So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Try again using an analogy that doesn't involve a power difference between speaker and listener and a person children are taught to listen to, trust and believe.

Glen Beck announcing that atheists cannot be real Americans; Tracy Morgan ranting during his comedy routine that he would kill his son if the boy ever "came out" as gay one day, amongst other homophobic things; Jim Hoft blaming journalist Lara Logan for the sexual assault she experienced in Egypt.
 
Glen Beck announcing that atheists cannot be real Americans; Tracy Morgan ranting during his comedy routine that he would kill his son if the boy ever "came out" as gay one day, amongst other homophobic things; Jim Hoft blaming journalist Lara Logan for the sexual assault she experienced in Egypt.
All media personalities with big audiences, and, they all receive plenty of criticism.

You have no proof EG was soliciting sex. He asked to talk and took no for an answer.

Honestly, I'm more confused by your false analogies than I am enlightened as to the point you are trying to make.
 
All media personalities with big audiences, and, they all receive plenty of criticism.

You have no proof EG was soliciting sex. He asked to talk and took no for an answer.

Honestly, I'm more confused by your false analogies than I am enlightened as to the point you are trying to make.

To recap:

...my point is only this: it's not 'just going up and talking to someone'. EG wasn't chatting for chatting's sake; he had an agenda. It wasn't exactly devious or anything like that - but people can take exception to the motivation behind words, whether real or perceived. When that happens, it's unfair to characterize their taking exception as 'being upset because someone came up and talked to them'. While it's technically true, it leaves out an important part of the objection.
 
Perhaps it might help those curious or confused about "where I'm coming from" to know how I'm reading this thread, so they understand maybe why I "don't seem to get it".

Here's what the arguments here are sounding like to me, in summary:

A: "If at TAM I find a complete stranger somehow interesting enough to have sex with in my opinion, I should be free and clear to ask him/her for sex if I want at any time."

B: "But what if they don't want to be asked?"

A: "Why should 'what they want' even matter?"

That's not a "straw man"; that's literally what this whole business sounds like to me. Please feel free to correct A's statements if you feel the message should be different because I really do want to understand this.

It strikes me as odd because A's two different statements in this case suggests cognitive dissonance to me. You ask a person to have sex with you because whether they want to have sex matters - yet whether they want to be asked for sex doesn't matter? How does that work? Sex is that thing you do with another person, right? There needs to be some kind of interaction there, right? Therefore, their opinions about sexual politics are worthy of consideration...right?

Or is all of that only "right" if the person in fact does want to have sex; and everyone else can take a long walk as far as you're concerned?

I say, if someone's willingness or unwillingness to be solicited for sex by a stranger is not important enough to consider and accommodate, then I don't see why peoples' desires to have sex with a stranger should be important enough to accommodate. If you want to have sex but don't want to be bothered with other peoples' feelings about it, go up to your room and have a long conversation with your hand. Barring that, there's always Mr. Baseball Cards outside the hotel. He knows some strangers who want to have sex with you.
 
Last edited:
To recap:
To recap how your issue was addressed:

Do you read minds? Did RW read EG's mind?

Was it a public elevator?

Did EG take a simple no answer and go on his way?

Did he not have a right to be in the elevator?

Is there are law against talking to people in a public elevator?


Get over the "he only wanted to screw" claim unless you have actual evidence, not unsupported speculation.
 
Last edited:
Exactly how so?

In a, "The enemy of my enemy is my friend," sort of way. Please note, though, that I am not suggesting that the possibility of being misconstrued by misogynists as supportive of their position in any way means you shouldn't say what you're saying. My position on this matter is solely descriptive, and may not even be correct.


I really think it is your point that you need to re-evaluate, but that's just my take on your posts.

That's entirely possible. I'll do both.


I can't follow your Zicam example, too many superfluous details.

Yeah, re-reading that bit, I'm not too sure what I was saying, other than that I think your original analogy to homeopathy is not apt--I still think so, but I haven't got anything better.

But as to your opinion, so RW can base her conclusions about EG's intent and motive on unsupported assumptions, and that's OK, the assumptions aren't relevant.

I really don't see why this is so difficult for me to get across. RW's conclusions about EG's intent are taken as given. I'm assuming they're correct because I'm not interested in the fact of the matter, and I think the fact of the matter is unknowable at this point anyway. I'm starting with that (arguably unfounded) assumption, and using it as a rhetorical example. I believe that's partly what RW was doing in her initial video, too, though I doubt she'd agree with the 'unfounded' part. Whatever the fact of EG's intent and motive were are only interesting if one wishes to put him on trial for his actions in this circumstance, and I'm not interested in doing so, though RW may have been.



And you realize we aren't saying RW doesn't have a right to her personal view of EG.

Yes, that is clear "as an unmuddied lake...as clear as an azure sky of deepest summer...." ;)


And now you say all you care about is RW called attention to something? :boggled:

That's my feeling toward her personally as regards this matter. That's not all I care about in general.


What are you arguing for? Just that some misogynist might possibly be comforted by McGraf's blog?

My opinion is that a good deal of the criticism that's been leveled at Rebecca, while arguably justified, has been unhelpful at best (though I have here been focussing narrowly on that part of said criticism that has been concerned with her judgement of EG).

In fact, I think the majority of what's been said on both sides since this whole thing began has only served to confuse and distract from important matters. Mostly, I just think the whole controversy is sad.
 
To recap how your issue was addressed:

Do you read minds? Did RW read EG's mind?

No. Evidently, RW perceived the question a certain way and acted as if her perception was accurate.

Was it a public elevator?

Yes; nobody is disputing EG's right to physically be there.

Did EG take a simple no answer and go on his way?

Yes, commendably.

Did he not have a right to be in the elevator?

Indisputably.

Is there are law against talking to people in a public elevator?

Never in life - AFIAK.


Get over the "he only wanted to screw" claim unless you have actual evidence, not unsupported speculation.

Get over your fixation on this being about RW. Perhaps your understandable unwillingness to sympathize with her specifically is an obstacle to discussion here.

If bookitty was on an elevator and a person approached and explicitly asked her to come up to his room for sex, my arguments in this thread are valid...or are they? Why not?
 
I share these sentiments; and my point is only this: it's not 'just going up and talking to someone'. EG wasn't chatting for chatting's sake; he had an agenda. It wasn't exactly devious or anything like that - but people can take exception to the motivation behind words, whether real or perceived. When that happens, it's unfair to characterize their taking exception as 'being upset because someone came up and talked to them'. While it's technically true, it leaves out an important part of the objection.

The 'motivation' factor is one of the reasons why it's not okay for white people to call black people the 'n' word even though 'black people call each other that all the time'.

You're right, but perhaps not in the way you think. What do you believe RW's motivation was for sexualizing EG? Why did she ignore his "don't take this the wrong way" introduction and interpret a request to chat over coffee as a request for sex? Why did she objectify him by not actually telling him how she felt or clarifying his offer but instead choose to humiliate him (I'm sure he's seen the video by now) in front of the world?

I mean, yeh, it was just a video blog, but to describe it that way leaves out an important part of the objection.
 
You're right, but perhaps not in the way you think. What do you believe RW's motivation was for sexualizing EG? Why did she ignore his "don't take this the wrong way" introduction and interpret a request to chat over coffee as a request for sex? Why did she objectify him by not actually telling him how she felt or clarifying his offer but instead choose to humiliate him (I'm sure he's seen the video by now) in front of the world?

Only she can answer those questions. I can't say with any certainty why exactly RW interpreted EG's comments the way she did - but she did, and reacted based on that interpretation, and that's why the implications of a person actually requesting sex in such a fashion are a valid focus of exploration inside the larger discussion of this debacle. Because if her interpretation of his comments was wrong, then I believe her reaction would be wrong, yeah, but solely because her interpretation was wrong.
 
Last edited:
Only she can answer those questions. I can't say with any certainty why exactly RW interpreted EG's comments the way she did - but she did, and reacted based on that interpretation, and that's why the implications of a person actually requesting sex in such a fashion are a valid focus of exploration inside the larger discussion of this debacle. Because if her interpretation of his comments was wrong, then I believe her reaction would be wrong, yeah, but solely because her interpretation was wrong.

Holy *********** hell. You finally are agreeing with what everyone's been saying since page 1.

Now, let's get to the part where you realize that asking someone to have a cup of coffee is not necessarily asking someone for sex.

Let's start here:

Do you have evidence that EG was looking for sex?
Do you have evidence that any time someone asks another person to share a cup of coffee, it is innuendo for sex?
Do you have any evidence, at all, that EG was sexualizing RW with his request to partake in a beverage?


Since you won't be able to provide any of those, I'm going to go ahead and assume that you'll understand why people are saying that RW overreacted to the invitation to partake in coffee.

On a different note, you're still wrong about not allowing people to ask strangers for sex, regardless of the circumstances. You can choose to consider it bad form, but that doesn't mean it should be outlawed (even if only be societal pressure). Again, you might as well not chew gum ever because you might offend a colleague.
 
Holy *********** hell. You finally are agreeing with what everyone's been saying since page 1.

I'm guessing this thread didn't get to be 75 pages long because "everybody" else but me has been saying the same thing since page 1. I could be mistaken.

Now, let's get to the part where you realize that asking someone to have a cup of coffee is not necessarily asking someone for sex.

Let's start here:

Do you have evidence that EG was looking for sex?
Do you have evidence that any time someone asks another person to share a cup of coffee, it is innuendo for sex?
Do you have any evidence, at all, that EG was sexualizing RW with his request to partake in a beverage?

Since you won't be able to provide any of those, I'm going to go ahead and assume that you'll understand why people are saying that RW overreacted to the invitation to partake in coffee.

What is your "evidence" that EG ever existed outside of RW's mind, or that she was ever propositioned, for coffee or anything else, in this instance or any other instance, ever?

We're discussing events that RW says happened. According to her, a stranger asked her for sex. Is that an okay thing or not, given the circumstances as described by her? Quibbling over whether it was "really a request for sex" fails to address the question of whether requesting sex in such a manner is appropriate/acceptable/whatever. If RW is the only source of information about this incident (and she is), if you want to discuss it, you've got to play the cards she deals you. You can't just capriciously decide to "okay, we'll pretend this basic situation really happened, but I think RW got this part and this part and this part wrong". All the details are part of one single anecdote. You take the anecdote as a whole or dismiss it as a whole.

On a different note, you're still wrong about not allowing people to ask strangers for sex, regardless of the circumstances. You can choose to consider it bad form, but that doesn't mean it should be outlawed (even if only be societal pressure). Again, you might as well not chew gum ever because you might offend a colleague.

I'm not suggesting disallowing anything. For the....fif...sixth time already.
 
Last edited:
We're discussing events that RW says happened. According to her, a stranger asked her for sex.

Actually according to her, she inferred it was. Although it fails to address the question you'd prefer to discuss, it is a massively important distinction. I believe everyone should be making that distinction because simply moving on dismisses whether or not people should be justified in indulging inference to the point that it's acceptable to inform others they should modify behavior based on what they perceive the other could possibly infer.

I mean, that is what Rebecca requested right? I mean, obviously people are uncomfortable with that which is a major point of contention.

Anyway...

Is that an okay thing or not, given the circumstances as described by her?

What do old people wear for underwear?
 
Actually according to her, she inferred it was. Although it fails to address the question you'd prefer to discuss, it is a massively important distinction. I believe everyone should be making that distinction because simply moving on dismisses whether or not people should be justified in indulging inference to the point that it's acceptable to inform others they should modify behavior based on what they perceive the other could possibly infer.

I mean, that is what Rebecca requested right? I mean, obviously people are uncomfortable with that which is a major point of contention.

Well fine, let's have that debate.

Watson either incorrectly inferred that EG was after sex, or she correctly inferred that he was after sex.

If her inference was incorrect, then her reaction to it necessarily was also incorrect.

I will leave a space here, should anyone wish to disagree, revise, or extend that:

_________________________________________________________











The other option is, her inference was correct. If it was, was her reaction correct or incorrect? As you point out, thus:


What do old people wear for underwear?

...it wasn't necessarily either correct or incorrect. So we're exploring the nuances atm.
 
I'm guessing this thread didn't get to be 75 pages long because "everybody" else but me has been saying the same thing since page 1. I could be mistaken.
Well, finally, you got something right. Guess you needed a gimme ;)


What is your "evidence" that EG ever existed outside of RW's mind, or that she was ever propositioned, for coffee or anything else, in this instance or any other instance, ever?

We're discussing events that RW says happened. According to her, a stranger asked her for sex. Is that an okay thing or not, given the circumstances as described by her? Quibbling over whether it was "really a request for sex" fails to address the question of whether requesting sex in such a manner is appropriate/acceptable/whatever. If RW is the only source of information about this incident (and she is), if you want to discuss it, you've got to play the cards she deals you. You can't just capriciously decide to "okay, we'll pretend this basic situation really happened, but I think RW got this part and this part and this part wrong". All the details are part of one single anecdote. You take the anecdote as a whole or dismiss it as a whole.
No. Simply No. RW says a stranger invited her to his room for coffee. She chose to interpret this as a request for sex. You have shown no evidence that this is a reasonable interpretation.


I'm not suggesting disallowing anything. For the....fif...sixth time already.
You're not? You haven't suggested that strangers at TAM should not be allowed to ask each other for sex (note that I included social norms as a means of disallowing the action, not simply making it illegal)?
 
Actually according to her, she inferred it was. Although it fails to address the question you'd prefer to discuss, it is a massively important distinction. I believe everyone should be making that distinction because simply moving on dismisses whether or not people should be justified in indulging inference to the point that it's acceptable to inform others they should modify behavior based on what they perceive the other could possibly infer.
In fact, this is what McGraff's blog hinges on - that RW's outrage (outraged, I tell you!) is predicated on RW's personal interpretation of a request to share a late night beverage. This is what RW used to imply that McGraff was supporting misogyny by not supporting RW's interpretation of the request for coffee.

Every issue raised hinges on RW's perception being inaccurate or not. As it stands, no one, not one single person, has produced evidence supporting RW's interpretation. Yet there are people who are jumping to her defense because someone dared to point out that RW was, perhaps, guilty of misinterpreting a friendly request for discussion for something more.



In response to Checkmite's post:
Checkmite said:
The other option is, her inference was correct. If it was, was her reaction correct or incorrect? As you point out, thus:
If her interpretation was correct, there are still two reactions here.

1) "Guys, don't do that"
2) "It's objectifying and misogynistic"

1) is perfectly acceptable as long as she's referring to herself specifically. As soon as she intends that to cover every woman and every guy, her reaction is inappropriate.

2) I still don't see how what happened is automatically misogyny or objectification. You (nor anyone, for that matter) has provided evidence that EG heard RW's lecture or earlier conversations. What evidence do we have that EG was even a part of the conference (which, btw, blows your TAM arguments out of the water)? But, for the sake of argument, let's allow that he was a part of the conference and he was a part of the conversation at the bar (lots of assumptions to make RW's reaction valid, but ok). That still doesn't necessarily mean it's misogyny or objectification. No more so than RW's interpretation of an invitation to coffee is ojectification/misogyny in it's own right (Oh, it's a guy who invited me to coffee in an elevator, must by an invite to sex. Yes, that's misogyny folks).
 
In a, "The enemy of my enemy is my friend," sort of way. Please note, though, that I am not suggesting that the possibility of being misconstrued by misogynists as supportive of their position in any way means you shouldn't say what you're saying. My position on this matter is solely descriptive, and may not even be correct.
I just don't see how McGraf is more responsible for a misogynist misinterpreting her statements than one taking RW's nonsense and saying, "see how absurd these feminist are?"


...Yeah, re-reading that bit, I'm not too sure what I was saying, other than that I think your original analogy to homeopathy is not apt--I still think so, but I haven't got anything better.
You just have not convinced me why RW's unsupported assumptions are not relevant to the debate. Sure, they are not relevant to her own personal knee jerk reaction to EG, but the unsupported assumptions are key to RW claiming we should agree EG's come on was sexist objectification.

What is it you think I should do, accept RW's knee jerk reaction as legit beyond her individual emotional problem with EG? You said you realize we get it RW has a right to her own feelings. What more do you want you don't think you are getting?


I really don't see why this is so difficult for me to get across. RW's conclusions about EG's intent are taken as given. I'm assuming they're correct
But the rest of us are not sure they are correct.


...because I'm not interested in the fact of the matter, and I think the fact of the matter is unknowable at this point anyway.
You are saying we have no data to decide, but we do have data. We don't have all the data. RW had non-verbal cues we don't have. But we have RW claiming EG thought [x], heard [X], intended [X] and we have evidence RW had a doubtful basis for her claims.


I'm starting with that (arguably unfounded) assumption, and using it as a rhetorical example. I believe that's partly what RW was doing in her initial video, too, though I doubt she'd agree with the 'unfounded' part. Whatever the fact of EG's intent and motive were are only interesting if one wishes to put him on trial for his actions in this circumstance, and I'm not interested in doing so, though RW may have been.
So what are you interested in?


My opinion is that a good deal of the criticism that's been leveled at Rebecca, while arguably justified, has been unhelpful at best (though I have here been focussing narrowly on that part of said criticism that has been concerned with her judgement of EG).

In fact, I think the majority of what's been said on both sides since this whole thing began has only served to confuse and distract from important matters. Mostly, I just think the whole controversy is sad.
I suspect we are getting to the bottom of your issue here finally. Just my opinion mind you, but now I think you may just have a personal bias and it's causing you to reject valid criticisms of RW.
 
...
Get over your fixation on this being about RW. Perhaps your understandable unwillingness to sympathize with her specifically is an obstacle to discussion here.

If bookitty was on an elevator and a person approached and explicitly asked her to come up to his room for sex, my arguments in this thread are valid...or are they? Why not?
I fail to see how changing the scenario to a directly verbalized request for sex is relative. That's not what happened.

This is about RW. It's about her calling those who don't see things her way anti-women misogynist supporters.

I can empathize with a woman who is intimidated by a man in an elevator. What I cannot empathize with is the response of making a public case of it when a simple, no thanks, obviously ended the encounter. It smacks of wanting to let everyone know guys hit on you rather than actual concern about addressing sexism in the skeptic/atheist communities. And as I said at the beginning of this discussion, I hate to see someone promoting females as weak. I don't see it that way. It was a simple matter to dismiss EG, no need for "guys don't do that", problem solved without their help.
 
Well fine, let's have that debate.

Watson either incorrectly inferred that EG was after sex, or she correctly inferred that he was after sex.

If her inference was incorrect, then her reaction to it necessarily was also incorrect.

I will leave a space here, should anyone wish to disagree, revise, or extend that:

_________________________________________________________


The other option is, her inference was correct. If it was, was her reaction correct or incorrect? As you point out, thus:

...it wasn't necessarily either correct or incorrect. So we're exploring the nuances atm.
Let me add a third option to correct your false dichotomy: RW had no way of knowing one way or the other and as a promoter of skepticism should have recognized that fact.
 
Well I've listened to the latest version of events from Ms. Watson.

According to her women aren't coming back to sceptical meetings because they'd feel terrible being in the same room as 30+ men they'd turned down the last time they were there. Which would seem to suggest she thinks men shouldn't approach women at sceptical conferences.

A little later Ms. Watson states that she thinks men at such events should be allowed to chat up the women who attend.

Like people, language is complicated; and having English as a second language, I might not always be able to read between the lines. But is this seeming contradiction really the gist you took from the conversation?

Are you implying that to »chat up« has the same connotations as »to approach« does? Or is it possible that Watson was talking about different situations at different times?

Linda's daughter had it right: she's an idiot.

Who's Linda?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom