So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is your "evidence" that EG ever existed outside of RW's mind, or that she was ever propositioned, for coffee or anything else, in this instance or any other instance, ever?

We're discussing events that RW says happened. According to her, a stranger asked her for sex.

Now we're squarely in la-la land, Checkmite. Are you seriously comparing doubting the reality of what she described actually happening, and doubting her interpretation of the words he uttered ? Really ?

Quibbling over whether it was "really a request for sex" fails to address the question of whether requesting sex in such a manner is appropriate/acceptable/whatever.

That's assuming it hasn't been adressed fifteen thousand times already.

If RW is the only source of information about this incident (and she is), if you want to discuss it, you've got to play the cards she deals you.

So if she had reported this situation and then said: "I believe he was one of our reptilian overlords in disguise", we'd have to go with that and not discuss whether her interpretation was correct ? This is just ******* crazy !
 
Oh, she is such a doll. You'd like her.

I didn't ask what's Linda like, I asked: »Who's Linda?«

Really, more and more I'm getting the impression that some of you guys don't use language as a means of communication but of obfuscation.
 
Like people, language is complicated; and having English as a second language, I might not always be able to read between the lines. But is this seeming contradiction really the gist you took from the conversation?

There's no seeming about it. Either people at sceptical/atheist conferences are expected to behave as asexual beings, or they're to be allowed to express sexual interest in each other.

Are you implying that to »chat up« has the same connotations as »to approach« does? Or is it possible that Watson was talking about different situations at different times?

What? How can you chat someone up without approaching them?

Who's Linda?

Another poster on this forum who has been contributing to this thread.
 
If RW is the only source of information about this incident (and she is), if you want to discuss it, you've got to play the cards she deals you.

Cool-a-rama.

I met this bloke the other day, he was Jesus. I believe him, he totally was.

He says everybody has to send me £50. I'll look forward to your contribution.


(ETA - Belz said it better)
 
Last edited:
Oh, she is such a doll. You'd like her.

Does she like coffee?

:D I think she's Canadian (or maybe I just like to think she's one of us); if she is, then we can infer statistically that there's an 81% probability she drinks slightly less than 2.6 cups of coffee per day.

I didn't ask what's Linda like, I asked: »Who's Linda?«

Really, more and more I'm getting the impression that some of you guys don't use language as a means of communication but of obfuscation.

Here's the post you're after, arko. :)
 
Last edited:
Which again brings up an interesting point: should people EVER speak to one another ? I mean, you never know when you'll make someone else uncomfortable. In fact, we should stay as far away from one another as possible !
STFU! Actually I made that argument also. We should all be good little robots.
 
If I expected to hear something I'm not already aware of, or if it was a transcript I could skim for the relevant parts, I'd be interested. But 70 minutes of an uninteresting conversation? No thanks.

I haven't finished it, because it's really quite tedious, but here's a partial list of highlights:

The first 24 minutes or so are about general skepticism.

At about 25 minutes and change in, Watson repeats her straw man about what Kirby said.

At about 26' 15" says that she had said that other people don't have her experiences, and that's "great," which is not very consistent with Watson's straw man about Kirby and her declaration that she wanted to give her an hour-long lecture.

At about 28' 30" Watson says that she doesn't think that atheists are more sexist or misogynistic than the general population.

At about 28' 57" she says that she doesn't think that there's a conscious decision to bat down women, which is pretty much what Kirby was saying, making Watson's straw man about Kirby all the more noticable.

At about 37' 30" she says that she "held out" about ten hours at the bar.

At about 40' 00" she says that he was in his early- to mid-50s.

At about 40' 40" she admits to having face-blindness or prosopagnosia. She admits to being unable to recognize faces until she sees them on several occasions. Until then, she requires distinctive hairdos, glasses, etc. for recognition.

That's when I stopped and went to bed.
 
I didn't ask what's Linda like, I asked: »Who's Linda?«

Really, more and more I'm getting the impression that some of you guys don't use language as a means of communication but of obfuscation.
I like Taco Tuesday.
 
You can't just capriciously decide to "okay, we'll pretend this basic situation really happened, but I think RW got this part and this part and this part wrong". All the details are part of one single anecdote. You take the anecdote as a whole or dismiss it as a whole.
Because people never incorporate fiction into their naratives? Like, if I say I went to the store yesterday and on my home was abducted by aliens, flown to pluto, saw god and Elvis it would then be impossible to accept that I went to the store if you were skeptical of the rest? I'm not so sure.

I accept RW's account at face value though.
 
At about 40' 40" she admits to having face-blindness or prosopagnosia. She admits to being unable to recognize faces until she sees them on several occasions. Until then, she requires distinctive hairdos, glasses, etc. for recognition.

Yes, I noticed that part. I guess that explains why she never seems to recognise me. :)

It does raise a couple of questions:
1) How can she be so sure that EG was in the group in the bar?
2) How can she be sure she hasn't interacted with him before, and the question wasn't actually out of the blue, maybe continuing some conversation he remembered but she didn't?


ETA: I guess it also explains why she wears distinctive glasses, so she can tell when she's looking in a mirror. ;)
 
Last edited:
Personally I feel it would be wrong, but even worse if the teacher called out a specific student by name as an example of this. Vilifying someone in her audience for not agreeing with her.

I wonder what sort of bully would do such a thing?

And Lo: There was a mighty whooshing sound as AvalonXQ's comments passed over the heads of the people. And there was much whining.
 
Last edited:
I haven't finished it, because it's really quite tedious, but here's a partial list of highlights:

The first 24 minutes or so are about general skepticism.

At about 25 minutes and change in, Watson repeats her straw man about what Kirby said.

At about 26' 15" says that she had said that other people don't have her experiences, and that's "great," which is not very consistent with Watson's straw man about Kirby and her declaration that she wanted to give her an hour-long lecture.

At about 28' 30" Watson says that she doesn't think that atheists are more sexist or misogynistic than the general population.

At about 28' 57" she says that she doesn't think that there's a conscious decision to bat down women, which is pretty much what Kirby was saying, making Watson's straw man about Kirby all the more noticable.

At about 37' 30" she says that she "held out" about ten hours at the bar.

At about 40' 00" she says that he was in his early- to mid-50s.

At about 40' 40" she admits to having face-blindness or prosopagnosia. She admits to being unable to recognize faces until she sees them on several occasions. Until then, she requires distinctive hairdos, glasses, etc. for recognition.

That's when I stopped and went to bed.

She also mentions that several of the boyfriends she's had in the recent past have been sceptics.

Obviously this is not supposed to be an option for anyone else given Ms. Watson's desire to see an end to sexual interest being expressed at sceptical events because some women don't like being hit on and don't come back.
 
Last edited:
Do you say so seriously? Is it genuinely considered by most to be part of the "conference experience" to get laid? Because - in all honesty - that part of it had completely escaped me. I've never seen it mentioned in any kind of literature for any conferences I've been to. Heck, I've never even seen it mentioned on the forums until this debacle. I had assumed that whatever kind of "hooking up" took place at conferences was proportional to the amount that normally happens in public.

Hang on, why have you introduced the word most here? I said 'some'. And yes, in my experience in any situation where there are large numbers of people engaging in a social activity especially in a setting that takes them out of their normal surroundings then some percentage of participants will have 'maybe hooking up with someone' somewhere on their list of 'things I'd like to do at this event'. You admit as much yourself in your last sentence. Not all of those people will even be conference participants, some of them will just be people who happen to be in the same place at the same time.

So we clearly agree that we have some people at the conference who would like to make/receive propositions and some who would not. We can now move on to whether we should weigh one set of preferences more heavily than another.

Because one of them has a choice to participate in the "event" of a proposition, and one doesn't. It is my nature to err on the side of those who don't have a choice.

Yep, you don't have a choice in how I decide to behave. Just like I don't have a choice in how you behave. I'm not sure that's something I want to change; you do?

But your argument still applies to just about any behaviour. I don't have a choice whether someone at TAM eats chocolate before breakfast, nobody would argue that means people should refrain from doing so.

I think the problem is that you are only focusing on the one segment of interactions (those between willing propositioners and unwilling propositionees) and eliminating those while not acknowledging that doing so implicitly means you are valuing the desires of the unwilling propositionees above all other participants in the event.

How about the people who do want to be propositioned make themselves known? If they want to meet people for sex at TAM, surely openly identifying themselves isn't the same kind of obstacle that it is for those who do not wish to participate.

How exactly would you propose they do so? Finish their talk with 'if anyone would like to **** after this raise your hand now?', wear a badge saying 'Yes, please!'?

Why do you default to this position? If its just about choice then those who don't want to be propositioned can choose to make it clear they don't want to be.

How are we supposed to choose between these two equally valid options, or the status quo?

Then why are you asking me if making a decision based on the discomfort of "just one person" is justified?

Because I think its a nonsense that you entertain this logic that if one person complains about something then nobody should do it anywhere where that one person is likely to be.

Your objection that in this case its not just one person (its a handful) doesn't change the logic.


Let's how about this. Instead of making this an issue of whether one kind of behavior is better than another, how about debating the merits of making participation in the casual sex scene - the entirety of it, including the initial "seduction" - a matter of being "opt-in", which I think it should be, rather than "opt-out", which you think it should be? Currently every single other activity, event, meal, or diversion of any kind which takes place at TAM, up to and including participation in the conference in the first place, is opt-in.

Just like the people who want to go to the Peppermill (if they do that anymore), or run to the Grand Canyon on Friday, or participate in the poker challenges (if they do that anymore), why not start a thread before the meeting, asking who is interested in "hooking up"? This will result in a list of names and faces that one who wishes to participate can put their efforts toward. The positives: much, much less effort wasted on the part of those who like to proposition; much less chance of disappointment for those who wish to be propositioned; much less chance of discomfort for those who do not wish to propositioned. Every-damn-body wins. Downsides, please?

Well it absolutely is a question about whether one kind of behaviour is better than another. By separating casual sex propositions into the 'opt in' category you are absolutely making a judgement about that behaviour in comparison to every other social interaction. There is absolutely no good reason for it.

Someone can approach me at a conference and ask 'hey would you like to go see a movie?' or 'hey do you wanna go bowling?' without us having to all identify ourselves beforehand and plan who among us are willing to see a movie or bowl.

And does it even solve the problem? Instead of being propositioned at TAM you end up being propositioned before TAM to see if you want to join the hooking up events. Is that better?

Of course you can. Will you do so around Dawkins, knowing he dislikes it? Up to you. I can tell you which one I would do, which one seems the most reasonable to me.

Which isn't your original argument. Are you discussing a one-on-one interaction where we know one of the participants dislikes it or are we discussing what I thought we were which was eliminating a behaviour totally from a population because we know that some segment of the population doesn't like it.

No; it means people who are aware and wish to be considerate of your wishes/feelings would desist from posting links to videos in threads you're participating in (I'm assuming you would have the foresight not to click on "the YouTube thread" and so forth). Those who don't care about your feelings of course would not.

Well I'm sure people who don't like being propositioned in hotel elevators at 4am would have the foresight not to hang out with a bunch of guys till 4am in a hotel bar and then ride the elevator alone back to their room but I'm not sure how that works out in practice.

But, seriously, you think that its a good idea that people don't post links to videos that might have some really useful and important content in a thread that might have 100s of participants because I have expressed a preference for it? Seriously?????

I need to go out so I've cut short the rest of your answer, there really wasn't anything I particularly wanted to say in response in any case. I'm not entirely sure what you are proposing though - it seems to have changed from 'people shouldn't hit on one another at TAM' to 'if people hit on people who don't like it at TAM then I reserve the right to call them a dick' - I'm fine with the latter although it does run the risk of people thinking you are something of a dick too if you choose to do so. Which in turn....and so on and so on until 85 page thread appears!
 
She also mentions the several of the boyfriends she's had in the recent past have been sceptics.
One well-known, though oddly not mentioned, example being her husband.
Obviously this is not supposed to be an option for anyone else given Ms. Watson's desire to see an end to sexual interest being expressed at sceptical events because some women don't like being hit on and don't come back.

It is hard to pin down exactly what she wants people to stop. I can certainly see that she doesn't want to be invited to someone's room for coffee at 4 AM in a lift by someone who has not (as far as she can recall) spoken to her before, when she has said she's tired and has just been speaking about not wanting to be objectified sexually. The question is, how much further can we generalise the request, since that example is so specific it's unlikely to occur again. I don't think she is really saying that women should never be propositioned at atheist or other conferences, only that it should not be out of the blue. The thing to be defined then is how well she thinks the two people should know each other before the subject is raised.

The other issue, and it has been discussed here though I don't know we've reached a conclusion, is whether she is correct to say that the request for coffee was objectifying her sexually, even if it was a request for something more than coffee. Why is it not enough just to say the advance was unwelcome?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom