So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Losing something you don't even have isn't really a "cost" - but if we want to define it that way, so does eating lunch with someone who has a nut allergy - you just can't order that cashew chicken. Or you can, but there will be negative consequences for your lunch partner, possibly severe ones; and if those consequences are unimportant to you, what on earth compelled you to go and eat lunch with that person anyway?

In the same vein, sex is something you do with another person. It's an interaction, and therefore kind of requires you to take your potential "targets'" feelings and sexual opinions into consideration at every step. It seems rather bizarre to both be interested in a set of people as romantic partners and insist that their feelings and concerns vis-a-vis sexual politics aren't important enough to factor into your "action" plan. And if it's not a romantic partner you're after but, as you say, "just getting laid"...well then, Mr. Baseball Cards has your back.



Surprisingly, no. While because of the nature of the discussion it's easy to slip into using the words "men" this and "women" that, I'm making an effort at using the word "people" when I can. Because I'm one of those who believes that it is possible for a woman to sexually harass a man, and I feel it is just as unacceptable as the reverse. What matters about the situation we're discussing isn't that we don't want to offend women; in my opinion, it's that we don't want to offend our colleagues. Three nights without sex isn't an amputation or a prison sentence; the vast majority of humans spend at least the first fifteen to twenty years of their lives without sex and don't suffer suffer from ill effects, atrophied sex organs, or hysteria.
Aaaand...we're back to:

"Because [insert action here] makes People uncomfortable, we just shouldn't do it at all."

See if you can spot the problem with that logic.
 
Aaaand...we're back to:

"Because [insert action here] makes People uncomfortable, we just shouldn't do it at all."

See if you can spot the problem with that logic.

It reminds me of the thinking that drives health and safety on the site where I work. At one point a notice was pinned up telling us how to use stairs. This temporarily generated more dangerous behaviour as people tried to stay within the rules in inventive ways.:)

Once the big problems are being or have been addressed special interest groups need to focus on ever more minor issues to justify their own existence.
 
We have data indicating there are women who do not appreciated being asked for conversation by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do is avoid talking to any stranger.

Certain social interactions, such as the ones you and Checkmite described, cause different reactions. Some of those reactions are positive, while others are negative.

What are the overall benefits and damages caused to the people involved in those interactions?

Do the damages of negative reactions outweigh the benefits of positive reactions to the extent that censorship is desirable?
 
Last edited:
This thread reminds me of the Beavis and Butthead episode where Beavis and Butthead took a teenage girl to court for sexually harassing them. The girl was attractive and didn't do anything at all to Beavis and Butthead, but because she was attractive it annoyed Beavis and Butthead that they got turned on when they looked at her but couldn't do anything about it.

From from that perspective, perhaps it was RW that was sexually harassing EG.
 
On the face of it this seems like a reasonable argument but on second reading something about it doesn't seem right. If I turn the argument on its head then it makes no sense and yet the logic is the same...

We have data indicating that men at TAMs would appreciate it if women offered them casual sex. Since we have no way of knowing if any man is one of them the prudent thing to do would be to offer all men at TAM casual sex. The men who would be comfortable with this will therefore be very pleased and the men who don't want casual sex will not care anyway. That's a net positive result on the side of 'dropping your drawers willy-nilly'.

Not quite. Presuming that females who would not react badly to a proposition would not care anyway is just a reiteration of definition: they won't react badly to being asked (by definition), and they can't react at all to a non-stimulus. On the other hand, "Men who don't want casual sex will not care" is not an equal presumption, because the proposed action (hitting on them) is a stimulus, and there can be a reaction, and if they do not want casual sex that reaction may easily be negative. I, for instance, would be made uncomfortable by a stranger coming up to me and asking me for sex.




Choosing when and where to use profanity yourself is a different proposition to determining whether other people should use profanity or not in a given situation. You may not use profanity around your dad for example, whereas I might. Should I not use profanity around my dad because you don't use it with yours? Should I refrain from profanity at all times in case someone's dad is in earshot?

The point of the profanity example was just to provide another instance of a common societal behavior which has boundaries that may not be strictly logical. It was not meant to be a mirror of the stranger-sex thing in every aspect.

Of course, if we follow this logic then given that you can probably find people who object to anything at any time then we won't do anything ever. In fact, there probably wouldn't be a TAM because some people object to the very existence of the conference.

I find it humorous that you actually quoted my saying "That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences...", yet your actual response suggests you hadn't read it.

And of course there is a cost in refraining from behaviour you would otherwise have indulged in! To claim otherwise is nonsense. The cost is whatever positive value that behaviour generates for you.

All right, fine. Which is worth more to you - having sex with someone you don't know, or avoiding the enmity of someone you don't know?
 
Aaaand...we're back to:

"Because [insert action here] makes People uncomfortable, we just shouldn't do it at all."

See if you can spot the problem with that logic.

How about "because [action] makes People who matter to us uncomfortable, we should refrain when they're around".
 
And that is how far the skeptical community has come in 76 pages of discussing a girl in an elevator.
I find your lack of faith in our ability to advance a discussion disturbing.

Still, if you are at TAM next year, I think we should get together and have coffee.
 
Losing something you don't even have isn't really a "cost" - but if we want to define it that way, so does eating lunch with someone who has a nut allergy - you just can't order that cashew chicken. Or you can, but there will be negative consequences for your lunch partner, possibly severe ones; and if those consequences are unimportant to you, what on earth compelled you to go and eat lunch with that person anyway?
Rubbish. Ivor's right, there is a cost. The cost is that over time men become more and more fearful of approaching women because they've been told time and time again by feminists that women don't like men fancying them. The cost is to women and society as a whole. Men become emasculated and scared to behave like men; and women end up sad and lonely, wondering were all the real men have gone and why none of them will ask them out anymore.

We end up with a society where the genders are increasingly pitted against each other, in entrenched positions of misogyny and misandry. And that sucks.

In the same vein, sex is something you do with another person. It's an interaction, and therefore kind of requires you to take your potential "targets'" feelings and sexual opinions into consideration at every step. It seems rather bizarre to both be interested in a set of people as romantic partners and insist that their feelings and concerns vis-a-vis sexual politics aren't important enough to factor into your "action" plan. And if it's not a romantic partner you're after but, as you say, "just getting laid"...well then, Mr. Baseball Cards has your back.
And there's nothing wrong with "just getting laid". Maybe some women don't mind the thought of "just getting laid" at a conference. Be that as it may, in the original story the Irish dude didn't ask her for sex, he asked her if she wanted coffee. It may have entered common parlance as a euphemism for hanky-panky, but he hardly asked her for a quickie there and then in the lift.

If a man never gets the opportunity to proposition a woman then we're all in the doo-doo.
 
Last edited:
Rubbish. Ivor's right, there is a cost. The cost is that over time men become more and more fearful of approaching women because they've been told time and time again by feminists that women don't like men fancying them. The cost is to women and society as a whole. Men become emasculated and scared to behave like men; and women end up sad and lonely, wondering were all the real men have gone and why none of them will ask them out anymore.

We end up with a society where the genders are increasingly pitted against each other, in entrenched positions of misogyny and misandry. And that sucks.

And as Joe Jackson said in his song "Real Men," if there's war between the sexes then there'll be no people left.
 
He wanted sex?

Yes. But since you won't let it go at that, whether my assessment of his motives is correct or not is entirely irrelevant to the point.

He cornered her?

Yes. Although I have seen round elevators, the idiom "to corner" applies to any situation in which a lone person is accosted while egress is hampered geometrically or otherwise.

Ms. Watson made what clear?

That she 1) Did not like to be sexually objectified at conferences--even gave a whole presentation about what those terms mean--and 2) was tired and going to bed.
 
How about "because [action] makes People who matter to us uncomfortable, we should refrain when they're around".
Providing we have established that understanding beforehand.

Otherwise, in our casual encounters with those whom we have never encountered before, and may never encounter again, we shrug it off, and get on with our lives.
These said encounters are not even worth mentioning. They could happen several times a day, every day ...
 
Aaaand...we're back to: Who are these people.

Oh, let me guess, everyone.

In this case, TAM attendees we presumably want to interact with. It is a much smaller set than "everyone"; small enough that a handful of people become statistically significant.
 
:p Yowza! Having to go back five pages to requote this:
Is there a source? I'd like to put this, or at least something about TAM 9 in the timeline.

At this point, just TAM scuttlebutt. I'll look into it.

Ok. Rechecked with attendee. According to him, it was fairly common knowledge around TAM that the Skepchicks as a community (with a couple of exceptions) made a big push via email to urge each speaker at TAM to speak out about Dawkins's comments. One speaker in particular he talked to, Carol Tavris, really didn't appreciate said push. Apparently, the speakers all got together pre-TAM to agree as a group that it was NOT a topic they felt would add anything to TAM, so they weren't going to bring it up.

I realize this is just "hearsay", however. Fwiw, I consider my sceptic source (whom I shall henceforth refer to as "Deep Doubt") very reliable. For an onymous source: If you want direct confirmation from one of the push targets, Carol TavrisWP probably your best bet (though one at a time, please, lest we inundate her with more shrill emails re elevator-gate). ;)
 
Last edited:
Not quite. Presuming that females who would not react badly to a proposition would not care anyway is just a reiteration of definition: they won't react badly to being asked (by definition), and they can't react at all to a non-stimulus.
Oh yes they can.

"Where have all the good men gone?"
"Why doesn't anyone ever chat me up?"
"Does my bum look big in this?"
"I'm so ugly!"
"Whaaaaaah!"

On the other hand, "Men who don't want casual sex will not care" is not an equal presumption, because the proposed action (hitting on them) is a stimulus, and there can be a reaction, and if they do not want casual sex that reaction may easily be negative. I, for instance, would be made uncomfortable by a stranger coming up to me and asking me for sex.
I wager that's because it's traditionally the man's role to chat up the woman. A woman being that forward would be considered very racy, and not that attractive, really. Men don't like women acting like men. Go figure.

(I am presuming you're a man, Checkmite, correct me if this is not the case)

All right, fine. Which is worth more to you - having sex with someone you don't know, or avoiding the enmity of someone you don't know?
My point is, what happened to make any woman feel uncomfortable by the thought of a man finding her attractive? That is what is so wrong, IMO.
 
That she 1) Did not like to be sexually objectified at conferences--even gave a whole presentation about what those terms mean--and 2) was tired and going to bed.

Can you please provide evidence of 1 and evidence of EG's awareness of 2?
 
It costs nothing, absolutely nothing, to say "I'm going to a special few-days-long conference dedicated to science and skepticism, where some attendees have expressed discomfort about offers for casual sex from strangers, so I will not pursue casual sex with strangers this weekend". It is no more a burden that not ordering fish when having dinner with someone who has told you they are sickened by the smell of it, or refraining from telling the aristocrats joke around a group when you know some members are abuse victims who react badly. That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences - but when you know that there will be people at this particular time and place where it won't go over well, putting up that temporary boundary costs nothing, and pays dividends in the form of making or keeping acquaintances.
I think you've found the answer to your own question. You just need to add presumption and special pleading to your argument and you've got it.
 
And as Joe Jackson said in his song "Real Men," if there's war between the sexes then there'll be no people left.
Well good for Joe for still having the balls to say so, when so many people are cowed by feminist-inspired political correctness.

Was it politically incorrect of me to say that? It was? Oh good!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom