So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm sure everyone has been waiting with bated breath for my take (yes, I'm being ironic), and I think 73 pages is long enough to wait. So here goes:

1) The guy did show bad judgment, not worthy of scorn, but...
2) Certainly worthy of RW's blog video of the incident. All I got out of it was, "Guys, here's a clue, don't do this." She didn't name him, either. And she's right, thus...
3) Stef and others overreacted to RW's reaction. That said, ...
4) RW didn't need to call out Stef by name. That showed poor judgment, too, but...
5) Not to the degree that people should be raking her over the coals for it. Disagreeing with her choice, even strongly so...well, sure. But gee whiz....

In summary: Pick-up guy shows poor judgment, the object of his affection shows poor judgment, and many of us go a little overboard with it all.
Please comment on RW failing to say, "Guys, don't do that to me", indicating she felt the need to speak for all women.

And do tell us specifically how McGraf "overreacted".

And what about RW saying McGraf was misogynist because she didn't think EG's actions were such a big deal?
 
Which has absolutely zero to do with the complaints being leveled against Camp Rebecca.

Isn't this the thread about Elevatorgate titled »So there was this female speaker on an elevator«? I was commenting on your »Man bites Dog« link that you posted to correct my estimation of elevator assaults based on Laden's LMGTFY search. :confused:
 
Isn't this the thread about Elevatorgate titled »So there was this female speaker on an elevator«? I was commenting on your »Man bites Dog« link that you posted to correct my estimation of elevator assaults based on Laden's LMGTFY search. :confused:
How is a woman erring on the side of caution the reason some guy in a hotel bar at 4am should know better than to ask said woman when they get to the elevator to his room for coffee?

I don't have a fear of hotel elevators. If EG is supposed to use the lowest common denominator to judge when to ask women to his hotel room then by all rights he should never ask any woman ever, because at least some women will be 'uncomfortable' by any come-on.

OTOH, some women might be 'uncomfortable' in the elevator and other women, not so much. How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't?
 
How is a woman erring on the side of caution the reason some guy in a hotel bar at 4am should know better than to ask said woman when they get to the elevator to his room for coffee?

Maybe it's because English is my second language (well, not counting Franconian and computer languages) — but I cannot parse this question. I can however parse and understand within the »bar/elevator/4am hotel room invitation« context the offering of coffee — for all practical purposes the grandaddy of codes for sex.

How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't?

This is one of the questions folks will have to ask and answer for themselves for centuries, I guess. At least until Homo Sapiens develop telepathy. ;)

Rule of thumb: if your action has a chance to make your person of interest uncomfortable, don't act. Wait until a better moment arrives.
 
I didn't find TAA's musings half as brilliant as you, Dani. Read for example about Greg Laden's Google searches for Richard Dawkins about elevator incidents where girls and women are sexually assaulted, molested, attacked. These things happen on a daily basis, and it's advisable for women to err on the side of caution, as blauregen wrote.

Jennifer Ouellette weighed in as well (longer, but worth reading).

And this justifies sexism against men ? Or does it make TAA's opinion worthless ?

There IS sexism towards men in the modern world. Just watch commercials. Men are rarely right when they disagree with women in commercials. That is a symptom of a larger problem, and just the tip of the iceberg.

I'm not in favour of any discrimination.
 
Maybe it's because English is my second language (well, not counting Franconian and computer languages) — but I cannot parse this question. I can however parse and understand within the »bar/elevator/4am hotel room invitation« context the offering of coffee — for all practical purposes the grandaddy of codes for sex.

And ?

Rule of thumb: if your action has a chance to make your person of interest uncomfortable, don't act. Wait until a better moment arrives.

There is ALWAYS a chance your actions will make people uncomfortable. Your advice is unreasonable.
 
There is ALWAYS a chance your actions will make people uncomfortable. Your advice is unreasonable.
Maybe I should clarify, then.

New rule of thumb: in a scenario, where you are alone with a person who could reasonably interpret your approach as a potential threat, don't approach the person. Wait until a better moment arrives, for example in secure, public surroundings with acquaintances of the person in proximity.
 
Maybe I should clarify, then.

New rule of thumb: in a scenario, where you are alone with a person who could reasonably interpret your approach as a potential threat, don't approach the person. Wait until a better moment arrives, for example in secure, public surroundings with acquaintances of the person in proximity.

Many, many more rapists do that than attack women in elevators. Many rapists are very good at putting women at ease and gaining their trust.

There seems to be an underlying assumption that men who are socially awkward are more likely to be rapists than smooth-talkers. Why?

Are ugly men more likely to be rapists than handsome men?
 
New rule of thumb: in a scenario, where you are alone with a person who could reasonably interpret your approach as a potential threat, don't approach the person.

Same objection. I don't know if it makes that person uncomfortable or not. I also don't expect people to be mind-readers when the situation is reversed.

See... I think we've become over-sensitive over the last few decades. We've gone from "hey, who cares ? Toughen up !" to "oh, poor thing ! Did he hurt your feelings ?"

Isn't there something of a middle ground where we neither treat each other like objects or like delicate flowers ?
 
And I'd like to expand on something that was said before:

What if he had been attractive ? Or Brad Pitt ? If it had been Pitt I'm sure Watson would've been flattered. So it's not just the time, or the setting, or the fact she was tired at all. The guy should've known that, no matter _where_ or _when_ he asked he, she would've said no.
 
So, what can we learn from this? Don't hit on Watson in an elevator.



We can learn from this that all women, are different. As are all men.


We can learn from this that some women believe that all women are the same as them. Actually, that's the sexist bit. The "I am a woman so I know how all women feel.", as if women are simple creatures easily worked out. I mean, I wish they were, but they're not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom