So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/1003/Senex/c.jpg[/qimg]


I haven't found a picture of my bum at 17 but this is a picture of me in the school musical at 17. You probably can project what my bum looked like and I kid you not one night I was working as a bus boy and I had to turn around and tell the crowd of women, "Enough. Stop grabbing my ass. I'm getting serious now."

And the truth was I wasn't tired of getting goosed but I started to feel offended I wasn't able to turn the interest in my bottom into interest in losing my virginity. I felt somehow they should have gone together and they weren't.

Thank you, sir.

I applaud your 17 year old ass; and can plainly see that, at least at that age, it apparently had the ability to make women break out in to a song and dance routines.

Paranormal? Or is your ass merely a kind of science we have yet to discover? Honestly we can't be sure without funding for a lab.
 
If I could recognize her to the point that I was reasonably sure it was miss Watson, I'd probably say, "I hope you appreciate how many perfectly good jokes I'm passing up right now."

This would spark a blog about how women shouldn't have to 'appreciate' men acting like they should all the time. (Keeping their mouths shut that is. And while we're at it, go back to the kitchen and make them a sandwich.)

If I found myself alone on an elevator with Rebecca Watson, I'd bend over cupping my hand to my ear saying, "Huh? What was that? Hey, don't blame me!!" Then I'd straighten up and take a step back.

After a moment I'd look at my crotch and say, "Whoa. Settle down. No need to get angry. Be the adult here."
 
I'd helpfully inform her that her hair dye accentuated how very pasty she looks, especially under the harsh artificial lighting in the elevator.

She'd no doubt be overcome with gratitude and offer me a coffee.
 
Actually, if one has the time, you just wait for everyone to uncover it all. ;)

whoa. that girl just winked at me. i wonder. maybe she likes me? should i ask her if she'd be interested in some nasty down and dirty sex up in my room? nah, too direct. I'll be nice to her. I'll tell her she's interesting and subtly ask her up to my room for coffee. That way if I'm wrong, she couldn't possibly be offended. Yeah, that's the ticket.
 
The fact that the person who started this whole brouhaha, who is taking such a hard line about objectifying women, calls her little organization the skep"chicks" and put out a calender full of pictures of women made into sex objects tells you how ridiculous the whole thing is.

But don't you know? That's ok because they have a version with men in it.
 
Of course, I guess you could call me sexist in some ways. If I'm going to ask someone to help me put shingles on my roof, I'll almost definitely ask a man even though anybody - man or woman - could do it. That's not because I think women are frail or don't belong on the roof. It's because I seriously doubt any woman I know would do it without at least asking, "Can't you get one your guy friends to help you?"

Even if that's the case, I would still encourage you to ask, if only to reinforce the idea that it's a reasonable expectation from either gender. For the record, I have helped shingle roofs. :)

I guess I have a different approach to empowering women. In one of the linked blogs, a woman kept track of how often men versus women were interrupted in meetings. She found that women were interrupted far more often. For the moment set aside that there could be other factors at work and assume that it was gender related.

Her solution? Talk to the men and ask them not to interrupt women so much.

My solution? Talk to the women and tell them not to let anyone, man or woman, interrupt them when they have the floor. Say, "Excuse me, but I was talking. Please don't interrupt." And then continue talking. People who do that don't get interrupted twice.

I didn't notice that until you pointed it out. That is a common theme to the stories about sexist events. The event makes the woman uncomfortable, but she walks away and the man is left unchallenged. Yes, it may be that some women are socialized to be passive, but it makes sense to change the socialization, rather than continuing to give the men the active role (as the aggressor and then as the one who is supposed to figure out they should change their behavior).

Linda
 
Assumptions are all very well, but the assumption that you make doesn't help me with my future behaviour. The assumption you make allows me to work out:

Not to approach women at conferences in elevators for coffee after they've just made a presentation which included a passage asking not to be approached at conferences..

We don't know if Rebecca ever talked about being approached. Yes, that is what she said she talked about, both in her presentation and at the bar. But the video of her presentation shows that she is wrong about that. And we don't have independent confirmation of what was talked about at the bar, except someone's vague reference to atheist proselytizing on another blog, which doesn't make it sound like it was overwhelmingly about sexism (note: in her 70 minute interview, she refers to the bar conversation as being 10 hours pretty much exclusively about sexism in atheist/skeptic community). It looks suspiciously like Rebecca has reworked her memory of what was actually discussed to fit with subsequent events.

To that end, I suspect your sentence above may be more accurately worded as...

"Not to approach women at conferences in elevators for coffee after they've just made a presentation which can later be remembered as including a passage asking not to be approached at conferences, regardless of what was actually said.."

Linda
 
I listened to the 70 minute interview with Ann Althouse.

The first half hour or so was about skepticism in general and then they got to the elevator incident. As expected, Rebecca gave the false version of what got her in trouble. What was very interesting was that because of this, Ann focussed only on questioning her about the elevator incident, and pushed her very hard to answer specifically what it was that made the incident sexism vs. a mere indication of interest. And what it would look like if done by a man who wanted to go about it the right way - i.e. the non-sexualizing way. That is, Ann tried to pin her down to provide answers to those questions I asked in my first post, on the first page of this thread. And Rebecca's inability to answer these questions highlighted the vacuity of what she had been trying to claim, and highlighted the legitimacy of those initial bloggers who called her to task on it which she subsequently attacked (thereby setting off the ****-storm).

It ends with a discussion of Richard's posts, and Rebecca ends with a comment about Richard having something to say about evolutionary biology, but that she wouldn't look to him for something to say about feminism. Which makes sense. Rebecca's feminism is whining about imagined slights, while Richard's feminism is about supporting those who are fighting the oppression of human rights in women, and about providing free child care at skeptical conferences.

Linda
 
I didn't notice that until you pointed it out. That is a common theme to the stories about sexist events. The event makes the woman uncomfortable, but she walks away and the man is left unchallenged.

Interrupting is notable, but I'd like to see some data about which sex has a greater tendency to drone on and on and never let anyone get a word in edgewise.
 
... I didn't notice that until you pointed it out. That is a common theme to the stories about sexist events. The event makes the woman uncomfortable, but she walks away and the man is left unchallenged. Yes, it may be that some women are socialized to be passive, but it makes sense to change the socialization, rather than continuing to give the men the active role (as the aggressor and then as the one who is supposed to figure out they should change their behavior).

Linda
More than one person is perceiving the suggestion the woman is the one who needs to change as telling women to "suck it up". And I've been thinking about why that perception is bothering me so much. Even more than wanting the aggressor to 'figure out' they should change the behavior, sometimes it is even just the expectation that it is up to the aggressor to do the changing. That perpetuates the powerless woman role.

I perceive the solutions much as you do, empowering women rather than trying to un-empower men. In addition, I see it as something women have control over, as opposed to the un-empowered position of asking/wanting/expecting someone else to act differently to meet women's needs.

If a person in a position of power over the woman displays unwanted sexist behavior which has a negative impact on the woman, then what it takes to correct the situation may indeed involve motivating someone else to change. If there is nothing the woman can do solely by herself, then suggesting a woman react differently to the sexism could be a case of telling women to "suck it up".

The difference is in the power to affect the outcome. It may sound cliche' but it is still true, you can choose not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest that has no other effects. (I'm not discounting other effects like would happen if it were your boss, or if it was embarrassing because you were a speaker and it came from the audience. These are not the circumstances I am referring to.)

If you have the power to control the outcome (and you do have the power to control your response) then it is much more liberating to use that power and IMO, to view the solution as being up to men to change, contributes to lessening the status of women.

-
 
Last edited:
Interrupting is notable, but I'd like to see some data about which sex has a greater tendency to drone on and on and never let anyone get a word in edgewise.

Yeah, it can't just be my husband who does this.

Linda
 
What's the difference between an Iron man and Iron woman?

An Iron man is a sporting event.

Iron woman is a command.
 
...

To that end, I suspect your sentence above may be more accurately worded as...

"Not to approach women at conferences in elevators for coffee after they've just made a presentation which can later be remembered as including a passage asking not to be approached at conferences, regardless of what was actually said.."

Linda

You are preaching to the choir.

You deal with people however they are. If drunk women are grabbing your ass -- you politely decline and go to your room. You don't light them up on the internet unnecessarily. (and I can -- a famous woman who was a DA from L&O grabbed my ass recently and you could torture me and I won't give up her name. No really, torture me;) -- you won't get the name out of me.)
 
Last edited:
More than one person is perceiving the suggestion the woman is the one who needs to change as telling women to "suck it up". And I've been thinking about why that perception is bothering me so much. Even more than wanting the aggressor to 'figure out' they should change the behavior, sometimes it is even just the expectation that it is up to the aggressor to do the changing. That perpetuates the powerless woman role.
I perceive the solutions much as you do, empowering women rather than trying to un-empower men. In addition, I see it as something women have control over, as opposed to the un-empowered position of asking/wanting/expecting someone else to act differently to meet women's needs.

If a person in a position of power over the woman displays unwanted sexist behavior which has a negative impact on the woman, then what it takes to correct the situation may indeed involve motivating someone else to change. If there is nothing the woman can do solely by herself, then suggesting a woman react differently to the sexism could be a case of telling women to "suck it up".

The difference is in the power to affect the outcome. It may sound cliche' but it is still true, you can choose not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest that has no other effects. (I'm not discounting other effects like would happen if it were your boss, or if it was embarrassing because you were a speaker and it came from the audience. These are not the circumstances I am referring to.)

If you have the power to control the outcome (and you do have the power to control your response) then it is much more liberating to use that power and IMO, to view the solution as being up to men to change, contributes to lessening the status of women.

-

These days I've been trying to put into words what you said in this post. I highlighted the parts that I find especially eloquent to illustrate exactly how I view this problem. Thank you.

Feminism is confusing: some of the feminists' complaints seem to suggest that women are very fragile people in need of special protection that requires the rest (other women included) to cater to their demands, while other feminists (with whom I agree) demand the opposite and don't want to be "coddled" the way the first group energically demands, and in fact some people from this second group find this "coddling" sexist. Of course, I'm painting with a broad brush and every person has a unique view (or maybe not) but Linda, Paula Kirby and you are much closer to this second group I described.
 
More than one person is perceiving the suggestion the woman is the one who needs to change as telling women to "suck it up". And I've been thinking about why that perception is bothering me so much. Even more than wanting the aggressor to 'figure out' they should change the behavior, sometimes it is even just the expectation that it is up to the aggressor to do the changing. That perpetuates the powerless woman role.

I perceive the solutions much as you do, empowering women rather than trying to un-empower men. In addition, I see it as something women have control over, as opposed to the un-empowered position of asking/wanting/expecting someone else to act differently to meet women's needs.

If a person in a position of power over the woman displays unwanted sexist behavior which has a negative impact on the woman, then what it takes to correct the situation may indeed involve motivating someone else to change. If there is nothing the woman can do solely by herself, then suggesting a woman react differently to the sexism could be a case of telling women to "suck it up".

The difference is in the power to affect the outcome. It may sound cliche' but it is still true, you can choose not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest that has no other effects. (I'm not discounting other effects like would happen if it were your boss, or if it was embarrassing because you were a speaker and it came from the audience. These are not the circumstances I am referring to.)

If you have the power to control the outcome (and you do have the power to control your response) then it is much more liberating to use that power and IMO, to view the solution as being up to men to change, contributes to lessening the status of women.

These days I've been trying to put into words what you said in this post. I highlighted the parts that I find especially eloquent to illustrate exactly how I view this problem. Thank you.

Feminism is confusing: some of the feminists' complaints seem to suggest that women are very fragile people in need of special protection that requires the rest (other women included) to cater to their demands, while other feminists (with whom I agree) demand the opposite and don't want to be "coddled" the way the first group energically demands, and in fact some people from this second group find this "coddling" sexist. Of course, I'm painting with a broad brush and every person has a unique view (or maybe not) but Linda, Paula Kirby and you are much closer to this second group I described.
Thank you both.

I don't think this problem is simple. I was born in 1961 and have witnessed some very important historical milestones. I think it's too easy to define feminism into a very narrow thing and take it to some place counter to what it was meant to be. I've very glad of the contributions of Gloria Steinem but thought her and others went off of the tracks at times. Was equally grateful to the likes of Camille Paglia for helping to change the discussion and help the movement toward what I think is a better direction.

I'm willing to concede that I am not a woman and I don't have all of the answers. But then I don't think anyone, male or female, does.
 
These days I've been trying to put into words what you said in this post. I highlighted the parts that I find especially eloquent to illustrate exactly how I view this problem. Thank you.

Feminism is confusing: some of the feminists' complaints seem to suggest that women are very fragile people in need of special protection that requires the rest (other women included) to cater to their demands, while other feminists (with whom I agree) demand the opposite and don't want to be "coddled" the way the first group energically demands, and in fact some people from this second group find this "coddling" sexist. Of course, I'm painting with a broad brush and every person has a unique view (or maybe not) but Linda, Paula Kirby and you are much closer to this second group I described.

And Watson goes from one extreme to the other as she sees fit. From throwing drunken bordello themed parties at events and bragging about meeting her husband by hitting on him and heavily promoting her skep"chicks" using sex to taking a very serious, all business line on what should go on at these things practically overnight.

She's dishonest, shallow and not much of a thinker, but she is a shameless self promoter who knows how to push peoples' buttons.

If you're tired of hearing about her, I doubt you'll get much relief soon. Controversy has worked even better then sex for her in getting attention, so I expect we'll be seeing a lot more of this from her. It wouldn't surprise me if she turns into a sort of Ann Coultier type of the skeptic and feminist world, not really saying anything that matters, just making outrageous comments and accusations to stir things up.
 
According to her women aren't coming back to sceptical meetings because they'd feel terrible being in the same room as 30+ men they'd turned down the last time they were there. Which would seem to suggest she thinks men shouldn't approach women at sceptical conferences.

A little later Ms. Watson states that she thinks men at such events should be allowed to chat up the women who attend.
Might the new hair color be to blame?
Get over the "he only wanted to screw" claim unless you have actual evidence, not unsupported speculation.
Sometimes, an initial approach is made, in part, to discover whether a further chance to raise the "shall we screw" option may be in the cards, or not.
Don't women realize how much of an affront it is to us when they point their breastises at us in close quarters?

Keep those glands pointed the other way for goodness sake. And while you are at it, cover them better. You should be able to find clothing that conceals your ability to feed infants.
Note: marplot does not speak for all men.

Question: does RW get more revenue if more web sites refer to her?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom