So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sexist, no, but showing poor judgment nonetheless, IMO.
Hah! If that's your opinion, you have lots of catching up to do. Because you agree with McGraf!

RW is convinced EG's actions were "sexual objectification" of her. That is a literal quote from the blog I cited above, not a paraphrased one.
 
Interesting rationalization.
No.

If you say so; good luck waiting for RW to come to this thread and answer these questions you're directing at her.
They're not.

Of course I do. Are you going to tell me I've been equivocal about that in this thread?
YES!
Over such a trivial thing? Why not? Since other women have also stated the same feelings, then certainly.
That makes no sense. Would you carry that logic to every situation? Men should never ask women out?

Your position is so ludicrous as to be laughable. Now YOU presume to speak for everyone.

If somebody you know told you they were sexually abused as a child, and that "jokes" referencing sexual abuse and pedophilia, including the infamous "aristocrats" joke, make them very uncomfortable, would you so loudly insist upon your right to tell them in his presence, and that he should just get over it?
Straw man.

I don't like the jokes but I would never insist that these jokes can NEVER be told. And don't call straw man you just made that very argument.

Or would you simply tell other jokes instead, and refrain from the pedophile jokes?
I don't like those jokes. I wouldn't tell other people that they can't tell the jokes.

These questions are for the whole thread, not just RandFan.
Not relevant to the discussion. I'm for the discussion. I'm for everyone voicing their opinion. You have me confused with someone else.

The difference between you and I is I don't demand that everyone conform to any single POV. You do. Yes you do. See above.

On this issue? Again, certainly. It takes actually less effort to not proposition strange women in elevators than it does to do so, so I'm not sure how simply saying "okay" places a burden on anyone, let alone an undue one.
Why just elevators? Why not all situations? You are special pleading and you are inconsistent.

I've already suggested a solution, and a very specific one at that: since we know that there are people at skeptic conferences who are uncomfortable with being propositioned by strangers out of the blue, save some energy and don't proposition strangers out of the blue. How is that "unspecific", how is that "hedging"?
Thank you for the specific. I'm not sure you've made it before. You deserve credit for being specific. I'm sorry I have to slap you on the hand.

It's an asinine solution. It's unreasonable. It punishes everyone for the feelings of a few. But why stop there? That's what I don't get. Why this special pleading? Why just this variable? It's arbitrary meant only to appear narrowly defined without reason other than one person didn't like to be propositioned in an elevator.

Look, if you said, "In my opinion people should consider other people's feelings and that they might be made uncomfortable. Please consider that before you make such a decision". I'd clap my hands for you. Hell, I'd stand up and cheer.
 
Last edited:
There are more options than that. For example, talk to a person while he's with friends, while witnesses are around, in a public, unconfined space, or have them approach you. And: use more topical pickup lines like coffee or etchings. ;)

Being approached by a woman seems rare, but it happens. (Attention, anecdote: the 2 women with whom I had lasting relationships approached me in a public space. I was the passive one.)
FTR: IMO, approaching a woman in an elevator is a poor choice. I said so at the beginning and I've never denied that it was my opinion. The difference is I don't declare that it is categorically wrong. There are just to many variables to make that statement. I honestly believe that Brad Pitt could make MANY women insanely happy by asking them for coffee in an elevator. So yeah, there are other options but all could be seen as creepy depending on the situation and the person making the proposition. We could say "ugly need not apply".

Otherwise I agree. :)
 
Not at all helpful, sometimes coffee is just coffee. But, hey, I'm open minded. Do you have something other than wild eyed speculation and assertions? Are you going to next tell us that your assertions are valid because you asserted them?

I'm pretty sure Thrasher was being sarcastic.
 
Is there any combination of circumstances where the approach can be highlighted as the problem, rather than superficial or unchangeable factors?

I think this turns it around a bit, if it's all about already being attractive or already being interested, suddenly it doesn't matter how you go about it. I don't care too much for that implication.
That's a straw man. You are equating a polite, "Want coffee in my room?", to whipping your dong out from under your trenchcoat.
 
That's a straw man. You are equating a polite, "Want coffee in my room?", to whipping your dong out from under your trenchcoat.

The comments I am responded to seemed to discount ANY considerations of circumstance or approach and chalked it all up to the attractiveness of the coffee-bearer or existing level of interest in the offeree.

I don't consider it a straw man since, as stated, I felt the opinion was overly broad, and by my question I was giving the person an opportunity to qualify the statement.

I don't think I am at odds with you here. You seem to accept that approach matters, but disagree that EG himself used a bad approach. That is not the opinion I am disputing--that's perfectly reasonable IMO.
 
Last edited:
So Rebecca Watson latches on to the slightly loony end of feminism as a vehicle to further her self-obsessed self-publicity thing.
PZ Myers again goes into his grovel-to-the-feminist-chicks mode, hoping it might get him a solidarity shag.
And Richard Dawkins reacts like a bit of a dick.

God knows why any of this raised a single eyebrow.
 
Last edited:
There are more options than that. For example, talk to a person while he's with friends, while witnesses are around, in a public, unconfined space, or have them approach you. And: use more topical pickup lines like coffee or etchings. ;)

Being approached by a woman seems rare, but it happens. (Attention, anecdote: the 2 women with whom I had lasting relationships approached me in a public space. I was the passive one.)


I've never approached a woman in an elevator, so I don't know why you choose my post to quote. Mine was addressing the line of reasoning that if one is aware their approach has a low possibility of success, one shouldn't try the attempt.

__________________________________________________________

As to the other speculation on my perpetual singleness, I don't want to go off topic or make a this thread about me. I don't go after only women 'out of my league', and I don't believe I have a personality that women just don't want. I've noticed that people tend to want to rationalize someone who is having dating troubles into 'their fault/something wrong with them/terrible at picking' categories. Most all are post-hoc rationalizations and are of almost no predictive value.
 


Well then, you now have clarification.

That makes no sense. Would you carry that logic to every situation? Men should never ask women out?


To my knowledge, nobody complained about being "asked out". A few have said that the specific situation of being propositioned by a stranger makes them uncomfortable. I have no trouble accommodating that if I'm in a place where I know they will be (TAM, for instance). IMO, extending that to mean pre-emptively accommodating every possible situation we can think of in like manner, regardless of likelihood or even plausibility, would be a slippery slope argument.

Your position is so ludicrous as to be laughable. Now YOU presume to speak for everyone.

You asked me if I considered a certain action reasonable; I answered that I thought it was. That's not "presuming to speak for everyone" - unless your question was loaded that way.



I don't like the jokes but I would never insist that these jokes can NEVER be told. And don't call straw man you just made that very argument.

Fair enough. Let me post it again, with a couple of changes:

If somebody you (not everyone) know told you they were sexually abused as a child, and that "jokes" referencing sexual abuse and pedophilia, including the infamous "aristocrats" joke, make them very uncomfortable, would you so loudly insist upon your right to tell them in his presence, and that he should just get over it? Would you tell him how unreasonable it is to feel uncomfortable because of a joke, and needle him and those sympathetic to him about how you're supposed to know whether any particular person is receptive to your pedophilia jokes without telling them? Would you (not everyone) give him grief about how most sexual abuse victims you know don't have a problem with the jokes, or that you were also a victim and don't have a problem with them, therefore he should go stuff it?

Also, there is a difference between an analogy - even a bad analogy - and a straw man. For instance, you can tell me how the scenario I've given above is not analogous to the situation of certain people and being propositioned by strangers.



I don't like those jokes. I wouldn't tell other people that they can't tell the jokes.

Fine; but if you did, and someone told you they made him feel uncomfortable, would you (nobody else, just you) voluntarily stop telling them? I mean, it would never occur to me to ask a stranger for sex at any time in any situation, but in this discussion I'm asked to judge whether doing so would be reasonable or unreasonable.

The difference between you and I is I don't demand that everyone conform to any single POV. You do. Yes you do. See above.

No, I don't "demand" anything. I've explained that I feel accommodating those peoples' feelings is a reasonable thing to do.

Why just elevators? Why not all situations? You are special pleading and you are inconsistent.

I personally don't see a problem with not asking strangers for sex out of the blue in any situation. But in this case, the reason "elevator" keeps being mentioned is because that was the content of the original complaint.

It's an asinine solution. It's unreasonable. It punishes everyone for the feelings of a few.

How is choosing not to spontaneously ask strangers for sex a "punishment"?

But why stop there? That's what I don't get. Why this special pleading? Why just this variable? It's arbitrary meant only to appear narrowly defined without reason other than one person didn't like to be propositioned in an elevator.

But it's not just one person.

There are other people in this thread, who are not "RW", who have nothing to do with "RW", who have indicated that strangers coming up to them presuming they'd be game for casual sex would make them uncomfortable. Are you sure you are not hung up on the idea that "the only one who ever complained was RW"?

Look, if you said, "In my opinion people should consider other people's feelings and that they might be made uncomfortable. Please consider that before you make such a decision". I'd clap my hands for you. Hell, I'd stand up and cheer.

Right, because that's not being unspecific or hedging.
 
So it was sexist of EG to hit on RW because the odds of success were predictably low?
Because the odds of creeping someone out were predictably high.

Mine was addressing the line of reasoning that if one is aware their approach has a low possibility of success, one shouldn't try the attempt.
The person who invented that was Skeptic Ginger, and she was not endorsing the idea but setting it up as a straw man, just to be knocked down as obviously ridiculous. There's no need to bother countering something that nobody's taking seriously in the first place.
 
The person who invented that was Skeptic Ginger, and she was not endorsing the idea but setting it up as a straw man, just to be knocked down as obviously ridiculous. There's no need to bother countering something that nobody's taking seriously in the first place.

I was well aware of why it was set up, but not that it's a straw man. That was your essentially your line of reasoning taken to it's logical end. The point is that chance of success alone is not what makes the elevator approach less than ideal.

But even assuming that it is a straw man, it's still a line of inquiry to address, just not one to attribute to an opponent. Clarification and all that.
 
Because the odds of creeping someone out were predictably high.

<snip>

That's the same reason I'd think twice before approaching a lost child in a shopping center.

I and other men have to alter our behaviour to calm the irrational fears other people have about our motives and reactions.

What a screwed up society we live in.
 
That's the same reason I'd think twice before approaching a lost child in a shopping center.

I and other men have to alter our behaviour to calm the irrational fears other people have about our motives and reactions.

What a screwed up society we live in.

This.

Whenever I take my child to the play area I make a big show of letting people see me interacting with what is obviously my own child. Because if you're a man sat at a playground mothers look at you like you're a lion at a petting zoo. I mean lots of women steal children, but they're seen as part of the herd.

Caution is good, I want my wife to be cautious, but we're at the point where you practically have to apologize to others for them having the wrong idea about you. "Sorry I made you think I was a child molester/rapist by the simple fact that I exist and am male. My fault."
 
RW confirmed later with her comments that she was speaking to all males re all females. You need to look beyond the video.
Thanks, I'll check up on it. Faced with new knowledge, I might have a slightly different take on this. (Is that ok, Jekyll's Guest? ;))

You missed the point. RW has promoted the smart and sexy brand for female skeptics since day one. There's the SkepChick calendars and the TAM SkepChick parties including one a couple years ago that was literally "bordello" themed.

McGraf had a legitimate comment about the hypocrisy.
I'll have to re-read. I admittedly came to this very late, and thus had to scramble here, there, and everywhere to "catch up." I very well could have missed material matters.

I find it interesting that you think I missed a point, rather than just disagreed. Here's the "hypocritical" comment from Stef to which I was referring:

Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?


Someone who truly abides by feminist principles would, in my view, have to react in the same manner were the situation reversed; if a woman were to engage a man in the same way, she would probably be creeping him out and making him uncomfortable and unfairly sexualizing him, right? But of course no one ever makes that claim, which is why I see Watson's comment as so hypocritical

I think I got the point. I doubt you're trying to say that selling skepchick calendars is equivalent to propositioning someone who is likely physically weaker, at 4am in an elevator, who has already indicated they would not be interested. I am genuinely struggling with what Stef finds hypocritical up to this point in the saga, without Stef herself having missed RW's point (as evidenced by the questions she posed as noted above).
Nope, that is not the comment I am talking about.

This one is:(emphasis mine, so you don't miss a key part of the quote)
What would have been especially helpful is to include what "the above" was of which RW spoke, but I found it, and will reproduce it here:

My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”

So, you claimed that RW said "McGraf was misogynist because she didn't think EG's actions were such a big deal."

In fact, in the part you bolded, RW calls Stef's words "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" which, when "repeated verbatim by (Stef) online...validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another."

I think RW is overreacting here. I think RW is not 100% correct. But I think RW is not saying what you say she is saying. Pedantic point, perhaps, but worth noting, I think.

You have catching up to do.
Clearly, but I'm getting there. Can you recommend the best place for me to find a complete chronological timeline of events, so I can read it like a book, and not like a research project?
 
Exactly which is precisely why I'm not having one.
I know. I was agreeing with you. :)

It was then making dumb claims like Dawkins said what he did because of white male privilege and engage in other fallacies that blew it all up. She saved her hissy fit for later.
Glad I missed that part. What a flaming (insert nasty word here which I can't say because the mods will have a fit) :cool:
 
Hah! If that's your opinion, you have lots of catching up to do. Because you agree with McGraf!

RW is convinced EG's actions were "sexual objectification" of her. That is a literal quote from the blog I cited above, not a paraphrased one.
I think it's clear that I agree and disagree with Stef and RW on various points.
 
Because the odds of creeping someone out were predictably high.
Your opinion is not universally shared. Now what?


The person who invented [the line of reasoning that if one is aware their approach has a low possibility of success, one shouldn't try the attempt.] was Skeptic Ginger, and she was not endorsing the idea but setting it up as a straw man, just to be knocked down as obviously ridiculous. There's no need to bother countering something that nobody's taking seriously in the first place.
I invented? Hardly! I wasn't even first to suggest the logical conclusion of your advice here in the thread, and you weren't the first to make such an impractical suggestion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom