So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think this video on the science of flirting techniques breaks it down nicely. If she's 'soliciting' an advance, she will:

  1. begin with a bright smile, one that comes from her eyes as well as her lips.
  2. say hello and then ask a question that requires more than a yes or no answer.
  3. keep the conversation light (her object is to banter, not get bogged down in a serious discussion).
  4. fiddle a little: with her hair, her jewelry, her clothing (nb: major solicitation tip-off! people do this subconsciously when they're attracted to someone; her doing it intentionally excites you by subliminally telegraphing her interest).
  5. put a "fun" spin on whatever she says; and not break eye contact, unless you're showing her something (hmm).
  6. lean in as she talks (also, if she's really 'soliciting', her feet will be pointed towards you).
  7. touch you lightly on you arm or hand to create a little sexual tension (if it's above the belt; below the belt, a lot of sexual tension: congratulations, muchacho, your advance has just been solicited).
  8. when it's time to go, give you a brief hug or peck on the cheek to convey warmth and reinforce her interest.
So there you have it: the eight telltale signs of solicitation test. Probably not necessary to score a perfect eight out of eight to score; but be warned, the lower the grade, the higher the risk your pass will fail.


:flirt: :groom: :cupid: :eusa_pray:

"the higher the risk your pass will fail"

Ah, there's always a risk of that. And if you're wrong - misogynist! actually based on my limited knowledge, women aren't usually as straight forward as that list makes them sound.

Mmm. I wonder if she, in her drunken stupor, smiled or locked eyes with him at some point that night without even realizing it. Or, I don't know, maybe even did so on purpose so she'd have a story to tell? Nah, that's just more misogyny.
 
Last edited:
One thing that needs to be pointed out is that the elevator incident does not qualify as sexual objectification under the criteria given in her slide. One of the points is that it has to focus primarily on the physical, which EG clearly did not do.

Yes, but I think their position is that the unspoken thing was that he wanted to sleep with her, and since sex focuses on the physical or something, he was in effect focusing on her physically.

Very nuanced, some of these feminists arguments. Nuance inside of nuance. Really, can they blame some of us for "not getting it"?
 
And granted I have never met the woman, but based on audio, video and photographic records, I still have a problem with that conclusion. Maybe just not my type.

I think you have to factor in the fact that they were leaving a bar at 4 am after a long night of drinking. Not a time when peoples' judgement is at its best.
 
Oh, ****. I saw "1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,51,101,Last". It wasn't until I clicked on "Last" that I realized the "101" was misleadingly paltry.

Now I don't feel so bad.

Linda
The Amanda Knox thread is on it's third full thread (they have to be closed and restarted when they take up too much bandwidth or something. And it's been going on over a year, 3 years I think. But I don't know if that is longer than that truther thread or not.
 
That's not even the major issue; it's a minor one.
Well, to me it was the key issue when I first saw RW's original video blog. I saw it almost as an aside, "Oh, by the way guys, don't do this." I didn't read any terror into what she was saying, and I really didn't start seeing what the big deal was about anything RW said early on, until she called out Stef in public...and then a lot of the rest that followed of course.

To me a much bigger issue is the fear-mongering about this: the constant comments about how terrifying it is for a woman to get into an elevator at a good hotel, despite the fact that an elevator at a good hotel is safer than almost all environments I can think of.
I've never personally been told or read much along the lines that getting into an elevator in a good hotel is "terrifying," nor is it what RW was describing, so I'm not really interested in addressing it.
I can only think of two explanations for this behavior:

1) That they are trying to convince women to be terrified, and therefore keep them away from conventions in hotels.

2) That they are unbelievably stupid.

There is certainly evidence that many women, and some men, do not see how making women as paranoid as possible disempowers them.
Hey, politicians use the same concept to get (re)elected! :)
 
Sorry, I was jotting notes as the video rolled. I didn't mean it was relevant to anything. ;)
I didn't take it as meaning to be relevant. Just annoying to sound it out in my head. :)

I like Linda's point here. Did EG talking to RW increase RW's danger?
By itself, I would guess no.
Or was getting on the elevator with her the issue?
By itself, again, I would guess no.
It's likely had he rode the elevator not saying anything that RW would not have blogged that a man got on the elevator with her, guys don't do that.
Agreed.

Are women asking men to not enter an elevator a woman alone is on lest he make her uncomfortable?
That's not what I got out of anything RW said, at least.
Should a man get off and offer the car to the woman?
Not necessary to, as I see it.
Can you see where I'm going with this?
Not really, honestly.

The problem was not talking to RW who felt "cornered". Because if that was the case, then we should expect men not to get on elevators if a woman is alone on them. One would logically feel just as "cornered" had the man spoken or not.
I agree that it alone was not the problem. It was the sum of the whole picture. I put "cornered" in quotes for a reason. It's a feeling to be "cornered," not just because you're alone with someone, but because there are certain circumstances in addition to being alone with that person that make it feel awkward at best, terrifying at worst. (You can feel "cornered" without feeling in danger.)

I would suspect RW's feeling was very close to the former, at least based on the original blog video post. (I don't know what the heck happened after that! :)) I took it as advice not to do this, not because she necessarily felt frightened, but that because of all the circumstances and how someone could reasonably feel about it, it's just a very bad idea.

We only have what RW described to go on and she hasn't said the guy's body language was intimidating. She's had plenty of opportunity to add whatever else she based her conclusion about EG on and she's not adding anything except the location, time and words spoken.
I agree.

IE, if someone is intimidating, there are many locations and times that would make a person uncomfortable and that really is a different debate.
Again, agreed.
 
Last edited:
Well, to me it was the key issue when I first saw RW's original video blog. I saw it almost as an aside, "Oh, by the way guys, don't do this." I didn't read any terror into what she was saying, and I really didn't start seeing what the big deal was about anything RW said early on, until she called out Stef in public...and then a lot of the rest that followed of course....
I'm pretty sure you missed the point. The reason a lot of what's on RW's first video is a side issue, is the debate is about her later comments, it is not about her first comments.
 
...
[Just getting on the elevator was] not what I got out of anything RW said, at least. Not necessary to, as I see it....

Not really, honestly.
Well let me stop you and try to explain.

If talking was not the issue, and getting on the elevator was not the issue, how can the combination become an issue?

I'm not saying combined things can never be bad when uncombined they are not. If you mix bleach with ammonia, chlorine gas is released. But in the elevator example, how does the elevator make the come-on worse and vice versa?

What Linda pointed out was that talking to someone on the elevator did not make rape more likely. In fact, it made it less likely.

If RW were not a marketed skeptic, we could give her leeway for her poor logic. But she brands herself as a skeptic and logical thinker. It would be clear to someone using logic, that talking to the woman on the elevator was not any more creepy than riding the elevator without talking. Either the words EG spoke were creepy or they were not. But adding the fact the words were spoken on the elevator should have made the elevator encounter less creepy, not more creepy.


I don't buy the "cornered" premise. It has not been substantiated. Rather it seems people are accepting it without critical analysis.
 
I'm pretty sure you missed the point. The reason a lot of what's on RW's first video is a side issue, is the debate is about her later comments, it is not about her first comments.
It doesn't sound like I missed the point at all then.
 
Well let me stop you and try to explain.

If talking was not the issue, and getting on the elevator was not the issue, how can the combination become an issue?

I'm not saying combined things can never be bad when uncombined they are not. If you mix bleach with ammonia, chlorine gas is released. But in the elevator example, how does the elevator make the come-on worse and vice versa?

What Linda pointed out was that talking to someone on the elevator did not make rape more likely. In fact, it made it less likely.

If RW were not a marketed skeptic, we could give her leeway for her poor logic. But she brands herself as a skeptic and logical thinker. It would be clear to someone using logic, that talking to the woman on the elevator was not any more creepy than riding the elevator without talking. Either the words EG spoke were creepy or they were not. But adding the fact the words were spoken on the elevator should have made the elevator encounter less creepy, not more creepy.


I don't buy the "cornered" premise. It has not been substantiated. Rather it seems people are accepting it without critical analysis.
You've misunderstood me if you think my position is that talking + elevator = creepy or dangerous.
 
Well, to me it was the key issue when I first saw RW's original video blog. I saw it almost as an aside, "Oh, by the way guys, don't do this." I didn't read any terror into what she was saying, and I really didn't start seeing what the big deal was about anything RW said early on, until she called out Stef in public...and then a lot of the rest that followed of course.

I had the same experience.

I've never personally been told or read much along the lines that getting into an elevator in a good hotel is "terrifying," nor is it what RW was describing, so I'm not really interested in addressing it.Hey, politicians use the same concept to get (re)elected! :)

I have. There's some of it going on here, mostly in another thread.

As for politicians, well, that is what they do. I am interested in skepticism, though, and I would not like advertising for skepticism be along the lines of, "Become a skeptic! It's as scummy as politics but not as well paid!"
 
Depends on your definition of sexist, but one could easily hate women without the attitude that they are inferior because of their gender.

Hating someone solely based on their gender is sexist. Same as hating someone solely based on their race is racist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom