So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh my GOD! Somebody disregarded Rebecca Watson's feelings? Call INTERPOL, quick.

The more I hear, the more I'm convinced. Disregarding Watson's feelings is like disregarding Rush Limbaugh's intellect, or disregarding Barack Obama's campaign promises.

Just so long as you don't try to get into Rush Limbaugh's or Obama's pants, you're in the clear. :p
 
We're here and they aren't. :)

Tell that to Mr. Acamapichtli who lives in the Mesoamerican Pyramid above me. You should see what drips down!

Riiight. Sexual attractiveness doesn't have anything to do with it. :rolleyes:

I agree!

...

Coffee?

Has anyone suggested in all of this, that it was incredibly presumptuous of RW to think that anyone wanted to have sex with her ?

She's kinda cute, and a little better looking than ordinary, but she does seem to have an ego that was crafted by the very 'sexist skeptical community' she now apparently hates.

Going by old posts and events involving RW she seems to have luxuriated in being the hottest woman in a very limited pool, and being drooled over by a lot of men that are maybe socially inept and lacking in female companionship. She used her sexual appeal like a tool, and frankly I'm coming up short for how she climbed as high in the community unless you take in to account her fan club.

Honestly, I'm in a roleplaying game group that has 3 female players, and if she joined she'd be 3rd hottest.
 
Last edited:
I've tried to answer every question you've asked in a straightforward manner. Thank you for your reciprocation.
Sorry Check, to me my narcism is more important to me than yours. Are you really clueless as to my meaning? have I otherwise been coy or obtuse?
 
Sorry Check, to me my narcism is more important to me than yours. Are you really clueless as to my meaning? have I otherwise been coy or obtuse?

Hey, if I'm supposed to believe that "you wanna come alone to my hotel room in the middle of the night?" does not imply sex, I'm not going to assume anything's meaning.

Since you insist, then fine: I'd like you to explain how my opinion that X is reasonable is "presuming to speak for everyone" and a "demand that everyone follow my point of view" when your opinion that X is unreasonable isn't any of those.

Extra credit for explaining how "You may as well not bother hitting on strange women in elevators anyway because it never actually works" is a bogus argument, while "it's pointless to suggest that people not hit up strangers for sex at TAM because it'll never happen" somehow has some traction.
 
Since you insist, then fine: I'd like you to explain how my opinion that X is reasonable is "presuming to speak for everyone"
You missed it. I conceded that it was just your opinion. Keep up.

"You may as well not bother hitting on strange women in elevators anyway because it never actually works" is a bogus argument
I think you are confusing me with someone else.

"it's pointless to suggest that people not hit up strangers for sex at TAM because it'll never happen"
Never? Again, you have me confused with someone else. I think your idea is naive at best. Futher I think there is a far better way to deal with the problem. Just my opinion.

So step away from the "gotcha" assumptions, take a deep breath, relax and listen to what I'm saying and not what you think I'm saying.
 
I understand if someone says "it's something you should consider". That's fine, it might be good advice. And I gather you will say that is all you are doing. Fine, so long as you can live with disappointment.
"it's pointless to suggest that people not hit up strangers for sex at TAM because it'll never happen" somehow has some traction.
:rolleyes: Nope, those don't reconcile My opinion that you will be disapointed doest not translate to "never happen".
 
Last edited:
So step away from the "gotcha" assumptions, take a deep breath, relax and listen to what I'm saying and not what you think I'm saying.

If you'd like me to do that, then answer questions directly, rather than with things like "I think your arguments speak for themselves". How am I supposed to "listen to what you're saying" when you're not actually saying anything? Of course I have to try and make some kind of inference about what you "mean" by that (which you can conveniently dismiss as "not what I actually said").
 
It is entirely possible. After having been told by three different people three different versions of what "the real issue" is in this thread, things start to blend together.
I'll admit I've been there. And this subject is finally wearing thin on me. :)
 
Hey, if I'm supposed to believe that "you wanna come alone to my hotel room in the middle of the night?" does not imply sex, I'm not going to assume anything's meaning.
First, your characterization of the exchange is blatantly designed to imply sex whereas the actual exchange was crafted to imply that sex was not the intention. I've received similar invitations from women, accepted, and they didn't involve sex. I've made similar such offers, had them accepted, and didn't have sex. And by similar, I mean conferences.
 
If you'd like me to do that, then answer questions directly, rather than with things like "I think your arguments speak for themselves". How am I supposed to "listen to what you're saying" when you're not actually saying anything? Of course I have to try and make some kind of inference about what you "mean" by that (which you can conveniently dismiss as "not what I actually said").
I don't think my answer inapropriate and I think you are making far too much of this, but I don't care to debate it anymore. I'm not commiting to leaving the thread or refusing to discuss other issues as it relates to elevatorgate with you but this line is dead.
 
Last edited:
First, your characterization of the exchange is blatantly designed to imply sex whereas the actual exchange was crafted to imply that sex was not the intention. I've received similar invitations from women, accepted, and they didn't involve sex. I've made similar such offers, had them accepted, and didn't have sex. And by similar, I mean conferences.

And second...?

I guess I won't say it's impossible that it wasn't an invitation for sex. I will say that interpreting it as such can't fairly be called outlandish or unreasonable.
 
Last edited:
And second...?

I guess I won't say it's impossible that it wasn't an invitation for sex. I will say that interpreting it as such can't fairly be called outlandish or unreasonable.

No, but insisting that it must have been is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom