So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course, the young woman I approached in that hospital elevator after midnight is now my wife of 23 years.

"I buy her a steel chain every year on our anniversary. I tried gold, but she was able to weaken the shackle and was halfway out of the basement window before I caught her."
 
I think I'd be inclined to tell her how uncomfortable she makes me feel. Do I acknowledge her, talk to her about the weather, smile politely?

Is there anything I or any other man can do to make her feel less uncomfortable about being alone on an elevator with a man?

Until proven otherwise I and other men are to be considered sexual predators of women and children.

I was about to agree with 3Point14's post above this, but I like this even better. 3point14 went on to suggest cowering in the corner, but I think repeated genuflecting and groveling are more in order. I think a highly submissive stance would surely put her at ease. **Leans back from computer** Honey, where's my leash?
 
Because if self-proclaimed skeptics are going to expect that others alter their behaviour in some way I think they should have some consistent logic for what they are asking so that we can assess whether the argument holds water or not.

Well, I wrote a response to this, but then I accidentally did one of the many things in Windows 7 that you can do to do something irreversible.

Rather than retype it, I'll ask you. Is this statement of yours rhetoric about Watson or a serious question for a reasonable person, or something else?
 
Since the topic is about outrage and offense, I'd like to put a word in for men. Don't women realize how much of an affront it is to us when they point their breastises at us in close quarters?

Keep those glands pointed the other way for goodness sake. And while you are at it, cover them better. You should be able to find clothing that conceals your ability to feed infants.
 
Well, I wrote a response to this, but then I accidentally did one of the many things in Windows 7 that you can do to do something irreversible.

Rather than retype it, I'll ask you. Is this statement of yours rhetoric about Watson or a serious question for a reasonable person, or something else?

I've long since given up discussing the Watson situation in specifics.

There seems to be a school of thought that if someone takes offence at something I or anyone else have done then we need to alter our behaviour so that they are not offended. I can't see how this results in anything other than a tyranny of lowest offence threshold.

I was hoping someone would explain to me how it doesn't.
 
"based on what I know of most people, would this likely be unwelcome in this circumstance?"

So other than behaviour that is calculated to offend, pretty much anything could be OK?

I'm not sure if your suggestion would have avoided this 90 page thread or any of the other hullabaloo.
 
I've long since given up discussing the Watson situation in specifics.

There seems to be a school of thought that if someone takes offence at something I or anyone else have done then we need to alter our behaviour so that they are not offended. I can't see how this results in anything other than a tyranny of lowest offence threshold.

I was hoping someone would explain to me how it doesn't.

Then I'll answer from my perspective. It doesn't result in anything other than such a tyranny. It's also bad.

Skeptics have to give offense. That's part of what skepticism is for. Challenging homeopathy is going to offend people who believe it cured them. Challenging religion is going to offend people who value it.

The "giving offense" thing, however, is an alibi. People are only whipping it out because they think it seems more defensible and less transparent than what they really want to ram through, which is pure dogmatism and taboos on their sacred cows.
 
Really?

I know it makes me a very bad man, but I'd be awfully tempted to ask her if she wanted a cup of tea or something, just for the incredibly poor comedy value. I'd find it funny. She wouldn't. I think I'd manage to resist, but it would be very hard work. Is that just me?

If I could recognize her to the point that I was reasonably sure it was miss Watson, I'd probably say, "I hope you appreciate how many perfectly good jokes I'm passing up right now."

This would spark a blog about how women shouldn't have to 'appreciate' men acting like they should all the time. (Keeping their mouths shut that is. And while we're at it, go back to the kitchen and make them a sandwich.)
 
Last edited:
If I could recognize her to the point that I was reasonably sure it was miss Watson, I'd probably say, "I hope you appreciate how many perfectly good jokes I'm passing up right now."

As Joe said to Cy Borg, I've got a better idea, thanks to cursuswalker:

 
Last edited:
:p Yowza! Having to go back five pages to requote this:
Is there a source? I'd like to put this, or at least something about TAM 9 in the timeline.

At this point, just TAM scuttlebutt. I'll look into it.

Ok. Rechecked with attendee. According to him, it was fairly common knowledge around TAM that the Skepchicks as a community (with a couple of exceptions) made a big push via email to urge each speaker at TAM to speak out about Dawkins's comments. One speaker in particular he talked to, Carol Tavris, really didn't appreciate said push. Apparently, the speakers all got together pre-TAM to agree as a group that it was NOT a topic they felt would add anything to TAM, so they weren't going to bring it up.

I realize this is just "hearsay", however. Fwiw, I consider my sceptic source (whom I shall henceforth refer to as "Deep Doubt") very reliable. For an onymous source: If you want direct confirmation from one of the push targets, Carol TavrisWP probably your best bet (though one at a time, please, lest we inundate her with more shrill emails re elevator-gate). ;)

Another update: took my own advice and exchanged a couple of emails with Dr Tavris, and she's been very helpful, gracious and patient with me in clarifying what went on with the emails to the TAM presenters.

The emails were not, as rumored, sent by the Skepchicks (apologies for having suggested they were). They were sent by a fellow named Sasha Pixlee, on behalf of a group calling itself (from the email Dr Tavris and other TAM presenters were sent) "More Than Men, a new project run by and for concerned men in cooperation with the Women Thinking Free Foundation". His concerns about Elevatorgate et al, and motives for his email, can be discerned from this post at his website, "Sasha's Den of Iniquity".

While the Skepchicks' polemic against "straight white male privilege" in the atheist and skeptic movement clearly struck a chord with Sasha, they're not responsible for his overenthusiam; the emailing of TAM presenters was undertaken by him alone on his own more-than-manly initiative, it appears. My guess is talk of the emails was conflated with talk of the Skepchick letter-writing campaign vs Dawkins, leading to the TAM scuttlebutt I reported earlier, and which I mentioned in passing as if fact; whatever, my bad: a good lesson in going to the sources before passing on hearsay.

Thanks very much to Dr Tavris, whom I very much enjoyed corresponding with, for clearing up my confusion in the matter; and for any misinformation spread, sorry again. Mistakes were made, and, as usual, by me.
 
Another update: took my own advice and exchanged a couple of emails with Dr Tavris, and she's been very helpful, gracious and patient with me in clarifying what went on with the emails to the TAM presenters.

The emails were not, as rumored, sent by the Skepchicks (apologies for having suggested they were). They were sent by a fellow named Sasha Pixlee, on behalf of a group calling itself (from the email Dr Tavris and other TAM presenters were sent) "More Than Men, a new project run by and for concerned men in cooperation with the Women Thinking Free Foundation". His concerns about Elevatorgate et al, and motives for his email, can be discerned from this post at his website, "Sasha's Den of Iniquity".

While the Skepchicks' polemic against "straight white male privilege" in the atheist and skeptic movement clearly struck a chord with Sasha, they're not responsible for his overenthusiam; the emailing of TAM presenters was undertaken by him alone on his own more-than-manly initiative, it appears. My guess is talk of the emails was conflated with talk of the Skepchick letter-writing campaign vs Dawkins, leading to the TAM scuttlebutt I reported earlier, and which I mentioned in passing as if fact; whatever, my bad: a good lesson in going to the sources before passing on hearsay.

Thanks very much to Dr Tavris, whom I very much enjoyed corresponding with, for clearing up my confusion in the matter; and for any misinformation spread, sorry again. Mistakes were made, and, as usual, by me.

Thanks for the update. Nice work.
 
Another update: took my own advice and exchanged a couple of emails with Dr Tavris, and she's been very helpful, gracious and patient with me in clarifying what went on with the emails to the TAM presenters.

The emails were not, as rumored, sent by the Skepchicks (apologies for having suggested they were). They were sent by a fellow named Sasha Pixlee, on behalf of a group calling itself (from the email Dr Tavris and other TAM presenters were sent) "More Than Men, a new project run by and for concerned men in cooperation with the Women Thinking Free Foundation". His concerns about Elevatorgate et al, and motives for his email, can be discerned from this post at his website, "Sasha's Den of Iniquity".

While the Skepchicks' polemic against "straight white male privilege" in the atheist and skeptic movement clearly struck a chord with Sasha, they're not responsible for his overenthusiam; the emailing of TAM presenters was undertaken by him alone on his own more-than-manly initiative, it appears. My guess is talk of the emails was conflated with talk of the Skepchick letter-writing campaign vs Dawkins, leading to the TAM scuttlebutt I reported earlier, and which I mentioned in passing as if fact; whatever, my bad: a good lesson in going to the sources before passing on hearsay.

Thanks very much to Dr Tavris, whom I very much enjoyed corresponding with, for clearing up my confusion in the matter; and for any misinformation spread, sorry again. Mistakes were made, and, as usual, by me.
That's great. I love it when one of us goes the extra mile to get the evidence. Good for you.
 
Aren't eunuchs technically less than men?

May mean less is more, more or less.

...the Women Thinking Free Foundation".

I'm not saying a word.

And I'm just the messenger.

(You know, one might be tempted, mightily, to aver that every More-Than-Man would like a Foundation of Thinking-Free Women, so no surprise they hooked up; thankfully however, I, though only a man, no more no less, am no thrall to such temptations, thankfully.) :eusa_silenced:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom