceiving exaggeration.
 
First off let me say I think criticism of the video is perfectly fine. I'm not here to defend HIS opinion. That said.

Absolutely she has that right. However, when she said, "guys don't do that", in the context of her speech ,I'm not certain that "me" (RW) was her purpose. Arguable I know but it's a fair argument either way and I think given the context it goes to "don't do that to all women".

Do you mean ever? Or just her first vlog? In any event, yes, she did. Start at @12:00


I watched it last night, and then watched it again, two more times after you linked it, up until about 19 minutes where she goes into her uterus. She called it sexual objectification and even post a definition of sexual objectification, that's not sexism.

I'm really not sure what point this is supposed to make. This is the kind of stuff driving this whole thing over the edge. What are we to do with that kind of information? It's been oft said that the devil lies in the details and this is may very well be one of those big details.

I was just pointing out that he has, throughout his entire vblog, completely misrepresented RW's position. There are completely valid points worth making and it baffles me that he felt compelled to twist it and season it, it order to make his lack of a point, while totally ignoring actual points. For instance, your biggest issue is her stating the Priviledged Delusion. That's a real assertion she made and worth addressing.

Perhaps but then she certainly isn't helping anything. "Take a risk, except when you shouldn't." (see the previous video)

Keep in mind, I am not arguing her justification for saying anything she's said, just pointing out that he is claiming she said things she didn't say. In all honesty, though, she did keep it to a proposition, alone, in an elevator. While there may not be statistics to prove that an elevator is more dangerous than a dark alley, and while not all women might feel the same sense of "no escape if this situation goes awry," I just don't think it's all that crazy to feel a little unnerved. Also, at the beginning of all this, people were listing possibilities of why he might have chosen that method, from him being socially inept to being an Aspie. People wouldn't be making possible excuses for him if they felt it was a completely socially acceptable way to approach another person.

You are going to need to reconcile these two. If a guy wants to have casual sex with someone how will they do that without making an unsolicited advance? Or are you saying an unsolicited advance is copacetic if the woman makes it? Or is it just skeptics events that RW and these other women have a problem with?

It's these kinds of incongruity that I find frustrating.

I can't reconcile anything for RW. As I stated, I appreciated advances over being invisible. I could give advice but it would only be what would be successful for me. I can certainly understand the jumping from one foot to the other, sensation but you also have to understand that there is not only one type of woman. Some enjoy completely anonymous sex, with no names involved, some enjoy a brief period of verbal game playing and seduction before having casual sex, some prefer friends with benefits, and some prefer relationship sex, and some dabble in all of the above. How you choose to navigate that mine field is entirely up to you.
 
I looked from 12' 00" to about 17' 00", and I didn't see it. I saw her talk about "sexual objectification" and linking that to EG, and I saw her refer to McGraw about parroting misogynistic thought, but I didn't see where she referred to what EG was doing as sexism per se.
Hey, I might be wrong. I'm happy to concede that possibility. What was her point if it wasn't that EG's actions were sexist? I'll look at it again... like I'm dying to do that. :)
 
I watched it last night, and then watched it again, two more times after you linked it, up until about 19 minutes where she goes into her uterus. She called it sexual objectification and even post a definition of sexual objectification, that's not sexism.

One thing that needs to be pointed out is that the elevator incident does not qualify as sexual objectification under the criteria given in her slide. One of the points is that it has to focus primarily on the physical, which EG clearly did not do.
 
I watched it last night, and then watched it again, two more times after you linked it, up until about 19 minutes where she goes into her uterus. She called it sexual objectification and even post a definition of sexual objectification, that's not sexism.
I'm really confused. epepke is making the same point. I might be laboring under a misconception of my own. It's kinda blind sided me. Hey, I'm human. Not sold yet but I'll keep at it.

I was just pointing out that he has, throughout his entire vblog, completely misrepresented RW's position.
I can't agree with "completely" but that's fine. We can move on.

There are completely valid points worth making and it baffles me that he felt compelled to twist it and season it, it order to make his lack of a point, while totally ignoring actual points. For instance, your biggest issue is her stating the Priviledged Delusion. That's a real assertion she made and worth addressing.



Keep in mind, I am not arguing her justification for saying anything she's said, just pointing out that he is claiming she said things she didn't say. In all honesty, though, she did keep it to a proposition, alone, in an elevator. While there may not be statistics to prove that an elevator is more dangerous than a dark alley, and while not all women might feel the same sense of "no escape if this situation goes awry," I just don't think it's all that crazy to feel a little unnerved. Also, at the beginning of all this, people were listing possibilities of why he might have chosen that method, from him being socially inept to being an Aspie. People wouldn't be making possible excuses for him if they felt it was a completely socially acceptable way to approach another person.

I can't reconcile anything for RW. As I stated, I appreciated advances over being invisible. I could give advice but it would only be what would be successful for me. I can certainly understand the jumping from one foot to the other, sensation but you also have to understand that there is not only one type of woman. Some enjoy completely anonymous sex, with no names involved, some enjoy a brief period of verbal game playing and seduction before having casual sex, some prefer friends with benefits, and some prefer relationship sex, and some dabble in all of the above. How you choose to navigate that mine field is entirely up to you.
I've no complaints. :)
 
Hey, I might be wrong. I'm happy to concede that possibility. What was her point if it wasn't that EG's actions were sexist? I'll look at it again... like I'm dying to do that. :)

I don't know that she has a point, frankly. All I see is a bunch of hand-waving and blathering which isn't about the subject of her talk. I don't even know if she eventually talked about the religious right, because I didn't watch the rest.

In the absence of an honest argument with some reason in it, I don't even know how to get to the idea that there is a point.

It reminds me of an old story about a kid who spends all day digging through the manure in a stable thinking "there has to be a pony in here somewhere."
 
There's a point where Ann asks something to the effect of: "There are plenty of socially awkward men, should we consider their feelings?" To which RW replies: "No, they should better themselves."

Ah, so taking people's feelings in consideration is a one-way street for her, then ?
 
I don't know that she has a point, frankly. All I see is a bunch of hand-waving and blathering which isn't about the subject of her talk. I don't even know if she eventually talked about the religious right, because I didn't watch the rest.

In the absence of an honest argument with some reason in it, I don't even know how to get to the idea that there is a point.

It reminds me of an old story about a kid who spends all day digging through the manure in a stable thinking "there has to be a pony in here somewhere."
:) Fair enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom