So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
At about 40' 40" she admits to having face-blindness or prosopagnosia. She admits to being unable to recognize faces until she sees them on several occasions. Until then, she requires distinctive hairdos, glasses, etc. for recognition.

...

.....

OK, I'm about ready to just say "foolish bovine" and just wash my hands of this whole Elevatorgate thing.

"I was propositioned by a stranger! Well i think he was a stranger, I don't recognize faces...and it may not have been a proposition..."

I hope her overblown cache in the community takes an appropriate hit after all this.
 
No. Simply No. RW says a stranger invited her to his room for coffee. She chose to interpret this as a request for sex. You have shown no evidence that this is a reasonable interpretation.

It's not my anecdote. I'm pursuing a discussion of the implications of the situation as if her interpretation was the correct one, without knowing for sure whether it was; I do believe I plainly stated that much earlier in the thread. But I'll repeat it here for anyone who missed it.

I'm interested in the discussion of the appropriateness of sexual propositions toward people who are not receptive to them. All of my opinions here address the instance of a generic person being definitely propositioned by a generic stranger for sex. I realize that focusing on the 'RW vs EG' event specifically and arguing the minutae of that business is a distraction, so a couple of posts ago I proposed the scenario of bookitty (as an example of someone who would not want strangers coming up and asking for sex) being explicitly asked for sex. I would like to have that discussion. People who do not, don't have to - but I would ask that people stop replying to my posts picking nits about 'well how do you get sex from coffee' and 'does RW speak for all women', etc, because while those things are part of the larger issue in this whole thread, they have no bearing on the specific part of the issue my posts are meant to address. Fair?

You're not? You haven't suggested that strangers at TAM should not be allowed to ask each other for sex (note that I included social norms as a means of disallowing the action, not simply making it illegal)?

No. I'm not talking about imposing rules, or even societal norms as pressure. I'm talking about you, as the person reading this post (not just 'Bob' but anyone reading); why would you personally, regardless of whatever the 'norm' is, find giving up asking strangers for sex at (short event) knowing there are without any doubt some people there who will feel hurt, slighted, insulted, or otherwise made uncomfortable by your request, to be an unreasonable choice?

We can even simplify it further: instead of talking about the set of 'sex objects' at the conference as a whole, let's narrow it down.

Here is a woman, a complete stranger, that you find compelling enough to want to have sex with. One of the arguments I'm hearing a lot is 'special pleading' - what makes these people different, that their feelings are worth making an exception for? Well, what makes this woman different is that she is the one you took an interest in, out of all the other women you happened to see that day; you want to have a sexual relationship with her. You want to ask her. Now here is a convenient moment, but wait: there is a very real possibility that by asking her out of the blue like this, she will feel disrespected and will pointedly avoid you for the rest of the conference. It might hurt her. Might even go home and blog about 'that guy', meaning you, and decide it's not worth going to (events) anymore. Statistically speaking, she may be exactly as likely to react this way as she is to fall into your arms - you don't know, and have no way of finding out because the moment is here now. It's time to make a decision. Tell me your thought process right now.

I will get to everyone else's posts eventually - I'm mobile with my iPod at the moment so please be patient.
 
Last edited:
You know what I find really tiresome? Drunk people. They're loud, irrational and often transgress social norms such as failing to pick up when you're not interested in whatever they're trying to talk about at you.

For these reasons I believe alcohol is incompatible with the goals of the sceptical movement and is putting off many people who would otherwise attend.

I therefore suggest alcohol should be banned from the next TAM.
 
No. I'm not talking about imposing rules, or even societal norms as pressure. I'm talking about you, as the person reading this post (not just 'Bob' but anyone reading); why would you personally, regardless of whatever the 'norm' is, find giving up asking strangers for sex at (short event) knowing there are without any doubt some people there who will feel hurt, slighted, insulted, or otherwise made uncomfortable by your request, to be an unreasonable choice?

See for me it's not about me personally but about the general principle. While I may not want to proposition women randomly at events I simply object to the idea that one person with a low threshold of offence is the standard by which we decide what is appropriate and inappropriate behaviour at an event.

If a woman said she hated it when people wear jeans to conferences as people should be more professional we'd be looking at the proposition objectively and trying to see if there was a point or not and evaluating the benefits of not wearing jeans and the drawbacks of removing the freedom to wear jeans.

Because its about something remotely sexual this approach seems to go out the window. That's the bit that bugs me.


We can even simplify it further: instead of talking about the set of 'sex objects' at the conference as a whole, let's narrow it down.

Here is a woman, a complete stranger, that you find compelling enough to want to have sex with. One of the arguments I'm hearing a lot is 'special pleading' - what makes these people different, that their feelings are worth making an exception for? Well, what makes this woman different is that she is the one you took an interest in, out of all the other women you happened to see that day; you want to have a sexual relationship with her. You want to ask her. Now here is a convenient moment, but wait: there is a very real possibility that by asking her out of the blue like this, she will feel disrespected and will pointedly avoid you for the rest of the conference. It might hurt her. Might even go home and blog about 'that guy', meaning you, and decide it's not worth going to (events) anymore. Statistically speaking, she may be exactly as likely to react this way as she is to fall into your arms - you don't know, and have no way of finding out because the moment is here now. It's time to make a decision. Tell me your thought process right now.

I think to get an answer to this you're going to have to ask the guys who proposition women randomly at such events and they seem to be fairly rare.

I can only speculate that the reasoning is that a bad attempt has more chance of success than no attempt at all.
 
You know what I find really tiresome? Drunk people. They're loud, irrational and often transgress social norms such as failing to pick up when you're not interested in whatever they're trying to talk about at you.

For these reasons I believe alcohol is incompatible with the goals of the sceptical movement and is putting off many people who would otherwise attend.

I therefore suggest alcohol should be banned from the next TAM.
I think some would accuse you of a straw man. Otherwise I agree with you. So to get around that we should instead should suggest and encourage attendees not to consume alcohol. I would go further and suggest and encourage no fraternization at all. Last time I was at TAM there was an obnoxiously loud mouth woman bending my ear. It made me uncomfortable.
 
Last edited:
I think some would accuse you of a straw man. Otherwise I agree with you. So to get around that we should instead should suggest and encourage attendees not to consume alcohol. I would go further and suggest and encourage no fraternization at all. Last time I was at TAM there was an obnoxiously loud mouth woman bending my ear. It made me uncomfortable.

I think the correct solution is to have 2 simultaneous TAM meetings - one run under the tyranny of lowest offence threshold where all attendees can make a list of everything they find objectionable and agree to refrain from any activity mentioned on the list for the duration. Across the street we can have a Roman orgy-esque anything goes TAM where people have to be grown up enough to deal with other people or politely excuse themself.

Wonder which one would sell more tickets?
 
I think the correct solution is to have 2 simultaneous TAM meetings - one run under the tyranny of lowest offence threshold where all attendees can make a list of everything they find objectionable and agree to refrain from any activity mentioned on the list for the duration. Across the street we can have a Roman orgy-esque anything goes TAM where people have to be grown up enough to deal with other people or politely excuse themself.

Wonder which one would sell more tickets?

Roman orgy ? Will there be fruits ?
 
I think the correct solution is to have 2 simultaneous TAM meetings - one run under the tyranny of lowest offence threshold where all attendees can make a list of everything they find objectionable and agree to refrain from any activity mentioned on the list for the duration. Across the street we can have a Roman orgy-esque anything goes TAM where people have to be grown up enough to deal with other people or politely excuse themself.

Wonder which one would sell more tickets?
:D

Someone much wiser than myself told me that life IS theatre of the absurd.

A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
 
...or not.

With respect for those who were making an honest effort.

I've been trying as best I can to respond straightforwardly, even to posts which were obviously sneering and condescending. As it becomes more hostile in this thread, I'm finding it difficult to justify putting up with it. I don't mind people disagreeing, even strongly. I don't mind being told I'm just plain wrong. I am interested in the issue, but not to the extent that I will subject myself to being patronized in order to pursue it. Consider me successfully chased out of the thread.
 
Last edited:
I think the correct solution is to have 2 simultaneous TAM meetings - one run under the tyranny of lowest offence threshold where all attendees can make a list of everything they find objectionable and agree to refrain from any activity mentioned on the list for the duration. Across the street we can have a Roman orgy-esque anything goes TAM where people have to be grown up enough to deal with other people or politely excuse themself.

Wonder which one would sell more tickets?


I see a REAL big problem with this. Namely, Watson would be at *your* TAM, and you'd still have to put up with her.
 
...or not.

With respect for those who were making an honest effort.

I've been trying as best I can to respond straightforwardly, even to posts which were obviously sneering and condescending. As it becomes more hostile in this thread, I'm finding it difficult to justify putting up with it. I don't mind people disagreeing, even strongly. I don't mind being told I'm just plain wrong. I am interested in the issue, but not to the extent that I will subject myself to being patronized in order to pursue it. Consider me successfully chased out of the thread.

I'm admittedly not reading every single word of this thread since it's so long but I've noticed on at least a couple occasions making posts assuming EG's words were a blatant attempt at getting sex, which isn't exactly fair play.
 
Do we have to have the "lowest offense threshold" to want a threshold at all?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom