So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you listen critically, all of her anecdotes up to the point were people contacting her or commenting on her stuff directly. Not a single person was named. At 12:00 in is when she shifts gears to something that was not sent to her, which is a marked departure.

Thanks for the time stamp. This is when Watson said "parroting of misogynistic thought," earlier than I had thought. She claimed that the real problematic statement of McGraff's is "My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her." That's "parroting of misogynistic thought" to Watson.

Yes, she makes this clear. She really does mean that having a concern about that is parroting misogynistic thought.
 
It's funny how she tends to leave out details that make her look bad, or create details that make her look better isn't it?
Well, this is human nature, after all.

I do agree though, that the attraction to RW by some in the skeptical community is greater than the benefit the community seems to be getting in return.
 
An interesting, unemotional look at the affair.

I liked the discussion overall.

Here are my only nitpicks: He responds to the same straw man against Dawkins that has been refuted. He pronounces superfluous incorrectly. His discussion of the email "rape threat" against RW misses the point that it is a red herring. He repeats the false claim there is a 'special' risk of rape in an elevator. Taking precautions is not the same as expecting men refrain from talking to single women on elevators.

I found it interesting that he brought up the need for guys to sometimes take the risk of making a woman uncomfortable if they ever want to make a move. I haven't seen that issue brought up in the same way in these discussions.
 
Last edited:
Things I learned from the PZ Myers discussion board.

Saying that women in a bar full of drunks should probably expect to have the occasional pass made from guys they don't like = they deserve to get raped for being there. Same with parties where they are dressed like whores.

Hitting on a woman who isn't interested makes you a misogynist.

Making an unwanted pass at a woman is sexual objectification. Nude pin ups are not sexual objectification (that's sexual expression).

I don't agree. Am I crazy? Is it me?
 
I liked the discussion overall.

Here are my only nitpicks: He responds to the same straw man against Dawkins that has been refuted. He pronounces superfluous incorrectly. His discussion of the email "rape threat" against RW misses the point that it is a red herring. He repeats the false claim there is a 'special' risk of rape in an elevator. Taking precautions is not the same as expecting men refrain from talking to single women on elevators.

I found it interesting that he brought up the need for guys to sometimes take the risk of making a woman uncomfortable if they ever want to make a move. I haven't seen that issue brought up in the same way in these discussions.
Agreed. Plus he missed some of the more egregious errors of ad honinem and others. But I liked the attempt to br fair and level headed. And yes, liked that riskof making someone uncomfortable was stressed as a reality of social interaction.

I've made people feel uncomfortable, Iv'e been made to feel uncomfortable.
 
...snip...

I say that it brings me joy only because the tale of my banning from the forum is one of my favorite stories to tell at parties. In fact, someone at the SGU dinner at TAM 9 asked me about it and I told the table of 10 or 12 the entire tale. It's true: seven years ago I had my own account ("rebecca") and a sock puppet ("Radial Tire") that the admin and moderators knew about for a year or two before they suspended me for it.

...snip...

As admin: since sock puppet accounts have not been allowed and I have been an admin (July 2004) we have never allowed an account that we have had sufficient evidence or confidence to conclude that it is a sock puppet remain unchallenged on the Forum. If anybody on the moderating team did know that rebecca was using a sock puppet (ETA) and took no action then they were in breach of their Moderator Agreement.
Posted By: Darat
 
Last edited:
:wide-eyed That's "one of [her] favorite stories to tell at parties"?! Quite the raconteuse, one imagines:


:fg:

:slp::slp::slp:
 
Last edited:
As admin: since sock puppet accounts have not been allowed and I have been an admin (July 2004) we have never allowed an account that we have had sufficient evidence or confidence to conclude that it is a sock puppet remain unchallenged on the Forum. If anybody on the moderating team did know that rebecca was using a sock puppet (ETA) and took no action then they were in breach of their Moderator Agreement.
Posted By: Darat

When was Rebecca a moderator? Was she in breach of the Moderator Agreement herself?

Her join date as rebecca appears to be 2004, and she was posting as Radial Tire in May 2005; I can't tell when that account became active. The sock was not apparently detected until May 2008. Her recollection of some of the details, at least, seems a little off.
 
When was Rebecca a moderator? Was she in breach of the Moderator Agreement herself?

Her join date as rebecca appears to be 2004, and she was posting as Radial Tire in May 2005; I can't tell when that account became active. The sock was not apparently detected until May 2008. Her recollection of some of the details, at least, seems a little off.

As admin:

She agreed to abide by the Moderator Agreement on "5th October 2005, 02:14 AM", the date stamp is taken direct from the thread in the moderator only section in which all new members of the Moderating Team have to agree to follow the Moderator Agreement.

At that time there would still be some sock puppets accounts floating around that were perfectly OK when they were created (sock puppets were at one time allowed). Just having an old sock puppet account would have been fine but using it - obviously not.
 
When was Rebecca a moderator? Was she in breach of the Moderator Agreement herself?

Her join date as rebecca appears to be 2004, and she was posting as Radial Tire in May 2005; I can't tell when that account became active. The sock was not apparently detected until May 2008. Her recollection of some of the details, at least, seems a little off.
As I recall she was not bannned for having a sock. She was banned for posting members priviate information gained from the moderator section.

Could be wrong. My version doesn't sound like a dinner party boast.
 
As I recall she was not bannned for having a sock. She was banned for posting members priviate information gained from the moderator section.

Could be wrong. My version doesn't sound like a dinner party boast.

Yeah. I pointed out that she was banned for her mischief as a moderator, not the sock puppet thing, and she did a quick follow up post where she stated she was banned for banning a friend of hers as a joke when she got moderator powers.

Great story. She must have everyone rolling when she tells that one.
 
Last edited:
Banning notice
Jeff Wagg said:
Rebecca has been banned under unusual circumstances following her actions regarding a flaw in the auto-unsuspension tool in the forum software. She was accidentally given powers that she wasn't entitled to, and rather than report that fact, she used them to cause mischief. We cannot allow this type of behavior on the forum.

This decision was made by the JREF staff, and not the administrators or moderators of the forum.
 
As I recall she was not bannned for having a sock. She was banned for posting members priviate information gained from the moderator section.

Well, you and I remember it like that, but since Rebecca remembers it differently, I suggest we both avoid elevators.

ETA: The banning did follow from her actions after the suspension for having a sock puppet expired, when, apparently due to a bug in the forum software, she was reinstated with the moderator powers she had once been entitled to.
 
Last edited:
Yeah. I pointed out that she was banned for her mischief as a moderator, not the sock puppet thing, and she did a quick follow up post where she stated she was banned for banning a friend of hers as a joke when she got moderator powers.

Great story. She must have everyone rolling when she tells that one.

I think you may have misunderstood the story. The mods can correct me if I'm wrong.

It is my understanding that, at the time she was banned, rebecca was not a mod at all. What happened was her account was suspended for some infraction. When her suspension was lifted, some glitch in the software restored her mod powers from far previous times when she actually was a mod.

She then started a thread bragging about it, and people in the thread said things like "Oooh, ban me!" and she did. She also posted screencaps of the moderator section of the forum, which contains all reports and complaints, and all discussion between mods regarding mod actions.

Could be misremembering. Who knows. It was a while ago.
 
Yeah. I pointed out that she was banned for her mischief as a moderator, not the sock puppet thing, and she did a quick follow up post where she stated she was banned for banning a friend of hers as a joke when she got moderator powers.

Great story. She must have everyone rolling when she tells that one.

As admin: As these things tend to be subject to Chinese whispers so to try and to ensure the facts don't get obscured by the whispers, my post from the time (the link will also take you to an archived thread that dealt with the matter):

The facts:

When rebecca's recent suspension was lifted the account was reset to be a member of the "moderators" usergroup. The lifting of suspensions is an automated feature of the software. This may be a bug with the software somehow related to the fact that at one time rebecca was a moderator (no other accounts that have been "auto-unsuspended" have been reset to an incorrect usergroup).

rebecca then accessed the mod-only section of the Forum and also the profiles of two Members, she made various edits to posts and banned the two accounts she accessed.

All moderator and admin actions are automatically logged by the software so we could access exactly what she looked at and how she had used the moderator permissions that came with the mistaken usergroup. rebecca did not inform any of the admins or Jeff that her account had been reset incorrectly.

When I realized what had happened, I banned her account, checked the log to determine exactly what she had done and reversed her actions. I then referred the matter to the JREF.
 
I think you may have misunderstood the story. The mods can correct me if I'm wrong.

It is my understanding that, at the time she was banned, rebecca was not a mod at all. What happened was her account was suspended for some infraction. When her suspension was lifted, some glitch in the software restored her mod powers from far previous times when she actually was a mod.

She then started a thread bragging about it, and people in the thread said things like "Oooh, ban me!" and she did. She also posted screencaps of the moderator section of the forum, which contains all reports and complaints, and all discussion between mods regarding mod actions.

Could be misremembering. Who knows. It was a while ago.

I'm just relating what she posted. Actually she did say the moderator powers came from an error. Guess I should have been more clear.

Anyway, that's a lot different then being banned for having a sock puppet account that the mods supposedly knew about and allowed for a few years.

But yeah, probably just innocent misremembering. Watson doesn't seem to be real strong in that department.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom