So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
My point was, should a man EVER ask another woman? However, to your point. I'm not sure how to respond without being rude. You are suggesting that since RW has a problem that all men and women should alter their behavior for her? That is frankly absurd and it's that kind of thinking that really bothers me about all of this. What logic brings you to the point that you would suggest that men and women be celibate for the sake of one woman?
The 21st century kind. ie the pretzel kind. Break out the mustard. :boggled:

Great reply overall, btw. Thanks for saving me the keystrokes.

I will admit to agreeing with CM about one thing kind of generally: why is this thread so immensely popular? Is it mainly the topic of men hitting on women or is it much more because she's a loud n proud atheist? Other? Honest question and again I admit I have not read most of the replies.
 
Last edited:
To my knowledge, nobody complained about being "asked out".
Disingenuous. It's a figure of speech.

You asked me if I considered a certain action reasonable; I answered that I thought it was. That's not "presuming to speak for everyone" - unless your question was loaded that way.
A simple "IMO" would be nice. It's still a fatuous notion but you are entitled to an opinion.

If somebody you (not everyone) know told you they were sexually abused as a child, and that "jokes" referencing sexual abuse and pedophilia, including the infamous "aristocrats" joke, make them very uncomfortable, would you so loudly insist upon your right to tell them in his presence, and that he should just get over it? Would you tell him how unreasonable it is to feel uncomfortable because of a joke, and needle him and those sympathetic to him about how you're supposed to know whether any particular person is receptive to your pedophilia jokes without telling them? Would you (not everyone) give him grief about how most sexual abuse victims you know don't have a problem with the jokes, or that you were also a victim and don't have a problem with them, therefore he should go stuff it?
Can you explain the relevance? I've said time and again I respect RW's opinion. I respect her right to voice here opinion. I respect her right to not want to be propositioned in an elevator and her right to recommend others not do that to her or anyone else. Is there anything you don't get about that?

Fine; but if you did, and someone told you they made him feel uncomfortable, would you (nobody else, just you) voluntarily stop telling them? I mean, it would never occur to me to ask a stranger for sex at any time in any situation, but in this discussion I'm asked to judge whether doing so would be reasonable or unreasonable.
(see above)


No, I don't "demand" anything. I've explained that I feel accommodating those peoples' feelings is a reasonable thing to do.
{sigh} How - do - we - know - who - they - are?

I personally don't see a problem with not asking strangers for sex out of the blue in any situation.
You are entitled to an opinion. You are entitled to share that opinion. I don't share it. Fair enough?

How is choosing not to spontaneously ask strangers for sex a "punishment"?
So long as you don't expect people to follow that prescription, it's not.


But it's not just one person.
You need to explain why that is relevant? More than one person disagrees.

There are other people in this thread, who are not "RW", who have nothing to do with "RW", who have indicated that strangers coming up to them presuming they'd be game for casual sex would make them uncomfortable. Are you sure you are not hung up on the idea that "the only one who ever complained was RW"?
They are entitled to their feelings. They are entitled to hope that they are never propositioned in such a way. They are even entitled to ask others to respect their wishes. They are unreasonable if they think everyone is going to voluntary stop asking strangers for casual sex. It's like thinking that parental wishes that their children abstain from sex will actually keep their children chaste.
 
I find it interesting that you think I missed a point, rather than just disagreed. Here's the "hypocritical" comment from Stef to which I was referring:

McGraf said:
Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?

Someone who truly abides by feminist principles would, in my view, have to react in the same manner were the situation reversed; if a woman were to engage a man in the same way, she would probably be creeping him out and making him uncomfortable and unfairly sexualizing him, right? But of course no one ever makes that claim, which is why I see Watson's comment as so hypocritical
How is this not also correctly identifying hypocrisy? McGraf is merely saying the same thing I referred to, RW is OK with sexual interests of women, and with women expressing their sexual interests and freely responding to expressions of interest from males. Then along comes someone who was no different, a male expressing sexual interest in a female, and in this case RW decides it is not OK.


I think I got the point. I doubt you're trying to say that selling skepchick calendars is equivalent to propositioning someone who is likely physically weaker, at 4am in an elevator, who has already indicated they would not be interested. I am genuinely struggling with what Stef finds hypocritical up to this point in the saga, without Stef herself having missed RW's point (as evidenced by the questions she posed as noted above).
Now you've gone well beyond the facts in evidence, and maybe that's why you don't see the hypocrisy.

The guy asked about coffee, for Pete's sake. He didn't say, "Let's go do it." You don't know what he heard or interpreted from RW's prior discussions. That's all assumptions on RW's part as was the "he only wanted sex" assumption. Maybe he wanted to eventually marry her. RW's assumptions are far from those of a critical thinker in this case.


So, you claimed that RW said "McGraf was misogynist because she didn't think EG's actions were such a big deal."

In fact, in the part you bolded, RW calls Stef's words "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" which, when "repeated verbatim by (Stef) online...validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another."

I think RW is overreacting here. I think RW is not 100% correct. But I think RW is not saying what you say she is saying. Pedantic point, perhaps, but worth noting, I think.

Clearly, but I'm getting there. Can you recommend the best place for me to find a complete chronological timeline of events, so I can read it like a book, and not like a research project?
Your pedantic objection is a fail. RW's comments about McGraf's blog entry were straight forward.
 
The 21st century kind. ie the pretzel kind. Break out the mustard. :boggled:

Great reply overall, btw. Thanks for saving me the keystrokes.

I will admit to agreeing with CM about one thing kind of generally: why is this thread so immensely popular? Is it mainly the topic of men hitting on women or is it much more because she's a loud n proud atheist? Other? Honest question and again I admit I have not read most of the replies.
It's a great question. On a couple of occasions I decided I was going to let it drop but here I am. :o Something visceral about it. I have my suspicions.
 
Well, I actually don't.

But on the other hand, I'm concerned about the over sensitivity that our society is developing towards certain topics, to the point that there are obvious, blatant double standards.
:eye-poppi :eek: :jaw-dropp

Wow somebody else gets it. I know you aren't the only one, but it feels like it sometimes. Thx for not just getting it but stating it.
 
Sure, but the new knowledge that may or may not shape the opinion is not necessarily so.

Well, how deep and philosophical do we want this to get? :)

One could argue that anything short of scientifically provable phenomena is subjective.

For instance we would agree that child sacrifice is evil, whereas an Aztec would argue that it is civic duty. What is your universal evidence that we are right?
 
<snip>

As to the other speculation on my perpetual singleness, I don't want to go off topic or make a this thread about me. I don't go after only women 'out of my league', and I don't believe I have a personality that women just don't want. I've noticed that people tend to want to rationalize someone who is having dating troubles into 'their fault/something wrong with them/terrible at picking' categories. Most all are post-hoc rationalizations and are of almost no predictive value.

To bring it back on topic I was wondering why there are men who pester women for sex at sceptical and atheist conferences when it is apparently has such a low probability of success. What prevents these men learning that women do not respond as they want them to to such behaviour?

One possibility is that a significant minority of women *do* respond to such behaviour in a positive (as far as the men doing the pestering are concerned) way. If so, then perhaps Ms. Watson should be chastising the women who encourage such behaviour rather than the men who engage in it?
 
:) Nothing wrong with that. Dawkins (or is it Watson?) help us if we are not allowed to disagree.

That's what's so insidious about Watson's behavior -- it's the common radical feminist tactic of shutting down dissent by labeling all dissenters as ignorant misogynists.
 
Well, how deep and philosophical do we want this to get? :)

One could argue that anything short of scientifically provable phenomena is subjective.

For instance we would agree that child sacrifice is evil, whereas an Aztec would argue that it is civic duty. What is your universal evidence that we are right?
I don't even know that I'm here typing this, so yeah, we can get deep. :)
 
RW has promoted the smart and sexy brand for female skeptics since day one.
I must have watched the wrong video then. The one I saw featured a dorky, dumpy, HS librarian looking kinda girl. Course beauty is in the eye of etc, but one should be able to walk the talk. :cool:

I honestly believe that Brad Pitt could make MANY women insanely happy by asking them for coffee in an elevator.
I'm sure "RW" would have declined in a self-righteous hissy though.

Right. :rolleyes:


So Rebecca Watson latches on to the slightly loony end of feminism as a vehicle to further her self-obsessed self-publicity thing.
PZ Myers again goes into his grovel-to-the-feminist-chicks mode, hoping it might get him a solidarity shag.
And Richard Dawkins reacts like a bit of a dick.

God knows why any of this raised a single eyebrow.
Boredom. :cool:

Yeah I forgot about the PZ Meyers dribblings. Almost entertaining it was so lame.


That's what's so insidious about Watson's behavior -- it's the common radical feminist tactic of shutting down dissent by labeling all dissenters as ignorant misogynists.
Why not? It works amazingly well. It's the gender equivalent of the race card, ie people who label someone racist if they disagree with a viewpoint favorable to minorities.
 
Disingenuous. It's a figure of speech.

Where I live, being 'asked out' means a date, not sex. However, if it also means sex then you have my answer already.

A simple "IMO" would be nice. It's still a fatuous notion but you are entitled to an opinion.

Nitpicking. It's my post; I would think 'IMO' should be a foregone conclusion if I wasn't citing numbers or data.

Can you explain the relevance?

Since you keep asking me if I think we should do something 'just because RW', I thought I would point out that it's not 'just because RW'; there's nothing special about her that is pertinent to anything I'm saying.

I've said time and again I respect RW's opinion. I respect her right to voice here opinion. I respect her right to not want to be propositioned in an elevator and her right to recommend others not do that to her or anyone else. Is there anything you don't get about that?

Yes: namely why, if all that's true, you have such a big problem with me making similar recommendations.

{sigh} How - do - we - know - who - they - are?

It would be helpful; but is it necessarily a 'burden' when we don't? How about just not trying to score one-nights at TAM with people you don't know? As I've pointed out before, it's Las Vegas; if you're hankering to race the submarine that badly, just walk out the door and see the gentleman with all those things that look like baseball cards.

You are entitled to an opinion. You are entitled to share that opinion. I don't share it. Fair enough?

Absolutely.

So long as you don't expect people to follow that prescription, it's not.

I don't think it necessarily would be even if I did.

You need to explain why that is relevant? More than one person disagrees.

Explained above. If you portray it as doing something adverse on account of 'just RW', it's worth pointing out that's inaccurate.

They are entitled to their feelings. They are entitled to hope that they are never propositioned in such a way. They are even entitled to ask others to respect their wishes. They are unreasonable if they think everyone is going to voluntary stop asking strangers for casual sex. It's like thinking that parental wishes that their children abstain from sex will actually keep their children chaste.

If that's why you think such a request is unreasonable, that's fine. My arguments are mostly directed towards people with other opinions about why it's unreasonable; like, for instance, that it's unfair 'because men are sexual beings' and such.
 
I don't even know that I'm here typing this, so yeah, we can get deep. :)

Cool.

So, what evidence could be presented for men hitting on women in elevators that would make RW's discomfort anything more than a purely subjective matter?
 
To bring it back on topic I was wondering why there are men who pester women for sex at sceptical and atheist conferences when it is apparently has such a low probability of success. What prevents these men learning that women do not respond as they want them to to such behaviour?

Wishful thinking, coupled with their own unwillingness to learn, I would wager.

One possibility is that a significant minority of women *do* respond to such behaviour in a positive (as far as the men doing the pestering are concerned) way. If so, then perhaps Ms. Watson should be chastising the women who encourage such behaviour rather than the men who engage in it?

I'm unaware of a single incidence in which said approach was successful, let alone a significant minority of times. It is possible, but there is no data.
 
To bring it back on topic I was wondering why there are men who pester women for sex at sceptical and atheist conferences when it is apparently has such a low probability of success. What prevents these men learning that women do not respond as they want them to to such behaviour?

One possibility is that a significant minority of women *do* respond to such behaviour in a positive (as far as the men doing the pestering are concerned) way. If so, then perhaps Ms. Watson should be chastising the women who encourage such behaviour rather than the men who engage in it?

I'm not sure what you mean by "pestering" in this context. Do you mean asking in any way at all, or asking in a way that is unwelcome to the recipient, or something else? And how do you know what their success rate is?
 
Yes: namely why, if all that's true, you have such a big problem with me making similar recommendations.
It's in the context of the discussion. If you simply said, "look, I think people should consider other people's feelings before they ask strangers to come to their hotel room for coffee (because let's be clear, that is what we are talking about) or "IMO, people shouldn't ask strangers to their room for coffee during a conference". It's odd, bizarre and isn't going to happen but I would respect it.

It would be helpful; but is it necessarily a 'burden' when we don't?
I've no idea how it isn't. If you accept the proposition that seduction and casual sex with strangers is part or our society then I don't understand it at all.

How about just not trying to score one-nights at TAM with people you don't know? As I've pointed out before, it's Las Vegas; if you're hankering to race the submarine that badly, just walk out the door and see the gentleman with all those things that look like baseball cards.
I've no idea why. What is your reason? You think women at a skeptics conference are special?

If that's why you think such a request is unreasonable, that's fine. My arguments are mostly directed towards people with other opinions about why it's unreasonable; like, for instance, that it's unfair 'because men are sexual beings' and such.
I'm not familiar with that argument but fine.

Thanks.
 
The 21st century kind. ie the pretzel kind. Break out the mustard. :boggled:

Great reply overall, btw. Thanks for saving me the keystrokes.

I will admit to agreeing with CM about one thing kind of generally: why is this thread so immensely popular? Is it mainly the topic of men hitting on women or is it much more because she's a loud n proud atheist? Other? Honest question and again I admit I have not read most of the replies.

Guessing, but...

Everyone here fancies themselves as clever, rational, enlightened and prejudice free (myself, obviously included).

When we enlightened, prejudiced free men are told that we aren't allowed to try to pick up women (yes, yes, yes, I'm grossly oversimplifying for brevity) because it's sexist, we panic.

We're an enlightened prejudice free intellectuals, We think We don't think that's sexism, is it???

So we think about it ourselves first, examine the issue and then, once we've come to our conclusion, be it that we change our minds or decide the proposition is a load of fetid dingo's kidneys, we rush to the internet to tell our intellectual brothers and sisters that we're okay, we're not sexist, we're still enlightened, and here's why...

And we find that not all of our brother's and sister's agree. Some think that our oh so rational point of view is total kidneys and we tell them so, safe and certain in the knowledge that, by pointing out one or two salient points that our enlightened (although, obviously not quite as enlightened as we) brothers and sisters have missed, their point of view will be suitably rectified and we can go about our day, occasionally glancing at a shapely pair of legs or a particularly obvious pair of breasts, safe in the knowledge that we're not sexist.

But it doesn't work like that. Our brothers and sisters with the dingos ideas have points that, while of course are of no note whatsoever, they believe to be salient to the issue. So we have to explain it to them again.

At that point, it's inevitable that someone will post 'I haven't read all the thread (The thread's 30 pages long by this point so who can blame them?), but I think...' and it all goes round again. And no-one can let it drop because, well, we're clever, enlightened, rational, prejudice free individuals, we can't possibly be sexist. Enlightened, rational, clever women don't sleep with sexist men, so we just can't let it lie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom