So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
They also miss the point: it's not the generic awkwardness of the shared silence/muzak most of us may feel — it's that especially creepy situation that emerges from a socially inept man (which I myself pretty much am) hitting on a woman in a confined space.

Who gives a **? Judging from the comments all over, many give a **.

Well, I actually don't.

But on the other hand, I'm concerned about the over sensitivity that our society is developing towards certain topics, to the point that there are obvious, blatant double standards. And that's actually the point.

Like TAA says, if the situation were reversed, or man and man, or woman and woman, it wouldn't be an issue to anyone.

So:

1. If this incident is an example to illustrate gender discrimination towards women, it's wrong.
2. If it's about treating women with special care, putting their comfort before one's own, then the problem is not about gender discrimination, like has been claimed, and there is also the additional problem that many men and women strongly disagree with this viewpoint.
3. If it's, like you say, about a socially inept man, well - excuse my tautology - then it's about a socially inept man. Socially inept people are more likely to create social awkward moments, and that's something that happens in any social context, not just when people flirt. If hitting on someone isn't sexist in itself (and it's not because that would make procreation sexist) a clumsy attempt is just that: a clumsy attempt, and nothing else.

I'm under the impression that you're advocating for 2. That's a legitimate position, of course, but it's not what we've been discussing here, nor was what AAT was addressing. And I and many other people (men and women) disagree.

Gender equality, for example, is caring about men's and women's comfort equally.
 
Being skeptics here and all that. Are we actually sure there IS an Elevator Guy? Surely by now he's be coming out and saying "no, this is how it REALLY went ..."

:duck:
 
I don't think this is about Watson anymore.
As long as you reference RW or respond to people discussing RW then it is.

No, it is exactly the right question. There's not a single person in this thread who has indicated they think Watson speaks for all women in anything she says; therefore, your two "right questions" are directed at ghosts and can lead to no discussion at all.
Had RW said, IMO, I would agree. She didn't. There are women (and men) who disagree. So, the only questions are those.

Who says we can't? While you're talking about arguing against what people are "really saying rather than what you think they are saying", why don't you tell me who exactly in this thread seems to have a problem taking these women at face value? That's a manufactured controversy.
Do you take them at face value?

This is very clearly about more than simply Watson claiming to speak for all women.
Clearly. It's about RW's fallacies, particular her ad hominem (white male privelage). It's about her refusal to acknowledge that there are reasoned positions different than hers. It's about her "you just don't get it" rhetoric. Her putting all people who disagree with her in a single group and telling them to get a blow up doll.

No, it wasn't enough simply to objectively verify that other women don't feel represented by Watson; we've also got to attack the "reasonableness" of her initial complaint in and of itself - discomfort at being propositioned for sex by a stranger.
RW was reasonable to express her discomfort. It reasonable that every one alter their behavior because she experienced discomfort?

Everything must be done to ridicule this notion
No. That's all in your head.

Lest a few women also come forward and admit discomfort
I don't need anymore women to admit discomfort. I'd gladly concede the point. Irrelevant.

...thereby shifting the discussion from "just because RW feels that way"? Bookitty indicated she would have felt similar to Watson about such a scenario, and pointedly did not claim to speak for all women; her submissions to the discussion were either ignored or declared irrelevant on account of being "unreasonable".
You are missing the point. Answer this question, what are men to do? Only follow RW's admonition or consider her advisement and discuss the issues without simply assuming that RW speaks for all women?

What is it with this terminal need to discredit discomfort with casual sex (and, by extension, requests for it)? Why do we have to portray a request that we recognize and respect that discomfort in some people as an assault on our rights?
I've said over and over that I respect RW's feelings and opinions. That's a straw man.

It's a psychological preference.
Yes, and? You are not providing any solutions. THIS IS THE PROBLEM. What are we to do? You WON'T answer. Do men never ask? Why can't you be specific? Why all the hedging? Is it okay for men to ask women in an elevator or not?
 
Last edited:
So it was sexist of EG to hit on RW because the odds of success were predictably low?

I ask for a woman's number or email about once a week. I send several emails from dating sites ever week. I haven't had a girlfriend in four years, and not been on a date in two and a half. (If someone wants to do the math on that for how many rejections that equates too please put it in spoiler tags because frankly I don't want to know.)

So I shouldn't ask anyone any more obviously. :rolleyes:
 
Thanks, I value your opinion. Question, if anyone disagrees are they wrong?
Thanks RandFan, and let me see I'm very glad to see you back.

I'm not sure I understand the question. If they disagree with my take, are they wrong? Is that what you're asking?

If so, yeah, I think they're perception is off, but I'm willing to disagree reasonably, and even have my mind changed if someone points out something I'm missing.
 
If so, yeah, I think they're perception is off, but I'm willing to disagree reasonably, and even have my mind changed if someone points out something I'm missing.

How exactly is someone supposed to argue against something that is 100% personal perception?

You're saying you see the world a certain way, if someone sees it another way they are wrong, but all they need to do is convince you otherwise?
 
This is very clearly about more than simply Watson claiming to speak for all women. If that were the only matter being discussed here, all it would've taken is for one woman here to say "she doesn't speak for me". Currently many have done so; so that issue is settled - she doesn't, and further nobody here is disputing that. But more keeps happening, doesn't it?

Yes, because Watson herself has made it clear that those women -- the women who have made it clear they disagree with her -- are ignorant of feminism and parroting misogynist thought.

The issue blew up because Watson insists on attacking anyone who doesn't agree with her assessment. The issue persists because Watson refuses to back down from her untenable position.
 
I ask for a woman's number or email about once a week. I send several emails from dating sites ever week. I haven't had a girlfriend in four years, and not been on a date in two and a half. (If someone wants to do the math on that for how many rejections that equates too please put it in spoiler tags because frankly I don't want to know.)

So I shouldn't ask anyone any more obviously. :rolleyes:

A bit OT, but why do you continue?

Having conducted such an extensive sample of women you're attracted to and been rejected, how do you remain motivated to keep sending emails that are ignored and going on dates that come to nothing?

Do you ever suspect you have a personality that women tend to find unattractive in a potential partner?
 
Last edited:
Do you ever suspect you have a personality that women tend to find unattractive in a potential partner?

A less depressing possibility is that he simply concentrates on women that are not a good match for him/are not attracted to his type/are 'out of his league'.

Just saying, it might be a situation where standards should be relaxed or reexamined, rather than a need to just settle for being a hermit.
 
Thanks RandFan, and let me see I'm very glad to see you back.

I'm not sure I understand the question. If they disagree with my take, are they wrong? Is that what you're asking?

If so, yeah, I think they're perception is off, but I'm willing to disagree reasonably, and even have my mind changed if someone points out something I'm missing.
Cool, thanks. :)
 
Please comment on RW failing to say, "Guys, don't do that to me", indicating she felt the need to speak for all women.
I'll let you know after I've had achance to watch it again. I watched it while the kids were playing and the TV was on (yeah, great dad, I know). But I recall it not as speaking for all women, but rather simply her take on what happened to her.

And do tell us specifically how McGraf "overreacted".
By calling her hypocritical after, what I believe, was a misdiagnosis of the situation. (If I did what that guy did under all of the same circumstances, I would absolutely expect Rebecca or anyone else to be nervous and find me "creepy.")

And what about RW saying McGraf was misogynist because she didn't think EG's actions were such a big deal?
Where did she do that? Are you referring to this bit from here?:

Then, switching gears, Watson made a remark to the extent that there are people in our own community who would not stand up for her in these sorts of situations; my name, organization, and a few sentences from my blog post then flashed on the screen before my eyes. She went on to explain how I didn’t understand what objectification meant and was espousing anti-woman sentiment.
I think the last clause is a bit harsh, and an overreaction.

That's sort of my take on a large portion of this 74-page thread: lots of overreaction. But then, maybe I'm underreacting?
 
Last edited:
As long as you reference RW or respond to people discussing RW then it is.

Interesting rationalization.

Had RW said, IMO, I would agree. She didn't. There are women (and men) who disagree. So, the only questions are those.

If you say so; good luck waiting for RW to come to this thread and answer these questions you're directing at her.

Do you take them at face value?

Of course I do. Are you going to tell me I've been equivocal about that in this thread?

Clearly. It's about RW's fallacies, particular her ad hominem (white male privelage). It's about her refusal to acknowledge that there are reasoned positions different than hers. It's about her "you just don't get it" rhetoric. Her putting all people who disagree with her in a single group and telling them to get a blow up doll.

There has been much space in this thread devoted to whether feeling uncomfortable about being propositioned for sex by a stranger is reasonable, independent of who reports the feeling. Maybe you didn't participate in those arguments, but they were there.

RW was reasonable to express her discomfort. It reasonable that every one alter their behavior because she experienced discomfort?

Over such a trivial thing? Why not? Since other women have also stated the same feelings, then certainly.

If somebody you know told you they were sexually abused as a child, and that "jokes" referencing sexual abuse and pedophilia, including the infamous "aristocrats" joke, make them very uncomfortable, would you so loudly insist upon your right to tell them in his presence, and that he should just get over it? Would you tell him how unreasonable it is to feel uncomfortable because of a joke, and needle him and those sympathetic to him about how you're supposed to know whether any particular person is receptive to your pedophilia jokes without telling them? Would you give him grief about how most sexual abuse victims you know don't have a problem with the jokes, or that you were also a victim and don't have a problem with them, therefore he should go stuff it?

Or would you simply tell other jokes instead, and refrain from the pedophile jokes?

These questions are for the whole thread, not just RandFan.



You are missing the point. Answer this question, what are men to do? Only follow RW's admonition or consider her advisement and discuss the issues without simply assuming that RW speaks for all women?

On this issue? Again, certainly. It takes actually less effort to not proposition strange women in elevators than it does to do so, so I'm not sure how simply saying "okay" places a burden on anyone, let alone an undue one.

No. That's all in your head.

I don't need anymore women to admit discomfort. I'd gladly concede the point. Irrelevant.

I've said over and over that I respect RW's feelings and opinions. That's a straw man.

This thread went on for dozens of pages before you got here. You can't call my characterization of things that have happened in the course of the thread a "straw man" just because they don't apply to your posts specifically.

Yes, and? You are not providing any solutions. THIS IS THE PROBLEM. What are we to do? You WON'T answer. Do men never ask? Why can't you be specific? Why all the hedging? Is it okay for men to ask women in an elevator or not?

No, no - we've got to get all our ships sailing in the same direction first. Not everyone is willing to believe "this is the problem" in this thread. If you're going to concede, then concede - or if you're going to agree with my point, then agree with my point. Don't frame your concession as an argument against me. I've already suggested a solution, and a very specific one at that: since we know that there are people at skeptic conferences who are uncomfortable with being propositioned by strangers out of the blue, save some energy and don't proposition strangers out of the blue. How is that "unspecific", how is that "hedging"?
 
What are we to do? [...] Is it okay for men to ask women in an elevator or not?

So I shouldn't ask anyone any more obviously. :rolleyes:

There are more options than that. For example, talk to a person while he's with friends, while witnesses are around, in a public, unconfined space, or have them approach you. And: use more topical pickup lines like coffee or etchings. ;)

Being approached by a woman seems rare, but it happens. (Attention, anecdote: the 2 women with whom I had lasting relationships approached me in a public space. I was the passive one.)
 
How exactly is someone supposed to argue against something that is 100% personal perception?
By pointing out things I may not have thought of, or things I may have missed in all that I have read and viewed (which would mean it is not necessarily100% personal perception).

You're saying you see the world a certain way, if someone sees it another way they are perceived to be wrong, but all they need to do is convince you otherwise?
Yep. That's "all," with one minor italicized addendum. Tell me how this is inconsistent with skepticism.
 
Tell me how this is inconsistent with skepticism.

I believe that you are forming your opinion based on arbitrary points that are so open to personal preference as to make them unacceptable as evidence.

'Sprouts taste bad" is not a skeptical statement, whereas "I have gathered that sprouts taste bad to some" is.
 
I'll let you know after I've had achance to watch it again. I watched it while the kids were playing and the TV was on (yeah, great dad, I know). But I recall it not as speaking for all women, but rather simply her take on what happened to her.
RW confirmed later with her comments that she was speaking to all males re all females. You need to look beyond the video.

By calling her hypocritical after, what I believe, was a misdiagnosis of the situation. (If I did what that guy did under all of the same circumstances, I would absolutely expect Rebecca or anyone else to be nervous and find me "creepy.")
You missed the point. RW has promoted the smart and sexy brand for female skeptics since day one. There's the SkepChick calendars and the TAM SkepChick parties including one a couple years ago that was literally "bordello" themed.

McGraf had a legitimate comment about the hypocrisy.

Where did she do that? Are you referring to this bit from here?:

I think the last clause is a bit harsh, and an overreaction.

That's sort of my take on a large protion of this 74-page thread: lots of overreaction. But then, maybe I'm underreacting?
Nope, that is not the comment I am talking about.

This one is:
But those are unimportant details in comparison to the first quoted sentence [of McGraf's in her initial blog reply to the RW video], which demonstrates an ignorance of Feminism 101 – in this case, the difference between sexual attraction and sexual objectification. The former is great – be attracted to people! Flirt, have fun, make friends, have sex, meet the love of your life, whatever floats your boat. But the latter involves dismissing a person’s feelings, desires, and identity, with a complete disinterest in how one’s actions will affect the “object” in question. That’s what we shouldn’t be doing. No, we feminists are not outlawing sexuality.

I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another. It also negatively affects the women who are nervous about being in similar situations. Some of them have been raped or otherwise sexually assaulted, and some just don’t want to be put in that position. And they read these posts and watch these videos and they think, “If something were to happen to me and these women won’t stand up for me, who will?”
(emphasis mine, so you don't miss a key part of the quote)

You have catching up to do.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom