So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do we have to have the "lowest offense threshold" to want a threshold at all?

Not at all. But anything other than the lowest offence threshold means that sometimes people are going to have to be offended and deal with it. Which means we can't just equate 'I was offended by X' with 'X is bad and must stop'

Now how can we determine what the threshold is?

I guess we could try to document a code of behaviour that pretty much everyone can agree on.

Another way would be that people behave how they see fit and if people don't like them they steer clear of them.

I tend more towards the latter, but I don't think there is ever going to be a solution that pleases everyone.

ETA: Actually the more I think about I'm not sure the answer is 'not at all' even though it instinctively seems to be so. I'm not sure how you avoid a steady slide towards the lowest denominator if you place value on not offending someone over the right to offend. If its just the weight of numbers that is making the difference then you end up in the situation where its OK to offend minorities and that can't be right either.

I'll think on it. Do you have anything to offer?
 
Last edited:
Not at all. But anything other than the lowest offence threshold means that sometimes people are going to have to be offended and deal with it. Which means we can't just equate 'I was offended by X' with 'X is bad and must stop'

Now how can we determine what the threshold is?

I guess we could try to document a code of behaviour that pretty much everyone can agree on.

Another way would be that people behave how they see fit and if people don't like them they steer clear of them.

I tend more towards the latter, but I don't think there is ever going to be a solution that pleases everyone.

There's really two questions here:

1 - What should the formal rules be?
2 - What should someone who wants to take reasonable steps to avoid offending people do?

For #1 I prefer "behave as you see fit, absent obvious extremes". But it seems to me most of the discussion centers around #2. Figuring out a "threshold" that isn't necessarily the lowest may help to answer this.
 
Last edited:
...or not.

With respect for those who were making an honest effort.

I've been trying as best I can to respond straightforwardly, even to posts which were obviously sneering and condescending. As it becomes more hostile in this thread, I'm finding it difficult to justify putting up with it. I don't mind people disagreeing, even strongly. I don't mind being told I'm just plain wrong. I am interested in the issue, but not to the extent that I will subject myself to being patronized in order to pursue it. Consider me successfully chased out of the thread.
Oh, yes, you've been nothing but fair in your discussion in this thread.

And if my posts are condescending and sneering, it's because I feel the way you have ignored, obfuscated, strawmaned, ad homed, and shifted goal posts is worthy of every woo-ist on this forum. You, and others, I had believed to be better than that. And yet when these things are pointed out to you, you dig in your heels adamantly.

And still can't admit you were wrong.
 
And Lo: There was a mighty whooshing sound as AvalonXQ's comments passed over the heads of the people. And there was much whining.

Some of Avalon's best posts seem to be met by silence. I think it speaks to their quality.
 
Perhaps it might help those curious or confused about "where I'm coming from" to know how I'm reading this thread, so they understand maybe why I "don't seem to get it".

Here's what the arguments here are sounding like to me, in summary:

OK, here is what they sound like to me:

A: "If at TAM I find a complete stranger somehow interesting enough to have sex with in my opinion talk to in order to determine if they are interested in me, I should be free and clear to ask him/her for sex if I want at any time if they would like to continue the conversation."

B: "But what if they don't want to be asked?"

A: "Why should 'what they want' even matterHow will I know if I don't ask??"

Yes, the difference is that simple.

I don't assume motive without any further evidence, but even if you do assume motive how awful are the words he used? They may be clumsy, but to assign a sexist or misogynist tag to these words requires a lot more assumptions than a skeptic should be comfortable with. Even if he was heterosexual (assumption 1) and found her attractive (assumption 2) he still may have been more interested in her talk than her attractiveness. So one would have to assume that her sexuality was more important to his interest than her other qualities (assumption 3) and that the prime motivation for his approach was sex over all else (assumption 4). But even then, you have to make the final leap that finding someone primarily sexually attractive is sexist (assumption 5). Sorry, but that reasoning is weak and should be pounced on in this community.

That's not a "straw man"; that's literally what this whole business sounds like to me. Please feel free to correct A's statements if you feel the message should be different because I really do want to understand this.

I get it. That's what it sounded like to me at first. then I looked into RW's reaction and thought "what is wrong here?" What was wrong was her.

It strikes me as odd because A's two different statements in this case suggests cognitive dissonance to me. You ask a person to have sex with you because whether they want to have sex matters - yet whether they want to be asked for sex doesn't matter? How does that work? Sex is that thing you do with another person, right? There needs to be some kind of interaction there, right? Therefore, their opinions about sexual politics are worthy of consideration...right?

I think my version suffers less from such dissonance. In fact, in this light EG was treating RW as an equal, a person capable of making their own decisions. Odd for a feminist to complain about that, but whatevs.
 
...or not.

With respect for those who were making an honest effort.

I've been trying as best I can to respond straightforwardly, even to posts which were obviously sneering and condescending. As it becomes more hostile in this thread, I'm finding it difficult to justify putting up with it. I don't mind people disagreeing, even strongly. I don't mind being told I'm just plain wrong. I am interested in the issue, but not to the extent that I will subject myself to being patronized in order to pursue it. Consider me successfully chased out of the thread.
Sorry you feel that way. Social interaction means things don't always go our way. I guess that was a microcosm of perceived rude behavior and discontent. I wish you no ill will.
 
I think some would accuse you of a straw man. Otherwise I agree with you. So to get around that we should instead should suggest and encourage attendees not to consume alcohol. I would go further and suggest and encourage no fraternization at all. Last time I was at TAM there was an obnoxiously loud mouth woman bending my ear. It made me uncomfortable.
I don't see it as a straw man. I see it as an apt analogy. I don't like obnoxious drunken behavior at these events either. And I'm certain it is a problem because there was such a drunk at the second to last Seattle Skeptics meetup. We should address this issue as surely it keeps people from attending. [/sarcasm] [/satire]
 
Last edited:
...or not.

With respect for those who were making an honest effort.

I've been trying as best I can to respond straightforwardly, even to posts which were obviously sneering and condescending. As it becomes more hostile in this thread, I'm finding it difficult to justify putting up with it. I don't mind people disagreeing, even strongly. I don't mind being told I'm just plain wrong. I am interested in the issue, but not to the extent that I will subject myself to being patronized in order to pursue it. Consider me successfully chased out of the thread.
Some of what seems like sarcasm here is actually also satire intended to illustrate certain points.
 
I think some would accuse you of a straw man. Otherwise I agree with you. So to get around that we should instead should suggest and encourage attendees not to consume alcohol. I would go further and suggest and encourage no fraternization at all. Last time I was at TAM there was an obnoxiously loud mouth woman bending my ear. It made me uncomfortable.

I don't see it as a straw man. I see it as an apt analogy. I don't like obnoxious drunken behavior at these events either. And I'm certain it is a problem because there was such a drunk at the second to last Seattle Skeptics meetup. We should address this issue as surely it keeps people from attending.[/sarcasm]
Oh, I was talking about the solution not the problem. To be sure my sentiments were with Ivor. Big time. I didn't even say it was a straw man only that some might accuse him of one.

Otherwise I agree with both of you.
 
Do we have to have the "lowest offense threshold" to want a threshold at all?
No. I suggested whipping out dongs from under trenchcoats was beyond the threshold. But when you get to flirting and hitting on people, the difference between sexism and legitimate interest is a much fuzzier line.
 
No. I suggested whipping out dongs from under trenchcoats was beyond the threshold. But when you get to flirting and hitting on people, the difference between sexism and legitimate interest is a much fuzzier line.

Considering the Angry Vagina Crafts, I'm not sure that any but the largest dongs would be inappropriate.
 
I think the reason for the controversy is, as usual, that there's misunderstanding, and that people aren't considering the possibility of misunderstanding enough.

When I first saw Rebecca's video, after having been warned that Dawkins made a rude comment about it, I still didn't get it, and my reaction was a bit like Dawkins'. However, factoring Rebecca's obvious feelings, and assuming she's probably not completely irrational, I assumed there was something I didn't get about the story.

That something, I believe, was my impression that ElevatorGuy was someone Rebecca had just been socializing with at the bar. After I learned that they had not even been introduced, Rebecca's reaction suddenly seems a lot more understandable to me. Her imploration, 'Guys, don't do that', which had appeared to me as being quite annoyingly vague, could now be translated into something sensible:
"Don't approach women that are complete strangers when no one else is around."

Unfortunately, when not everybody immediately understood Rebecca's reaction, she didn't feel the need to be more specific about what happened. Instead, she assumed that because everyone didn't immediately feel what she had felt, it was proper to tell them off with a quite rude story. Certainly, a man 'joking' that the females who didn't agree with him were simply too unattractive to ever get laid, and that they should give up any hope for companionship and cure their itches with a sexual toy instead, would not be popular. I don't have any problem forgiving Rebecca, but: Gals, don't do that.

And, the same goes of course for Dawkin's comment. When he did not understand what made Rebecca upset, he should nevertheless have given her the benefit of the doubt: perhaps there was something more that he needed to know. He should have asked a polite question, rather than mocking Rebecca.
 
I just don't see how McGraf is more responsible for a misogynist misinterpreting her statements than one taking RW's nonsense and saying, "see how absurd these feminist are?"

She's not. I haven't said she is. I don't see how it's possible to infer that I think she is from anything that I've said.

You just have not convinced me why RW's unsupported assumptions are not relevant to the debate. Sure, they are not relevant to her own personal knee jerk reaction to EG, but the unsupported assumptions are key to RW claiming we should agree EG's come on was sexist objectification.

Well then it's a good thing that I've not been trying to convince you that RW's unsupported assumptions are not relevant to the debate. Her assumptions are central to the debate. Whether or not those assumptions are factually accurate is irrelevant to the portion of the debate that I'm interested in.

What is it you think I should do, accept RW's knee jerk reaction as legit beyond her individual emotional problem with EG? You said you realize we get it RW has a right to her own feelings. What more do you want you don't think you are getting?

Nope. I'd like to see the debate move away from Rebecca and her problem with EG, and explore more whether any part of her larger thesis has any merit. RW's reaction to EG really ought not to matter to anyone but her and EG.

But the rest of us are not sure they are correct.

Yes, I know. I'm not sure either. I think the truth is unknowable. I think it's a useless waste of time and effort to quibble over it. That's why I want to give her the benefit of the doubt and move on to more important matters.


You are saying we have no data to decide, but we do have data. We don't have all the data. RW had non-verbal cues we don't have. But we have RW claiming EG thought [x], heard [X], intended [X] and we have evidence RW had a doubtful basis for her claims.

Yes, I've already conceded as much. Reasonable people on both sides have disagreed over both the quality and interpretation of that available data. But again, I think it's not enough, and I don't think it's worth pursuing.


So what are you interested in?

Have you really missed it? I've stated my interest quite a few times in a number of different ways. I want to know whether or not there's anything to RW's thesis that sexual objectification is rampant in the skeptical community, and if it's responsible for keeping women from participating as much as they otherwise would. She see's EG as one example of a supposedly common behaviour, but it's impossible to know whether she's right about him without first knowing what he knew and what his intentions were. Regardless, the truth of this one example says nothing at all about whether the larger problem is real.


I suspect we are getting to the bottom of your issue here finally. Just my opinion mind you, but now I think you may just have a personal bias and it's causing you to reject valid criticisms of RW.

Wow. If that's an honest statement then you and I are on completely different planets. I'm not defending her at all. I'm interested in her argument, only. From what I've seen, she does a lousy job of communicating and supporting her argument, and that complicates matters. I've agreed with nearly all the criticisms of her that I've seen. It's just that many of them are pointless when it comes to the larger picture. If anything, I'd say it seems more likely that you have a personal bias that's causing you to cling to criticisms of RW that may be true, but just don't matter.
 
Last edited:
I think the reason for the controversy is, as usual, that there's misunderstanding, and that people aren't considering the possibility of misunderstanding enough.

When I first saw Rebecca's video, after having been warned that Dawkins made a rude comment about it, I still didn't get it, and my reaction was a bit like Dawkins'. However, factoring Rebecca's obvious feelings, and assuming she's probably not completely irrational, I assumed there was something I didn't get about the story.

That something, I believe, was my impression that ElevatorGuy was someone Rebecca had just been socializing with at the bar. After I learned that they had not even been introduced, Rebecca's reaction suddenly seems a lot more understandable to me. Her imploration, 'Guys, don't do that', which had appeared to me as being quite annoyingly vague, could now be translated into something sensible:
"Don't approach women that are complete strangers when no one else is around."

Unfortunately, when not everybody immediately understood Rebecca's reaction, she didn't feel the need to be more specific about what happened. Instead, she assumed that because everyone didn't immediately feel what she had felt, it was proper to tell them off with a quite rude story. Certainly, a man 'joking' that the females who didn't agree with him were simply too unattractive to ever get laid, and that they should give up any hope for companionship and cure their itches with a sexual toy instead, would not be popular. I don't have any problem forgiving Rebecca, but: Gals, don't do that.

And, the same goes of course for Dawkin's comment. When he did not understand what made Rebecca upset, he should nevertheless have given her the benefit of the doubt: perhaps there was something more that he needed to know. He should have asked a polite question, rather than mocking Rebecca.
I would say you have bearly scratched the surface of data to make a decision. There is ever so much more. Yesterday was a watershed thanks to RW's video where she makes some glaring admissions.

In the end I don't personally care. I'm happy to let her have her take at face value. IMO it doesn't warrant her refusal to discuss the reasonable criticisms made. "You don't get it" ISN'T argument. Nor is it conducive to skepticism, critical thinking, or the dialectic. Her *"white male privelage" BS broke new records for fallacy by a supposed skeptic. Though, considering the emotional and disgusting vitriol leveled at her and the poorly worded reponse by Dawkins I get it, but I can't condone it. Especially from one who holds herself up as an icon. If sexism is hurting the cause then so is she.

*I have brought this up at least a dozen times in various forums including NESS and no one has defended it nor have her defenders conceded that it was embarassingly innapropriate. We don't want to let EG go but this bit of stinking sophistry no one wants to touch.
 
Last edited:
At about 40' 40" she admits to having face-blindness or prosopagnosia. She admits to being unable to recognize faces until she sees them on several occasions. Until then, she requires distinctive hairdos, glasses, etc. for recognition.

...

.....

OK, I'm about ready to just say "foolish bovine" and just wash my hands of this whole Elevatorgate thing.

"I was propositioned by a stranger! Well i think he was a stranger, I don't recognize faces...and it may not have been a proposition..." ...

*Sigh* And to think, if ONLY Elevator Guy had been dressed appropriately to attend an atheists' convention where RW was speaking, all this ugliness might have been avoided...

03754485.jpg


“…don’t take this the wrong way, but I find you
very interesting, and I would like to talk more,
would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?”
 
I think the reason for the controversy is, as usual, that there's misunderstanding, and that people aren't considering the possibility of misunderstanding enough......
Your review suggests you missed a whole lot of the thread.

While there is a lot of extra stuff in this post, a summary of the actual issues being debated can be found in it. Read the middle, skip the beginning and the end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom