In a, "The enemy of my enemy is my friend," sort of way. Please note, though, that I am not suggesting that the possibility of being misconstrued by misogynists as supportive of their position in any way means you shouldn't say what you're saying. My position on this matter is solely descriptive, and may not even be correct.
I really think it is your point that you need to re-evaluate, but that's just my take on your posts.
That's entirely possible. I'll do both.
I can't follow your Zicam example, too many superfluous details.
Yeah, re-reading that bit,
I'm not too sure what I was saying, other than that I think your original analogy to homeopathy is not apt--I still think so, but I haven't got anything better.
But as to your opinion, so RW can base her conclusions about EG's intent and motive on unsupported assumptions, and that's OK, the assumptions aren't relevant.
I really don't see why this is so difficult for me to get across. RW's conclusions about EG's intent are taken as given.
I'm assuming they're correct because I'm not interested in the fact of the matter, and I think the fact of the matter is unknowable at this point anyway. I'm starting with that (arguably unfounded) assumption, and using it as a rhetorical example. I believe that's partly what RW was doing in her initial video, too, though I doubt she'd agree with the 'unfounded' part. Whatever the fact of EG's intent and motive were are only interesting if one wishes to put him on trial for his actions in this circumstance, and
I'm not interested in doing so, though RW may have been.
And you realize we aren't saying RW doesn't have a right to her personal view of EG.
Yes, that is clear "as an unmuddied lake...as clear as an azure sky of deepest summer...."
And now you say all you care about is RW called attention to something?
That's my feeling toward her personally as regards this matter. That's not all I care about in general.
What are you arguing for? Just that some misogynist might possibly be comforted by McGraf's blog?
My opinion is that a good deal of the criticism that's been leveled at Rebecca, while arguably justified, has been unhelpful at best (though I have here been focussing narrowly on that part of said criticism that has been concerned with her judgement of EG).
In fact, I think the majority of what's been said on both sides since this whole thing began has only served to confuse and distract from important matters. Mostly, I just think the whole controversy is sad.