So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
More importantly, this is the type of bullying that she says causes women to avoid skeptical events. She has become that which she attempts to fight.

"Attempts to fight" gives her too much credit. It astonishes me, given the massive evidence of her behavior, how many people bend over backward to try to make sense of it. Oh, she has a point, or an opinion, or some real feelings. All of the evidence points to the conclusion that she is good at self-aggrandizing and little else.
 
My point is that the setting (elevator, late hour, etc.) may have something to do with her discomfort, but since we agree, for the sake of argument, that her reaction would've been different if it had been someone she was interested in, her actual reaction might have more to do with the person's age, looks or manners than RW admits.

I can agree with that, that it's a possibility.
 
"Attempts to fight" gives her too much credit. It astonishes me, given the massive evidence of her behavior, how many people bend over backward to try to make sense of it. Oh, she has a point, or an opinion, or some real feelings. All of the evidence points to the conclusion that she is good at self-aggrandizing and little else.

I'm not sure that "self-aggrandizing" is the exact word I'd just but let's just say that from the time I first became familiar with RW on this board it seemed to me that she liked attention and pursued it and I think this whole situation growing as big as it has is a manifestation of that, to some degree at least.
 
I don't think it necessarily is supporting misogynist beliefs. I think it likely that misogynists will believe it is supporting their beliefs.

I doubt it.

I'm pretty sure that nothing would make a misogynist happier than to believe that all women are so feeble that they go weak at the knees at being in an elevator with a man in a good hotel in Dublin, even at 4 AM.

As Paula Kirby said, it may be true that women are as lily-livered as this, but if it were shown to be true, it would reduce her opinion of women.
 
I'm going to be charitable and assume that you just haven't been paying much attention. Watson herself is playing a damned good imitation of Mr. Freeze in producing a chilling effect. This kind of comment and blogomania has already convinced Shroedinger's Cat not ever to go to any large skeptic event. There is evidence that it has had an effect on Paula Kirby:

No need for charity; I agree with you. That I've pointed out something I think is wrong in many of the criticisms of RW, should not be inferred as support for whatever it is she does. Actually, beyond what I've surmised from this whole dust-up, I don't really have a clue what she does. I was previously aware of the Skepchicks' existence, but have not read their writings and I don't listen to podcasts or follow twits around or whatever.

I thought the video of Dawkins sitting next to Watson on that panel was hilarious. I wasn't familliar with Paula Kirby before that, but it seems obvious that RW is no intellectual heavyweight, and that Dawkins was painfully aware of it, sitting there listening to her.


Now, please pay attention to this: This is evidence that Watson herself is producing a chilling effect. Anecdotal, sure, but still more evidence than Watson has presented for her thesis.

Noted. And that seems to be a real problem, but it's existence doesn't really argue against the chilling effect RW thinks she sees.

With respect to women's attendance and leadership, the question is not whether sexism exists; it's what the reason is for women's lower rates of attendance and leadership (which involves deciding whether it's sexism or not). Watson either isn't even capable of understanding the difference or wants to gloss over the difference, as she has shown several times with respect to Kirby.

Even Watson is willing to admit that she would change her mind if shown evidence, but Watson doesn't supply evidence. Some rape threads she shows screen shots of, some vague pronouncements about a lot of women she's talked to, and above all, a guy who takes "no" to mean "no" in an elevator. Wowie zowie, Batman! Is this a mountain of evidence, or what?

I did admit somewhere upthread that RW fails Skepticism 101 in my view. As you point out, she doesn't bring much substance to the table. I'm not trying to support her in any way, shape or form.


Disagreements mean sexism and misogyny to Watson, and she has said so, or, rather, approvingly quoted someone else who did. It is not possible to disagree with her without being bad in some way.

A lot of people have that problem. That's one thing I fully agree with in that blog that Skeptic Ginger links to above, that the skeptical community has acquired a huge cult-of-personality problem.

I'm sorry, but we cannot get to the point of evaluating the question you ask, because evaluating it, which requires discussion necessarily involving disagreements, is bad.

We can't? Is Rebecca here? I thought she was banned... ;)
 
Last edited:
No need for charity; I agree with you.

I don't find that blameworthy. I've tried to keep track of all this, and it's been difficult. That's why I made the timeline, which was kind of difficult in itself.

That I've pointed out something I think is wrong in many of the criticisms of RW, should not be inferred as support for whatever it is she does. Actually, beyond what I've surmised from this whole dust-up, I don't really have a clue what she does. I was previously aware of the Skepchicks' existence, but have not read their writings and I don't listen to podcasts or follow twits around or whatever.

The criticisms are in context, though. If Watson were just some blogger, I really wouldn't care about her.

I thought the video of Dawkins sitting next to Watson on that panel was hilarious. I wasn't familliar with Paula Kirby before that, but it seems obvious that RW is no intellectual heavyweight, and that Dawkins was painfully aware of it, sitting there listening to her.

There was a very interesting blog at http://kazez.blogspot.com/2011/07/elevator-guy-hits-wires.html suggesting that Watson's straw man about Kirby was the moment when Dawkins lost patience with Watson.

Noted. And that seems to be a real problem, but it's existence doesn't really argue against the chilling effect RW thinks she sees.

It argues against hegemonic idea of Watson that sexism and a chilling effect therefrom are the reason that women are underrepresented. Again, Watson's idea could be argued between adults, but Watson simply will not have it.
 
Well I've listened to the latest version of events from Ms. Watson.

According to her women aren't coming back to sceptical meetings because they'd feel terrible being in the same room as 30+ men they'd turned down the last time they were there. Which would seem to suggest she thinks men shouldn't approach women at sceptical conferences.

A little later Ms. Watson states that she thinks men at such events should be allowed to chat up the women who attend.

:boggled:

Linda's daughter had it right: she's an idiot.
 
Forget about the hair. She shouldn't have so many books behind her. Children could get the idea she's an intellectual or something.

Those vacuum molded fake books you get at Bed, Bath And Beyond are getting more and more realistic.

On the plus side though it decreases her chances of being hit on in an elevator.

She must look positively anemic under that kind of lighting.


This thread seems to be unleashing my inner woman. Hear her BE CATTY!
 
Last edited:
Those vacuum molded fake books you get at Bed, Bath And Beyond are getting more and more realistic.

This gets to the following point. As e-books take over more and more, how will we know when someone is a well read intellectual or at least trying to act like one? Will the eggheads of the future have two Kindles in the background instead of just one? And even if you have two Kindle's, how do we know they're not filled with Archie comics and Danielle Steele novels?
 
This gets to the following point. As e-books take over more and more, how will we know when someone is a well read intellectual or at least trying to act like one? Will the eggheads of the future have two Kindles in the background instead of just one? And even if you have two Kindle's, how do we know they're not filled with Archie comics and Danielle Steele novels?

Just like now i imagine. If you're interested in making a statement you'll have a fancy library with leather-bound editions from important authors.

If you like to read you have paperbacks scattered everywhere/a kindle on the windowsill.
 
I don't think it necessarily is supporting misogynist beliefs. I think it likely that misogynists will believe it is supporting their beliefs.
Exactly how so?


Of course you're allowed your own view of the encounter, as well as to question RW's conclusions about EG's intent. And you certainly do not have to support her assumptions. Frankly, I'm stunned that you could infer the opposite from anything I've said here. I'm obviously in need of reevaluating my communication style...
I really think it is your point that you need to re-evaluate, but that's just my take on your posts.


I don't think that this analogy is apt. For one thing, I'm not really setting a standard at all. I don't think you're incorrect to wonder whether RW's assessment of EG's intent is accurate, that's just not an avenue I'm personally interested in exploring. But a better analogy to what I am interested in, sticking to the homeopathy theme, would be to look at what the travesty involving those Zicam nasal swabs says about homeopathy believers. If you're familiar with the case, Zicam claims in it's labeling to be "homeopathic" but actually includes 'effective' doses of zinc and perhaps other components in its preparations, along with inert homeopathic 'ingredients'. If it were genuinely homeopathic, Zicam would have no effect at all, but in actuality, it destroys people's sense of smell. Whether or not Zicam is harmful, or therapeutic for that matter, says nothing at all about homeopathy or about its adherents' beliefs.

In analyzing homeopathy, I don't care what Zicam does. Just as in analyzing whether or not the skeptical community is rife with sexism, I don't care whether or not RW's assessment of EG is correct. She's drawn my attention to the question, but that's pretty much it. Going forward from there, I would agree with you and Linda and others that Rebecca has likely done more harm than good regarding women feeling at home within the movement.
I can't follow your Zicam example, too many superfluous details.

But as to your opinion, so RW can base her conclusions about EG's intent and motive on unsupported assumptions, and that's OK, the assumptions aren't relevant. And you realize we aren't saying RW doesn't have a right to her personal view of EG. And now you say all you care about is RW called attention to something? :boggled:


What are you arguing for? Just that some misogynist might possibly be comforted by McGraf's blog?
 
I doubt it.

I'm pretty sure that nothing would make a misogynist happier than to believe that all women are so feeble that they go weak at the knees at being in an elevator with a man in a good hotel in Dublin, even at 4 AM.

As Paula Kirby said, it may be true that women are as lily-livered as this, but if it were shown to be true, it would reduce her opinion of women.
This ^
 
Well, I'm using past experiences of conferences and the knowledge that people do get propositioned and hook up and that some people see it as a part of the conference experience.

Do you say so seriously? Is it genuinely considered by most to be part of the "conference experience" to get laid? Because - in all honesty - that part of it had completely escaped me. I've never seen it mentioned in any kind of literature for any conferences I've been to. Heck, I've never even seen it mentioned on the forums until this debacle. I had assumed that whatever kind of "hooking up" took place at conferences was proportional to the amount that normally happens in public.

Now how did you go about determining that some people's desire not to be propositioned trumps other people's desire to proposition?

Because one of them has a choice to participate in the "event" of a proposition, and one doesn't. It is my nature to err on the side of those who don't have a choice.

Or people who don't want to be propositioned could make themselves known? But then of course people would need to openly identify themselves and that would no doubt make some uncomfortable so that's not the answer either.

How about the people who do want to be propositioned make themselves known? If they want to meet people for sex at TAM, surely openly identifying themselves isn't the same kind of obstacle that it is for those who do not wish to participate.

But it doesn't have to be. It only needs one person to express an opinion to provide quantifiable data.

Then why are you asking me if making a decision based on the discomfort of "just one person" is justified?

I can't help but think that everything you say cuts both ways though. These are your colleagues and you want to get to know them and interact with them so you need to differ from your usual behaviour and cut them some slack if they proposition you.

None of this is really satisfying as a logical argument unless we start with the assumption that one behaviour is necessarily more correct than another.

Okay; let us abandon that line of argument and begin another.

Let's how about this. Instead of making this an issue of whether one kind of behavior is better than another, how about debating the merits of making participation in the casual sex scene - the entirety of it, including the initial "seduction" - a matter of being "opt-in", which I think it should be, rather than "opt-out", which you think it should be? Currently every single other activity, event, meal, or diversion of any kind which takes place at TAM, up to and including participation in the conference in the first place, is opt-in.

Just like the people who want to go to the Peppermill (if they do that anymore), or run to the Grand Canyon on Friday, or participate in the poker challenges (if they do that anymore), why not start a thread before the meeting, asking who is interested in "hooking up"? This will result in a list of names and faces that one who wishes to participate can put their efforts toward. The positives: much, much less effort wasted on the part of those who like to proposition; much less chance of disappointment for those who wish to be propositioned; much less chance of discomfort for those who do not wish to propositioned. Every-damn-body wins. Downsides, please?

Not great advice since I neither attend TAM nor hit on women however, I don't see why 'sexual propositions' are a special case whereas 'chewing gum' isn't. Can I chew gum at TAM or not?

Of course you can. Will you do so around Dawkins, knowing he dislikes it? Up to you. I can tell you which one I would do, which one seems the most reasonable to me.

Being free to do something I choose to do does not mean I choose to do it. You seem to be tied up with the sex thing though.

So don't choose to do it. Or choose to do it, and deal with people calling you out for it.

Let's try another non-sexual, real-life personal example:

In this thread, on at least one occasion someone has posted a link to a video and said something along the lines of 'watch this video'.

Now, I dislike that. As a general rule and for multiple reasons I generally don't watch videos linked to from internet forums. The fact that someone does that therefore gives me a modicum of discomfort and also makes me feel a little bit excluded from the discussion.

Now, if I'm following your logic, the fact that I have now expressed this view means that people on this forum should be considerate of my wishes/feelings and desist from posting links to videos in this forum.

My argument is that, well I should suck it up. I can't expect a whole forum to behave as if I'm special and cater to my whims.

No; it means people who are aware and wish to be considerate of your wishes/feelings would desist from posting links to videos in threads you're participating in (I'm assuming you would have the foresight not to click on "the YouTube thread" and so forth). Those who don't care about your feelings of course would not.

Again, it's not about imposing a rule; it's about making a choice. If you care you will act; if you do not, then you won't. But be honest with everyone and say outright that you don't care about their feelings, so that I can do things like point out the irony of caring enough about someone's willingness to have sex with you to ask them, but not caring at all about the same person's willingness to be asked for sex.

Yes, and we 'agree' to these rules for good reasons, because there was a significant problem that affected a significant number of people and where the costs of limiting other people's behaviours were less than the benefits of reducing the scale of the issues that people were facing.

I believe it has been pointed out that there is in fact a very small number of minorities at TAMs. Perhaps equal, say, to the number of people who would rather not be approached by strangers for sex. (...or perhaps not.) But I digress...

Even in these cases though there is still disagreement on where the line should be drawn.

But, so what? How do we get from 'we generally agree that racism is a bad thing' to 'if a few people dislike something at TAM nobody should do it'? I'm just not clear on when something switches from being 'a few people whining about nothing' to 'a significant issue we should do something about' and how we weight the desires of Group A who want to do something v Group B who don't like something.

It comes from deciding, personally, what is important to you when it comes to other peoples' feelings.

I guess I just generally tend towards letting people be free to act like dicks if they really want to unless someone can really convince me that the dickishness is out of hand and creating a real problem.

It's not a matter of "letting" anyone do anything. I can't stop anyone from acting like a dick. I just reserve the right to say "that kind of behavior is dickish and I would recommend against it". That's not violating anyone's rights, is it?
 
Last edited:
Um, the question I was referring to was this:


I've bolded "the question of" to help you with your difficulties.

Ah, I appreciate this and apologize for the length of time it took me to respond. I had initially tried to respond to this by finding every instance in the thread where that particular topic had been evoked and/or discussed; however, by the time I was farming page 11, the list of compiled links began to reach impractical size and I foresaw logistical difficulties vis-a-vis correctly parsing all the links and managing the resulting post. Not to mention the tediousness of the task was getting to me (one of those things that seems like a good idea until you actually start carrying it out, I suppose).

So, I think it shall have to suffice to say that the topic of the appropriateness of EG's actions in the incident in question was first evoked by poster fls in this post, on the first page of the thread, and has continued to be an actively-discussed aspect of this issue ever since.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom