So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
RW: "...to have the guts to say you're wrong".
:rolleyes: Just don't say that to RW.

Ann Althouse: I'll tell you, I would have gotten out of the elevator as soon as he had gotten in.

Really Ann? What if it was a black man? Would you have the temerity to say publicly that you would have jumped out if it had been a man of color? Seriously? What the hell is the matter with people? Unbelievable.

Skepticism? Ann, what is the basis for your fear?

RW: He was in his early 50's.

Odds are this guy was hot. A real Brad Pitt kinda guy.

/\/\arko: What was your point?
 
(emphasis mine) I'm listening to it but I want to make quick point.

This is a very big problem for BOTH sides. There are not two opposing sides with monolithic views. It might appear that way but that is a faulty perception.

Do we now want to quibble over the meaning of »you guys« after dissecting the nuances of »coffee«? I wrote and meant »you guys«, fellow commenters, members of this forum, compadres, comrades, fellow skeptics, brothers and sisters.

I don't see (maybe due to faulty perception, but I don't think so) any two clear-cut »sides« on the group of topics and subtopics in this and other threads, neither do I see any group holding one monolithic view.
 
I think if the guy was in his early 50s it mitigates towards the position of him really just wanting to talk and have coffee.
 
I stated it in my subsequent post, though, honestly, I think it's obvious enough to go without saying. If anyone here is claiming to know the FACT of what happened and what EG had in his head at the time, then the are either dishonest or stupid.

I was composing responses to two different posters simultaneously in my head. I neglected to be complete in the first, and I qualified my position in the second. You've caught me making a minor omission, and if it caused you to misunderstand me then I certainly do regret that. However, my position remains the same.

Fair enough, then.
 
Funny you should say that. I met someone who claimed (no way to verify) that they had literally been hit on by Brad Pitt, and he was behaving so drunkenly bad that they wanted no part.

Whether my friend actually met Brad Pitt is irrelevant to the point that even a celebrity can strike out if they're being an ass. So, I maintain it may depend on the approach. I'll admit celebrity status or being especially attractive probably gets you more leeway with people, but where do you go with that?

Gnome, you have deliberately modified the parameters I was proposing:

Simply swap EG with Brad Pitt in the exact same situation, with the exact same proposal.
 
Do we now want to quibble over the meaning of »you guys« after dissecting the nuances of »coffee«? I wrote and meant »you guys«, fellow commenters, members of this forum, compadres, comrades, fellow skeptics, brothers and sisters.

I don't see (maybe due to faulty perception, but I don't think so) any two clear-cut »sides« on the group of topics and subtopics in this and other threads, neither do I see any group holding one monolithic view.
Fair enough. Sorry.
 
/\/\arko: What was your point?

Oh right, thanks for reminding me, RandFan. Just wanted to keep you informed is all (I'm just that nice). Also, it was meant as an addition for the timeline epepke is keeping, I believe. I can't seem to find it, but he linked to it several times during this thread.

Also: »A weird time on bloggingheads« at skepchick.org, with interesting user comments about Ann Althouse's history (»Boobgate«).
 
I think if the guy was in his early 50s it mitigates towards the position of him really just wanting to talk and have coffee.

Agreed.

Not that guys of that age can't be lecherous, just that it is more likely he viewed her more as an interesting person than a sexual object.
 
Gnome, you have deliberately modified the parameters I was proposing:

Simply swap EG with Brad Pitt in the exact same situation, with the exact same proposal.

Due to the update regarding age should we change this to Harrison Ford?
 
Oh right, thanks for reminding me, RandFan. Just wanted to keep you informed is all (I'm just that nice). Also, it was meant as an addition for the timeline epepke is keeping, I believe. I can't seem to find it, but he linked to it several times during this thread.


As such, I appreciate the offering.

The permanent home for the timeline is http://theismatheism.blogspot.com/
 
Gnome, you have deliberately modified the parameters I was proposing:

Simply swap EG with Brad Pitt in the exact same situation, with the exact same proposal.

I can't say that I know. I might predict based on Pitt's general popularity, but I've no idea of RW's specific response.

For the sake of argument let's say that she would have responded differently... I'm eager to move on to your point.
 
Oh right, thanks for reminding me, RandFan. Just wanted to keep you informed is all (I'm just that nice). Also, it was meant as an addition for the timeline epepke is keeping, I believe. I can't seem to find it, but he linked to it several times during this thread.

Also: »A weird time on bloggingheads« at skepchick.org, with interesting user comments about Ann Althouse's history (»Boobgate«).
Cool, thanks. :) I'll climb down off of my soapbox for a few minutes and have some more coffee. That's help clam me down. To bad meth is illegal.
 
See, now I feel guilty cos I was really snippy and you withdrew with class and style, damn you.

My apologies for snippyness.

No problem. Snippiness doesn't bother me, as long as we're not alone in an elevator. Apparently I misjudged the flow of the conversation jumping in at this late point. It happens. Anyway, I have no desire to derail an active discussion, so I'll just be lurking now.
 
Maybe I didn't word it well but it's entirely possible and even quite likely that if no propositioning went on at all a TAM (or any other given event) then some people would be disappointed. No stimulus would result in a disappointed reaction.

I don't see how we can deduce the likelihood of that, because nobody has mentioned that they would be disappointed if nobody hit on them.

As far as I see you have four basic groups - people who would like to proposition, people who would not like to proposition, people who would like to receive a proposition and people who would not like to receive a proposition.

I can't see a simple way to satisfy them all, nor do I see how I can prioritise the preferences of the 'don't like to be propositioned' over the 'would like to be propositioned' or the 'would like to proposition' groups.

The people who do not wish to be propositioned have made themselves known; they're the only ones who have given data we can act on. We cannot just presume the existence of another category without any complaints. Now, if somebody wishes to be propositioned, and they decide to make themselves known - well, suddenly all our problems are solved because now you know for sure who is receptive to strangers' requests for sex and you can concentrate on them.



This honestly makes no sense to me. First off we do know that some people do like being propositioned as it happens all the time. Beyond that though I still don't see how we avoid a tyranny of taking offence if we only need 1 person to object to something to provide information that we shouldn't do it. Beyond even that, the drawing of the boundary to the TAM is completely arbitrary. Why extrapolate the preferences of a handful of people to everyone at TAM but not everyone in Vegas, or everyone in the US?

It is more than one person.

Again, it comes down to a group of colleagues as opposed to an entire country. These are people who are different simply because, presumably, you wish to interact with them. Therefore it seems to me that you would be willing to differ from your usual behavior or at least be more considerate when dealing with them than with the public at large. Indeed, by spending money on a plane ticket and a hotel room and the admission to the conference, you've already done something you don't typically do in favor of interacting with that small, specific group of people.

You've switched here back from the general to the specific though. We have information that some TAM attendees don't like gum chewing in their vicinity - employing your original logic people should desist from chewing gum while at TAM.

If specificity would make a difference, perhaps you would then be served by reading the names of those women in this thread who have announced that they would not appreciate complete strangers asking them for sex and planning your macking accordingly.


Why is it 'different'? You don't value the principle of being able to determine for yourself how you behave rather than have your actions determined by the lowest denominator of offence taker?

As I said, spurious. The principle of self-determination does not demand that you ask strangers for sex simply because there are people who would rather you didn't. That's just spite.



Regardless, the 'rules' still have to be imposed somehow though even if they are self-imposed and there needs to be some internal consistency to them. I don't see how we can get an internally consistent rule about 'don't hit on women at TAM' that also doesn't result in 'don't chew gum at TAM' 'don't drink beer at TAM' 'don't have TAM at all' unless we just assume that 'hitting on women' is a special case in which there really is no argument it's just an instruction not to hit on women.

We already agree to "rules" to refrain from criticizing people based on race, sexual orientation, and so forth. We have not let our acquiescence to these rules lead us down the slippery slope of "never criticizing anyone for any reason at all".
 
RW attacked McGraf's words, and said they validate misogyny. This is true. She did not claim that McGraf herself was a misogynist, nor did she insist that said validation was McGraf's intention in choosing those words. Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have read into it some key points that simply are not there.

@rebeccawatson "[@stef_witha_f]'s post was a pretty standard parity [parody?] of misogynistic thought," clarifying later that she meant "parroting."

As thus: "@AaronFriel "parroting." This is what's known as "attacking the argument, not the person." Nothing to do with ridicule."
 
Last edited:
[RW did not claim that McGraf's "simply seeing things differently made her an anti-feminist misogynist." It's your claim that she did so which I find absurd and ludicrous. RW attacked McGraf's words, and said they validate misogyny. This is true. She did not claim that McGraf herself was a misogynist, nor did she insist that said validation was McGraf's intention in choosing those words. Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have read into it some key points that simply are not there.

... which is also a pretty standard radical feminist tactic, as it allows you to dismiss your opponents' points as invalid without even giving them the courtesy of being individuals with their own opinions, or having to address their actual ideas.

"She doesn't mean to be a misogynist, but she is too ignorant and oppressed to really understand the misogyny in what she's saying."

Yuck. Bullying indeed.
 
Fair enough. I'll bow out then. Cheers.
I wish you would recognize what's wrong with your arguments rather than bowing out. Dave Grimes has a nice blog that covers my arguments quite well.

Your Dogma Is Chasing My Karma

Let me quote a couple sentences which I totally agree with, then you tell me does this address your particular argument or not?
Rebecca Watson herself stated the she was "sexually objectified" rather than found to be sexually attractive. This is a assertion without any basis and perhaps a massive overstatement - she was asked for coffee politely and she politely refused. She has EVERY right to feel uncomfortable. But she has no basis to assert the intentions of the proposer....

Watson was well within her rights to feel uncomfortable, emotions are entirely subjective....
You seem to be concerned people are not in agreement with the sentences I bolded. But we are.
 
I don't see how we can deduce the likelihood of that, because nobody has mentioned that they would be disappointed if nobody hit on them.
I would be disappointed if I attended TAM and no one hit on me. Forced obstinance is hardly a skeptical position to have.
The people who do not wish to be propositioned have made themselves known; they're the only ones who have given data we can act on. We cannot just presume the existence of another category without any complaints. Now, if somebody wishes to be propositioned, and they decide to make themselves known - well, suddenly all our problems are solved because now you know for sure who is receptive to strangers' requests for sex and you can concentrate on them.
1 person has made herself known. Is there a list somewhere for TAM attendees to see who has and hasn't declared themselves off limits? I certainly haven't seen it, but I may have missed it while perusing the forums.




It is more than one person.
Evidence for this assertion? Interestingly: This is no different from your first paragraph in this very post - that there is no evidence to date of anyone who wants to be propositioned (a claim readily proven false by a reading of this thread). Quite the hypocrite there.

Again, it comes down to a group of colleagues as opposed to an entire country. These are people who are different simply because, presumably, you wish to interact with them. Therefore it seems to me that you would be willing to differ from your usual behavior or at least be more considerate when dealing with them than with the public at large. Indeed, by spending money on a plane ticket and a hotel room and the admission to the conference, you've already done something you don't typically do in favor of interacting with that small, specific group of people.
Don't chew gum in an elevator. Just don't do that, guys.


If specificity would make a difference, perhaps you would then be served by reading the names of those women in this thread who have announced that they would not appreciate complete strangers asking them for sex and planning your macking accordingly.
I'm pretty sure this is a non-sequitor, but I'd have to look at what argument you're actually trying to refute. (I looked, non-sequitor it is. Fraggles isn't asking for specific people. He's talking about arguing a specific point and then denying it applies to other specific points - it's basically a special pleading fallacy. In this case, hitting on women at TAM is the specific point receiving special pleading, whereas when someone else mentions gum chewing as an annoying habit you're willing to allow it.)



As I said, spurious. The principle of self-determination does not demand that you ask strangers for sex simply because there are people who would rather you didn't. That's just spite.
"The principle of self-determination does not demand that you refrain from asking strangers from sex simply because there are people who would rather you didn't." Try again?




We already agree to "rules" to refrain from criticizing people based on race, sexual orientation, and so forth. We have not let our acquiescence to these rules lead us down the slippery slope of "never criticizing anyone for any reason at all".
Look, people hit on people all the time. It happens. It happens in person, it happens over the internet and even on these very forums (look at MdC and Kate, Rox and Hawk, etc). Who's to say that people should refrain from looking for human interaction/connection at TAM? That some people are uncomfortable with that is just a part of human interaction. Likewise, that some people encourage that is just a part of human interaction. Perhaps people are, ya know, turned on by their colleagues (and, really? Colleagues? This isn't a work conference, btw. This is vacation for many people. It's certainly not akin to attending a work-related conference (although I'll admit that for some people it is) to the point of laying out strict sexual invitation policies above and beyond: don't break the law).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom