So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you've no basis to believe otherwise, yes.

I'm not sure how actions can said to be rational if the underlying belief for those actions are not.
:boggled:

Not sure where the disconnect is here. Just because you are not aware of evidence the elevator is safe, what is the belief based on that it isn't? It's not based on evidence. Because there isn't any.
 
.... If 70 minutes is too long for you to watch (or merely listen to while doing stuff), then maybe 28367 forum posts isn't the wisest investment of spare time as well.
If I expected to hear something I'm not already aware of, or if it was a transcript I could skim for the relevant parts, I'd be interested. But 70 minutes of an uninteresting conversation? No thanks.
 
:boggled:

Not sure where the disconnect is here. Just because you are not aware of evidence the elevator is safe, what is the belief based on that it isn't? It's not based on evidence. Because there isn't any.
I think you are missing my point. I'm not claiming that RW's beliefs are rational. I'm not claiming that RW has a basis to justify the belief. I don't know. I'm conceding that it's possible that she has a basis and I'm avoiding a presumption. FWIW: I doubt that she has such a basis.
 
But, so what? How do we get from 'we generally agree that racism is a bad thing' to 'if a few people dislike something at TAM nobody should do it'? I'm just not clear on when something switches from being 'a few people whining about nothing' to 'a significant issue we should do something about' and how we weight the desires of Group A who want to do something v Group B who don't like something.

This would probably have something to do with an honest discussion, where evidence gets presented. Discussions have certain prerequisites, such as intellectual honesty, which Watson has not demonstrated.

What you may be having difficulty with is the fact that the problem that I (certainly) and many other people (probably) have with Watson is her anti-skepticism, which amounts to being against discussion.

Anybody who disagrees with Watson or even who simply doesn't genuflect bob her and/or his head up and down to her pontifications is to be summarily dismissed. Examples:

1) Paula Kirby is to be lied about, then Watson wants to give her an hour-long lecture, and uses a talk to comment on her.
2) Stef McGraw is called "parroting misogynistic thought," is "ignorant of Feminism 101.
3) Rose St. Clair is denigrated as a "young woman" (by the 30-year-old Watson), also ignorant of feminism.

What Watson's opinions are is a secondary matter. It's secondary because Watson herself has gone about this in an anti-skeptical way that prevents them from being discussed as opinions. This, to me, is the primary matter.
 
... It's been obvious all along that everyone agrees with those.
Your position is becoming more clear. But you are being inconsistent.

You believe the unsupported assumptions about EG are not relevant. And you believe we don't disagree RW has a right to her reaction to EG.

But it is her unsupported assumptions about EG that result in other women, McGraf, myself and Linda included, viewing the elevator encounter as described by RW differently than RW viewed it. How is that supporting misogynist beliefs?

Honestly, I've tried but I can't wrap my head around your position. Why am I not allowed my own view of RW's encounter as described? Why am I not allowed to question her conclusions about EG's intent? Why should I have to support what I believe are unsupported assumptions?


However, what I'm actually concerned about is that too many people seem to be making this about whether or not RW's judgement of EG's knowledge and intent was correct or not, while I don't think it matters. I'm interested in the reality and effect of the offense she thinks EG is guilty of, regardless of whether or not he's actually guilty. Perhaps she's wrong to accuse EG of objectifying her according to her definition of the term.

What I want to know is, how often others commit that offense; how many people even recognize it as an offense in the first place; does the prevalence--if any--of that offense actually have the chilling effect on women in the skeptical movement that RW seems to think it does? Too many of the comments I've seen seem only to say something like, well it didn't happen this time, full stop.
By this standard, people who believe in homeopathy are correct to do so and those of us who recognize homeopathy believers base their position on unsupported assumptions are wrong to say so. It's not about whether homeopathy works or not, it's about the reality and effect of their beliefs.
 
I can't say that I know. I might predict based on Pitt's general popularity, but I've no idea of RW's specific response.

For the sake of argument let's say that she would have responded differently... I'm eager to move on to your point.

My point is that the setting (elevator, late hour, etc.) may have something to do with her discomfort, but since we agree, for the sake of argument, that her reaction would've been different if it had been someone she was interested in, her actual reaction might have more to do with the person's age, looks or manners than RW admits.
 
... which is also a pretty standard radical feminist tactic, as it allows you to dismiss your opponents' points as invalid without even giving them the courtesy of being individuals with their own opinions, or having to address their actual ideas.

And couldn't that be viewed as objectification ?
 
Anybody who disagrees with Watson or even who simply doesn't genuflect bob her and/or his head up and down to her pontifications is to be summarily dismissed. Examples:
Great examples but I fear you missed the granddaddy of them all.

The Privilege Delusion

Thanks, wealthy old heterosexual white man!
I'll take Ad hominem for a $1,000 Alex. (well of course Dawkins would say that he's a wealthy old heterosexual white man).

Try that with a female blogger (well of course she would say that, she's a woman). See how that works out for you.

And, please, for the love of god would someone, anyone, tell me how to falsify this red herring stereotype? I've no problem with criticizing patriarchy and white male privilege. I'm not sure how controversial that is. But how does one apply such things to an individual?

Didn't RW set some kind of record for fallacy with that single statement?
 
What I want to know is, how often others commit that offense; how many people even recognize it as an offense in the first place; does the prevalence--if any--of that offense actually have the chilling effect on women in the skeptical movement that RW seems to think it does? Too many of the comments I've seen seem only to say something like, well it didn't happen this time, full stop.

I'm going to be charitable and assume that you just haven't been paying much attention. Watson herself is playing a damned good imitation of Mr. Freeze in producing a chilling effect. This kind of comment and blogomania has already convinced Shroedinger's Cat not ever to go to any large skeptic event. There is evidence that it has had an effect on Paula Kirby:

I have been keeping very quiet over the last week or so, saddened to see the movement tearing itself apart over something that I do not see as central to atheist activism in the first place, and reluctant to do or say anything that might add fuel to the flames.

Now, please pay attention to this: This is evidence that Watson herself is producing a chilling effect. Anecdotal, sure, but still more evidence than Watson has presented for her thesis.

With respect to women's attendance and leadership, the question is not whether sexism exists; it's what the reason is for women's lower rates of attendance and leadership (which involves deciding whether it's sexism or not). Watson either isn't even capable of understanding the difference or wants to gloss over the difference, as she has shown several times with respect to Kirby.

Even Watson is willing to admit that she would change her mind if shown evidence, but Watson doesn't supply evidence. Some rape threads she shows screen shots of, some vague pronouncements about a lot of women she's talked to, and above all, a guy who takes "no" to mean "no" in an elevator. Wowie zowie, Batman! Is this a mountain of evidence, or what?

Disagreements mean sexism and misogyny to Watson, and she has said so, or, rather, approvingly quoted someone else who did. It is not possible to disagree with her without being bad in some way.

I'm sorry, but we cannot get to the point of evaluating the question you ask, because evaluating it, which requires discussion necessarily involving disagreements, is bad.
 
What Watson's opinions are is a secondary matter. It's secondary because Watson herself has gone about this in an anti-skeptical way that prevents them from being discussed as opinions. This, to me, is the primary matter.

More importantly, this is the type of bullying that she says causes women to avoid skeptical events. She has become that which she attempts to fight.
 
More importantly, this is the type of bullying that she says causes women to avoid skeptical events. She has become that which she attempts to fight.

"When you look into the abyss, the abyss also looks into you." - Friedrich Nietzsche
 
She does have some basis for the assertion in that she apparently believes, rightly or wrongly, that EG heard her announcement in the bar and was present for her earlier discussion of being objectified at conferences.

Maybe. But bear in mind that trying to change someone's mind is not "objectifying" or "disregarding their feelings". We all try to change each other's minds. So even IF he had heard her, which we still don't know, it wouldn't change much. Plus, Brad Pitt.
 
Great examples but I fear you missed the granddaddy of them all.

I'll take Ad hominem for a $1,000 Alex. (well of course Dawkins would say that he's a wealthy old heterosexual white man).

Try that with a female blogger (well of course she would say that, she's a woman). See how that works out for you.

Yeah, that's a prime example. I omitted it because an example of an ad hominem against a MAN would just pass right through the brains of some of the people here without firing many neurons.

And, please, for the love of god would someone, anyone, tell me how to falsify this red herring stereotype? I've no problem with criticizing patriarchy and white male privilege. I'm not sure how controversial that is. But how does one apply such things to an individual?

Didn't RW set some kind of record for fallacy with that single statement?

She would have, if it weren't such a common thing for feminists to say.
 
Your position is becoming more clear. But you are being inconsistent.

What can I say? I'm a hobgoblin with a little...er...mind. :o

You believe the unsupported assumptions about EG are not relevant. And you believe we don't disagree RW has a right to her reaction to EG.

But it is her unsupported assumptions about EG that result in other women, McGraf, myself and Linda included, viewing the elevator encounter as described by RW differently than RW viewed it. How is that supporting misogynist beliefs?

I don't think it necessarily is supporting misogynist beliefs. I think it likely that misogynists will believe it is supporting their beliefs.

Honestly, I've tried but I can't wrap my head around your position. Why am I not allowed my own view of RW's encounter as described? Why am I not allowed to question her conclusions about EG's intent? Why should I have to support what I believe are unsupported assumptions?

Of course you're allowed your own view of the encounter, as well as to question RW's conclusions about EG's intent. And you certainly do not have to support her assumptions. Frankly, I'm stunned that you could infer the opposite from anything I've said here. I'm obviously in need of reevaluating my communication style...


By this standard, people who believe in homeopathy are correct to do so and those of us who recognize homeopathy believers base their position on unsupported assumptions are wrong to say so. It's not about whether homeopathy works or not, it's about the reality and effect of their beliefs.

I don't think that this analogy is apt. For one thing, I'm not really setting a standard at all. I don't think you're incorrect to wonder whether RW's assessment of EG's intent is accurate, that's just not an avenue I'm personally interested in exploring. But a better analogy to what I am interested in, sticking to the homeopathy theme, would be to look at what the travesty involving those Zicam nasal swabs says about homeopathy believers. If you're familiar with the case, Zicam claims in it's labeling to be "homeopathic" but actually includes 'effective' doses of zinc and perhaps other components in its preparations, along with inert homeopathic 'ingredients'. If it were genuinely homeopathic, Zicam would have no effect at all, but in actuality, it destroys people's sense of smell. Whether or not Zicam is harmful, or therapeutic for that matter, says nothing at all about homeopathy or about its adherents' beliefs.

In analyzing homeopathy, I don't care what Zicam does. Just as in analyzing whether or not the skeptical community is rife with sexism, I don't care whether or not RW's assessment of EG is correct. She's drawn my attention to the question, but that's pretty much it. Going forward from there, I would agree with you and Linda and others that Rebecca has likely done more harm than good regarding women feeling at home within the movement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom