So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If he did, then why did he disregard them in the first place?

You know, after a couple of weeks, even the original stuff is seeming less and less important. Just in the past few days, an aggressive gay wino accosted me wanting a kiss. Oh, can I write a blog where I write, "Gays, don't do this?" Just today, as I was trying to get the wheelchair out to get a lover of mine in to get an X-ray, a wino accosted me and said, "Can I ask you a question?" Since I'm in a bad mood, I said, "No. I am trying to get someone in a wheelchair into a ******* medical facility. Have you no sense?"

Maybe I could make a blog. Yay me!

So a fatuous, hypocritical, lying, talentless, white, middle class, Western, privileged woman, who gets her notoriety from throwing parties and encouraging people to make two-foot-long angry vagina images, who has probably not ever had to work at a job giving her calluses, nor who seems to have developed a productive relationship with soap, was forced against her will to feel uncomfortable in the interval she had allocated to herself between drinking a lot and insulting other people. Big fat hairy whoop.
 
:p Yowza! Having to go back five pages to requote this:


Ok. Rechecked with attendee. According to him, it was fairly common knowledge around TAM that the Skepchicks as a community (with a couple of exceptions) made a big push via email to urge each speaker at TAM to speak out about Dawkins's comments. One speaker in particular he talked to, Carol Tavris, really didn't appreciate said push. Apparently, the speakers all got together pre-TAM to agree as a group that it was NOT a topic they felt would add anything to TAM, so they weren't going to bring it up.

I realize this is just "hearsay", however. Fwiw, I consider my sceptic source (whom I shall henceforth refer to as "Deep Doubt") very reliable. For an onymous source: If you want direct confirmation from one of the push targets, Carol TavrisWP probably your best bet (though one at a time, please, lest we inundate her with more shrill emails re elevator-gate). ;)
Interesting. I do find this credible (retracting past statement I found it not credible). The details about the speakers agreeing not to bring the controversy up is consistent with the returning Seattle Skeptics who went to TAM. They reported nothing was said about the topic at the podium, only lots of coffee and elevator jokes in the informal settings.

But a formal, 'email every speaker', campaign? That's a bit much. How embarrassing.
 
I have none. I'm not arguing that RW's assesment of the EG's motives and foreknowlege is correct, only that, assuming they were correct, her response is entirely justified.

That's where I was going, too. If RW was right about EG's intentions, her initial response was acceptable IMO (subsequent mountains and molehills notwithstanding). She may have been wrong about EG asking her for sex, but that isn't pertinent to the question of whether asking for sex in that manner is a recommended course of action.
 
You know, after a couple of weeks, even the original stuff is seeming less and less important. Just in the past few days, an aggressive gay wino accosted me wanting a kiss. Oh, can I write a blog where I write, "Gays, don't do this?" Just today, as I was trying to get the wheelchair out to get a lover of mine in to get an X-ray, a wino accosted me and said, "Can I ask you a question?" Since I'm in a bad mood, I said, "No. I am trying to get someone in a wheelchair into a ******* medical facility. Have you no sense?"

Maybe I could make a blog. Yay me!

Welcome to the internet.

So a fatuous, hypocritical, lying, talentless, white, middle class, Western, privileged woman, who gets her notoriety from throwing parties and encouraging people to make two-foot-long angry vagina images, who has probably not ever had to work at a job giving her calluses, nor who seems to have developed a productive relationship with soap, was forced against her will to feel uncomfortable in the interval she had allocated to herself between drinking a lot and insulting other people. Big fat hairy whoop.

A pretty good example of why my blog reader's subscription list is pretty shallow. Science and skepticism are great; I don't care so much what people had for lunch, and I'm not going to wade through a dozen posts about bad hair days to find one post of useful information in a blog.

It's one reason, also, why the only skeptical podcast I listen to is Skeptoid. SGU, I'm sorry to say, just...wanders too much.
 
Of course I'm aware that all three of your points have been repeated ad nauseum throughout this whole debacle.

I ignore them because they are entirely irrelevant.
Many people do not agree with your assessment.

1) We don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar, because we are not putting EG on trial (at least I'm not). RW assumed that EG had heard both, and her judgement that EG did not "get it" (no pun intended) was predicated on that assumption, as was her admonishment, "Guys, don't do that." Of course it's possible that she misinterpreted the actual event to be an example of what she'd been talking about earlier in the day. I'll even allow that, tired, drunk(?) and alone at 4am confirmation bias might be even a more likely culprit than normal. But it just doesn't matter. The entire point is, don't do that--where 'that' does not refer to cold-propositioning sex, or inviting someone for coffee, or whatever. 'That' refers to what RW thought it was at the time--willfully ignoring a woman's stated desires while pursuing her for sex.
Oh for the love of Pete, not this again!!!

Prometheus, RW's personal reactions and beliefs about the incident are not what the issue is. Please, make an effort to find out why this is a straw man! I'm tired of correcting this, maybe someone else can help you.

2) If he did, then why did he disregard them in the first place? Of course it's possible that he didn't know what they were, either because she was mistaken and he hadn't actually been listening (unlikely, as he pretty much admitted the opposite in the way he worded his invitation) or because he didn't "get it" which RW herself seems to give him the benefit of the doubt on in her initial video. But it just doesn't matter. RW was attempting to construct an instructive example from something that happened to her during the conference she was blogging about. It's the instructive part that is the point. not how closely the construct happens to jive with the real event.
It was noted that someone also at the bar blogged about the events and made no mention of RW's claimed conversation at the bar, despite the fact it would have been important to mention. So we are not positive the bar discussion included anything related to EG's subsequent actions.

On the face of it, RW seems to be saying that EG should have known her statement, "I'm tired and going to bed", was absolute and definitive.

(Do you really think a guy would ask a woman back to his hotel room if he didn't have sex in mind?) ...
Yes. What planet are you from? He found her interesting and wanted to continue interacting with her. He could have been interested in a quickie, a temporary hook up (while the conference was on), a possible relationship, or actual conversation and coffee.
 
I think this is part of the problem.

Questions like "should this behavior be socially acceptable or not" can't be answered definitively answered for everyone with facts or figures, anymore than "which is better food, Greek or Italian?" You can say "well this food tends to be healthier and have fewer calories", but that will only convince people who think being healthier is more important than taste or filling-ness or expense. We can try to work toward a consensus. But it's a far cry from the sorts of questions that we, as skeptics, excel in tackling. "Does pseudoscience X work?" "No it doesn't; studies A, B, and C clearly highlight the lack of efficacy, and only by ignoring facts can you conclude otherwise."
I knew people were not going to know what I meant by RW's social skills. Sigh...

I'm talking about her rationalizing that attacking the behavior and not the person (the socially correct thing to do) makes her attacks OK. It doesn't.
 
I have none. I'm not arguing that RW's assesment of the EG's motives and foreknowlege is correct, only that, assuming they were correct, her response is entirely justified.
That's nice. Now all you need do is to find out what the real issue is here, since you don't know what it is.
 
Many people do not agree with your assessment.

How nice for them. Of course the same statement is equally true for all 3k+ posts in this thread. So what?

Oh for the love of Pete, not this again!!!

Prometheus, RW's personal reactions and beliefs about the incident are not what the issue is. Please, make an effort to find out why this is a straw man! I'm tired of correcting this, maybe someone else can help you.

If you're going to accuse me of constructing a straw man, then you'll have to show me where exactly I'm falsely attributing any argument to anyone. Otherwise, I'll politely request that you withdraw the accusation. As it stands now, I am in need of no correction on this matter because I have made no attempt at all to analyze actual events. I have only commented on RW's constructed example and the advice that should be drawn from that regardless of whether it is merely a construct, or an accurate description of an actual event.


It was noted that someone also at the bar blogged about the events and made no mention of RW's claimed conversation at the bar, despite the fact it would have been important to mention. So we are not positive the bar discussion included anything related to EG's subsequent actions.

I'd be interested in seeing that blog if anyone has a link, but it's not actually relevant to my point at all. Again, everything I've said rests on a purely hypothetical situation. Rebecca, and her followers, seem inclined to believe that that hypothetical is in accord with an actual event. Others question the congruity of the two. I don't care one way or the other.


On the face of it, RW seems to be saying that EG should have known her statement, "I'm tired and going to bed", was absolute and definitive.

No. On the face of it, RW seems to be saying that guys should not behave as she believes EG was behaving. If I've missed something she's said subsequently to qualify that, then I will be happy to adjust my opinion of her position accordingly. But her "Naming Names" blog post seems only to corroborate my understanding.

Yes. What planet are you from? He found her interesting and wanted to continue interacting with her. He could have been interested in a quickie, a temporary hook up (while the conference was on), a possible relationship, or actual conversation and coffee.

Sorry, I often forget how sarcasm isn't so obvious in print as it sounds in my head. Perhaps, though, you missed where I said multiple times that which of those possibilities, or any others, which might be true are irrelevant to me because I'm only talking about a hypothetical construct.
 
Certain social interactions, such as the ones you and Checkmite described, cause different reactions. Some of those reactions are positive, while others are negative.

What are the overall benefits and damages caused to the people involved in those interactions?

Do the damages of negative reactions outweigh the benefits of positive reactions to the extent that censorship is desirable?

If we start considering people's potential negative reactions to the point of inaction, then what's the point ?
 
That's where I was going, too. If RW was right about EG's intentions, her initial response was acceptable IMO (subsequent mountains and molehills notwithstanding). She may have been wrong about EG asking her for sex, but that isn't pertinent to the question of whether asking for sex in that manner is a recommended course of action.

Can't see that anybody has asked that question. It's more the kind of thing people accuse others of asking because they are either unwilling or unable to see the point.
 
1) We don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar

Your entire post hinged upon the presumption that he did. And now we don't need to know ? Do you even know what you're arguing ?

The entire point is, don't do that--where 'that' does not refer to cold-propositioning sex, or inviting someone for coffee, or whatever. 'That' refers to what RW thought it was at the time--willfully ignoring a woman's stated desires while pursuing her for sex.

Ah, so when you said:

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep.

You weren't implying that this was a fact, but just Rebecca's perspective ? Please. Re-read what you said, and tell me with a straight face that this is what it meant.

2) If he did, then why did he disregard them in the first place?

It's amazing how "we don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar" and yet again your answer to my second point hinges upon the presumption that he did. Seeing as we don't need to know, why do you assume he disregarded her feelings "in the first place" ?

But it just doesn't matter. RW was attempting to construct an instructive example from something that happened to her during the conference she was blogging about. It's the instructive part that is the point. not how closely the construct happens to jive with the real event.

And now you're right back to telling me that this:

It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings.

Is just you stating RW's perceptions ? I don't buy it.

Whether he wanted sex, or coffee or conversation or anything else is irrelevant because none of those possibilities is consistent with respecting her announcement that she was tired and going to bed. Whatever EG wanted, he wanted it badly enough to ignore what RW had already said she wanted. That's objectification, be it sexual or otherwise.

And for a THIRD time you assume that this thing you "don't need to know" is true. Only this time you don't even try to cloak it in false pretense that this is not your own point of view.

Everything you are arguing here hinges entirely on something you now claim is not important. I think you need to think that through.
 
Oh my GOD! Somebody disregarded Rebecca Watson's feelings? Call INTERPOL, quick.

The more I hear, the more I'm convinced. Disregarding Watson's feelings is like disregarding Rush Limbaugh's intellect, or disregarding Barack Obama's campaign promises.
 
1) We don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar

Your entire post hinged upon the presumption that he did. And now we don't need to know ?

Yes. Do you have trouble with the meaning of the word presumption?

Do you even know what you're arguing ?

Yes. Do you know what I'm arguing?

The entire point is, don't do that--where 'that' does not refer to cold-propositioning sex, or inviting someone for coffee, or whatever. 'That' refers to what RW thought it was at the time--willfully ignoring a woman's stated desires while pursuing her for sex.

Ah, so when you said:

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep.

You weren't implying that this was a fact, but just Rebecca's perspective ? Please. Re-read what you said, and tell me with a straight face that this is what it meant.

Yes, (with a straight face) that is exactly what I meant. Otherwise I wouldn't have typed it.

2) If he did, then why did he disregard them in the first place?

It's amazing how "we don't need to know whether EG heard Rebecca's presentation or her announcement in the bar" and yet again your answer to my second point hinges upon the presumption that he did. Seeing as we don't need to know, why do you assume he disregarded her feelings "in the first place" ?

I'm sorry, I guess you really do have trouble with the meaning of the word presumption, don't you? :rolleyes:

But it just doesn't matter. RW was attempting to construct an instructive example from something that happened to her during the conference she was blogging about. It's the instructive part that is the point. not how closely the construct happens to jive with the real event.

And now you're right back to telling me that this:

It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings.

Is just you stating RW's perceptions ? I don't buy it.

It's a good thing you don't buy it; I doubt you could pay for it, as you seem to have trouble just paying attention. I said what I meant. Each of my statements is entirely consistent with the others, so long as you leave the pedantry and willful blindness aside.

Whether he wanted sex, or coffee or conversation or anything else is irrelevant because none of those possibilities is consistent with respecting her announcement that she was tired and going to bed. Whatever EG wanted, he wanted it badly enough to ignore what RW had already said she wanted. That's objectification, be it sexual or otherwise.

And for a THIRD time you assume that this thing you "don't need to know" is true. Only this time you don't even try to cloak it in false pretense that this is not your own point of view.

Everything you are arguing here hinges entirely on something you now claim is not important. I think you need to think that through.

This one:

Presumption – noun
1. the act of presuming.

2. assumption of something as true.
3. belief on reasonable grounds or probable evidence.

I don't need to know if it's true or not because that is what I am assuming. I believe that RW was doing so as well. If I (or she) is wrong then EG is not (quite) as creepy, but the same conclusion holds: Disregarding a person's (known) feelings/intentions/POV while attempting to get something from that person is objectifying said person. Don't do that.
 
Has anyone suggested in all of this, that it was incredibly presumptuous of RW to think that anyone wanted to have sex with her ?

For those who missed the animated forensic reconstruction of the incident:

Part 1


Part 2 (addresses your point directly)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom