So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
And Watson goes from one extreme to the other as she sees fit. From throwing drunken bordello themed parties at events and bragging about meeting her husband by hitting on him and heavily promoting her skep"chicks" using sex to taking a very serious, all business line on what should go on at these things practically overnight.

She's dishonest, shallow and not much of a thinker, but she is a shameless self promoter who knows how to push peoples' buttons.

If you're tired of hearing about her, I doubt you'll get much relief soon. Controversy has worked even better then sex for her in getting attention, so I expect we'll be seeing a lot more of this from her. It wouldn't surprise me if she turns into a sort of Ann Coultier type of the skeptic and feminist world, not really saying anything that matters, just making outrageous comments and accusations to stir things up.

"It's only sexist if a guy does it"...
 
...Sometimes, an initial approach is made, in part, to discover whether a further chance to raise the "shall we screw" option may be in the cards, or not. ...
The issue isn't, did he or didn't he? The issue is, did he ONLY want to screw? Only the latter would fit the definition of "objectification".
 
So, I'm listening to this Ann Althouse interview, and my impression is as follows:

The only proper interpretation of EG's action is malice (i.e., sexualizing) rather than potential social ineptitude.

There's a point where Ann asks something to the effect of: "There are plenty of socially awkward men, should we consider their feelings?" To which RW replies: "No, they should better themselves."

Why isn't one way of bettering yourself trial and error?

Yes, EG probably wasn't the classiest of people, but assigning intent seems impossible, since we can't read minds.

That's my annoyance, that there's RW's way or you're wrong and need to drop seven grand on a doll to have intercourse with.
 
I notice Watson has changed the content of her store. No more sexually themed buttons or t-shirts for that feminist grrrl! I guess the massive contradictions have actually started to register with her. Or maybe PZ Myers gently pointed some of them out.

I wonder if she'll get to editing her blogs and vlogs next. That blog where she tells us she's up for casual sex at conferences might seem kind of odd, considering her views. I mean, how does a one night stand happen if someone doesn't get hit on at some point, and hence objectified. Then there's something about how she met her husband by hitting on him when she first met him. And the bordello themed party. Guess we won't be seeing many more of those in the future. Sad. I heard they could get pretty wild and crazy! Those skepchicks can really partay when they get rolling. Who needs sex to promote yourself when you have her talent for stirring up controversy and division.

Judging by that huge grin she's wearing in her latest video and the links to her store she's put in there, and her jolly greeting "Oh hello subscribers, both new and not-so-new!" she's happier then a pig in excrement about all this. And why not? She's getting what she wanted, probably beyond her wildest dreams.

Kind of sad to see someone getting over by cynically hurting the skeptic movement like she has, but eh, that's life.
 
Last edited:
Every issue raised hinges on RW's perception being inaccurate or not. As it stands, no one, not one single person, has produced evidence supporting RW's interpretation. Yet there are people who are jumping to her defense because someone dared to point out that RW was, perhaps, guilty of misinterpreting a friendly request for discussion for something more.

That evidence does not exist. I think Checkmite raised a very good point; if what she said is accurate, was she justified in her initial reaction?

In response to Checkmite's post:
If her interpretation was correct, there are still two reactions here.

1) "Guys, don't do that"
2) "It's objectifying and misogynistic"

1) is perfectly acceptable as long as she's referring to herself specifically. As soon as she intends that to cover every woman and every guy, her reaction is inappropriate.

She did say, specifically, "it makes me very uncomfortable..." which in itself can be interpreted in as many different ways as "come back to my room for coffee..." I think there is a chance that people who disagree with the whole interpretation are going to perceive that as, "it makes me very uncomfortable, therefor you shouldn't do it, ever!" People somewhere in the middle see it as a general, "it makes me very uncomfortable so don't do it to me." And people who are completely against cold propositions are going to see it as, "it made a woman uncomfortable, so let that be a lesson to you." Mind you, this is arguing from the beginning. I don't know how far things have spiraled, at this point. RW could very well be calling for the chemical castration of all male skeptics but at the very start, I didn't take it as a moral lesson, just a personal anecdote.


2) I still don't see how what happened is automatically misogyny or objectification. You (nor anyone, for that matter) has provided evidence that EG heard RW's lecture or earlier conversations. What evidence do we have that EG was even a part of the conference (which, btw, blows your TAM arguments out of the water)? But, for the sake of argument, let's allow that he was a part of the conference and he was a part of the conversation at the bar (lots of assumptions to make RW's reaction valid, but ok). That still doesn't necessarily mean it's misogyny or objectification. No more so than RW's interpretation of an invitation to coffee is ojectification/misogyny in it's own right (Oh, it's a guy who invited me to coffee in an elevator, must by an invite to sex. Yes, that's misogyny folks).

I would call it more sexist but yes, this is a bit of assumption that men don't really care about conversation, it's all about the end game. It's a little bit deductive and how it's interpreted would depend largely on the individual's experience and prejudice, prior to the incident. From one point of view, "I find you very interesting and want to take some more..." is mildly indicative that he was present for at least some of it, in which case, it clearly wasn't objectification. He may have been listening to her all night and was intellectually attracted to her, meaning there was zero chance of it being sexually objectifying. Then, he could have been staring at her boobs all night, not listening to a word she said, and decided that his best chance at getting in her pants was to act like he cared what she said. Back to Checkmite's point, though, deciding if she was right or wrong is just going to turn into 70+ pages of arguing over who's interpretation is better. Every single one of us lack the time travel and mind reading skills we would need to decide if RW's assumption of EG's intent is, in deed, accurate.

From my best understanding, I don't recall her calling this an example of misogyny. I would have to see the posts and reactions that she has called misogyny to decide if she is correct in that accusation but the accusations appeared to be directed at the responses to her, prior to and after the incident, not the incident, itself. I think some of the reactions to her original video were also sexist but I would have to go back and see if she called the actual incident an example of sexism. As far as I know, the actual incident was used as an example for objectification.
 
"...if what she said is accurate, was she justified in her initial reaction?
Please forgive me because I know this wasn't directed at me and I know I run the risk of creating a straw man and for that I apologize in advance. But I think we often talk past each other and some important points are missed. Again, I do not claim that you agree or disagree with the following but I would like your opinion.

  • Was she justified in her initial reaction? (from her perspective and others) Yes.
  • Was it justified on behalf of everyone? No.
  • Was she justified in making a polite recommendation? Yes.
  • Was saying "guys don't do that" helpful? No. "Guys, please consider your actions as some of us might find that objectionable" would have been.
  • Did her comments about objectification, white privilege and her assertions that it was creepy, conducive to a discussion about appropriate conduct? No.
  • Has she acknowledge that there are valid criticisms and complaints (assuming there are valid criticisms)?
 
Please forgive me because I know this wasn't directed at me and I know I run the risk of creating a straw man and for that I apologize in advance. But I think we often talk past each other and some important points are missed. Again, I do not claim that you agree or disagree with the following but I would like your opinion.

  • Was she justified in her initial reaction? (from her perspective and others) Yes.
  • Was it justified on behalf of everyone? No.
  • Was she justified in making a polite recommendation? Yes.
  • Was saying "guys don't do that" helpful? No. "Guys, please consider your actions as some of us might find that objectionable" would have been.
  • Did her comments about objectification, white privilege and her assertions that it was creepy, conducive to a discussion about appropriate conduct? No.
  • Has she acknowledge that there are valid criticisms and complaints (assuming there are valid criticisms)?

I don't really disagree with any of that. Of course after the fact, there are better ways she could have put it, but in the end, the message is the same. The way I heard her, originally, which could be wrong is, "guys, don't do that. If you happen to find yourself alone in an elevator with me, don't proposition me." I think as opinions polarized different groups, she's gotten bolder and turned this into a, "you're either with us or sexist," argument.

[*]Did her comments about objectification, white privilege and her assertions that it was creepy, conducive to a discussion about appropriate conduct? No.

About this, though, I don't think this was intended to spark a discussion about appropriate conduct. Objectification and creepy were her subjective experience in a vblog, that lasted a total of two minutes. The white priviledge may have some merit, though. Of course it all hangs on the argument that she does, in fact, experience objectification, sexism, and misogyny. I think by that point, she was emotional and looking to be insulting, which absolutely was not conducive, at all. However, she was responding to RD's post that was very sarcastic. I will say this; her level of threat, in the elevator seemed to increase with her emotion. I do suspect that as she replays the moment, in her mind, it has gradually turned from and eye rolling, "don't objectify me," and a slight sense of creepy to, "I didn't know if I was going to make it out of there, alive."

[*]Has she acknowledge that there are valid criticisms and complaints (assuming there are valid criticisms)?

There are valid criticisms and no, I think it was agreed by even the most staunch supporters of her original position, that she is now arguing for the sake of being right and no longer interested in a discussion. I think that was agreed upon on page 2.
 
oh btw, here's the video of Watson "bullying" McGraw.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqzE16UsNW4&feature=player_embedded#at=230

Not quite as brutal as it has been painted here.
9 minutes in and so far she has demonstrated that there are people who disagree with and who are abusive and lacking in critical thinking... and? How is that appropriate? Does it dispel the notion that there are any reasonable criticisms?

She then begins to relate the EG incident and says that she recognizes him from the group but doesn't recognize him from before that day. In another video she says she is unable to complete this common human feat as she suffers from prosopagnosia.

11 minutes, back to the extreme examples. Hasn't she demonstrated already that such people exist? What is the point of continuing this? At what point does it just become a revel of polemics?

13 minutes okay, here it is.

We have a problem when young women ARE THIS IGNORANT ABOUT FEMINISM!

Of course to RW "there are many things wrong with" with the response.

Asking someone back to your room at 4:00 am is the very definition of unsolicited sexual comment....

AND?

{sigh}

She just said that she's not against flirting and propositioning. How does she reconcile that? How does that not maker position absurd?

RW then quotes McGraw "she takes issue with a man showing interest in her".

This is where I really lose it. This is where all of the "you don't get it", "white male privilege" non falsifiable, heads I win tails you lose, uncritical, non-skeptical rhetoric that rears its ugly head. "Parroting misogynistic thought."

Feminism 101. Proof? Oh, hey, there's a blog that agrees with her. I'll take confirmation bias for $1,000 Alex.

Okay, now we are weighing the rights of women to be free from objectification with the rights of men to hit on women. As if there is nothing more black and white....

I'm going to take a break. This is a very important subject and RW has no more skepticism, critical thinking and self analysis to consider her own views than the idiots she used to paint a broad brush of the rest of us.
 
There are valid criticisms and no, I think it was agreed by even the most staunch supporters of her original position, that she is now arguing for the sake of being right and no longer interested in a discussion. I think that was agreed upon on page 2.
Agreed, and you know what? At some point we have to move on. Me included. I think we begin to lose the important points.

Thanks.
 
....
There's a point where Ann asks something to the effect of: "There are plenty of socially awkward men, should we consider their feelings?" To which RW replies: "No, they should better themselves." ....
Does anyone else see the irony here?

"I don't need to change how I respond, they need to change how they address me."
 
Agreed, and you know what? At some point we have to move on. Me included. I think we begin to lose the important points.

Thanks.

To be honest, I was away on vacation from the 24th and got back yesterday. My jaw dropped when I logged on JREF, this morning and this was still on the first page.

Just an amusing side note, we were staying on the 3rd floor and never let an elevator ride pass without some kind of joke. The best was when my 14 year old daughter (yes, even she's heard of this) called me a sexist for drinking a cup of coffee in the elevator.
 
I'm glad you agree it was brutal.

Did you really think that was brutal? I didn't. I saw it as a reasoned response to a different opinion.

And is that really the bar that you want to set? If Deepak Chopra were in the audience of a lecture, would you ask the speaker to ignore a recent article that perfectly illustrates a point merely because Chopra wouldn't be able to respond at that moment? Why does being an unknown make a difference.

Skeptics write articles about other skeptics, skeptics call each other out. If the movement is actually devoted to rational thinking, this should be welcome. If there should be guidelines to protect the ego of skeptics, then the movement needs to establish them. At the time Watson's lecture was given, no such rules had even been discussed.

Many people have been saying that Watson's position in the elevator incident is anti-feminist. That "protecting" women from discomfort weakens them because it implies that they can not take care of themselves. Why would an unwanted critique of a publicly made statement be any different. Why should McGraw be "protected" from having her own words analyzed?
 
To be honest, I was away on vacation from the 24th and got back yesterday. My jaw dropped when I logged on JREF, this morning and this was still on the first page.

Just an amusing side note, we were staying on the 3rd floor and never let an elevator ride pass without some kind of joke. The best was when my 14 year old daughter (yes, even she's heard of this) called me a sexist for drinking a cup of coffee in the elevator.
:D Thanks. I was in a foul mood before your last post. Good stuff. We have to find some humor in all of this.
 
....
She did say, specifically, "it makes me very uncomfortable..." .... deciding if she was right or wrong is just going to turn into 70+ pages of arguing over who's interpretation is better.....
From my best understanding, I don't recall her calling this an example of misogyny. I would have to see the posts and reactions that she has called misogyny to decide if she is correct in that accusation but the accusations appeared to be directed at the responses to her, prior to and after the incident, not the incident, itself. I think some of the reactions to her original video were also sexist but I would have to go back and see if she called the actual incident an example of sexism. As far as I know, the actual incident was used as an example for objectification.
It's been cited and quoted about a dozen times in this thread alone.

You can find what you haven't looked at in this post.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom