So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
She's not. I haven't said she is. I don't see how it's possible to infer that I think she is from anything that I've said.

[snip]
I am completely lost Prometheus. I do not understand your discussion. Everything I thought you were saying so far you've gone on to say you weren't saying. I apologize but I give up. :boggled:

If you want to start over and just summarize what you started this discussion with, skip the why and the things you are not concerned about and just make your main points, I will try to start over. If you don't want to, I will understand.


If you are concerned about the issues RW brought up and not the RW name calling of McGraf and the rest of us who don't see things the way RW sees them, perhaps my thread is what you are looking for: EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Or, if it is the lack of skepticism that has been applied by many skeptics to the debate, this thread may be for you: Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?
 
Last edited:
I am completely lost Prometheus. I do not understand your discussion. Everything I thought you were saying so far you've gone on to say you weren't saying. I apologize but I give up. :boggled:

If you want to start over and just summarize what you started this discussion with, skip the why and the things you are not concerned about and just make your main points, I will try to start over. If you don't want to, I will understand.


If you are concerned about the issues RW brought up and not the RW name calling of McGraf and the rest of us who don't see things the way RW sees them, perhaps my thread is what you are looking for: EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Or, if it is the lack of skepticism that has been applied by many skeptics to the debate, this thread may be for you: Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

Ahh. I missed those other threads entirelyl...remember when I tried to bow out of this thread earlier, I admitted that I had misjudged the flow of conversation here and was thus off-topic....

Sorry for being a pain. :o
 
Ahh. I missed those other threads entirelyl...remember when I tried to bow out of this thread earlier, I admitted that I had misjudged the flow of conversation here and was thus off-topic....

Sorry for being a pain. :o
I wouldn't be so quick to conclude it was your fault. ;)
 
There's really two questions here:

1 - What should the formal rules be?
2 - What should someone who wants to take reasonable steps to avoid offending people do?

For #1 I prefer "behave as you see fit, absent obvious extremes". But it seems to me most of the discussion centers around #2. Figuring out a "threshold" that isn't necessarily the lowest may help to answer this.

I'm going to withdraw my 'not at all' having thought about it some more. I can't see a way in which the simple heurisitic 'if a offends b by doing x then a should not do x' does not tend towards the equilibrium point of lowest offence threshold given enough time and interactions.


Because if self-proclaimed skeptics are going to expect that others alter their behaviour in some way I think they should have some consistent logic for what they are asking so that we can assess whether the argument holds water or not.
 
Well, one thing is for sure. If I ever find myself on an elevator with Rebecca, I'm going to keep my mouth shut.
 
Well, one thing is for sure. If I ever find myself on an elevator with Rebecca, I'm going to keep my mouth shut.

Really?

I know it makes me a very bad man, but I'd be awfully tempted to ask her if she wanted a cup of tea or something, just for the incredibly poor comedy value. I'd find it funny. She wouldn't. I think I'd manage to resist, but it would be very hard work. Is that just me?
 
Really?

I know it makes me a very bad man, but I'd be awfully tempted to ask her if she wanted a cup of tea or something, just for the incredibly poor comedy value. I'd find it funny. She wouldn't. I think I'd manage to resist, but it would be very hard work. Is that just me?

I think I'd be inclined to tell her how uncomfortable she makes me feel. Do I acknowledge her, talk to her about the weather, smile politely?

Is there anything I or any other man can do to make her feel less uncomfortable about being alone on an elevator with a man?

Until proven otherwise I and other men are to be considered sexual predators of women and children.
 
Really?

I know it makes me a very bad man, but I'd be awfully tempted to ask her if she wanted a cup of tea or something, just for the incredibly poor comedy value. I'd find it funny. She wouldn't.

Wait, wait ! If there's even the slightest possibility of discomfert on her part, you have to refrain from doing anything. I hope you don't make noises with your nose when breathing, because that's annoying, and you shouldn't do that in the presence of other folks !
 
I'm going to withdraw my 'not at all' having thought about it some more. I can't see a way in which the simple heurisitic 'if a offends b by doing x then a should not do x' does not tend towards the equilibrium point of lowest offence threshold given enough time and interactions.

Good thing I'm not proposing that heuristic--only an interest in how one's behavior may come off to others.
 
If it's inappropriate for a man to approach a woman in an elevator, then I must be a bad man!

Of course, the young woman I approached in that hospital elevator after midnight is now my wife of 23 years.
 
If it's inappropriate for a man to approach a woman in an elevator, then I must be a bad man!

Of course, the young woman I approached in that hospital elevator after midnight is now my wife of 23 years.

Now we have a data point. Does this change anyone's opinion?

No? I thought not. Nobody has illusions that there's any skepticism involved in the pro-Watson side here.
 
If it's inappropriate for a man to approach a woman in an elevator, then I must be a bad man!

Of course, the young woman I approached in that hospital elevator after midnight is now my wife of 23 years.

:confused:

I thought a person had to be out of a coma before they could get married?
 
I think I'd be inclined to tell her how uncomfortable she makes me feel. Do I acknowledge her, talk to her about the weather, smile politely?

Is there anything I or any other man can do to make her feel less uncomfortable about being alone on an elevator with a man?

Until proven otherwise I and other men are to be considered sexual predators of women and children.


Thinking about it, it might be tremendously amusing to spent the entire elevator journey squeezed like petrified mouse into the corner furthest from her, letting out feeble squeaks and screams every time she so much as breathes heavily.
 
Good thing I'm not proposing that heuristic--only an interest in how one's behavior may come off to others.

Well I'm confused as to what you are actually proposing then. Given an interaction between A and B where you believe A has a chance of causing offence to B then A can either still do it or can choose not to do it.

Considering it and still doing it is pretty much the same as not considering it and doing it anyway so the only way having an interest in how your behaviour comes off to others differs from not having an interest is where you choose not to do something.

Certainly others before you were happy to suggest that if some people don't like X then people shouldn't do X.
 
Now we have a data point. Does this change anyone's opinion?

No? I thought not. Nobody has illusions that there's any skepticism involved in the pro-Watson side here.
A guy asked me to coffee in the elevator of the Revlon building at UCLA. I had said something about the Raeling clone claim and he agreed it was unlikely. We discussed the topic in the cafeteria of the old hospital. There was no sex and I never felt uncomfortable. Though to be sure he was young and attractive and I'm not a woman so there's that.
 
Well I'm confused as to what you are actually proposing then. Given an interaction between A and B where you believe A has a chance of causing offence to B then A can either still do it or can choose not to do it.

Considering it and still doing it is pretty much the same as not considering it and doing it anyway so the only way having an interest in how your behaviour comes off to others differs from not having an interest is where you choose not to do something.

Certainly others before you were happy to suggest that if some people don't like X then people shouldn't do X.

It's the difference between "could this possibly offend anyone at all?" and "based on what I know of most people, would this likely be unwelcome in this circumstance?"

The first is an unfair burden. The second is not. And, as well, nobody expects perfection on the second question, because cultures differ, circumstances differ, and it's not an exact science. That does not mean it isn't worth trying.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom