So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's how about this. Instead of making this an issue of whether one kind of behavior is better than another, how about debating the merits of making participation in the casual sex scene - the entirety of it, including the initial "seduction" - a matter of being "opt-in", which I think it should be, rather than "opt-out", which you think it should be?

I think this is the best reply to that suggestion:

drama.png
 
This gets to the following point. As e-books take over more and more, how will we know when someone is a well read intellectual or at least trying to act like one? Will the eggheads of the future have two Kindles in the background instead of just one? And even if you have two Kindle's, how do we know they're not filled with Archie comics and Danielle Steele novels?
I fear to tell you what was stashed under my bed during high school. I was well read all right. Mom, I buy the magazines for the articles.

How is that for being creepy?
 
In game theory terms, failing to even try is a dominated strategy.

That is just not true. Just like any strategy, whether it is dominated or not lies strictly on the payoffs. "Not trying" could be the best response in some cases when the "trying" strategy's payoff is sufficiently negative; and any time a strategy can be a best response, it isn't strictly dominated.
 
Last edited:
...
Because one of them has a choice to participate in the "event" of a proposition, and one doesn't. It is my nature to err on the side of those who don't have a choice....
Was it you or Bookitty or both who brought this argument up?

Honestly, the idea it's an issue that one has no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place is beyond ludicrous. Are you seriously saying someone is a victim because they have no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place?

:boggled:
 
Honestly, the idea it's an issue that one has no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place is beyond ludicrous. Are you seriously saying someone is a victim because they have no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place?
Like I had a choice to read your response? Now I'm a victim.
 
Was it you or Bookitty or both who brought this argument up?

Honestly, the idea it's an issue that one has no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place is beyond ludicrous. Are you seriously saying someone is a victim because they have no choice if someone else chooses to speak to them in a public place?

:boggled:

No; I don't believe I used the word "victim". But if we're going that route, is it possible for anyone to feel victimized by anyone's words?

Tell me this: if a public school teacher were to tell her class that atheists are immoral and going to hell, would you complain solely and exclusively on the basis of the statement's unconstitutionality? Would you have no other problem with it whatsoever aside from that? Do you think everyone here would feel likewise?

I don't recall anyone objecting to people coming up and talking to them. An attempt to recruit for sex might be taken by some as more than the sum of its parts.
 
Last edited:
No; I don't believe I used the word "victim". But if we're going that route, is it possible for anyone to feel victimized by anyone's words?

Tell me this: if a public school teacher were to tell her class that atheists are immoral and going to hell, would you complain solely and exclusively on the basis of the statement's unconstitutionality? Would you have no other problem with it whatsoever aside from that? Do you think everyone here would feel likewise?

I don't recall anyone objecting to people coming up and talking to them. An attempt to recruit for sex might be taken by some as more than the sum of its parts.
I'm confused as to how your example compares to what SG is saying.

ETA: I'm not sure I would feel victimized for that. However, I think sexual harassment quite a different thing. On the other hand I'm a bit dubious as to if RW was sexually harassed. I'm not a reasonable woman so I would need more information.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to make an observation and maybe turn things round a little.

If I were being hit on by a mid 40's year old skep-chick in an elevator I'd be tempted to blog about it as well.

Ladies, us older guys have week hearts, please don't come onto us in elevators after a few pints, while the spirit is willing, the flesh might be week and we wouldn't like to disappoint. Come up in 1/2 hour once we've had a coffee and a little blue pill.
 
Tell me this: if a public school teacher were to tell her class that atheists are immoral and going to hell, would you complain solely and exclusively on the basis of the statement's unconstitutionality? Would you have no other problem with it whatsoever aside from that? Do you think everyone here would feel likewise?

Personally I feel it would be wrong, but even worse if the teacher called out a specific student by name as an example of this. Vilifying someone in her audience for not agreeing with her.

I wonder what sort of bully would do such a thing?
 
Personally I feel it would be wrong, but even worse if the teacher called out a specific student by name as an example of this. Vilifying someone in her audience for not agreeing with her.

I wonder what sort of bully would do such a thing?

I share these sentiments; and my point is only this: it's not 'just going up and talking to someone'. EG wasn't chatting for chatting's sake; he had an agenda. It wasn't exactly devious or anything like that - but people can take exception to the motivation behind words, whether real or perceived. When that happens, it's unfair to characterize their taking exception as 'being upset because someone came up and talked to them'. While it's technically true, it leaves out an important part of the objection.

The 'motivation' factor is one of the reasons why it's not okay for white people to call black people the 'n' word even though 'black people call each other that all the time'.
 
Last edited:
The 'motivation' factor is one of the reasons why it's not okay for white people to call black people the 'n' word even though 'black people call each other that all the time'.
Do you say this because black people can only perceive one possible motivation or that there can only be one possible motivation? I don't use the "N" word because no good will likely come of it. IMO, it's not as if it's impossible for me to have the same motivation as a black person or that there is no possible innocent motivation.



I'm bothered by that kind of presumption. It divides arbitrarily.
 
According to her women aren't coming back to sceptical meetings because they'd feel terrible being in the same room as 30+ men they'd turned down the last time they were there. Which would seem to suggest she thinks men shouldn't approach women at sceptical conferences.

****, you'd swear those skeptical conferences are dating clubs. I gotta try 'em.
 
Do you say this because black people can only perceive one possible motivation or that there can only be one possible motivation? I don't use the "N" word because no good will likely come of it. IMO, it's not as if it's impossible for me to have the same motivation as a black person or that there is no possible innocent motivation.

Hmmm - I worded that bad, didn't I? Try this instead: the "motivation" behind words is the reason that black people can call each other the "n" word "all the time" without becoming upset with each other; and yet Michael Richards' rant could still hurt.
 
No; I don't believe I used the word "victim". But if we're going that route, is it possible for anyone to feel victimized by anyone's words?

Tell me this: if a public school teacher were to tell her class that atheists are immoral and going to hell, would you complain solely and exclusively on the basis of the statement's unconstitutionality? Would you have no other problem with it whatsoever aside from that? Do you think everyone here would feel likewise?

I don't recall anyone objecting to people coming up and talking to them. An attempt to recruit for sex might be taken by some as more than the sum of its parts.
Try again using an analogy that doesn't involve a power difference between speaker and listener and a person children are taught to listen to, trust and believe.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm - I worded that bad, didn't I? Try this instead: the "motivation" behind words is the reason that black people can call each other the "n" word "all the time" without becoming upset with each other; and yet Michael Richards' rant could still hurt.
Fair enough. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom