So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Everyone here fancies themselves as clever, rational, enlightened and prejudice free (myself, obviously included).

I would like to go on official record as stating that I am not always rational, and have many prejudices (most of which I at least acknowledge and make some effort to control); and what I will not tolerate is being beaten over the head by the prejudices of others, or being singled out by the self-deceived.
 
Guessing, but...

Everyone here fancies themselves as clever, rational, enlightened and prejudice free (myself, obviously included).

When we enlightened, prejudiced free men are told that we aren't allowed to try to pick up women (yes, yes, yes, I'm grossly oversimplifying for brevity) because it's sexist, we panic.

We're an enlightened prejudice free intellectuals, We think We don't think that's sexism, is it???

So we think about it ourselves first, examine the issue and then, once we've come to our conclusion, be it that we change our minds or decide the proposition is a load of fetid dingo's kidneys, we rush to the internet to tell our intellectual brothers and sisters that we're okay, we're not sexist, we're still enlightened, and here's why...

And we find that not all of our brother's and sister's agree. Some think that our oh so rational point of view is total kidneys and we tell them so, safe and certain in the knowledge that, by pointing out one or two salient points that our enlightened (although, obviously not quite as enlightened as we) brothers and sisters have missed, their point of view will be suitably rectified and we can go about our day, occasionally glancing at a shapely pair of legs or a particularly obvious pair of breasts, safe in the knowledge that we're not sexist.

But it doesn't work like that. Our brothers and sisters with the dingos ideas have points that, while of course are of no note whatsoever, they believe to be salient to the issue. So we have to explain it to them again.

At that point, it's inevitable that someone will post 'I haven't read all the thread (The thread's 30 pages long by this point so who can blame them?), but I think...' and it all goes round again. And no-one can let it drop because, well, we're clever, enlightened, rational, prejudice free individuals, we can't possibly be sexist. Enlightened, rational, clever women don't sleep with sexist men, so we just can't let it lie.
Ego, ain't it a bitch?

Great post!
 
I've no idea why. What is your reason? You think women at a skeptics conference are special?

We have data indicating there are women who attend TAMs who do not appreciate being asked for sex by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do (assuming we're trying to be amiable about the concerns raised) is avoid asking any strangers for sex at TAM. The women who would be uncomfortable with a proposition will thus not be creeped out, and the ones who wouldn't be uncomfortable will not care anyway. There is a net positive result on the side of 'don't'.
 
How is this not also correctly identifying hypocrisy? McGraf is merely saying the same thing I referred to, RW is OK with sexual interests of women, and with women expressing their sexual interests and freely responding to expressions of interest from males. Then along comes someone who was no different, a male expressing sexual interest in a female, and in this case RW decides it is not OK.
But according to RW's story, the reported facts of which I will take at face value, it was more than just that, and as such, is not hypcritical.

Again, if I followed someone to an elevator at 4am, after knowing that someone was tired and wants to crash for the night, I would absolutely expect that someone to be creeped out by me, even Iif I legitimately only wanted to talk over some coffee. That "have coffee" is so prevalent in pop culture as a euphemism for "have sex" does not PROVE that's what he wanted, but it doesn't help WHATSOEVER to make the experience less "creepy."
Now you've gone well beyond the facts in evidence, and maybe that's why you don't see the hypocrisy.
I disagree.

The guy asked about coffee, for Pete's sake. He didn't say, "Let's go do it." You don't know what he heard or interpreted from RW's prior discussions. That's all assumptions on RW's part as was the "he only wanted sex" assumption.
But there was more to it than just asking about coffee, and while he may have honestly meant only coffee, as noted above, it's understandable that one would consider it creepy how he did it, and that he used such a tired old line/euphemisim. If he honestly didn't know how that could look to a reasonable person, he is a social fool. It doesn't matter if RW is right or wrong about whether he really wanted just to talk over some coffee; if all of the facts are considered to be true, I too would advise the young man not to do that to her, or anyone similarly situated.

So no, I did not go "well beyond" the facts in evidence.

Maybe he wanted to eventually marry her. RW's assumptions are far from those of a critical thinker in this case.
If she insists, that yes, absolutely, there is no doubt he wanted sex only and had no interest in a conversation with coffee, then yes, that's not very skeptical of her.

Your pedantic objection is a fail. RW's comments about McGraf's blog entry were straight forward.
I notice this time you said the comments were about the blog entry, not about McGraf herself. You are saying she attacked the words, not the person, which was my point, and I do think the distinction is important, being a skeptic.

But I can still accept your original point of view, because even if RW is attacking Stef's words and not Stef herself, when you say something like "ancient anti-woman rhetoric," those extra words are not by acident, and they come across as pretty personal, perhaps closely enough in spirit to actually calling Stef misogynist.
 
Last edited:
We have data indicating there are women who attend TAMs who do not appreciate being asked for sex by strangers. Since we have no way of knowing whether any given woman is one of them, the prudent thing to do (assuming we're trying to be amiable about the concerns raised) is avoid asking any strangers for sex at TAM. The women who would be uncomfortable with a proposition will thus not be creeped out, and the ones who wouldn't be uncomfortable will not care anyway. There is a net positive result on the side of 'don't'.
You didn't answer the question but that's fine. I respect your opinion. Perhaps this discussion will lead to that. I doubt it. In truth I think it is rather a silly idea. It's like the religious fanatics that want adolescents to be chaste. They fail to understand human nature and basic human sex drives also.

Now, just a moment, I'm not saying that because your solution is fatuous that there are no solutions. I think raising awareness and getting people to talk about the issues important. I'd ask people to think about what they do and try to be considerate of others. I think it silly to prohibit anything. History has shown that it doesn't work so why not just be frank and honest and try to improve our game? Try to better understand each other? IMO, if I'm also entitled, I'd suggest that we not stigmatize certain behaviors because some people find those behaviors uncomfortable or creepy. I find that counterproductive and anything but a net positive.
 
I'm not sure what you mean by "pestering" in this context. Do you mean asking in any way at all, or asking in a way that is unwelcome to the recipient, or something else?

Any behaviour by a man directed at woman that the woman interprets as being sexually motivated, unwanted and offensive.

And how do you know what their success rate is?

I don't know the success rate precisely, but it seems unlikely that it would be extremely low or zero if it is as significant as Ms. Watson wants us to believe it is.

The behaviour must be being reinforced or else it would become extinct.
 
How is this not also correctly identifying hypocrisy? McGraf is merely saying the same thing I referred to, RW is OK with sexual interests of women, and with women expressing their sexual interests and freely responding to expressions of interest from males. Then along comes someone who was no different, a male expressing sexual interest in a female, and in this case RW decides it is not OK.

Now you've gone well beyond the facts in evidence, and maybe that's why you don't see the hypocrisy.

The guy asked about coffee, for Pete's sake. He didn't say, "Let's go do it." You don't know what he heard or interpreted from RW's prior discussions. That's all assumptions on RW's part as was the "he only wanted sex" assumption. Maybe he wanted to eventually marry her. RW's assumptions are far from those of a critical thinker in this case.


Your pedantic objection is a fail. RW's comments about McGraf's blog entry were straight forward.

The highlighted line is, I think, the key here--and it's not because RW is being hypocritical, as McGraw misconstrues and RW then calls out in her presentation at CFI.

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep. It's not just that he asked for sex out of the blue--which, as we've seen in this thread, some women find creepy while others do not. It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings. That's the part that's objectifying her. Guys, don't do that.

To me, I would expect that this would increase the creepiness factor, too. Even if you're not generally creeped out by being cold-propositioned for sex, would it change your attitude if the guy doing so were simultaneously demonstrating that he doesn't care what your feelings are--that he'll pursue you even after you've expressed that you don't want him to--in fact that he'll corner you in an enclosed space to do so?
 
Last edited:
Cool.

So, what evidence could be presented for men hitting on women in elevators that would make RW's discomfort anything more than a purely subjective matter?
I don't know. I suppose anything short of a large enough sampling of similarly situated EG-types and RW-types, complete with conversation transcript, and video of the non-verbal, would not be sufficient.
 
The highlighted line is, I think, the key here--and it's not because RW is being hypocritical, as McGraw misconstrues and RW then calls out in her presentation at CFI.

The critical difference between this situation and another generic, if equally inept, attempt to pick up a woman is that EG approached her after she'd already stated publicly that she was creeped out by such approaches and that she was at that moment only interested in going to sleep. It's not just that he asked for sex out of the blue--which, as we've seen in this thread, some women find creepy while others do not. It's that he did so despite her already making clear that she would not be receptive. He willfully disregarded her stated feelings. That's the part that's objectifying her. Guys, don't do that.

To me, I would expect that this would increase the creepiness factor, too. Even if you're not generally creeped out by being cold-propositioned for sex, would it change your attitude if the guy doing so were simultaneously demonstrating that he doesn't care what your feelings are--that he'll pursue you even after you've expressed that you don't want him to--in fact that he'll corner you in an enclosed space to do so?

He wanted sex?

He cornered her?

Ms. Watson made what clear?
 
Is there any combination of circumstances where the approach can be highlighted as the problem, rather than superficial or unchangeable factors?

I think this turns it around a bit, if it's all about already being attractive or already being interested, suddenly it doesn't matter how you go about it. I don't care too much for that implication.

Okay let's clear this one criterion then. Let's assume it WAS Brad Pitt. What do you think Rebecca's reaction would've been ?
 
Okay let's clear this one criterion then. Let's assume it WAS Brad Pitt. What do you think Rebecca's reaction would've been ?
I think a better question might be to assume it was a stranger who looked exactly like Brad Pitt.
 
I think a better question might be to assume it was a stranger who looked exactly like Brad Pitt.

What's the difference? Does Watson have an acquaintence with Pitt I'm not aware of? I missed that issue of People.
 
I think a better question might be to assume it was a stranger who looked exactly like Brad Pitt.

Why? How well does Ms. Watson know Brad Pitt?

That many people think they know famous people better than they actually do might be the reason EG propositioned Ms. Watson in the first place...
 
The story of a woman who pretended to be a man for 18 months:

If you have never been sexually attracted to women, you will never quite understand the monumental power of female sexuality, except by proxy or in theory, nor will you quite know the immense advantage it gives us over men. Dating women as a man was a lesson in female power, and it made me, of all things, into a momentary misogynist, which I suppose was the best indicator that my experiment had worked. I saw my own sex from the other side, and I disliked women irrationally for a while because of it. I disliked their superiority, their accusatory smiles, their entitlement to choose or dash me with a fingertip, an execution so lazy, so effortless, it made the defeats and even the successes unbearably humiliating. Typical male power feels by comparison like a blunt instrument, its salvos and field strategies laughably remedial next to the damage a woman can do with a single cutting word: no
.

Ouch. Amen, sister.
 
Any behaviour by a man directed at woman that the woman interprets as being sexually motivated, unwanted and offensive.
Pestering seems the wrong word, especially if a significant proportion of women respond positively to it. Pestering implies, to me at least, a certain persistence in the face of signals to contrary, which doesn't even seem to match the initial elevator incident; he asked once, and took no for an answer.

I don't know the success rate precisely, but it seems unlikely that it would be extremely low or zero if it is as significant as Ms. Watson wants us to believe it is.

The behaviour must be being reinforced or else it would become extinct.
Not necessarily; if it was the same people persisting in the behaviour, and that was because it was working, then yes, you may be right. However, there are many people who simply don't seem to learn from experience. It is also possible that the behaviour is exhibited by people who are still learning and don't yet know any better. The actual people exhibiting the behaviour may be constantly changing, but the prevalence of the behaviour may stay relatively constant.
 
I ask for a woman's number or email about once a week. I send several emails from dating sites ever week. I haven't had a girlfriend in four years, and not been on a date in two and a half. (If someone wants to do the math on that for how many rejections that equates too please put it in spoiler tags because frankly I don't want to know.)

So I shouldn't ask anyone any more obviously. :rolleyes:

If I were a teacher, I'd create a mathematical test question on that.
 
This whole thing has become a bit of a Rorschach Test among skeptics. At each point there is not really enough information to make an informed decision, yet we make a decision at that point and move on to the next with that decision in tow and try to make the next point conform to our building view of the situation.

We can get to some great detail even, breaking down the preamble of the request, the request, the word coffee, the amount of knowledge EG had before entering the elevator, the amount of preparation EG expended to end up on the same car with RW, the extent that EG stared at her breast rather than her eyes. It is all quite obvious if you are in one camp and out the door stupid if you are in another. but in the end it is built on sand, since the initial description was vague and lacking in details and later descriptions were imperfect memories that we know can be infected by emotions and every attempt to make a recall.

And yet, there is little disagreement on the creep factor. Randfan keeps reiterating so often that it is getting boring: Yes, she has the right to be creeped out by an admittedly in-artful approach.

So, what this boils down to is what you want to argue about. If you want to argue about whether EG was creepy you get to sling mud left and right about a guy who is smartly keeping out of the fray.

If you want to argue about what the dialogue should be in the skeptical movement regarding feminism, then you either agree with RW or you are a misogynist or parroting misogynist ideas.

And that is how far the skeptical community has come in 76 pages of discussing a girl in an elevator.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom