So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rubbish. Ivor's right, there is a cost. The cost is that over time men become more and more fearful of approaching women because they've been told time and time again by feminists that women don't like men fancying them. The cost is to women and society as a whole. Men become emasculated and scared to behave like men; and women end up sad and lonely, wondering were all the real men have gone and why none of them will ask them out anymore.

In fairness I should say I almost stopped reading at that last sentence ("real men"?), but I kept going in case you had something more thoughtful to say.

Rubbish. Ivor's right, there is a cost. The cost is that over time men become more and more fearful of approaching women because they've been told time and time again by feminists that women don't like men fancying them. The cost is to women and society as a whole. Men become emasculated and scared to behave like men; and women end up sad and lonely, wondering were all the real men have gone and why none of them will ask them out anymore.

We end up with a society where the genders are increasingly pitted against each other, in entrenched positions of misogyny and misandry. And that sucks.

It is also a slippery slope argument. Accommodating the needs of a small number within a slightly larger number does not have to lead to men being "emasculated" and never looking at women, or women being lonely. Any more than encouraging people to wash their hands after using the restroom has to lead to an antiseptic, germophobic society that's afraid to send their kids outside without HEPA respirators.


And there's nothing wrong with "just getting laid". Maybe some women don't mind the thought of "just getting laid" at a conference. Be that as it may, in the original story the Irish dude didn't ask her for sex, he asked her if she wanted coffee. It may have entered common parlance as a euphemism for hanky-panky, but he hardly asked her for a quickie there and then in the lift.

Yeah, he asked her for one up in his room. What's the difference?

If a man never gets the opportunity to proposition a woman then we're all in the doo-doo.

Here's a novel idea - try talking to someone with a couple of days to sound out whether they're receptive to sex. I have enough faith in the human capacity for deductive intuition to predict you'll be able to find out without risking an insult.

And no, there's not a thing wrong with "just getting laid". That's the whole point of Mr. Baseball Cards outside the hotel. You will never find me disparaging a person who makes use of his services. I would consider it bad form to make "just getting laid" more of a priority than compassion for our fellow conference attendees, and that opinion is certainly what underwrites the rest of my opinions on this topic, but my opinions hardly constitute an act of Congress or a demand that all must submit to my point of view.
 
Well, how deep and philosophical do we want this to get? :)

One could argue that anything short of scientifically provable phenomena is subjective.

For instance we would agree that child sacrifice is evil, whereas an Aztec would argue that it is civic duty. What is your universal evidence that we are right?
We're here and they aren't. :)
 
In this case, TAM attendees we presumably want to interact with.
And for some of us in more ways than one. {picture me with bushy eye brows, mustache and a cigar}

It is a much smaller set than "everyone"; small enough that a handful of people become statistically significant.
I'm not sure why we shouldn't carry that to other groups (why isn't this special pleading?). What if you want to "interact" with people in any other social context? Now, I understand if someone says "it's something you should consider". That's fine, it might be good advice. And I gather you will say that is all you are doing. Fine, so long as you can live with disappointment. Sorry to be cynical but IMO it would be nice if adolescents would put off intercourse until they are legal adults. And I would give them that advice. Hell, I did. But then I labor under no illusions.
 
That's what's so insidious about Watson's behavior -- it's the common radical feminist tactic of shutting down dissent by labeling all dissenters as ignorant misogynists.
Factions of lots of groups employ the same tactic:
Right Wingers
Blacks
Jews
Americans
9/11 Truthers ...

I'd say it's a human tactic.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes they can.

"Where have all the good men gone?"
"Why doesn't anyone ever chat me up?"
"Does my bum look big in this?"
"I'm so ugly!"
"Whaaaaaah!"

...

I wager that's because it's traditionally the man's role to chat up the woman. A woman being that forward would be considered very racy, and not that attractive, really. Men don't like women acting like men. Go figure.

(I am presuming you're a man, Checkmite, correct me if this is not the case)

Yes I am. In any case, it's not traditional to ask complete strangers for sex, either, making this particular tangent somewhat of an argumentative stalemate.


My point is, what happened to make any woman feel uncomfortable by the thought of a man finding her attractive? That is what is so wrong, IMO.

I'm not sure that's really the problem. I suppose it's fair to characterize a woman who is acidic toward any suggestion that she is attractive as an example of "oversteering" - but you oversteer only because there was something over there that needed to be avoided. Perhaps we can mark this sort of thing down as "a few troublemakers spoiling it for the rest of us", if you will.
 
In fairness I should say I almost stopped reading at that last sentence ("real men"?), but I kept going in case you had something more thoughtful to say.
Cheers. ;)

It is also a slippery slope argument. Accommodating the needs of a small number within a slightly larger number does not have to lead to men being "emasculated" and never looking at women, or women being lonely. Any more than encouraging people to wash their hands after using the restroom has to lead to an antiseptic, germophobic society that's afraid to send their kids outside without HEPA respirators.
It is indicative of what is happening generally. The more incidents like this happen and get reported, the more it affects everyone's behaviour. Look at how sensationalist paedophile scares have led to children not being allowed to walk to school anymore. Dominant social themes do change behaviour over time.

Yeah, he asked her for one up in his room. What's the difference?
The difference between coffee and sex? :boggled: You really need me to explain that to you? The point is, why was she insulted by a man fancying her? That is the bit I cannot compute. If a man propositioned me I would be flattered. Wouldn't any woman?

Here's a novel idea - try talking to someone with a couple of days to sound out whether they're receptive to sex. I have enough faith in the human capacity for deductive intuition to predict you'll be able to find out without risking an insult.
I'm not ruling out dating, I'm just saying that propositioning a woman in a lift is not a crime, and men shouldn't be made to feel that it is by some jumped-up feminist.
 
Fine, so long as you can live with disappointment. Sorry to be cynical but IMO it would be nice if adolescents would put off intercourse until they are legal adults. And I would give them that advice. Hell, I did. But then I labor under no illusions.

Unlike me, for example...right?
 
Where I live, being 'asked out' means a date, not sex. However, if it also means sex then you have my answer already.....
So is coffee in one's hotel room possibly a date to talk and get to know a person or is the only thing possible sex?
 
So is coffee in one's hotel room possibly a date to talk and get to know a person or is the only thing possible sex?
'xactly. I've gone back to guy's apartments from clubs in the past when they've asked me for coffee, and made it plain that yes I would love to but that means absolutely no sex, literally coffee means coffee. And you know what? They say "yeah, sure!" and keep to their word.

Coffee can mean coffee, chat, swap phone numbers and call a cab home.
 
It is indicative of what is happening generally. The more incidents like this happen and get reported, the more it affects everyone's behaviour. Look at how sensationalist paedophile scares have led to children not being allowed to walk to school anymore. Dominant social themes do change behaviour over time.

Yes but not in the way or to the extent you think. Children are allowed to walk to school all the time. I would wager that more children walk to school than are bussed or driven by their parents. The idea of children "not being allowed to walk to school anymore" is a "suburban myth"; a construct, something that people just presume is true because it has to be true if the slippery-slope logic holds. The problem is that reality does not reflect that. That man you read about in the paper that one time who tried to help a lost kid and the parent demanded his arrest - that's actually not becoming the "norm", it's not in danger of becoming the norm.

Likewise, not hitting strangers in elevators up for sex during a science conference does not create a danger of a sexless society where men and women are afraid to interact. That does not happen in real life.


The difference between coffee and sex? :boggled: You really need me to explain that to you? The point is, why was she insulted by a man fancying her? That is the bit I cannot compute. If a man propositioned me I would be flattered. Wouldn't any woman?

It seemed to me that it was the manner. It is my understanding that she said "don't do that", not "don't ever do anything".


I'm not ruling out dating, I'm just saying that propositioning a woman in a lift is not a crime, and men shouldn't be made to feel that it is by some jumped-up feminist.

I agree that characterizing the situation as a "crime", or that feeling attraction toward a woman is something a man should be "ashamed of", is hyperbolic. But there is a middle ground between "it must never happen in any situation" and "it should be perfectly fine in every situation and those opposed can eat cake".

My solution may not mark the mean of that middle ground - but I feel it's closer than many others'.
 
But according to RW's story, the reported facts of which I will take at face value, it was more than just that, and as such, is not hypcritical.
You can take the "facts" at face value, most of us have:
5 star hotel
elevator alone
4am
after leaving the bar
EG was in the bar
RW believes elevators in 5 star hotels in Dublin are places assaults occur

It's the conclusions you cannot take at face value, unless you think RW can read minds:
EG heard RW's panel talk and bar discussion
EG interpreted RW's words the way RW believed
EG only wanted sex
EG's actions amounted to sexist objectification of RW
McGraf's comments reinforce misogyny
Elevators in 5 star hotels in Dublin are actually places one should fear assaults occur

Again, if I followed someone to an elevator at 4am, after knowing that someone was tired and wants to crash for the night, I would absolutely expect that someone to be creeped out by me, even Iif I legitimately only wanted to talk over some coffee. That "have coffee" is so prevalent in pop culture as a euphemism for "have sex" does not PROVE that's what he wanted, but it doesn't help WHATSOEVER to make the experience less "creepy."I disagree.

But there was more to it than just asking about coffee, and while he may have honestly meant only coffee, as noted above, it's understandable that one would consider it creepy how he did it, and that he used such a tired old line/euphemisim. If he honestly didn't know how that could look to a reasonable person, he is a social fool. It doesn't matter if RW is right or wrong about whether he really wanted just to talk over some coffee; if all of the facts are considered to be true, I too would advise the young man not to do that to her, or anyone similarly situated.

So no, I did not go "well beyond" the facts in evidence.
Yes, you did and you continue to do so here unless you were EG. Otherwise you are assuming your imagined experience is the same as everyone would have had.

If she insists, that yes, absolutely, there is no doubt he wanted sex only and had no interest in a conversation with coffee, then yes, that's not very skeptical of her.
Can you find a single quote from RW where she did not insist?

I notice this time you said the comments were about the blog entry, not about McGraf herself. You are saying she attacked the words, not the person, which was my point, and I do think the distinction is important, being a skeptic.

But I can still accept your original point of view, because even if RW is attacking Stef's words and not Stef herself, when you say something like "ancient anti-woman rhetoric," those extra words are not by acident, and they come across as pretty personal, perhaps closely enough in spirit to actually calling Stef misogynist.
RW has excused herself a number of times by saying she didn't attack EG only his actions, and so on. It's disingenuous because it is not relevant. It remains RW's conclusions here that people take issue with, not her social skills.
 
Prometheus, I can't believe you haven't already read what I'm about to type, considering it's been uttered about a dozen times already:

1) WE HAVE NO IDEA if EG heard that. And if he did, his "don't take it the wrong way" might be a way he thought it'd show that he did care. How is that objectifying ?

2) If he didn't care about her feelings why did he take no for an answer ?

3) You are again assuming he wanted sex. You don't know that.

Of course I'm aware that all three of your points have been repeated ad nauseum throughout this whole debacle.

I ignore them because they are entirely irrelevant.

1) We don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar, because we are not putting EG on trial (at least I'm not). RW assumed that EG had heard both, and her judgement that EG did not "get it" (no pun intended) was predicated on that assumption, as was her admonishment, "Guys, don't do that." Of course it's possible that she misinterpreted the actual event to be an example of what she'd been talking about earlier in the day. I'll even allow that, tired, drunk(?) and alone at 4am confirmation bias might be even a more likely culprit than normal. But it just doesn't matter. The entire point is, don't do that--where 'that' does not refer to cold-propositioning sex, or inviting someone for coffee, or whatever. 'That' refers to what RW thought it was at the time--willfully ignoring a woman's stated desires while pursuing her for sex.

2) If he did, then why did he disregard them in the first place? Of course it's possible that he didn't know what they were, either because she was mistaken and he hadn't actually been listening (unlikely, as he pretty much admitted the opposite in the way he worded his invitation) or because he didn't "get it" which RW herself seems to give him the benefit of the doubt on in her initial video. But it just doesn't matter. RW was attempting to construct an instructive example from something that happened to her during the conference she was blogging about. It's the instructive part that is the point. not how closely the construct happens to jive with the real event.

3) Yes, I'm assuming he wanted sex. No, I do not know that. You are correct. Since I'm trying to approach this skeptically, I'll leave aside the argument from incredulity (Do you really think a guy would ask a woman back to his hotel room if he didn't have sex in mind?) and the ad hominem (if he didn't at least realize that that's how she'd interpret his invitation then EG is a freakin' dumbass), and merely stick to my point--it just doesn't matter. Whether he wanted sex, or coffee or conversation or anything else is irrelevant because none of those possibilities is consistent with respecting her announcement that she was tired and going to bed. Whatever EG wanted, he wanted it badly enough to ignore what RW had already said she wanted. That's objectification, be it sexual or otherwise.
 
The highlighted line is, I think, the key here--and it's not because RW is being hypocritical, as McGraw misconstrues and RW then calls out in her presentation at CFI.

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep. It's not just that he asked for sex out of the blue--which, as we've seen in this thread, some women find creepy while others do not. It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings. That's the part that's objectifying her. Guys, don't do that.

To me, I would expect that this would increase the creepiness factor, too. Even if you're not generally creeped out by being cold-propositioned for sex, would it change your attitude if the guy doing so were simultaneously demonstrating that he doesn't care what your feelings are--that he'll pursue you even after you've expressed that you don't want him to--in fact that he'll corner you in an enclosed space to do so?
Where is your evidence EG heard RW?

Where is your evidence EG interpreted RW's words as RW believes she communicated them?


And what Ivor said:
He wanted sex?

He cornered her?

Ms. Watson made what clear?
 
This whole thing has become a bit of a Rorschach Test among skeptics. At each point there is not really enough information to make an informed decision, yet we make a decision at that point and move on to the next with that decision in tow and try to make the next point conform to our building view of the situation.
Speak for yourself.

Some of us are at least attempting to be rational and specifically cite the logic and evidence we are basing our conclusions on. I'm not claiming to be doing a perfect job at it, but I'm most certainly doing a better job than a lot of people.

And yet, there is little disagreement on the creep factor. Randfan keeps reiterating so often that it is getting boring: Yes, she has the right to be creeped out by an admittedly in-artful approach.
That is not saying the guy or the situation were obviously creepy or would have been to everyone. Given the story on its face, I would have just said, no thanks, and not been creeped out.


If you want to argue about what the dialogue should be in the skeptical movement regarding feminism, then you either agree with RW or you are a misogynist or parroting misogynist ideas.

And that is how far the skeptical community has come in 76 pages of discussing a girl in an elevator.
At least you noticed this part. :)
 
Can you please provide evidence of 1 and evidence of EG's awareness of 2?

Nope, but as I explained in my responses to others EG's actual knowlege and intent are irrelevant. Rebecca's initial video was commenting on her perception of them, and her admonishment to all men was predicated on that perception. I don't believe she said anything at all about the appropriateness of EG or anyone else propositioning a woman they do know have such foreknowledge about. If RW was mistaken what EG heard or knew about her, then the actual event is just not a good example of the point she was making, but the point still stands.
 
Some of us are at least attempting to be rational and specifically cite the logic and evidence we are basing our conclusions on. I'm not claiming to be doing a perfect job at it, but I'm most certainly doing a better job than a lot of people.

I think this is part of the problem.

Questions like "should this behavior be socially acceptable or not" can't be answered definitively answered for everyone with facts or figures, anymore than "which is better food, Greek or Italian?" You can say "well this food tends to be healthier and have fewer calories", but that will only convince people who think being healthier is more important than taste or filling-ness or expense. We can try to work toward a consensus. But it's a far cry from the sorts of questions that we, as skeptics, excel in tackling. "Does pseudoscience X work?" "No it doesn't; studies A, B, and C clearly highlight the lack of efficacy, and only by ignoring facts can you conclude otherwise."
 
Where is your evidence EG heard RW?

Where is your evidence EG interpreted RW's words as RW believes she communicated them?


And what Ivor said:

I have none. I'm not arguing that RW's assesment of the EG's motives and foreknowlege is correct, only that, assuming they were correct, her response is entirely justified.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom