So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hating someone solely based on their gender is sexist. Same as hating someone solely based on their race is racist.

Well obviously if you define sexist that way it is, that is why I said it depended on the definition.

When I looked up the definition of racism 10+ years ago in the dictionary it mentioned the innate belief of superiority because of race and you could have hatred without this belief, some people might be similarly operating under this definition which has changed.
 
Last edited:
Well obviously if you define sexist that way it is, that is why I said it depended on the definition.

Sexism is discrimination based on gender, correct?

I can't see how misogyny is not discrimination based on gender.
 
Sexism is discrimination based on gender, correct?

I can't see how misogyny is not discrimination based on gender.

I was thinking of the definition along the lines of believing a person to be inferior because of their gender.

You could argue that hatred itself is a form of discrimination, but in the same way someone who loved a certain gender would be sexist and loved a particular race would be racist.
 
"the higher the risk your pass will fail"

Ah, there's always a risk of that. And if you're wrong - misogynist! actually based on my limited knowledge, women aren't usually as straight forward as that list makes them sound.

Mmm. I wonder if she, in her drunken stupor, smiled or locked eyes with him at some point that night without even realizing it. Or, I don't know, maybe even did so on purpose so she'd have a story to tell? Nah, that's just more misogyny.


Ah, misogyny and the unsolicited advance. :balcony (Bit of a leap...)

I'm being mostly facetious with that 'scientific' list, of course. Just to point out that while there are in our culture fairly common ways and means to "solicit an advance" (i.e. flirt, accepting for the moment the tradition that it's the woman's prerogative), any list one attempts will be controversial and inadequate. Part of social fluency (vs the social ineptitude EG has frequently been charged with) seems to be familiarity with this sort of list, the ability to handle it appropriately, suavely, with aplomb, and various other vague phrases denoting one's social iq.

It's easier with practice (they tell me & EG); but practice itself involves innocent trial-and-error, and no one's ever perfect at it; we tend to make the rules up as we go along, to separate the artists from the rule-followers, I suppose. It seems there are a lot of women who are uncomfortable at events where they are outnumbered, such as skeptic cons; if guys are aware of this (speaking of heterosexual cases for simplicity), maybe they'll be a bit warier about making a pass. Won't assume that every woman there meets the criteria in the Skepchicks solicited promo: "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds"? If that change in attitude is one outcome of all this wrangle, probably a good thing.

But it's never going to be as literal and well-defined as skeptics would like. And high-profile counterexamples of unsolicited advances working out abound (the US President and First Lady, e.g. -- she says she had no interest in him at first; but his stubborn persistence paid off, obviously. Of course there are ways and there are ways: did Barack, finding Michelle interesting and himself in an elevator with her, ever, not wanting to be taken the wrong way, invite her up to his room for "coffee" after drinking with others til 4 AM then sharing an elevator in a foreign country, her having spoken about the difficulties women face the previous evening and revealing later she suffers from prosopagnosia? If so, look for it in The Audacity of Hope II: How a Skinny Nerd Scored a Righteous Babe on a Cup a Joe, a Prayer, an Elevator and a Crippling Bout of Prosopagnosia (aka "Barack Off? Not this Nerd, Sister!"), coming to a kindle-store near you.) :mglook
 
Last edited:
I was thinking of the definition along the lines of believing a person to be inferior because of their gender.

You could argue that hatred itself is a form of discrimination, but in the same way someone who loved a certain gender would be sexist and loved a particular race would be racist.

I would still argue that misogyny, being defined as treating someone poorly (hating someone) based on their gender, is no less than sexism. Even your chosen definition.

ETA: And since we're starting to just go in semantic loop-de-loops, I'm going to drop this line of argument :D
 
Being both a misongynist and a misandrist is like being fifteen plus fifteen years old. We have misanthrope and thirty.

Not if you love people with intersex conditions. Unless you don't think they qualify as people? Why do you hate them? :mad:







;)
 
Depends on your definition of sexist, but one could easily hate women without the attitude that they are inferior because of their gender.

I agree with DonkeyBob, if you hate based on gender and not some individual reason, that is sexism. You've chosen "believe women are inferior", but "hate women" is equally sexist. I would imagine if a woman hated men and didn't think them inferior that would be sexist.

And if you think about it, why does the misogynist hate them? It has to be for some imagined quality making it sexist.
 
Well obviously if you define sexist that way it is, that is why I said it depended on the definition.

When I looked up the definition of racism 10+ years ago in the dictionary it mentioned the innate belief of superiority because of race and you could have hatred without this belief, some people might be similarly operating under this definition which has changed.
Perhaps you mis-remember the definition, misread the definition, or the definition was not complete.

I'm pretty sure all it takes is hating people of a certain ethnicity to be considered a racist.
 
Well obviously if you define sexist that way it is, that is why I said it depended on the definition.

When I looked up the definition of racism 10+ years ago in the dictionary it mentioned the innate belief of superiority because of race and you could have hatred without this belief, some people might be similarly operating under this definition which has changed.
Perhaps you mis-remember the definition, misread the definition, or the definition was not complete.

I'm pretty sure all it takes is hating people of a certain ethnicity to be considered a racist.
It was one of the usages. If you look at a dictionary you will find that there is often more than one meaning.

People often say things like "a square is by definition not a circle" And perhaps that is always true but a square has more than one meaning. When using the idiom "don't be a square", people don't mean an equilateral rectangle.
 
Ah, misogyny and the unsolicited advance. :balcony (Bit of a leap...)

.... Won't assume that every woman there meets the criteria in the Skepchicks solicited promo: "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds"? If that change in attitude is one outcome of all this wrangle, probably a good thing.
Considering they used a demeaning image of the sex-pot nurse in the Tdap promo, it would seem the ladies might be having trouble with their evolving feminism.

[Catty evidence-less speculating, don't take this the wrong way. ;) ] I can picture this happy crowd of women who like their sexy image suddenly faced with a group leader who made an unthinking comment because she really wanted to let people know guys hit on her. [/Catty evidence-less] The comment had unforeseen consequences to which the leader who made said comment dug herself in deeper by trying to justify her public comment using the, "I am woman, don't hit on me if I believe I said so earlier", rationale. This position, however, is in direct conflict with the group's promoting themselves as sexy. Now they all have to choose between adopting this new feminism of "guys, don't do that" and their old feminist promoted self image of "guys, do do that, we are comfortable with our sexuality". We also have evidence that RW removed certain items promoting the 'we are sexy' image from her web site. Will the calendar be the next casualty of the rationalization of the casual comment? Will the group ignore the hypocrisy and carry on as if nothing changed? [/Speculating]


But it's never going to be as literal and well-defined as skeptics would like. And high-profile counterexamples of unsolicited advances working out abound (the US President and First Lady, e.g. -- she says she had no interest in him at first; but his stubborn persistence paid off, obviously. ...
Persistance is also one of the fantasy love themes in the best-selling-to-teens (aka not a going out of style theme) Twilight Saga. The fantasy is that someone loves you so much they persist against constant rejection. Some women like the idea of a man being that intensely in love with them before the woman shows any love back. The protagonist in the story does eventually reciprocate the persistent love, though she still leaves him for the love at first sight guy.

[Side thought] Maybe I should consider writing a romance novel with a 'best friends, equal partners and lovers' fantasy. I wonder if it would sell? [/side thought]
 
Last edited:
[Side thought] Maybe I should consider writing a romance novel with a 'best friends, equal partners and lovers' fantasy. I wonder if it would sell? [/side thought]
I say "go for it". Just make damn sure there is a scene in the elevator where a guy asks a girl to go for coffee while they are in an elevator.
 
I say "go for it". Just make damn sure there is a scene in the elevator where a guy asks a girl to go for coffee while they are in an elevator.
Oh man, that would be classic. But I would say SG should definitely be on the set when they make it into a movie, because you never know how the director will have the actor ask, "Would you like to come to my room for some coffee?"
 
Oh man, that would be classic. But I would say SG should definitely be on the set when they make it into a movie, because you never know how the director will have the actor ask, "Would you like to come to my room for some coffee?"
Thanks for the compliment. You are already predicting my novel will be a success. :D
 
According the the wikipedia definitions, misogyny is the hatred or dislike of women and sexism is the application of a dislike of either sex or the blind application of gender stereotypes. It appears that you can be sexist without being a misogynist but you can't be a misogynist without being a sexist. You can apply stereotypes without disliking the group.
 
Sometimes I like women, sometimes I don't; and there's no rhyme or reason to it whatsoever.
I've been diagnosed as a hitormisogynist :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom