So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are more options than that. For example, talk to a person while he's with friends, while witnesses are around, in a public, unconfined space, or have them approach you.


Many men are extremely shy about approaching women with other people around, for very good reason. Let's not forget, irrespective of RW's very legitimate feelings, and EG had his own, too.
 
What's the difference? Does Watson have an acquaintence with Pitt I'm not aware of? I missed that issue of People.
The difference is that one might be more inclined to trust Pitt, even if erroneously so, because of his celebrity.

Plus, I'd be more interested to see how people respond when the only thing that has changed in the fact pattern is one's perceived attractiveness. Making it Brad Pitt changes more than just that.
 
Why? How well does Ms. Watson know Brad Pitt?

That many people think they know famous people better than they actually do might be the reason EG propositioned Ms. Watson in the first place...
You answered your own question.


"...many people think they know famous people better than they actually do..."
 
So Rebecca Watson latches on to the slightly loony end of feminism as a vehicle to further her self-obsessed self-publicity thing.
PZ Myers again goes into his grovel-to-the-feminist-chicks mode, hoping it might get him a solidarity shag.
And Richard Dawkins reacts like a bit of a dick.

God knows why any of this raised a single eyebrow.

And this post by someone named Captain Obvious. :p My hats off to you !
 
Pestering seems the wrong word, especially if a significant proportion of women respond positively to it. Pestering implies, to me at least, a certain persistence in the face of signals to contrary, which doesn't even seem to match the initial elevator incident; he asked once, and took no for an answer.

You and I may think that, but Ms. Watson was under the impression EG sexualised and objectified her after she thought she had made it clear that she doesn't like that sort of behaviour directed at her.

Not necessarily; if it was the same people persisting in the behaviour, and that was because it was working, then yes, you may be right. However, there are many people who simply don't seem to learn from experience.

Those would be men like tyr_13.:)

It is also possible that the behaviour is exhibited by people who are still learning and don't yet know any better. The actual people exhibiting the behaviour may be constantly changing, but the prevalence of the behaviour may stay relatively constant.

That's a possibility.
 
IMO, if I'm also entitled, I'd suggest that we not stigmatize certain behaviors because some people find those behaviors uncomfortable or creepy. I find that counterproductive and anything but a net positive.

But there's the thing - agreeing that there's appropriate times and places for certain behaviors isn't necessarily stigmatizing them.

It's a common behavior in our society to use colloquial profanity regularly, for instance; yet I'd bet some salad that the majority of us (I'm sure there will be a couple of people who claim to be exceptions; they can feel free to disregard this analogy) have people in our lives that we will not use profanity around - our parents or grandparents, perhaps, or very young children, or people we consider to be our "senex". There's no tangible negative consequence for doing so, no objectively reasonable or statistically-supportable explanation for why - they're all subjective arguments - but nonetheless, we keep a civil tongue around them because it's just "not the time and place". And when we're not around them, we feel free to bleep it up all we want. We're not condemning profanity - we even use it, for ******* **** - but we simply respect the fact that everything, even common societal behaviors, have boundaries.

It costs nothing, absolutely nothing, to say "I'm going to a special few-days-long conference dedicated to science and skepticism, where some attendees have expressed discomfort about offers for casual sex from strangers, so I will not pursue casual sex with strangers this weekend". It is no more a burden that not ordering fish when having dinner with someone who has told you they are sickened by the smell of it, or refraining from telling the aristocrats joke around a group when you know some members are abuse victims who react badly. That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences - but when you know that there will be people at this particular time and place where it won't go over well, putting up that temporary boundary costs nothing, and pays dividends in the form of making or keeping acquaintances.
 
But there's the thing - agreeing that there's appropriate times and places for certain behaviors isn't necessarily stigmatizing them.

It's a common behavior in our society to use colloquial profanity regularly, for instance; yet I'd bet some salad that the majority of us (I'm sure there will be a couple of people who claim to be exceptions; they can feel free to disregard this analogy) have people in our lives that we will not use profanity around - our parents or grandparents, perhaps, or very young children, or people we consider to be our "senex". There's no tangible negative consequence for doing so, no objectively reasonable or statistically-supportable explanation for why - they're all subjective arguments - but nonetheless, we keep a civil tongue around them because it's just "not the time and place". And when we're not around them, we feel free to bleep it up all we want. We're not condemning profanity - we even use it, for ******* **** - but we simply respect the fact that everything, even common societal behaviors, have boundaries.

It costs nothing, absolutely nothing, to say "I'm going to a special few-days-long conference dedicated to science and skepticism, where some attendees have expressed discomfort about offers for casual sex from strangers, so I will not pursue casual sex with strangers this weekend". It is no more a burden that not ordering fish when having dinner with someone who has told you they are sickened by the smell of it, or refraining from telling the aristocrats joke around a group when you know some members are abuse victims who react badly. That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences - but when you know that there will be people at this particular time and place where it won't go over well, putting up that temporary boundary costs nothing, and pays dividends in the form of making or keeping acquaintances.

So I take it that you will choose not to use any profanity anywhere at TAM, knowing that at least a few of the attendees might be offended by it?

Should we take some time to illicit all of the behaviors that offend or creep out at least some of the TAM attendees, so we can refrain from doing any of them?
 
Last edited:
<snip>

That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences - but when you know that there will be people at this particular time and place where it won't go over well, putting up that temporary boundary costs nothing, and pays dividends in the form of making or keeping acquaintances.

Of course it has a cost. If a person wants to try to get laid or meet a romantic partner at a conference, not hitting on people comes at a cost to that person.

You're arguing for men to constantly defer to the whims of women. Many women say they find men who do that are not attractive to them.
 
We have data indicating there are women who attend TAMs who do not appreciate being asked for sex by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do (assuming we're trying to be amiable about the concerns raised) is avoid asking any strangers for sex at TAM.

We have data indicating there are women who do not appreciated being asked for conversation by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do is avoid talking to any stranger.
 
The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep. It's not just that he asked for sex out of the blue--which, as we've seen in this thread, some women find creepy while others do not. It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings. That's the part that's objectifying her. Guys, don't do that.

Prometheus, I can't believe you haven't already read what I'm about to type, considering it's been uttered about a dozen times already:

1) WE HAVE NO IDEA if EG heard that. And if he did, his "don't take it the wrong way" might be a way he thought it'd show that he did care. How is that objectifying ?

2) If he didn't care about her feelings why did he take no for an answer ?

3) You are again assuming he wanted sex. You don't know that.
 
We have data indicating there are women who do not appreciated being asked for conversation by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do is avoid talking to any stranger.

Really, the only way to be sure of avoiding offending anyone anywhere at anytime is to not exist. People that refuse to not-exist need to have a derisive term applied to them so they can know how selfish they are. I'm thinking Exister.
 
I think a better question might be to assume it was a stranger who looked exactly like Brad Pitt.

The difference is that one might be more inclined to trust Pitt, even if erroneously so, because of his celebrity.

Precisely why I'm framing the question that way. Sure, an elevator at 4pm in a foreign country may be factors for discomfort. But my point to Gnome is that, if we change the one factor RW has not pointed out, namely that this guy was uninteresting to her, we probably get vastly different results. EG's appearance and manner were most definitely factors in her decision, and it's worth addressing.
 
We have data indicating there are women who attend TAMs who do not appreciate being asked for sex by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do (assuming we're trying to be amiable about the concerns raised) is avoid asking any strangers for sex at TAM. The women who would be uncomfortable with a proposition will thus not be creeped out, and the ones who wouldn't be uncomfortable will not care anyway. There is a net positive result on the side of 'don't'.

On the face of it this seems like a reasonable argument but on second reading something about it doesn't seem right. If I turn the argument on its head then it makes no sense and yet the logic is the same...

We have data indicating that men at TAMs would appreciate it if women offered them casual sex. Since we have no way of knowing if any man is one of them the prudent thing to do would be to offer all men at TAM casual sex. The men who would be comfortable with this will therefore be very pleased and the men who don't want casual sex will not care anyway. That's a net positive result on the side of 'dropping your drawers willy-nilly'.

Hmm perhaps we need to consider all the participants and not just particular subsegments?


But there's the thing - agreeing that there's appropriate times and places for certain behaviors isn't necessarily stigmatizing them.

It's a common behavior in our society to use colloquial profanity regularly, for instance; yet I'd bet some salad that the majority of us (I'm sure there will be a couple of people who claim to be exceptions; they can feel free to disregard this analogy) have people in our lives that we will not use profanity around - our parents or grandparents, perhaps, or very young children, or people we consider to be our "senex". There's no tangible negative consequence for doing so, no objectively reasonable or statistically-supportable explanation for why - they're all subjective arguments - but nonetheless, we keep a civil tongue around them because it's just "not the time and place". And when we're not around them, we feel free to bleep it up all we want. We're not condemning profanity - we even use it, for ******* **** - but we simply respect the fact that everything, even common societal behaviors, have boundaries.

It costs nothing, absolutely nothing, to say "I'm going to a special few-days-long conference dedicated to science and skepticism, where some attendees have expressed discomfort about offers for casual sex from strangers, so I will not pursue casual sex with strangers this weekend". It is no more a burden that not ordering fish when having dinner with someone who has told you they are sickened by the smell of it, or refraining from telling the aristocrats joke around a group when you know some members are abuse victims who react badly. That's not to say "you must never order fish ever because someone in the restaurant you don't know about may be sickened by the smell of fish", or "you must never tell the aristocrats joke ever because someone in the audience could be an abuse victim" - that's an argument from adverse consequences - but when you know that there will be people at this particular time and place where it won't go over well, putting up that temporary boundary costs nothing, and pays dividends in the form of making or keeping acquaintances.

Choosing when and where to use profanity yourself is a different proposition to determining whether other people should use profanity or not in a given situation. You may not use profanity around your dad for example, whereas I might. Should I not use profanity around my dad because you don't use it with yours? Should I refrain from profanity at all times in case someone's dad is in earshot?

Of course, if we follow this logic then given that you can probably find people who object to anything at any time then we won't do anything ever. In fact, there probably wouldn't be a TAM because some people object to the very existence of the conference.

And of course there is a cost in refraining from behaviour you would otherwise have indulged in! To claim otherwise is nonsense. The cost is whatever positive value that behaviour generates for you.
 
You know, it occurs to me that it would be interesting to hear RW relate some approaches men have used with her that she deemed non-offensive. I'm not saying that as a joke, it really would be interesting. Of course, things have gone so far at this point that even if she did that then some people in response would take that exact approach with her just to be ironic or silly, so it's not practical. But I can't help but wonder, in the privacy of her own brain, what she deems acceptable.
 
Precisely why I'm framing the question that way. Sure, an elevator at 4pm in a foreign country may be factors for discomfort. But my point to Gnome is that, if we change the one factor RW has not pointed out, namely that this guy was uninteresting to her, we probably get vastly different results. EG's appearance and manner were most definitely factors in her decision, and it's worth addressing.
I understand. I guess I am just more interested in the result if it's a very attractive stranger, not a very attractive celebrity.
 
Of course it has a cost. If a person wants to try to get laid or meet a romantic partner at a conference, not hitting on people comes at a cost to that person.

Losing something you don't even have isn't really a "cost" - but if we want to define it that way, so does eating lunch with someone who has a nut allergy - you just can't order that cashew chicken. Or you can, but there will be negative consequences for your lunch partner, possibly severe ones; and if those consequences are unimportant to you, what on earth compelled you to go and eat lunch with that person anyway?

In the same vein, sex is something you do with another person. It's an interaction, and therefore kind of requires you to take your potential "targets'" feelings and sexual opinions into consideration at every step. It seems rather bizarre to both be interested in a set of people as romantic partners and insist that their feelings and concerns vis-a-vis sexual politics aren't important enough to factor into your "action" plan. And if it's not a romantic partner you're after but, as you say, "just getting laid"...well then, Mr. Baseball Cards has your back.

You're arguing for men to constantly defer to the whims of women. Many women say they find men who do that are not attractive to them.

Surprisingly, no. While because of the nature of the discussion it's easy to slip into using the words "men" this and "women" that, I'm making an effort at using the word "people" when I can. Because I'm one of those who believes that it is possible for a woman to sexually harass a man, and I feel it is just as unacceptable as the reverse. What matters about the situation we're discussing isn't that we don't want to offend women; in my opinion, it's that we don't want to offend our colleagues. Three nights without sex isn't an amputation or a prison sentence; the vast majority of humans spend at least the first fifteen to twenty years of their lives without sex and don't suffer suffer from ill effects, atrophied sex organs, or hysteria.
 
And yet, there is little disagreement on the creep factor. Randfan keeps reiterating so often that it is getting boring: Yes, she has the right to be creeped out by an admittedly in-artful approach.

Well, she has the right, but she also has the right to believe that Lord John Whorfin from Planet 10 by way of the eighth dimension is controlling her mind with Zoobie rays.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom