So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
RW's update: Update! Plus dating advice

rwupdate.jpg


I'm curious, based on the ratings and the context of what was said, is it more likely that 43% just don't get it or is it that some percentage of those who disagree have some valid complaints?
 
I think a lot more leeway. I don't think that can be overstated and I think it is significant. How much of our being uncomfortable with others is our faulty and inconsistent perceptions? Let me hasten to add that just because people would find the behavior of an attractive celebrity okay but find the same behavior of an unattractive Joe Sixpack doesn't justify the behavior of Joe Sixpack.
That wasn't the point. There were two points. They overlap.

1) Stating, "Guys, don't do that", is hypocritical if you only really want guys you are not attracted to not to do that.
2) RW stated her assessment of EG was based on [X]. She left out, he didn't appeal to her sexually. The Brad Pitt question asks if unattractiveness was really the issue, not [X].


...Let me concede two points: 1.) If a person is ignorant of the facts (the likelihood of being assaulted in an elevator) then their perceptions are not irrational. ...
But if the person were basing their perception solely on a false underlying premise which was not evidence based, that would not be 'rational'. Is it rational to believe all blacks are dangerous just because you were not aware of evidence they weren't? By that definition of rational, one could call all false beliefs rational.
 
....How much of our being uncomfortable with others is our faulty and inconsistent perceptions? Let me hasten to add that just because people would find the behavior of an attractive celebrity okay but find the same behavior of an unattractive Joe Sixpack doesn't justify the behavior of Joe Sixpack.
....

I'd have said that if our faulty and inconsistent perceptions contribute in large part to our feeling uncomfortable, then Joe Sixpack could justify his behaviour accordingly. Particularly if he's being discriminated against for not being an attractive celebrity.
 
Here's Rebecca Watson's »Bloggingheads« session with Ann Althouse.

http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/37611

Rebecca describes Elevator guy roughly in the middle, so we can settle the Brad Pitt hypothesis. But watch the whole thing. You guys babbled so much about Rebecca, it wouldn't hurt you to learn a bit more where she's coming from.
It's 70 minutes long. No thank you. I have listened to her side already in her blogs. And I'll take Linda's evaluation of the SGU episode where RW covered the issues. According to Linda, RW cherry picked the arguments she wanted to address and ignored the unskeptical things people voiced concern about.

But feel free to summarize the key points if you think they differ.
 
I don't see how we can deduce the likelihood of that, because nobody has mentioned that they would be disappointed if nobody hit on them.

Well, I'm using past experiences of conferences and the knowledge that people do get propositioned and hook up and that some people see it as a part of the conference experience.

If you prefer though we can use the segment of people 'people who would like to proposition others' which we know at least 1 of exists at such events based on the original incident alone.

Now how did you go about determining that some people's desire not to be propositioned trumps other people's desire to proposition?

The people who do not wish to be propositioned have made themselves known; they're the only ones who have given data we can act on. We cannot just presume the existence of another category without any complaints. Now, if somebody wishes to be propositioned, and they decide to make themselves known - well, suddenly all our problems are solved because now you know for sure who is receptive to strangers' requests for sex and you can concentrate on them.

Or people who don't want to be propositioned could make themselves known? But then of course people would need to openly identify themselves and that would no doubt make some uncomfortable so that's not the answer either.

It is more than one person.

But it doesn't have to be. It only needs one person to express an opinion to provide quantifiable data.

Again, it comes down to a group of colleagues as opposed to an entire country. These are people who are different simply because, presumably, you wish to interact with them. Therefore it seems to me that you would be willing to differ from your usual behavior or at least be more considerate when dealing with them than with the public at large. Indeed, by spending money on a plane ticket and a hotel room and the admission to the conference, you've already done something you don't typically do in favor of interacting with that small, specific group of people.

I can't help but think that everything you say cuts both ways though. These are your colleagues and you want to get to know them and interact with them so you need to differ from your usual behaviour and cut them some slack if they proposition you.

None of this is really satisfying as a logical argument unless we start with the assumption that one behaviour is necessarily more correct than another.

If specificity would make a difference, perhaps you would then be served by reading the names of those women in this thread who have announced that they would not appreciate complete strangers asking them for sex and planning your macking accordingly.

Not great advice since I neither attend TAM nor hit on women however, I don't see why 'sexual propositions' are a special case whereas 'chewing gum' isn't. Can I chew gum at TAM or not?

As I said, spurious. The principle of self-determination does not demand that you ask strangers for sex simply because there are people who would rather you didn't. That's just spite.

Being free to do something I choose to do does not mean I choose to do it. You seem to be tied up with the sex thing though.

Let's try another non-sexual, real-life personal example:

In this thread, on at least one occasion someone has posted a link to a video and said something along the lines of 'watch this video'.

Now, I dislike that. As a general rule and for multiple reasons I generally don't watch videos linked to from internet forums. The fact that someone does that therefore gives me a modicum of discomfort and also makes me feel a little bit excluded from the discussion.

Now, if I'm following your logic, the fact that I have now expressed this view means that people on this forum should be considerate of my wishes/feelings and desist from posting links to videos in this forum.

My argument is that, well I should suck it up. I can't expect a whole forum to behave as if I'm special and cater to my whims.

How would you see the above example?

We already agree to "rules" to refrain from criticizing people based on race, sexual orientation, and so forth. We have not let our acquiescence to these rules lead us down the slippery slope of "never criticizing anyone for any reason at all".

Yes, and we 'agree' to these rules for good reasons, because there was a significant problem that affected a significant number of people and where the costs of limiting other people's behaviours were less than the benefits of reducing the scale of the issues that people were facing.

Even in these cases though there is still disagreement on where the line should be drawn.

But, so what? How do we get from 'we generally agree that racism is a bad thing' to 'if a few people dislike something at TAM nobody should do it'? I'm just not clear on when something switches from being 'a few people whining about nothing' to 'a significant issue we should do something about' and how we weight the desires of Group A who want to do something v Group B who don't like something.

I guess I just generally tend towards letting people be free to act like dicks if they really want to unless someone can really convince me that the dickishness is out of hand and creating a real problem.
 
That wasn't the point. There were two points. They overlap.

1) Stating, "Guys, don't do that", is hypocritical if you only really want guys you are not attracted to not to do that.
2) RW stated her assessment of EG was based on [X]. She left out, he didn't appeal to her sexually. The Brad Pitt question asks if unattractiveness was really the issue, not [X].
I don't disagree with your points but I stand by mine. It's fine. We can disagree as to my point.

But if the person were basing their perception solely on a false underlying premise which was not evidence based, that would not be 'rational'. Is it rational to believe all blacks are dangerous just because you were not aware of evidence they weren't? By that definition of rational, one could call all false beliefs rational.
Rational is a perspective (relative) concept.

  • From the perspective of the person (let's say person A) who holds the false belief it is rational.
  • From the perspective of those who know the belief is false, persona A's belief is irrational.
If you believe that there is a tiger in the grass it is rational to flee. If I'm standing next to you and I have sound reason to believe that it is not, then it's not rational for me to flee.
 
Last edited:
I don't disagree with your points but I stand by mine. It's fine. We can disagree as to my point.

Rational is a perspective (relative) concept.

  • From the perspective of the person (let's say person A) who holds the false belief it is rational.
  • From the perspective of those who know the belief is false, persona A's belief is irrational.
If you believe that there is a tiger in the grass it is rational to flee. If I'm standing next to you and I have sound reason to believe that it is not, then it's not rational for me to flee.
So if you believe homeopathy works, that's rational?

You are talking about the action or result of one's belief. How about the belief itself?
 
Last edited:
Also: »A weird time on bloggingheads« at skepchick.org, with interesting user comments about Ann Althouse's history (»Boobgate«).

Minor correction in my above post: not Boobgate — »Breastgate«.

It's 70 minutes long. No thank you. [...] But feel free to summarize the key points if you think they differ.

No thank you. :)

I admit I've had a crush on Watson since she joined the SGU podcast, so I'm heavily biased, maybe can't think straight etc., but I'm not her mouthpiece/PR guy. If 70 minutes is too long for you to watch (or merely listen to while doing stuff), then maybe 28367 forum posts isn't the wisest investment of spare time as well.
 
Last edited:
If you are male and disagree with her, then you "need" to get a blow-up doll??

I don't know what women who disagree with her "need".

Apparently she is unaware that there are a considerable number of women who disagree with her.
See, here is where I can relate to RW, had I been inundated with a lot of hateful and mean spirited emails and responses I would have lashed out in a similar fashion. The problem is to not differentiate between the irrational idiots and the those with legitimate arguments. It's as if it is not possible for any reasonable disagreement. And that is counter to skepticism and critical thinking. No, to be fair, she's not alone.
 
I admit I've had a crush on Watson since she joined the SGU podcast, so I'm heavily biased, maybe can't think straight etc., but I'm not her mouthpiece/PR guy. If 70 minutes is too long for you to watch (or merely listen to while doing stuff), then maybe 28367 forum posts isn't the wisest investment of spare time as well.

Posting is more interactive. When you post you're often in a discussion of sorts.

Watching a 70 minute video of someone that has had a soapbox throughout this already is just plain crazy and in fact making a 70 minute video at this point seems pretty self-indulgent unless it involves a lot of serious consideration of the serious arguments that run counter to her own.

I think we should have a volunteer, or maybe 2-3 to get a cross section, watch it and give us an honest report back on what it says.

Unless it's a well thought out, planned presentation by someone that I already know from previous experience can at least present shorter things in an interesting, informative manner, I'm not going to watch a 70 minute video of anybody.
 
Posting is more interactive. When you post you're often in a discussion of sorts.

The video is a discussion.

»Sorry I forgot to post on this earlier, but last week I was asked to appear on a thing called BLoggingheads, where two people record themselves discussing a topic and then video of them each staring at their computers goes online to accompany the audio.« (http://skepchick.org/2011/07/a-weird-time-on-bloggingheads/)​

[...] and in fact making a 70 minute video at this point seems pretty self-indulgent unless it involves a lot of serious consideration of the serious arguments that run counter to her own.

So the premise of your objection to watch it is false; Watson didn't make the video, she was invited to a discussion.
 
I wish you would recognize what's wrong with your arguments rather than bowing out.

*sigh* Just when I thought I was out, they pulled me back in... :p


Dave Grimes has a nice blog that covers my arguments quite well.

Your Dogma Is Chasing My Karma

Thanks. I like his style, and I've bookmarked that blog for future reading...

Let me quote a couple sentences which I totally agree with, then you tell me does this address your particular argument or not?You seem to be concerned people are not in agreement with the sentences I bolded. But we are.

...however, I disagree with what I think is your take on the sentences you've quoted. The sentences you've bolded are not the issue for me at all. It's been obvious all along that everyone agrees with those.

Where I disagree with Grimes is in the sentences that you didn't bold: His characterizing the event merely as "she was asked for coffee politely and she politely refused," which commits the same error of ommision that RW jumped down McGraw's throat about, and his claim that Watson, "has no basis to assert the intentions of the proposer..." She does have some basis for the assertion in that she apparently believes, rightly or wrongly, that EG heard her announcement in the bar and was present for her earlier discussion of being objectified at conferences.

However, what I'm actually concerned about is that too many people seem to be making this about whether or not RW's judgement of EG's knowledge and intent was correct or not, while I don't think it matters. I'm interested in the reality and effect of the offense she thinks EG is guilty of, regardless of whether or not he's actually guilty. Perhaps she's wrong to accuse EG of objectifying her according to her definition of the term.

What I want to know is, how often others commit that offense; how many people even recognize it as an offense in the first place; does the prevalence--if any--of that offense actually have the chilling effect on women in the skeptical movement that RW seems to think it does? Too many of the comments I've seen seem only to say something like, well it didn't happen this time, full stop.
 
Last edited:
The video is a discussion.

»Sorry I forgot to post on this earlier, but last week I was asked to appear on a thing called BLoggingheads, where two people record themselves discussing a topic and then video of them each staring at their computers goes online to accompany the audio.« (http://skepchick.org/2011/07/a-weird-time-on-bloggingheads/)​



So the premise of your objection to watch it is false; Watson didn't make the video, she was invited to a discussion.

Yeah, but you can't participate in a video of other people having a discussion. When you post you're involved in a discussion yourself.

Okay, it wasn't a 70 self-indulgent "Look at me" video by RW, that's good. It's a discussion. Is it a discussion that looked at things from all angles or is it a Fox News-type of discussion where the a priori idea is to promote one particular view? If it was a balanced, rational discussion then I might watch it. If it's one-sided and/or over the top then I'll pass since we've already had way more than enough of that from all sides so far.
 
... I am not falsely attributing a position that I subsequently attack to anyone, which is the definition of a straw man. ...
You are arguing that we don't accept RW's right to her personal reaction to EG, but we do accept that aspect of this incident.


...RW did not later go "on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women and being common enough among our community..." That's what it was about all along. She chose an arguably poor example from a personal anecdote to relate in an informal video blog and failed to present real evidence, which I'll agree with anyone was a violation of Skepticism 101, but I see worse on this forum every day. Heck I've committed worse--and so have you, if you're honest.
This seems like a red herring. What difference does it make when RW communicated it was about sexism? I was merely pointing out that is when the uproar started, not when she was just giving her personal reaction to EG, which all but a few people ignored.


This passage corroborates what I've been saying. Watson's definition of 'unsolicited sexual comment' is only part of her claim that EG was sexually objectifying her. Her assumptions that he was present at her presentation, and that he heard her announcement in the bar are also necessary to the accusation. She said as much in that same post responding to McGraw's comments when she complained that McGraw had left these out of her initial post disagreeing with Watson. McGraw (inadvertantly, I believe) created a straw man out of Rebecca's position by leaving these out. I would disagree with Watson here that McGraw's response was necessarily misogynistic--I think it was just a careless error--but I also think it's arguably correct to say that this particular careless error happens to mirror language that is often offered in apology of a misogynistic stance.

This next quotation from RW says as much:
McGraf addressed RW's point:
(Note: This is slightly more than what I included in the transcript on my original blog post, and Watson said during her talk and in her post that I had “conveniently left off the fact that [she] had already expressed [her] desire to go to sleep.” In all honesty, transcribing is a bit tedious, I was simply trying to give what I thought was the most relevant part, so that those who didn’t want to watch a video wouldn’t have to. I’m sorry she feels she was slighted, but any left out details were completely unintentional, and her assumption that I had a clear alterior motive is misguided.)
Leaving the stuff out RW complains about did not change McGraf's points, nor mine. But for whatever reason, you have bought into the RW-as-mind-reader position.

Dave Grimes said it clearly:
She has EVERY right to feel uncomfortable. But she has no basis to assert the intentions of the proposer. He may have been quite genuine and friendly, or perhaps socially inept. He may indeed have been hitting on her, but Watson insists she was sexually objectified, which she defines as "dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question". This is unsupported conjecture and she has zero basis for this drastic condemnation...

When Stef McGraw suggested a different interpretation of Rebecca Watson's anecdote, Watson dismissed it as the "anti-woman rhetoric my audience was engaging in". This is not only a straw man dismissal, it is also an ad homimen attack. Worse, Watson included McGraw along side those calling for her to be raped from a pulpit position. At best this was terribly thought out juxtaposition, at worse it was positively odious slur. In either case it is classic straw manning - misrepresenting another's position rather than addressing it truthfully is a terrible faux pas for self-proclaimed skeptics to make. Curiously, Watson did the same thing to Rose St. Clare and Paula Kirby when presenting with their differing opinion....



The part I highlighted is an important omission on McGraw's part. According to RW it was the substantial content of her talk, not just it's general topic, which--together with RW's announcement in the bar (that Stef has said she left out not purposefully but because she didn't think it that important) which should have tipped off EG that his advance would not be welcome. Because of these omissions, the remainder of this comment from McGraw is a straw man version of RW's position, and RW has every right to be upset about it.
You are denying these were unsupported assumptions on RW's part. Are you suggesting RW could read EG's mind? Seeing someone in a room means they are listening? Listening means they are hearing what you think you are saying?


RW did not claim that McGraf's "simply seeing things differently made her an anti-feminist misogynist." It's your claim that she did so which I find absurd and ludicrous. RW attacked McGraf's words, and said they validate misogyny. This is true. She did not claim that McGraf herself was a misogynist, nor did she insist that said validation was McGraf's intention in choosing those words. Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have read into it some key points that simply are not there.
This is ridiculous. RW uses this as a distraction from the actual criticisms. It nice RW is attacking the action and not the person. So what?

McGaf said she perceived the EG encounter differently. How the hell is that supporting misogynist causes? Because McGraf didn't support RW? Seriously? RW didn't support McGraf. How misogynous RW's behavior is.

I see RW as hurting the feminist cause. She implies an independent female needs guys to not bother her because it makes her uncomfortable. I say, quit reinforcing the idea women are too mousy to just say no to the guy and move on.

Doesn't that make RW's whole reaction to EG reinforcing female stereotypes?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom