So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes. Do you have trouble with the meaning of the word presumption?

Yes. Do you know what I'm arguing?

Yeah, right. Where did you say it was a presumption and not a fact ? I'll make it easy for you. Here's your post:

The highlighted line is, I think, the key here--and it's not because RW is being hypocritical, as McGraw misconstrues and RW then calls out in her presentation at CFI.

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep. It's not just that he asked for sex out of the blue--which, as we've seen in this thread, some women find creepy while others do not. It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings. That's the part that's objectifying her. Guys, don't do that.

To me, I would expect that this would increase the creepiness factor, too. Even if you're not generally creeped out by being cold-propositioned for sex, would it change your attitude if the guy doing so were simultaneously demonstrating that he doesn't care what your feelings are--that he'll pursue you even after you've expressed that you don't want him to--in fact that he'll corner you in an enclosed space to do so?

So where's the presumption ? Those are statements of FACT, Prometheus. You've just been caught saying things you now regret. It's not my problem.
 
....
If you're going to accuse me of constructing a straw man, then you'll have to show me where exactly I'm falsely attributing any argument to anyone. Otherwise, I'll politely request that you withdraw the accusation. As it stands now, I am in need of no correction on this matter because I have made no attempt at all to analyze actual events. I have only commented on RW's constructed example and the advice that should be drawn from that regardless of whether it is merely a construct, or an accurate description of an actual event.
Warning, don't read my venting if it is going to just make you angry.

No worries. I takes a lot more than even false criticism to make me angry. ;)

Feel free to skip it. I am frustrated and perhaps you are not responsible for being the last of many prior posters with the same straw man.
So the responsibility is mine despite the fact your straw man has been addressed at least a dozen times in this thread starting with page 1? And despite the fact you aren't even addressing the key issue in this discussion. You come in making your pronouncements of how [x] is irrelevant blah blah blah. But no one is saying RW shouldn't have had her own reaction to EG.
OK, fine, it's up to me to point out yet again, no one cares about RW's personal reaction to EG. Yes, people are pointing out RW's false assumptions about EG, but even that is only a small piece of what sparked this gazillion post debate.

Well, I sincerely apologize if I made you angry. But while I did enter the debate late, and I am saying things that were said by others early on, I am not constructing a straw man. I am not falsely attributing a position that I subsequently attack to anyone, which is the definition of a straw man. If you think I am, then you simply misunderstand me. I am suggesting that much of the debate which has occurred before I jumped in was a fool's errand, but, really, that should be obvious to anyone at this point.




The thing that initiated this debate included the initial video, the response by McGraf and and Stclairose in the blogosphere and RW's further discussion of the elevator incident in the Student Conference.

Were it simply RW's video and the couple blogosphere replies who disagreed with her take on the incident, it would have in all likelihood faded away at that point.
It was RW, who upon hearing this different opinion to hers, went on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women, and being common enough among our community to be affecting the attendance of women at formal events.

I agree--with qualification. And this is precisely what I'm on about. It's much of the ensuing debate that has been one miscommunication after another on all sides. Please don't get the idea that I'm defending RW's behaviour subsequent to the the first few events. My qualification is that RW did not later go "on to make the whole thing about feminism, objectifying women, sexualizing women and being common enough among our community..." That's what it was about all along. She chose an arguably poor example from a personal anecdote to relate in an informal video blog and failed to present real evidence, which I'll agree with anyone was a violation of Skepticism 101, but I see worse on this forum every day. Heck I've committed worse--and so have you, if you're honest.




For a more extensive review, this post has a more links after the feces struck the cooling device as was previously noted.

I've seen epepke's timeline, and I've read/watched all but three of the items in it. When I get to those, I'll let you know if they happen to change my mind.


See this post for links to the pertinent sites quoted below (though you claim to have read them):
Watson on naming names at the CFI conference said:
...approaching a single woman in an elevator to invite her back to your hotel room is the definition of “unsolicited sexual comment.” But those are unimportant details in comparison to the first quoted sentence, which demonstrates an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification. The former is great – be attracted to people! Flirt, have fun, make friends, have sex, meet the love of your life, whatever floats your boat. But the latter involves dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question.

A lot of what is being debated here is Watson's definition of an "unsolicited sexual comment". Clearly here she is specifically claiming EG was sexually objectifying her. I don't see how one interprets RW's comments any other way. And I, for one, don't agree with RW's assessment of the incident.

This passage corroborates what I've been saying. Watson's definition of 'unsolicited sexual comment' is only part of her claim that EG was sexually objectifying her. Her assumptions that he was present at her presentation, and that he heard her announcement in the bar are also necessary to the accusation. She said as much in that same post responding to McGraw's comments when she complained that McGraw had left these out of her initial post disagreeing with Watson. McGraw (inadvertantly, I believe) created a straw man out of Rebecca's position by leaving these out. I would disagree with Watson here that McGraw's response was necessarily misogynistic--I think it was just a careless error--but I also think it's arguably correct to say that this particular careless error happens to mirror language that is often offered in apology of a misogynistic stance.

This next quotation from RW says as much:


Watson on naming names at the CFI conference said:
I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another....
It's important to stop here and read Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment RW quoted and was referring to:
Steph McGraf after seeing RW's original video said:
My concern is that she [RW] takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”
This is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"?

No, that was someone disagreeing with RW's take that EG was sexualizing her with an unsolicited sexual comment indicative of sexual objectification and not sexual attraction.

Yup. That's what I've been saying. I think RW's choice of words is unfortunately rather polemic, but the substance of her complaint is exactly what I've said. At this point I'm not sure why you're disagreeing with me.


RW makes her assessment based on the setting and whatever she has assumed EG must have heard her say earlier and must have understood that she meant. [/b]RW is certain she knows a lot about EG's motives and EGs underlying knowledge about RW. RW is calling McGraf's different take on EG, "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny".

It is an absurd ludicrous accusation. Clearly RW is not expressing intolerance of those that don't see EG the way RW saw him.[/b]

The accusation is neither absurd, nor ludicrous--just colorfully worded, and a bit unjust in that Stef's error is not willful.


the rest of McGraf's comments said:
Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?...

...If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?

The part I highlighted is an important omission on McGraw's part. According to RW it was the substantial content of her talk, not just it's general topic, which--together with RW's announcement in the bar (that Stef has said she left out not purposefully but because she didn't think it that important) which should have tipped off EG that his advance would not be welcome. Because of these omissions, the remainder of this comment from McGraw is a straw man version of RW's position, and RW has every right to be upset about it.



....I'd be interested in seeing that blog if anyone has a link, but it's not actually relevant to my point at all. Again, everything I've said rests on a purely hypothetical situation. Rebecca, and her followers, seem inclined to believe that that hypothetical is in accord with an actual event. Others question the congruity of the two. I don't care one way or the other.
You should be capable of looking for it yourself. Especially since you don't really see it as relevant data. Linda commented on it. Try looking at her comments (fls) from the beginning. She hasn't posted that much so it will go quickly, and while you are at it, try reading what she had to say. It's well worth the effort if you want to understand this debate that you have thoroughly misconstrued.

I've read several of Linda's comments (I'll go back and see if I've missed any). I even agree with most of them. But they don't invalidate my point, and I've not misconstrued the debate.


....No. On the face of it, RW seems to be saying that guys should not behave as she believes EG was behaving. If I've missed something she's said subsequently to qualify that, then I will be happy to adjust my opinion of her position accordingly. But her "Naming Names" blog post seems only to corroborate my understanding.
So you don't have an issue with RW's absurd complaint that McGraf's simply seeing things differently made her an anti-feminist misogynist? Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have missed the key points.

RW did not claim that McGraf's "simply seeing things differently made her an anti-feminist misogynist." It's your claim that she did so which I find absurd and ludicrous. RW attacked McGraf's words, and said they validate misogyny. This is true. She did not claim that McGraf herself was a misogynist, nor did she insist that said validation was McGraf's intention in choosing those words. Perhaps you should go back and re-read that blog. You seem to have read into it some key points that simply are not there.


.Sorry, I often forget how sarcasm isn't so obvious in print as it sounds in my head. Perhaps, though, you missed where I said multiple times that which of those possibilities, or any others, which might be true are irrelevant to me because I'm only talking about a hypothetical construct.
You lost me here.

My parenthetical comment, which you responded to, was not relevant to my point. I was sarcastically parroting what find to be a red herring.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, right. Where did you say it was a presumption and not a fact ? I'll make it easy for you. Here's your post:



So where's the presumption ? Those are statements of FACT, Prometheus. You've just been caught saying things you now regret. It's not my problem.

I stated it in my subsequent post, though, honestly, I think it's obvious enough to go without saying. If anyone here is claiming to know the FACT of what happened and what EG had in his head at the time, then the are either dishonest or stupid.

I was composing responses to two different posters simultaneously in my head. I neglected to be complete in the first, and I qualified my position in the second. You've caught me making a minor omission, and if it caused you to misunderstand me then I certainly do regret that. However, my position remains the same.
 
No it doesn't. I for one enjoy being propositioned by members of the opposite sex for coffee or anything else at 4 am in an elevator. She doesn't like it. Doesn't mean everyone else doesn't like it.

Yes, it does. What you like or don't like is not relevant to my point except to say that anyone who is aware of your likes and dislikes should take those into account if they proposition you for sex.

Assuming EG was a creepy space alien intent on kidnapping her for experiments, then she was lucky to get out of there unprobed.

Assuming that she made the whole thing up (as EG has never appeared) then she's just attention seeking and good at it.

Assumptions are all very well, but the assumption that you make doesn't help me with my future behaviour. The assumption you make allows me to work out:

Not to approach women at conferences in elevators for coffee after they've just made a presentation which included a passage asking not to be approached at conferences..

Now, that's pretty specific, and not really ever going to apply to me. What is going to apply to me, and to many other men, is the more general 'Is it okay to speak to women we don't know in elevators' - That's the useful discussion. the one you seem to want to have is no use to anyone.

The specificity is not inherent to my position, or to RW's, I believe. That's just what EG should have taken to heart, if he was actually aware of it as RW and I assume. What you should take to heart is don't do anything in pursuit of sex which the object of your pursuit has previously communicated to you would be unwelcome. I hope that kind of goes without saying, actually, as it is pretty trivial.
 
Yes, it does. What you like or don't like is not relevant to my point except to say that anyone who is aware of your likes and dislikes should take those into account if they proposition you for sex.



The specificity is not inherent to my position, or to RW's, I believe. That's just what EG should have taken to heart, if he was actually aware of it as RW and I assume. What you should take to heart is don't do anything in pursuit of sex which the object of your pursuit has previously communicated to you would be unwelcome. I hope that kind of goes without saying, actually, as it is pretty trivial.

Absolutely. And so pointless as to be not worth mentioning or debating. It's a given. Why talk about it? If we all agree with you that had EG known of this woman's desires beforehand he should not have approached her, can we have the more interesting discussion about if he didn't. That's the useful one. Your debate is utterly useless.

The interesting conversation is the one everyone else is having which is about something completely different.
 
Last edited:
Guessing, but...

Everyone here fancies themselves as clever, rational, enlightened and prejudice free (myself, obviously included).

When we enlightened, prejudiced free men are told that we aren't allowed to try to pick up women (yes, yes, yes, I'm grossly oversimplifying for brevity) because it's sexist, we panic.

We're an enlightened prejudice free intellectuals, We think We don't think that's sexism, is it???

So we think about it ourselves first, examine the issue and then, once we've come to our conclusion, be it that we change our minds or decide the proposition is a load of fetid dingo's kidneys, we rush to the internet to tell our intellectual brothers and sisters that we're okay, we're not sexist, we're still enlightened, and here's why...

And we find that not all of our brother's and sister's agree. Some think that our oh so rational point of view is total kidneys and we tell them so, safe and certain in the knowledge that, by pointing out one or two salient points that our enlightened (although, obviously not quite as enlightened as we) brothers and sisters have missed, their point of view will be suitably rectified and we can go about our day, occasionally glancing at a shapely pair of legs or a particularly obvious pair of breasts, safe in the knowledge that we're not sexist.

But it doesn't work like that. Our brothers and sisters with the dingos ideas have points that, while of course are of no note whatsoever, they believe to be salient to the issue. So we have to explain it to them again.

At that point, it's inevitable that someone will post 'I haven't read all the thread (The thread's 30 pages long by this point so who can blame them?), but I think...' and it all goes round again. And no-one can let it drop because, well, we're clever, enlightened, rational, prejudice free individuals, we can't possibly be sexist. Enlightened, rational, clever women don't sleep with sexist men, so we just can't let it lie.
Nah that's not it.


;)
 
We have data indicating there are women who attend TAMs who do not appreciate being asked for sex by strangers.
Actually we have data indicating there is ONE woman who attended ONE "TAM" who did not appreciate being asked for sex by a stranger. Which by itself means nothing beyond the scope of that one person.

Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do (assuming we're trying to be amiable about the concerns raised) is avoid asking any strangers for sex at TAM.
So much for a "scientific approach" eh?

Since this one woman is an extremely small sample size, again if means little at most; one should be no more or less prudent than one would had this never come up.

the ones who wouldn't be uncomfortable will not care anyway.
You have no idea whether any given one would care or not, and in fact it is reasonable to assume as least some will. Heck some are probably longing for the moment when they are propositioned (er by someone not ugly that is :cool: ).

This is mostly and simply about one person and their views not speaking for everyone, to say the least. In fact it's so simple that this is what fascinates me about this topic going on for 60+ pages.
 
Absolutely. And so pointless as to be not worth mentioning or debating. It's a given. Why talk about it? If we all agree with you that had EG known of this woman's desires beforehand he should not have approached her, can we have the more interesting discussion about if he didn't. That's the useful one. Your debate is utterly useless.

The interesting conversation is the one everyone else is having which is about something completely different.

Fair enough. I'll bow out then. Cheers.
 

Where is your evidence EG heard RW?

Where is your evidence EG interpreted RW's words as RW believes she communicated them?

Um, the question I was referring to was this:

Checkmite said:
She may have been wrong about EG asking her for sex, but that isn't pertinent to the question of whether asking for sex in that manner is a recommended course of action.

I've bolded "the question of" to help you with your difficulties.
 
Last edited:
Okay let's clear this one criterion then. Let's assume it WAS Brad Pitt. What do you think Rebecca's reaction would've been ?

Funny you should say that. I met someone who claimed (no way to verify) that they had literally been hit on by Brad Pitt, and he was behaving so drunkenly bad that they wanted no part.

Whether my friend actually met Brad Pitt is irrelevant to the point that even a celebrity can strike out if they're being an ass. So, I maintain it may depend on the approach. I'll admit celebrity status or being especially attractive probably gets you more leeway with people, but where do you go with that?
 
Well no, 'not reacting negatively to a proposition' is not the same as 'being perfectly happy that no proposition is forthcoming'. This conclusion seems to come from your faulty assumption that not doing something doesn't cost anything to anyone.

No; "being happy" would be a positive reaction. By my logic, no stimulus would result in no reaction, positive or negative.

No, I read it. It just didn't make sense. How do you arrive at this conclusion employing your logic? If the negative reaction of a sub-segment of attendees to a particular behaviour at TAM dictates whether that behaviour is acceptable or not then how do you determine that in other situations the negative reaction of sub-segments of the population can be safely ignored?

Because the attendees' reactions at TAM can be quantified. Several people here who attend TAMs have announced that such-and-such behavior makes them uncomfortable. You may not recognize their faces, but you have information that they are present at TAM. You know for certain they are present and will react badly. Conversely, you have no information about whether anyone at a random restaurant is going to react badly; I wouldn't consider it unreasonable to not act on information you don't have.

RW doesn't like being propositioned in lifts - so nobody should proposition anyone at TAM; RD doesn't like gum chewers, is that off the list? I don't like people who moan about being propositioned in lifts presumably RW should desist with that too?

You are entitled to ask. I see no reason why someone who chews gum would willingly continue to do so once they are cognizant that it is annoying bystanders as a matter of fact. Unless the gum chewer is a jerk.

You can replace the first half of that question with any action at all and it will still make the same sense. Which is worth more chewing gum or avoiding the enmity of someone you don't know?

The only answer that makes any sense then is 'it depends'

On what, specifically in this case?

What if the action is calling out someone on being racist? Or homophobic? Should we refrain from making racists or homophobes uncomfortable if they also happen to be people who matter to us?

That's different; if principle and personal integrity demand an action be taken, I can see that outweighing consideration for a person's feelings. There are no principles which "demand" asking strangers for sex; you may invent one for the sake of discussion, but I feel safe dismissing it as spurious.

And does this make it OK to do whatever I want around strangers if they don't matter to me?

Umm...yes? The only thing that regulates your behavior out among the random masses ultimately is the law.

Isn't TAM basically a gathering of a diverse group of strangers with some shared common interests? Good luck regulating behaviour so that nobody does anything which could make even a small group of people uncomfortable, especially since the act of regulating behaviour I'm sure would make at least a handful of people uncomfortable.

It's not about a rule being imposed upon people by an authority of some kind. If anyone here reading my posts has thought that's what I was advocating, I apologize for not being more clear. I cannot see why anyone, willingly and of his own accord, would not refrain from doing such a simple and trivial thing knowing that doing it would make his colleagues uncomfortable.

Since when was tradition a measure of anything though? It's not traditional to attend TAM either is it?

I didn't bring up tradition; he did.
 
Funny you should say that. I met someone who claimed (no way to verify) that they had literally been hit on by Brad Pitt, and he was behaving so drunkenly bad that they wanted no part.

Whether my friend actually met Brad Pitt is irrelevant to the point that even a celebrity can strike out if they're being an ass. So, I maintain it may depend on the approach. I'll admit celebrity status or being especially attractive probably gets you more leeway with people, but where do you go with that?
I think a lot more leeway. I don't think that can be overstated and I think it is significant. How much of our being uncomfortable with others is our faulty and inconsistent perceptions? Let me hasten to add that just because people would find the behavior of an attractive celebrity okay but find the same behavior of an unattractive Joe Sixpack doesn't justify the behavior of Joe Sixpack.

But this is one of the reasons I think this discussion important. I think we should live an examined life and I wonder if we did if we would really be so uncomfortable in many of the situations that currently make us uncomfortable? RW is entitled to her feelings but were they rational?

Let me concede two points: 1.) If a person is ignorant of the facts (the likelihood of being assaulted in an elevator) then their perceptions are not irrational. 2.) If a person knows the facts but is irrational then they are still entitled to their feelings. If someone is afraid of me because he is afraid of men with beards then the fact that his belief is irrational doesn't obviate his fear (though he might want to get therapy).
 
Last edited:
Here's Rebecca Watson's »Bloggingheads« session with Ann Althouse.

http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/37611

Rebecca describes Elevator guy roughly in the middle, so we can settle the Brad Pitt hypothesis. But watch the whole thing. You guys babbled so much about Rebecca, it wouldn't hurt you to learn a bit more where she's coming from.
 
Here's Rebecca Watson's »Bloggingheads« session with Ann Althouse.

http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/37611

Rebecca describes Elevator guy roughly in the middle, so we can settle the Brad Pitt hypothesis. But watch the whole thing. You guys babbled so much about Rebecca, it wouldn't hurt you to learn a bit more where she's coming from.
(emphasis mine) I'm listening to it but I want to make quick point.

This is a very big problem for BOTH sides. There are not two opposing sides with monolithic views. It might appear that way but that is a faulty perception.
 
No; "being happy" would be a positive reaction. By my logic, no stimulus would result in no reaction, positive or negative.

Maybe I didn't word it well but it's entirely possible and even quite likely that if no propositioning went on at all a TAM (or any other given event) then some people would be disappointed. No stimulus would result in a disappointed reaction.

As far as I see you have four basic groups - people who would like to proposition, people who would not like to proposition, people who would like to receive a proposition and people who would not like to receive a proposition.

I can't see a simple way to satisfy them all, nor do I see how I can prioritise the preferences of the 'don't like to be propositioned' over the 'would like to be propositioned' or the 'would like to proposition' groups.

Because the attendees' reactions at TAM can be quantified. Several people here who attend TAMs have announced that such-and-such behavior makes them uncomfortable. You may not recognize their faces, but you have information that they are present at TAM. You know for certain they are present and will react badly. Conversely, you have no information about whether anyone at a random restaurant is going to react badly; I wouldn't consider it unreasonable to not act on information you don't have.

This honestly makes no sense to me. First off we do know that some people do like being propositioned as it happens all the time. Beyond that though I still don't see how we avoid a tyranny of taking offence if we only need 1 person to object to something to provide information that we shouldn't do it. Beyond even that, the drawing of the boundary to the TAM is completely arbitrary. Why extrapolate the preferences of a handful of people to everyone at TAM but not everyone in Vegas, or everyone in the US?

You are entitled to ask. I see no reason why someone who chews gum would willingly continue to do so once they are cognizant that it is annoying bystanders as a matter of fact. Unless the gum chewer is a jerk.

You've switched here back from the general to the specific though. We have information that some TAM attendees don't like gum chewing in their vicinity - employing your original logic people should desist from chewing gum while at TAM.

The equivalent to the quote above would be to argue that if you proposition a woman in a lift and she declines and asks you to desist then you should do so. Something I wouldn't disagree with.

That's different; if principle and personal integrity demand an action be taken, I can see that outweighing consideration for a person's feelings. There are no principles which "demand" asking strangers for sex; you may invent one for the sake of discussion, but I feel safe dismissing it as spurious.

Why is it 'different'? You don't value the principle of being able to determine for yourself how you behave rather than have your actions determined by the lowest denominator of offence taker?

It's not about a rule being imposed upon people by an authority of some kind. If anyone here reading my posts has thought that's what I was advocating, I apologize for not being more clear. I cannot see why anyone, willingly and of his own accord, would not refrain from doing such a simple and trivial thing knowing that doing it would make his colleagues uncomfortable.

Regardless, the 'rules' still have to be imposed somehow though even if they are self-imposed and there needs to be some internal consistency to them. I don't see how we can get an internally consistent rule about 'don't hit on women at TAM' that also doesn't result in 'don't chew gum at TAM' 'don't drink beer at TAM' 'don't have TAM at all' unless we just assume that 'hitting on women' is a special case in which there really is no argument it's just an instruction not to hit on women.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom