So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
As far as I can tell, this is correct. She hasn't called the EG incident an example of sexism. At first, she only called it "sexualization" and later "objectification."

So the difference you two are making is, if you want sex that is different from prejudice against the female gender.

I think I get what you are saying now. It makes sense.
 
You can take this any way you want, but you aren't very good at reading meaning into what people say, and about communicating some of your own points.

I don't have a clue what, "rushing about with the goalposts" means. But I doubt it matters because I suspect it is another false charge.

I've seen this in other fora.

It's stated by people who keep insisting, in the face of all evidence, that the reason people have come to think poorly of Watson is based on the original EG incident and Watson's original blog. This, of course, is a straw man. It's always been about subsequent statements and reactions, where Watson has obviously escalated.

When there are enough statements by enough people that this is a straw man, then they switch to claiming that the goal posts have been changed. Since the reasons for the reaction are different from what they have been claiming, they call it a switching of the goal posts.

There is not enough information to decide whether such people were ill informed and really couldn't figure it out or could figure it out and hoped that by enough emotive language they could turn the tone of a discussion in their direction, and now it is clear that this doesn't work, so another tactic is to be tried.

If it is viewed tactically, I cannot fault the tactics. It quite frequently works, especially if you work rape or something emotive in there somewhere. @meg seems to be trying this in another thread. However, due perhaps to the audience or the accumulation of evidence or something, it doesn't seem to be working.
 
I've seen this in other fora.

It's stated by people who keep insisting, in the face of all evidence, that the reason people have come to think poorly of Watson is based on the original EG incident and Watson's original blog. This, of course, is a straw man. It's always been about subsequent statements and reactions, where Watson has obviously escalated.

When there are enough statements by enough people that this is a straw man, then they switch to claiming that the goal posts have been changed. Since the reasons for the reaction are different from what they have been claiming, they call it a switching of the goal posts.

There is not enough information to decide whether such people were ill informed and really couldn't figure it out or could figure it out and hoped that by enough emotive language they could turn the tone of a discussion in their direction, and now it is clear that this doesn't work, so another tactic is to be tried.

If it is viewed tactically, I cannot fault the tactics. It quite frequently works, especially if you work rape or something emotive in there somewhere. @meg seems to be trying this in another thread. However, due perhaps to the audience or the accumulation of evidence or something, it doesn't seem to be working.
Agreed.
 
I'm so glad someone said this. I've been hesitating to as it sounds so catty coming from me.

It's far from the cattiest. Two or three weeks ago, when this was pretty new, I showed the original video to my oldest and most seasoned girlfriend, telling her some of the details and background. She responded with words to this effect:

She's ticked off because he took "no" for an answer. If he had persisted a bit, she would have been happy. Because he didn't, she has to make this into a story about how uncomfortable it made her feel to be sexualized.

I offer this without comment.
 
It's far from the cattiest. Two or three weeks ago, when this was pretty new, I showed the original video to my oldest and most seasoned girlfriend, telling her some of the details and background. She responded with words to this effect:



I offer this without comment.


I was going to make a joke about, 'how many girlfriends do you have and what are their age and seasoning range?' but instead I'll go with, 'I hope she doesn't know you refer to her as the oldest and most seasoned, or she won't long be your girlfriend'.

Yeah, that one.

(I do know you're saying.)
 
I was going to make a joke about, 'how many girlfriends do you have and what are their age and seasoning range?' but instead I'll go with, 'I hope she doesn't know you refer to her as the oldest and most seasoned, or she won't long be your girlfriend'.

She just said, "tell him I laughed, and I just don't like too many peppers in the seasoning."
 
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I think you've become more interested in your campaign than discussion. I can see no other reason for all this rushing about with the goalposts.
[bolding mine] That's just too funny. Thanks!!

Unfortunately, it's yet another one of your assertions without evidence or even reasoning. If you want to accuse somebody of moving the goal posts, explain what you think they are, how the other person seemed to agree with where they were, then how they moved them. Otherwise it's just drivel.

Whether Skeptic Ginger is on a campaign or not is irrelevant. Address her arguments rather than her motivation.
 
I just spent a little while on the PZ Myers page.

Holy @#$. Richard Dawkins was out of his mind to wade into that. They've really lost the plot.

PZ Myers even made a post there where he said he was appearing in some calender or something and that he shouldn't have to expect to have people asking him to break his marriage vows.

I was tempted to reply that he was pretty hot for a middle aged professor and probably should expect the occasional pass, but held back.

I did point out that actually, if you throw bordello themed parties, put out pin up calenders, blog about how its ok to hook up at conferences and how you met your ex (on and on, the usual littany), yeah, you should be able to deal with someone making a pass at you once in a while.

Of course, I was immediately accused of saying that any woman who doesn't go around wearing a burca is asking to be raped.

When I asked how they'd react if a man did some of this stuff, I was ignored.

Then something awesome happened. Rebecca Watson herself showed up and her topic was none other then her banning from this very forum. Here's her version.

"I see, with no small amount of joy, that being banned from the JREF forum is being used as an example of . . . of . . . of my lack of integrity I suppose?

I say that it brings me joy only because the tale of my banning from the forum is one of my favorite stories to tell at parties. In fact, someone at the SGU dinner at TAM 9 asked me about it and I told the table of 10 or 12 the entire tale. It's true: seven years ago I had my own account ("rebecca") and a sock puppet ("Radial Tire") that the admin and moderators knew about for a year or two before they suspended me for it.

I won't post the full story here, because that would take away my ability to tell a hilarious story in person, but I will say that Radial Tire would post maybe once a month to a random thread (usually one long past it's expiration date) with something along the lines of, "Stick a penny in my treads to see when I should be changed!" And nothing more. Fans of Michael Kupperman should recognize the inspiration.

Whew. Typing all that out really drove home how evil I am. I bet I DID make up the elevator story and all the ****** mail I get and I don't even realize it, like Tyler Durden."


What a @#$ing @#$#.

This was met with great delight from her sycophants. When I tried to fill them in on a few details, I was met with more derision and accusations.

How does she have these people so far up her arse? It's amazing.
 
Last edited:
Did you really think that was brutal? I didn't. I saw it as a reasoned response to a different opinion.
You just said it was brutal. In fact, you were the first person in this thread to use the word brutal.

And is that really the bar that you want to set? If Deepak Chopra were in the audience of a lecture, would you ask the speaker to ignore a recent article that perfectly illustrates a point merely because Chopra wouldn't be able to respond at that moment? Why does being an unknown make a difference.

Skeptics write articles about other skeptics, skeptics call each other out. If the movement is actually devoted to rational thinking, this should be welcome. If there should be guidelines to protect the ego of skeptics, then the movement needs to establish them. At the time Watson's lecture was given, no such rules had even been discussed.

Many people have been saying that Watson's position in the elevator incident is anti-feminist. That "protecting" women from discomfort weakens them because it implies that they can not take care of themselves. Why would an unwanted critique of a publicly made statement be any different. Why should McGraw be "protected" from having her own words analyzed?

Talk about the apple in the pot calling the straw in the kettle orange. :eek:

Honestly, I find RW painful to listen to. She's a terrible public speaker with all those "uhs" and "ums" combined with sentence fragments that trail off. I mean, really painful. I'd probably walk out rather than stay and listen.

Anyway, her talk was supposed to be about, "The Religious Right vs. Every Woman on Earth." It's right there in big, bold letters at the top of the YouTube video. She drones on for 15 minutes about skeptics and her personal dealings with sexism. That's unprofessional, as several have pointed out.

If you listen critically, all of her anecdotes up to the point were people contacting her or commenting on her stuff directly. Not a single person was named. At 12:00 in is when she shifts gears to something that was not sent to her, which is a marked departure.

She then proceeds to point out that it's "one of your own." It really doesn't matter how "reasonable" you think the argument was. That was an ambush directed at a specific person, and she used the podium as a bully pulpit.

What really *********** cracks me up is that she says, "I'm not doing this to embarrass this person." Not more than two minutes before she ridiculed EG for saying, "Don't take this the wrong way" and likened it to people saying, "I'm not racist."

Anyway, she starts her "reasonable" argument by telling the audience that what she's about to say will embarrass this person. She then immediately says there's a problem when "young women are this ignorant about feminism." Why the hell did RW even need to get into it? It was a complete non-sequitur from the first 12 minutes, and the first 12 minutes had little if anything to do with the subject at hand.

I'm not going to go into any more detail. I think I've presented more than enough evidence of how unprofessional she is and how she bullied this person. Yes, BULLY, because the power was clearly unequal, unlike the elevator incident. I don't care that the blogger was a woman. I'm not saying she or anyone else needs to be protected.

I didn't respect RW before elevatorgate, and I've seen nothing to change my mind.
 
Last edited:
I just spent a little while on the PZ Myers page.

Holy @#$. Richard Dawkins was out of his mind to wade into that. They've really lost the plot.

PZ Myers even made a post there where he said he was appearing in some calender or something and that he shouldn't have to expect to have people asking him to break his marriage vows.

I was tempted to reply that he was pretty hot for a middle aged professor and probably should expect the occasional pass, but held back.

I did point out that actually, if you throw bordello themed parties, put out pin up calenders, blog about how its ok to hook up at conferences and how you met your ex (on and on, the usual littany), yeah, you should be able to deal with someone making a pass at you once in a while.

Of course, I was immediately accused of saying that any woman who doesn't go around wearing a burca is asking to be raped.

When I asked how they'd react if a man did some of this stuff, I was ignored.

Then something awesome happened. Rebecca Watson herself showed up and her topic was none other then her banning from this very forum. Here's her version.

"I see, with no small amount of joy, that being banned from the JREF forum is being used as an example of . . . of . . . of my lack of integrity I suppose?

I say that it brings me joy only because the tale of my banning from the forum is one of my favorite stories to tell at parties. In fact, someone at the SGU dinner at TAM 9 asked me about it and I told the table of 10 or 12 the entire tale. It's true: seven years ago I had my own account ("rebecca") and a sock puppet ("Radial Tire") that the admin and moderators knew about for a year or two before they suspended me for it.

I won't post the full story here, because that would take away my ability to tell a hilarious story in person, but I will say that Radial Tire would post maybe once a month to a random thread (usually one long past it's expiration date) with something along the lines of, "Stick a penny in my treads to see when I should be changed!" And nothing more. Fans of Michael Kupperman should recognize the inspiration.

Whew. Typing all that out really drove home how evil I am. I bet I DID make up the elevator story and all the ****** mail I get and I don't even realize it, like Tyler Durden."


What a @#$ing @#$#.

This was met with great delight from her sycophants. When I tried to fill them in on a few details, I was met with more derision and accusations.

How does she have these people so far up her arse? It's amazing.



It's funny how she tends to leave out details that make her look bad, or create details that make her look better isn't it? As for her followers, after reading the comments section on her site I am convinced she could defecate into a wine glass and take a picture of it and her followers would say "OMG Rebecca thanks for this wonderful art, you're a genius!"
 
Is there a better word for "feeling like one has been treated discourteously in social interaction"?

I call it 'life'. Most people, most of the time, aren't setting out for the purpose of coddling my feelings, so I doubt if a day goes by that I don't have an interaction that has some discourteous elements. I can't choose how other people interact with me, but I can choose how I react, and I can choose not to be injured by discourtesy. (or I can get completely butthurt over it and vent on the internet. YMMV)
 
Stop sexually objectifying Frank!

I saw him first! (claws your eyes)

Frank's Red Hot is an object. However, using it 'sexually' is ill advised. It's mostly vinegar and hot pepper. Do not use topically or internally except in the mouth of course when used on say, pizza. If it gets in your eye, flush with fresh cool water for five to ten minutes. If it gets in anywhere else flush with fresh cool water for as long as you need to. I mean, don't be embarrassed or try to act all tough by only briefly rinsing. Linger. Even in Arizona the water company will understand. (They might not understand why you were using Frank's in the first place, but the extended use of water will be reasonable.)

But you can have him. Too old for me.
 
You just said it was brutal. In fact, you were the first person in this thread to use the word brutal.

...

I didn't respect RW before elevatorgate, and I've seen nothing to change my mind.
I got to know RW here at JREF almost 10 years ago. I've followed her for years on The Skeptics Guide to the Universe. I did respect her. I could have easily survived the Dublin dust up. I thought it worh discussing. It was the "white male privelage" that got my hackles up. How does someone who weekly contributes to skepticism and critical thinking make such an idiotic ad hominem cluster @$%#? Don't get me wrong, IMO Dawkins made a poor showing with a false consolation fallcy.

I have lost respect. There is so much she could have done without abandoning her position. Just acknowledge that there are reasonable people out there with some fair complaints. Don't paint everyone with the same brush. Don't make this about the lowest denominator.
 
It's funny how she tends to leave out details that make her look bad, or create details that make her look better isn't it? As for her followers, after reading the comments section on her site I am convinced she could defecate into a wine glass and take a picture of it and her followers would say "OMG Rebecca thanks for this wonderful art, you're a genius!"

They seem to spend most of their time congratulating each other on being so enlightened. The moment anyone comes in with a criticism you're slammed as a troll who thinks any woman who doesn't go around in a burca deserves to be raped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom