Well then, you now have clarification.
That makes no sense. Would you carry that logic to every situation? Men should never ask women out?
To my knowledge, nobody complained about being "asked out". A few have said that the specific situation of being propositioned by a stranger makes them uncomfortable. I have no trouble accommodating that if I'm in a place where I know they will be (TAM, for instance). IMO, extending that to mean pre-emptively accommodating every possible situation we can think of in like manner, regardless of likelihood or even plausibility, would be a slippery slope argument.
Your position is so ludicrous as to be laughable. Now YOU presume to speak for everyone.
You asked me if I considered a certain action reasonable; I answered that I thought it was. That's not "presuming to speak for everyone" - unless your question was loaded that way.
I don't like the jokes but I would never insist that these jokes can NEVER be told. And don't call straw man you just made that very argument.
Fair enough. Let me post it again, with a couple of changes:
If somebody
you (not everyone) know told you they were sexually abused as a child, and that "jokes" referencing sexual abuse and pedophilia, including the infamous "aristocrats" joke, make them very uncomfortable, would
you so loudly insist upon
your right to tell them in his presence, and that he should just get over it? Would
you tell him how unreasonable it is to feel uncomfortable because of a joke, and needle him and those sympathetic to him about how
you're supposed to know whether any particular person is receptive to
your pedophilia jokes without telling them? Would
you (not everyone) give him grief about how most sexual abuse victims
you know don't have a problem with the jokes, or that
you were also a victim and don't have a problem with them, therefore he should go stuff it?
Also, there is a difference between an analogy - even a bad analogy - and a straw man. For instance, you can tell me how the scenario I've given above is not analogous to the situation of certain people and being propositioned by strangers.
I don't like those jokes. I wouldn't tell other people that they can't tell the jokes.
Fine; but if you did, and someone told you they made him feel uncomfortable, would
you (nobody else, just you) voluntarily stop telling them? I mean, it would never occur to me to ask a stranger for sex at any time in any situation, but in this discussion I'm asked to judge whether doing so would be reasonable or unreasonable.
The difference between you and I is I don't demand that everyone conform to any single POV. You do. Yes you do. See above.
No, I don't "demand" anything. I've explained that I feel accommodating those peoples' feelings is a reasonable thing to do.
Why just elevators? Why not all situations? You are special pleading and you are inconsistent.
I personally don't see a problem with not asking strangers for sex out of the blue in any situation. But in this case, the reason "elevator" keeps being mentioned is because that was the content of the original complaint.
It's an asinine solution. It's unreasonable. It punishes everyone for the feelings of a few.
How is choosing not to spontaneously ask strangers for sex a "punishment"?
But why stop there? That's what I don't get. Why this special pleading? Why just this variable? It's arbitrary meant only to appear narrowly defined without reason other than one person didn't like to be propositioned in an elevator.
But it's not just one person.
There
are other people in this thread, who are not "RW", who have nothing to do with "RW", who have indicated that strangers coming up to them presuming they'd be game for casual sex would make them uncomfortable. Are you sure you are not hung up on the idea that "the only one who ever complained was RW"?
Look, if you said, "In my opinion people should consider other people's feelings and that they might be made uncomfortable. Please consider that before you make such a decision". I'd clap my hands for you. Hell, I'd stand up and cheer.
Right, because that's not being unspecific or hedging.