So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why should McGraw be "protected" from having her own words analyzed?
No one, I mean no one is above criticism. Not Dawkins, Not Hitchens, even when he's sick. He would be angry to think anyone soft on him for it.

No, I have no problem with criticism. I have a problem with pseudo-intellectual non-falsifiable, positions that appear to be more about one's own ego than anything else. I found her response to McGraw presumptive and arrogant lacking any serious response. It was tailored to fit her narrative. And that's fine. She's entitled to free speech and she's entitled to her defenders. Just please note that I'm not in the least protective of McGraw. Let her have it with both barrels if she so choose. But since RW is handing out advice, I have some for her, don't become someone else's example of what not to do.
 
Did you really think that was brutal? I didn't. I saw it as a reasoned response to a different opinion.
An unsupportable claim is not a reasoned response. Nothing about McGraw's different perception of EG demonstrated "an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification." Nor is this comment by RW supportable:
I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another....


Both RW's and McGraw's perception of EG represent opinion. There is no empirical evidence (short of EG's direct testimony which we don't have) which the opinion rests on to resolve who is right and who is wrong.

And is that really the bar that you want to set? If Deepak Chopra were in the audience of a lecture, would you ask the speaker to ignore a recent article that perfectly illustrates a point merely because Chopra wouldn't be able to respond at that moment? Why does being an unknown make a difference....
This is not analogous to the situation. McGraw expressed her concerns about being named and quoted. It was her unequal position that she felt made it unethical. A better analogy would be that of Dr Drew who brings in people to interview, then controls and edits the interview in his favor.

Many people have been saying that Watson's position in the elevator incident is anti-feminist. That "protecting" women from discomfort weakens them because it implies that they can not take care of themselves. Why would an unwanted critique of a publicly made statement be any different. Why should McGraw be "protected" from having her own words analyzed?
You didn't address McGraw's issues. You made your own up to address. It's yet another battle with a straw man.

Here are McGraw's arguments you should be addressing rather than the ones you made up to address which no one had stated:
how can I respond? It didn't feel right to have to endure a widely respected keynote speaker's accusations that I was a living example of what was wrong with our movement while I sat there unable to defend my position.

There was no time at the conference where I, as a student attendee, could appropriately make any sort of public statement addressing what Watson claimed about my argument and me. She has said over Twitter that “An attendee has every right to counter during Q&A or by publicly blogging again later,” but there are issues with both of these approaches. First, the Q&A was not an option in my mind, as I wasn’t going to get up after her great talk and argue with her about something unrelated; I have more respect for a speaker than that. And second, yes, I currently am blogging about the issue, but this won’t reach everyone who went to the conference; I write for a successful student blog, not one like Skepchick that a large percentage of the secular community reads.

This is the crux of why I believe Watson to have behaved inappropriately for a keynote speaker.
 
An unsupportable claim is not a reasoned response. Nothing about McGraw's different perception of EG demonstrated "an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification." Nor is this comment by RW supportable:


Both RW's and McGraw's perception of EG represent opinion. There is no empirical evidence (short of EG's direct testimony which we don't have) which the opinion rests on to resolve who is right and who is wrong.

This is not analogous to the situation. McGraw expressed her concerns about being named and quoted. It was her unequal position that she felt made it unethical. A better analogy would be that of Dr Drew who brings in people to interview, then controls and edits the interview in his favor.

You didn't address McGraw's issues. You made your own up to address. It's yet another battle with a straw man.

Here are McGraw's arguments you should be addressing rather than the ones you made up to address which no one had stated:

Please don't take this the wrong way, but I think you've become more interested in your campaign than discussion. I can see no other reason for all this rushing about with the goalposts.

It doesn't matter whose opinion - McGraw's or Watson's - was right. The whole brouhaha started because McGraw thought that Watson was abusing a position of power.

And (as I have said repeatedly) that may very well have been the case. However, it's also been painted as some sort of aggressive bullying and an attack. The video shows that was not the case. It was a calm and reasonable response. It was a continuation of a discussion started by Watson, answered by McGraw, then back to Watson and then on to the entire freaking internet.

I continue to be amused. Watson is evil because she dare mention a rude moment. Watson is also evil for being rude herself. At no point is anyone other than Watson responsible for their own behavior.
 
Please forgive me because I know this wasn't directed at me and I know I run the risk of creating a straw man and for that I apologize in advance. But I think we often talk past each other and some important points are missed. Again, I do not claim that you agree or disagree with the following but I would like your opinion.

  • Was she justified in her initial reaction? (from her perspective and others) Yes.
  • Was it justified on behalf of everyone? No.
  • Was she justified in making a polite recommendation? Yes.
  • Was saying "guys don't do that" helpful? No. "Guys, please consider your actions as some of us might find that objectionable" would have been.
  • Did her comments about objectification, white privilege and her assertions that it was creepy, conducive to a discussion about appropriate conduct? No.
  • Has she acknowledge that there are valid criticisms and complaints (assuming there are valid criticisms)?

That sums it up nicely. They should just sticky this comment on top of every thread about this topic through out the web.

I thought her reaction was reasonable at first. It was kind of a girl bragging about her hotness by complaining about a guy hitting on her. Childish, but women do that all the time. Heck, she had a point too. Hitting on a lady at 4 am in an elevator is pretty awkward and has about a 0 chance of succeeding.

It's interesting how a lot of Watson's supporters will focus on that first reaction and ignore everything else, like it didn't happen. How could they not know about the rest of it at this point?

It's like even they know how weak and inconsistent her claims have been, so they pretend they never happened.
 
I continue to be amused. Watson is evil because she dare mention a rude moment.

Totally false characterization of what her critics have been saying. This is pretty common among her defenders, no doubt because if you actually focus on what she's said, all of it, its pretty indefensible.

Watson is a total light weight who successfully promoted herself through the sexual objectification of women. Now she's taken a fancy to hard line radical feminism without really giving it a lot of thought about how it relates to her other views. She's like one of these childish college girls who'll make out with their friends and flash their chests to get attention and free drinks at a bar one night, and then bitch out their male friends for reading Maxim a few days later because it "objectifies women" (probably just repeating something they heard in a class room).
 
That sums it up nicely. They should just sticky this comment on top of every thread about this topic through out the web.

I thought her reaction was reasonable at first. It was kind of a girl bragging about her hotness by complaining about a guy hitting on her. Childish, but women do that all the time. Heck, she had a point too. Hitting on a lady at 4 am in an elevator is pretty awkward and has about a 0 chance of succeeding.

It's interesting how a lot of Watson's supporters will focus on that first reaction and ignore everything else, like it didn't happen. How could they not know about the rest of it at this point?

It's like even they know how weak and inconsistent her claims have been, so they pretend they never happened.
Agreed. Thank you
 
I continue to be amused. Watson is evil because she dare mention a rude moment. Watson is also evil for being rude herself. At no point is anyone other than Watson responsible for their own behavior.
I continue to be amused that this straw man is trotted out.
 
Uuugh.

I'm really lost in trying to make points to some feminists I know about this whole topic.

Every time I tell them them that RW's Privilege Delusion is just an ad hominem, they just tell that 'Oh, the point is valid'

Along with saying that 'men don't get it' is also another valid point, despite it being sexism by disqualifying the opinions simply based on gender.

I mean, how do I respond to these arguments without being incendiary by calling them idiots.
 
It's been cited and quoted about a dozen times in this thread alone.

You can find what you haven't looked at in this post.

Thanks for the link, I read all the quotes and still don't see where she called the incident an example of sexism. All the links seem to reinforce what I said, she called the responses misogynistic and sexist and the original incident objectification. Of course, I am only guessing that what you are talking about is sexism because that's the part you bolded.
 
It doesn't matter whose opinion - McGraw's or Watson's - was right. The whole brouhaha started because McGraw thought that Watson was abusing a position of power.

No, that's false. Here is McGraw's first statement on the issue: http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/06/fursdays-wif-stef-32.html

There is nothing in there about Watson's abusing a position of power. At that point, of course, that would be an absurd conclusion anyway. Posting a video, especially on Youtube, isn't being in a position of power, unless it's the kind of economic power that most middle-class people take for granted. Anyone with a computer, camera, microphone, and Internet connection can do it, and, lamentably, many do.

And (as I have said repeatedly) that may very well have been the case. However, it's also been painted as some sort of aggressive bullying and an attack. The video shows that was not the case. It was a calm and reasonable response. It was a continuation of a discussion started by Watson, answered by McGraw, then back to Watson and then on to the entire freaking internet.

Again, false. The criticism of Watson's actions at the CFI, initially, were about her calling out Stef McGraw by name. McGraw addressed this in her second response at http://www.unifreethought.com/2011/...howComment=1309494284400#c1446541235942337573

Watson replied to this one, and as far as I can tell, the first significant external reaction to the CFI talk was by ERV at http://scienceblogs.com/erv/2011/07/bad_form_rebecca_watson.php

Most of the reaction, however, was both after and a result of Watson's tweets saying that McGraw was parroting misogynistic thought.

I continue to be amused. Watson is evil because she dare mention a rude moment. Watson is also evil for being rude herself. At no point is anyone other than Watson responsible for their own behavior.

You also continue to be ill-informed. I understand the appeal of believing that it's all because of Watson's original comment (whereas the original comment bears little to no relationship except historically). What is harder to see is why you persist in promulgating straw men, when you have ample evidence that the informed can see through them as easily as they can through air.
 
That sums it up nicely. They should just sticky this comment on top of every thread about this topic through out the web.

I thought her reaction was reasonable at first. It was kind of a girl bragging about her hotness by complaining about a guy hitting on her. Childish, but women do that all the time. Heck, she had a point too. Hitting on a lady at 4 am in an elevator is pretty awkward and has about a 0 chance of succeeding.

It's interesting how a lot of Watson's supporters will focus on that first reaction and ignore everything else, like it didn't happen. How could they not know about the rest of it at this point?

It's like even they know how weak and inconsistent her claims have been, so they pretend they never happened.

I only focus on the original incident when I see something I can either add or challenge about the original incident. There have been weak, inconsistent, and irrational responses on many sides of this. It's pretty obvious that it doesn't fall into an either or catagory.
 
Thanks for the link, I read all the quotes and still don't see where she called the incident an example of sexism. All the links seem to reinforce what I said, she called the responses misogynistic and sexist and the original incident objectification. Of course, I am only guessing that what you are talking about is sexism because that's the part you bolded.

As far as I can tell, this is correct. She hasn't called the EG incident an example of sexism. At first, she only called it "sexualization" and later "objectification."
 
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I think you've become more interested in your campaign than discussion. I can see no other reason for all this rushing about with the goalposts.
You can take this any way you want, but you aren't very good at reading meaning into what people say, and about communicating some of your own points.

I don't have a clue what, "rushing about with the goalposts" means. But I doubt it matters because I suspect it is another false charge.


It doesn't matter whose opinion - McGraw's or Watson's - was right. The whole brouhaha started because McGraw thought that Watson was abusing a position of power.
This is a non sequitur. You posted a straw man addressing an argument no one made. Your straw man was that anyone thought McGraw could not be criticized.

Now you've changed to another one. The complaints McGraw had about RW's use of McGraw's quote in RW's keynote address is a side issue. It is NOT what started the "whole brouhaha".

And (as I have said repeatedly) that may very well have been the case. However, it's also been painted as some sort of aggressive bullying and an attack. The video shows that was not the case. It was a calm and reasonable response. It was a continuation of a discussion started by Watson, answered by McGraw, then back to Watson and then on to the entire freaking internet.
You are welcome to continue asserting RW's response to McGraw was "reasonable". That doesn't make it so. How about addressing the facts, that is, RW's specific wording of her opinion of McGraw's comments.

Please stop telling us what you think about the straw man arguments you invent. Please answer the following questions as written:

Did what McGraw said display, "ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification." as RW claimed?

And was what McGraw said and example of "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another"?


I continue to be amused. Watson is evil because she dare mention a rude moment. Watson is also evil for being rude herself. At no point is anyone other than Watson responsible for their own behavior.
And I continue to get more tired of your straw men. I can't figure out why this discussion is so distorted in your mind. It's no wonder you disagree with so many people. You believe they are saying things they are not saying.
 
...
I thought her reaction was reasonable at first. It was kind of a girl bragging about her hotness by complaining about a guy hitting on her. Childish, but women do that all the time.....
I'm so glad someone said this. I've been hesitating to as it sounds so catty coming from me.


...It's interesting how a lot of Watson's supporters will focus on that first reaction and ignore everything else, like it didn't happen. How could they not know about the rest of it at this point?

It's like even they know how weak and inconsistent her claims have been, so they pretend they never happened.
I'm not sure how to explain this phenomena, but it is a fact and this thread is evidence of it. But I'm more generous, I think a lot of us read a bit (I make this mistake) and we are ready to respond so we don't read any further. It leads to a lot of misunderstandings of the essences of certain issues.
 
Last edited:
Totally false characterization of what her critics have been saying. This is pretty common among her defenders, no doubt because if you actually focus on what she's said, all of it, its pretty indefensible.

Watson is a total light weight who successfully promoted herself through the sexual objectification of women. Now she's taken a fancy to hard line radical feminism without really giving it a lot of thought about how it relates to her other views. She's like one of these childish college girls who'll make out with their friends and flash their chests to get attention and free drinks at a bar one night, and then bitch out their male friends for reading Maxim a few days later because it "objectifies women" (probably just repeating something they heard in a class room).
Now this post I agree with, no qualifications. :)

And yes, it is catty of me. Oh well.
 
Uuugh.

I'm really lost in trying to make points to some feminists I know about this whole topic.

Every time I tell them them that RW's Privilege Delusion is just an ad hominem, they just tell that 'Oh, the point is valid'

Along with saying that 'men don't get it' is also another valid point, despite it being sexism by disqualifying the opinions simply based on gender.

I mean, how do I respond to these arguments without being incendiary by calling them idiots.
Tell them some women don't get RW's position either. ;)
 
Thanks for the link, I read all the quotes and still don't see where she called the incident an example of sexism. All the links seem to reinforce what I said, she called the responses misogynistic and sexist and the original incident objectification. Of course, I am only guessing that what you are talking about is sexism because that's the part you bolded.
What is it you define as sexism? I'm not sure where you are coming from here.
 
....
You also continue to be ill-informed. I understand the appeal of believing that it's all because of Watson's original comment (whereas the original comment bears little to no relationship except historically). What is harder to see is why you persist in promulgating straw men, when you have ample evidence that the informed can see through them as easily as they can through air.
I remain fascinated by this phenomena of the human brain.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom