Did you really think that was brutal? I didn't. I saw it as a reasoned response to a different opinion.
You just said it was brutal. In fact, you were the first person in this thread to use the word brutal.
And is that really the bar that you want to set? If Deepak Chopra were in the audience of a lecture, would you ask the speaker to ignore a recent article that perfectly illustrates a point merely because Chopra wouldn't be able to respond at that moment? Why does being an unknown make a difference.
Skeptics write articles about other skeptics, skeptics call each other out. If the movement is actually devoted to rational thinking, this should be welcome. If there should be guidelines to protect the ego of skeptics, then the movement needs to establish them. At the time Watson's lecture was given, no such rules had even been discussed.
Many people have been saying that Watson's position in the elevator incident is anti-feminist. That "protecting" women from discomfort weakens them because it implies that they can not take care of themselves. Why would an unwanted critique of a publicly made statement be any different. Why should McGraw be "protected" from having her own words analyzed?
Talk about the apple in the pot calling the straw in the kettle orange.
Honestly, I find RW painful to listen to. She's a terrible public speaker with all those "uhs" and "ums" combined with sentence fragments that trail off. I mean, really painful. I'd probably walk out rather than stay and listen.
Anyway, her talk was supposed to be about, "The Religious Right vs. Every Woman on Earth." It's right there in big, bold letters at the top of the YouTube video. She drones on for 15 minutes about skeptics and her personal dealings with sexism. That's unprofessional, as several have pointed out.
If you listen critically, all of her anecdotes up to the point were people contacting her or commenting on her stuff directly. Not a single person was named. At 12:00 in is when she shifts gears to something that was not sent to her, which is a marked departure.
She then proceeds to point out that it's "one of your own." It really doesn't matter how "reasonable" you think the argument was. That was an ambush directed at a specific person, and she used the podium as a bully pulpit.
What really *********** cracks me up is that she says,
"I'm not doing this to embarrass this person." Not more than two minutes before she ridiculed EG for saying, "Don't take this the wrong way" and likened it to people saying, "I'm not racist."
Anyway, she starts her "reasonable" argument by telling the audience that what she's about to say will embarrass this person. She then immediately says there's a problem when "young women are this ignorant about feminism." Why the hell did RW even need to get into it? It was a complete non-sequitur from the first 12 minutes, and the first 12 minutes had little if anything to do with the subject at hand.
I'm not going to go into any more detail. I think I've presented more than enough evidence of how unprofessional she is and how she bullied this person. Yes, BULLY, because the power was clearly unequal, unlike the elevator incident. I don't care that the blogger was a woman. I'm not saying she or anyone else needs to be protected.
I didn't respect RW before elevatorgate, and I've seen nothing to change my mind.