So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, this whole incident does give a man and woman alone on an elevator something to talk about to break the ice...

"How would you feel if I was to ask to you now "Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more. Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?"?"

:)
 
Actually, this whole incident does give a man and woman alone on an elevator something to talk about to break the ice...

"How would you feel if I was to ask to you now "Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more. Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?"?"

:)

If anyone takes your advice I fear you may have started an infinite recursion.
 
They also miss the point: it's not the generic awkwardness of the shared silence/muzak most of us may feel — it's that especially creepy situation that emerges from a socially inept man (which I myself pretty much am) hitting on a woman in a confined space.
Isn't it creepy regardless of the confined space? It's not the first time it's been said but creepiness has nothing to do with elevators but social dynamics and the looks and personality of the guy. No one is likely to complain if Brad Pit asks them out to coffee. The place of the proposal doesn't even figure into it. And I'm not sure but I don't think you addressed TAA's point about what our view point would be if some guy had talking about how creeped out he had been because another guy asked him to coffee (the space is irrelevant). Not many of us would have been on his side. Homophobic would be the word to describe this guys feelings.

RW IS entitled to her feelings. She is entitled to offer an opinion. However, she doesn't speak for all women and many women have said they don't find it creepy. BionicDance, a lesbian, said she wouldn't find it creepy. So why does RW's opinion supersede all others?

It's the discussion I find important.
 
Allow me to translate:

What he said: "Do not take this the wrong way"
What he meant: "I have a long history of sexual assault"

What he said: "but I find you very interesting"
What he meant: "I have been following you around since before the conference started"

What he said: "and I would like to talk more."
What he meant: "You want it, and I'll give it to you."

What he said: "Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?"
What he meant: "If you consent to come to my room, the cops won't press charges."
Not at all helpful, sometimes coffee is just coffee. But, hey, I'm open minded. Do you have something other than wild eyed speculation and assertions? Are you going to next tell us that your assertions are valid because you asserted them?
 
...»bar/elevator/4am hotel room invitation« context the offering of coffee — for all practical purposes the grandaddy of codes for sex.
No, that would be "want to come up and see my etchings".

Rule of thumb: if your action has a chance to make your person of interest uncomfortable, don't act. Wait until a better moment arrives.
We've dealt with this. I'm not being flippant here. That means never asking. Most men will always have a chance to make a person of interest uncomfortable anytime, anyplace. Hell, I've been uncomfortable when a woman was interested in me and I wasn't interested in her.
 
We've dealt with this. I'm not being flippant here. That means never asking. Most men will always have a chance to make a person of interest uncomfortable anytime, anyplace. Hell, I've been uncomfortable when a woman was interested in me and I wasn't interested in her.

That's the real crux of the issue here. He was interested in her, she wasn't interested in him. That's the source of her discomfort.
 
I don't think it means men should never approach women. I think it means if you're not physically attractive, famous and/or rich you shouldn't approach women.

IIRC, Ms. Watson's advice for single men who do not consider EG's behaviour to be beyond the pale (i.e. men in her "abnormal" category) is to settle for masturbating with a blow up doll or sex toy.
 
Not at all helpful, sometimes coffee is just coffee. But, hey, I'm open minded. Do you have something other than wild eyed speculation and assertions?
How about rampant paranoia and severe insecurity? As I suspect is the case with anyone having a massive hissy about this whole thing?


In fact from what I gathered from the video, the girl herself didn't think it was some horrible, life-scarring event; it made her uncomfortable and she just thought it was inappropriate and stupid, which IMO clearly it was. But that's ALL it was. A guy (clumsily) hit on a woman. She declined. The end.

Or it should be. But it seems the growing hypersensitivities of our loony society aren't about to abate any time soon.
 
Or it should be. But it seems the growing hypersensitivities of our loony society aren't about to abate any time soon.

It's been said many times before about this age; it's fashionable to be the insulted victim.
 
That's the real crux of the issue here. He was interested in her, she wasn't interested in him. That's the source of her discomfort.

Is there any combination of circumstances where the approach can be highlighted as the problem, rather than superficial or unchangeable factors?

I think this turns it around a bit, if it's all about already being attractive or already being interested, suddenly it doesn't matter how you go about it. I don't care too much for that implication.
 
Well we live in a world where you work in a cubicle, travel home in a single passenger enclosed box, probably live in a box where you only know neighbors by maybe a polite nod, and do a lot of socializing online where you can choose to only mix with specially selected friends who share the same interests as you do.

We're isolated from social discomfort, and people we may find objectionable, to a degree unheard of in the past.
 
How about rampant paranoia and severe insecurity? As I suspect is the case with anyone having a massive hissy about this whole thing?
Exactly which is precisely why I'm not having one. I don't have a side. I don't claim that RW was wrong to think the guy creepy. I don't claim that she's not entitled to her opinion. I don't claim it was wrong to offer advise to other people (I'm not really sure who does actually).

In fact from what I gathered from the video, the girl herself didn't think it was some horrible, life-scarring event; it made her uncomfortable and she just thought it was inappropriate and stupid, which IMO clearly it was. But that's ALL it was. A guy (clumsily) hit on a woman. She declined. The end.
Which I've said, over and over and over (as has many other people have) other than to presume to speak for anyone else she DID NOTHING WRONG. Had she, like you, said "IMO". That would have been the end of it. It was then making dumb claims like Dawkins said what he did because of white male privilege and engage in other fallacies that blew it all up. She saved her hissy fit for later.

Or it should be. But it seems the growing hypersensitivities of our loony society aren't about to abate any time soon.
Yeah, but we do the best we can.
 
Last edited:
The story of a woman who pretended to be a man for 18 months:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/mar/18/gender.bookextracts

Here's how she found asking out women and dating them as a man:

...

I thought dating was going to be the fun part, the easiest part. Certainly as a man I had romantic access to far more women than I ever did as a lesbian. I could partake at last in the assumption of heterosexuality and ask out any woman I liked without insulting her. Of course, I was in for a mountain of rejections, but to be a guy I had to get out there.

I figured it couldn't hurt to enlist a compatriot for support, so I asked a friend, Curtis, to be my backup. He was perfect for the job. He was a handsome, well-built, gregarious type, secure and sensible enough not to take himself too seriously, or care much what a stranger might think of him.

Curtis had said he would nudge me when I got out of line and he spent most of our first night out together kicking me under the table. I was on a roll, eager to test my new treads. So as soon as we sat down, I picked out a couple of twentysomething women sitting at a table across the room. I gave them a few lingering looks to check their interest. I caught one woman's eye and held her gaze for a second, smiling. She returned the smile and looked away. This was signal enough for me, so I stood up, made my way over to their table and asked them whether they wanted to join us for a drink.

"No, thanks," one of them said, "we're on our way out in a minute."

Simple enough, right? A brush-off. No biggie. But as I turned away and slumped back across the room toward our table, I felt like the outcast kid in the lunchroom who trips and dumps his tray on the linoleum in front of the whole school.

"Rejection is a staple for guys," said Curtis, laughing as I crumpled into my seat with a humiliated sigh. "Get used to it."

"How do you handle it?"

"Let me tell you a story," he said. "When I was in college, there was this guy Dean, who got laid all the time. I mean this guy had different women coming out of his room every weekend and most week-nights, and he wasn't particularly good-looking. He was fat and kind of a slob. Nice guy, though, but nothing special. I couldn't figure out how he did it, so one time I just asked him. 'How do you get so many girls to go out with you?' He was a man of few words, kind of Coolidge-esque, if you know what I mean. So all he said was: 'I get rejected 90% of the time. But it's that 10%.' "

That made us both cackle and pound the table. "That's the thing about being a guy," Curtis finished. "Rejection is part of the game. It's expected."

Not only was dating one of the hardest of Ned's experiences, it was also the most fraught with deception. I decided I would out myself to anyone with whom I had more than a passing, unsuccessful, date or two. To most of the women I dated, even the odd date meant a lot, especially women who had been out roaming the singles scene for years in their mid-30s, trying to find a mate amid the serial daters.

For these women, men as a subspecies - not the particular men with whom they had been involved - were to blame for the wreck of a relationship and the psychic damage it had done them. It's hardly surprising, then, that in this atmosphere, as a single man dating women, I often felt attacked, judged, on the defensive.

Many of my dates - even the more passive ones - did most of the talking. I listened to them talk literally for hours about the most minute, mind-numbing details of their personal lives; men they were still in love with, men they had divorced, roommates and co-workers they hated, childhoods they were loath to remember yet somehow found the energy to recount ad nauseam. Listening to them was like undergoing a slow frontal lobotomy.

Weren't people supposed to be on their best behaviour on first dates? Weren't they supposed to at least pretend an interest in the other person, out of politeness if nothing else?

Certainly that's what I was doing, making polite conversation. So much so that I never expected to hear from these people again. I was boring myself. But to my surprise, many of them did contact me again - enthusiastically.

Ironically, one of the women who was the least well-adjusted, and the least graceful at dating, turned out to be one of the most important of my relationships. I had met Sasha, as I met most of my dates, through a personals website on the internet. We'd exchanged photographs and a number of emails. After a week or so of back and forth, we'd decided to get together for coffee.

That first date was lousy but the email relationship continued. Indeed, email is now central to dating. Correspondence was mandatory, even with the women I met at speed-dating events and followed up with later by email. These women wanted to be wooed by language. They weren't going to meet a strange man without measuring him first, and they weren't going to waste a meal or even a cup of coffee on a suitor who couldn't be bothered to craft a few lines beforehand. I was happy to oblige. It was rare, most of them told me, for a man to write at such length, much less to write with consideration and investment.

For a little contrast, I went on a few dates with men as a woman during the course of my time as Ned. The men I met on the internet, and then subsequently in person, didn't require this epistolary preamble, nor did they offer it. They were eager to meet as soon as possible, usually, I found, because they wanted to see what I looked like. Their feelings or fantasies would be based on that far more than, or perhaps to the exclusion of, anything I might write to them. On dates with men I felt physically appraised in a way that I never did by women, and, while this made me more sympathetic to the suspicions women were bringing to their dates with Ned, it had the opposite effect, too. Somehow men's seeming imposition of a superficial standard of beauty felt less intrusive, less harsh, than the character appraisals of women.

The women I met wanted a man to be confident. They wanted in many ways to defer to him. I could feel that on many dates, the unspoken desire to be held up and led, whether in conversation or even in physical space, and at times it made me feel quite small in my costume, like a young man must feel when he's just coming of age and he's suddenly expected to carry the world under his arm like a football. And some women did find Ned too small physically to be attractive. They wanted someone, they said, who could pin them to the bed or, as one woman put it, "someone who can drive the bus". Ned was too willowy for that. I began to understand from the inside why Robert Crumb draws his women so big and his diminutive self begging at their heels or riding them around the room.

Yet as much as these women wanted a take-control man, at the same time they wanted a man who was vulnerable to them, a man who would show his colours and open his doors, someone expressive, intuitive, attuned. This I was in spades, and I always got points for it. But I began to feel very sympathetic toward heterosexual men - the pressure to be a world-bestriding colossus is an immensely heavy burden to bear, and trying to be a sensitive new age guy at the same time is pretty well impossible. Expectation, expectation, expectation was the leitmotif of Ned's dating life....

If you have never been sexually attracted to women, you will never quite understand the monumental power of female sexuality, except by proxy or in theory, nor will you quite know the immense advantage it gives us over men. Dating women as a man was a lesson in female power, and it made me, of all things, into a momentary misogynist, which I suppose was the best indicator that my experiment had worked. I saw my own sex from the other side, and I disliked women irrationally for a while because of it. I disliked their superiority, their accusatory smiles, their entitlement to choose or dash me with a fingertip, an execution so lazy, so effortless, it made the defeats and even the successes unbearably humiliating. Typical male power feels by comparison like a blunt instrument, its salvos and field strategies laughably remedial next to the damage a woman can do with a single cutting word: no.

Sex is most powerful in the mind, and to men, in the mind, women have a lot of power, not only to arouse, but to give worth, self-worth, meaning, initiation, sustenance, everything. Seeing this more clearly through my experience, I began to wonder whether the most extreme men resort to violence with women because they think that's all they have, their one pathetic advantage over all she seems to hold above them. I make no excuses for this. There are none. But as a man I felt vaguely attuned to this mind-set or its possibility. I did not inhabit it, but I thought I saw how rejection might get twisted beyond recognition in the mind of a discarded male where misogyny and ultimately rape may be a vicious attempt to take what cannot be taken because it has not been bestowed.

...
 
We've dealt with this. I'm not being flippant here. That means never asking.

So don't ask. Why it's imperative that we as men need assurance of some kind of inalienable right to ask strange women for sex during a three-day skeptic conference puzzles me. It's as if the fact that some women aren't up for it and don't feel bad saying so ahead of time is some kind of personal attack on our "manliness" or something.

Are we all confident in the knowledge that, whatever she says, Watson doesn't speak for all women? If so, then why the heck are we still discussing this? In some peoples' cases, it seems like purely the notion itself that any woman would be uncomfortable with sexual advances is an unacceptable insult.
 
Last edited:
So don't ask.
My point was, should a man EVER ask another woman? However, to your point. I'm not sure how to respond without being rude. You are suggesting that since RW has a problem that all men and women should alter their behavior for her? That is frankly absurd and it's that kind of thinking that really bothers me about all of this. What logic brings you to the point that you would suggest that men and women be celibate for the sake of one woman?

Why it's imperative that we as men need assurance of some kind of inalienable right to ask strange women for sex during a three-day skeptic conference puzzles me.
Me too. Perhaps because it's a giant straw man.

It's as if the fact that some women aren't up for it and don't feel bad saying so ahead of time is some kind of personal attack on our "manliness" or something.
Can you show me where I or anyone else suggested otherwise? I'm not sure where you are getting this. You need to focus on what is being said and not what you think people are saying.
Are we all confident in the knowledge that, whatever she says, Watson doesn't speak for all women?
Wrong question. The right question is, well there are two, A.) Are we so confident in the knowledge that anything she says speaks for all women? More importantly, B.) does she think she speaks for all women? To date I can confidently say that she think she does.

Since many, many women have come forward and have said she doesn't then we can be confident that she doesn't. Why is it that we can't take these women at face value?

If so, then why the heck are we still discussing this?
You need not click on this thread. There is another world out there and many other topics to discuss.
 
Last edited:
So don't ask. Why it's imperative that we as men need assurance of some kind of inalienable right to ask strange women for sex during a three-day skeptic conference puzzles me. It's as if the fact that some women aren't up for it and don't feel bad saying so ahead of time is some kind of personal attack on our "manliness" or something.

So don't complain. Why it's imperative that we as women need assurance of some kind of inalienable right to not be propositioned for sex by strange men during a three-day skeptic conference puzzles me. It's as if the fact that some women are up for it, and don't feel bad about it is some kind of personal attack on our "femaleness" or something.
 
So don't ask. Why it's imperative that we as men need assurance of some kind of inalienable right to ask strange women for sex during a three-day skeptic conference puzzles me. It's as if the fact that some women aren't up for it and don't feel bad saying so ahead of time is some kind of personal attack on our "manliness" or something.

Are we all confident in the knowledge that, whatever she says, Watson doesn't speak for all women? If so, then why the heck are we still discussing this? In some peoples' cases, it seems like purely the notion itself that any woman would be uncomfortable with sexual advances is an unacceptable insult.

Because Ms. Watson gave EG's proposition as an example of an issue for the sceptical community to address. I.e. She's claiming EG exhibited a defect that exists in a sizable minority of the men in the sceptical community, one that will need to be fixed before more women will feel comfortable joining in.

She is both setting herself up as speaking for all women by making it a feminist issue and also insulting a lot of men who are socially awkward around women. Her latest effort is to tell such men to go **** a doll or a sex toy.

What a nice person Ms. Watson is.
 
Last edited:
My point was, should a man EVER ask another woman? However, to your point. I'm not sure how to respond without being rude. You are suggesting that since RW has a problem that all men and women should alter their behavior for her? That is frankly absurd and it's that kind of thinking that really bothers me about all of this. What logic brings you to the point that you would suggest that men and women be celibate for the sake of one woman?

I don't think this is about Watson anymore. I think "should we do Y just because RW thinks X?" is becoming a thought-stopping cliche'. Explanation below.


Wrong question. The right question is, well there are two, A.) Are we so confident in the knowledge that anything she says speaks for all women? More importantly, B.) does she think she speaks for all women? To date I can confidently say that she think she does.

No, it is exactly the right question. There's not a single person in this thread who has indicated they think Watson speaks for all women in anything she says; therefore, your two "right questions" are directed at ghosts and can lead to no discussion at all.


Since many, many women have come forward and have said she doesn't then we can be confident that she doesn't. Why is it that we can't take these women at face value?

Who says we can't? While you're talking about arguing against what people are "really saying rather than what you think they are saying", why don't you tell me who exactly in this thread seems to have a problem taking these women at face value? That's a manufactured controversy.

This is very clearly about more than simply Watson claiming to speak for all women. If that were the only matter being discussed here, all it would've taken is for one woman here to say "she doesn't speak for me". Currently many have done so; so that issue is settled - she doesn't, and further nobody here is disputing that. But more keeps happening, doesn't it? No, it wasn't enough simply to objectively verify that other women don't feel represented by Watson; we've also got to attack the "reasonableness" of her initial complaint in and of itself - discomfort at being propositioned for sex by a stranger. Everything must be done to ridicule this notion - why? Lest a few women also come forward and admit discomfort, thereby shifting the discussion from "just because RW feels that way"? Bookitty indicated she would have felt similar to Watson about such a scenario, and pointedly did not claim to speak for all women; her submissions to the discussion were either ignored or declared irrelevant on account of being "unreasonable". So no, it's not "all about just RW". That's a cop-out and a dodge.

What is it with this terminal need to discredit discomfort with casual sex (and, by extension, requests for it)? Why do we have to portray a request that we recognize and respect that discomfort in some people as an assault on our rights? It's a psychological preference. Does there have to be a "logical reason" behind someone's being introverted as opposed to extroverted? Does our decision to prefer red over green need to be informed by the latest statistical data, or be considered "unreasonable" otherwise? Do we have to pooh-pooh the few left who are partial to simple vanilla ice cream as relics, not to be taken seriously or accommodated?

I cannot believe that we're acting as if giving up a single weekend of trying to score with a stranger when we know there's some people, not "just RW", who would appreciate it if they could spend some time with like-minded people without alienating themselves by having to reject those peoples' sexual advances, is so unreasonable.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom