So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
So other than behaviour that is calculated to offend, pretty much anything could be OK?

I'm not sure if your suggestion would have avoided this 90 page thread or any of the other hullabaloo.

There's still a middle you're missing.

There's some space between "calculated to offend" and "likely to offend". That's where I'm headed for with my suggestions.

Now based on the comment above I don't mean offended in any sense of the word, like having one's beliefs challenged. In fact I don't tend to use the word offend myself except to extend a concept when other people bring it up.

Is there a better word for "feeling like one has been treated discourteously in social interaction"?
 
There's still a middle you're missing.

There's some space between "calculated to offend" and "likely to offend".

Well if you think its likely to offend and you do it anyway then its calculated to offend. The other option when you do something offensive is that you didn't think it would cause offence and you were wrong.
 
Well if you think its likely to offend and you do it anyway then its calculated to offend. The other option when you do something offensive is that you didn't think it would cause offence and you were wrong.

Maybe we're not disagreeing then.
 
Well if you think its likely to offend and you do it anyway then its calculated to offend. The other option when you do something offensive is that you didn't think it would cause offence and you were wrong.

No, calculated to offend is more than just saying something knowing it will likely offend. Calculated to offend implies that you say it the way you say it, at least in part, in order to cause offense.

It is quite possible to say or do something for a reason totally independent of offense, even while recognizing that it is almost certain to offend some people. Speaking out in support of unpopular issues, for example. Often, the purpose is not offense, but it may be acknowledged that offense will be an unintended but unavoidable consequence.

By analogy: When I take a certain allergy medication, the action is not calculated to make me drowsy, even though I'm pretty certain it WILL make me drowsy when I take it. The action is calculated to cure my allergies. The drowsiness is a side effect.
 
No, calculated to offend is more than just saying something knowing it will likely offend. Calculated to offend implies that you say it the way you say it, at least in part, in order to cause offense.

It is quite possible to say or do something for a reason totally independent of offense, even while recognizing that it is almost certain to offend some people. Speaking out in support of unpopular issues, for example. Often, the purpose is not offense, but it may be acknowledged that offense will be an unintended but unavoidable consequence.

Concur. I know that simply buying meat in the supermarket, or buying anything at WalMart, will cause offense to some. But if I decided to buy my turkeyburgers because they're reasonably healthy, I like them, and there was a good price, I don't think it's fair to say that my purchase was 'calculated to offend.'

(any debate about the relative healthiness of turkeyburgers should probably be split to another thread)
 
No, calculated to offend is more than just saying something knowing it will likely offend. Calculated to offend implies that you say it the way you say it, at least in part, in order to cause offense.

It is quite possible to say or do something for a reason totally independent of offense, even while recognizing that it is almost certain to offend some people. Speaking out in support of unpopular issues, for example. Often, the purpose is not offense, but it may be acknowledged that offense will be an unintended but unavoidable consequence.

By analogy: When I take a certain allergy medication, the action is not calculated to make me drowsy, even though I'm pretty certain it WILL make me drowsy when I take it. The action is calculated to cure my allergies. The drowsiness is a side effect.

I find your post offensively logical.
 
It should be noted that being "offensive" isn't inherently bad. Much aesthetic philosophy is devoted to the value of being offensive. Sometimes offensive speech is the best way to convey ideas and wrest us from our inirtia. Now, we ought not be offensive for the sake of our own gratification. That is the variable that makes sexual harraement pernicious. Also there are many environments where artistic or political offense are not appropriate.
 
I don't always find South Park funny, and I can go years between following it, but I am very glad it's out there shocking people. There is a lot of hypocrisy, and many sacred cows, out there and they need to be publicly outed.

We certainly can't count on the news industry.
 
One thing I don't believe anyone has mentioned is giving up the name of a famous person. That is different than using a pronoun or using a name of someone no one knows.

Let's compare this to an experience I had last year. One of my neighbors is a (semi) professional caterer. He catered a going away Law and Order party for a cast member who doesn't live that far from us. My neighbor has regular employees but sometimes when he caters a large party he needs extra help and he asks me to work for him on a per diem basis because we are friends and he knows my hours and he trusts me. I knew I might meet some L&O cast members so I was all in for this party.

Despite my having to sign a non-disclosure agreement before I could arrive on the premises and practically being strip searched in the field I parked in to prove I didn't have any cameras on me -- I do believe I won't be arrested for stating a female cast member of L&O who was a regular for years and very attractive groped me just like she groped all the guys working that day and she did it with the good natured intention of giving us each a story how a famous TV character grabbed their ass. I won't give up her name but a pretty woman from L&O grabbing my ass. That's history.

The attention I received from her was welcome to me, but even if it wasn't I think you shouldn't rat out famous people who give you attention unless they hurt you. As far as I am concerned it is all good.
 
Senex:

I am a 100% hetrosexual male, but I would greatly appreciate a picture of your ass.

Frankly after seeing you post in a myriad of threads about the multitudes of women who have found themselves powerless to grope you, I am deeply interested in seeing this miraculous mass of knotted muscle.

We may even be able to get you a shot at the $1million Challenge if you'd be prepared to expose females to your bottom under controlled laboratory conditions (which i assume would consist of the female researches whipping off their glasses, shaking down their hair, and then jumping you).
 
Senex:

I am a 100% hetrosexual male, but I would greatly appreciate a picture of your ass.

Frankly after seeing you post in a myriad of threads about the multitudes of women who have found themselves powerless to grope you, I am deeply interested in seeing this miraculous mass of knotted muscle.

We may even be able to get you a shot at the $1million Challenge if you'd be prepared to expose females to your bottom under controlled laboratory conditions (which i assume would consist of the female researches whipping off their glasses, shaking down their hair, and then jumping you).

Gee wiz -- no one has spoken about my bottom like that since I was 20 years old. This last story has nothing to do with my particular bottom. This was a beautiful famous TV character who was drunk and it appeared to me she wasn't clear how to tip so she gave a few seconds of attention to each of the slobs who worked there (and some of us were slobs). The bottom line was she just enjoyed teasing the hired help. I like to think she thought my bottom was special but that ship seems to have sailed (but that butt was tagged by her her).

I will look for a photo of my 18 year old butt to post.
 
One thing I don't believe anyone has mentioned is giving up the name of a famous person. That is different than using a pronoun or using a name of someone no one knows.

Let's compare this to an experience I had last year. One of my neighbors is a (semi) professional caterer. He catered a going away Law and Order party for a cast member who doesn't live that far from us. My neighbor has regular employees but sometimes when he caters a large party he needs extra help and he asks me to work for him on a per diem basis because we are friends and he knows my hours and he trusts me. I knew I might meet some L&O cast members so I was all in for this party.

Despite my having to sign a non-disclosure agreement before I could arrive on the premises and practically being strip searched in the field I parked in to prove I didn't have any cameras on me -- I do believe I won't be arrested for stating a female cast member of L&O who was a regular for years and very attractive groped me just like she groped all the guys working that day and she did it with the good natured intention of giving us each a story how a famous TV character grabbed their ass. I won't give up her name but a pretty woman from L&O grabbing my ass. That's history.

The attention I received from her was welcome to me, but even if it wasn't I think you shouldn't rat out famous people who give you attention unless they hurt you. As far as I am concerned it is all good.
I agree, besides, as Dylan told me over drinks, it's a social faux pas to drop names. That advice has stuck with me all these years. I shared it with Shermer at the TAM party while we discussed Broke Back Mountain over coffee. He seemed quite agreeable as he laughed and slapped his knee. Perhaps a bit too pleased.
 
What the hell. When feminists are getting all wound up about something, just stay away. Even if its something as minor as one of them getting hit on. Why would you tell them how silly they are being? That's the lesson to be learned here.

If it had been some hunk that she was into (or foxy lady), we wouldn't even be having this conversation.

The fact that the person who started this whole brouhaha, who is taking such a hard line about objectifying women, calls her little organization the skep"chicks" and put out a calender full of pictures of women made into sex objects tells you how ridiculous the whole thing is.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bc7uRF_JZI

The skepchicks seem to like to use sex to get attention. Either by objectifying themselves, or by complaining about being objectified. Whatever works.
 
Last edited:
The fact that the person who started this whole brouhaha, who is taking such a hard line about objectifying women, calls her little organization the skep"chicks" and put out a calender full of pictures of women made into sex objects tells you how ridiculous the whole thing is.

Hipster: "But she's doing it ironically!"
 
Senex:

I am a 100% hetrosexual male, but I would greatly appreciate a picture of your ass.

Frankly after seeing you post in a myriad of threads about the multitudes of women who have found themselves powerless to grope you, I am deeply interested in seeing this miraculous mass of knotted muscle.

We may even be able to get you a shot at the $1million Challenge if you'd be prepared to expose females to your bottom under controlled laboratory conditions (which i assume would consist of the female researches whipping off their glasses, shaking down their hair, and then jumping you).
c.jpg



I haven't found a picture of my bum at 17 but this is a picture of me in the school musical at 17. You probably can project what my bum looked like and I kid you not one night I was working as a bus boy and I had to turn around and tell the crowd of women, "Enough. Stop grabbing my ass. I'm getting serious now."

And the truth was I wasn't tired of getting goosed but I started to feel offended I wasn't able to turn the interest in my bottom into interest in losing my virginity. I felt somehow they should have gone together and they weren't.
 

I like how the article starts off by stating that Watson's speech was about women being made uncomfortable at these conferences due to men hitting on them constantly.

What I read is that her speech was about how to throw a really rockin' bordello themed party at atheist conferences. Girl power!

No wonder these things get so out of hand. This new info puts a new spin on things. So hard to get accurate info on the net. So much confusion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom