So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now I'm curious to ask my 22 yr old son if he's heard of SkepChick or RW. Almost anything I ask him about, he's already seen it online, but we surf on completely different beaches. He's an atheist and he knows about my interest in critical thinking but those are not topics he finds much interest in. He comes across Dawkins' name enough to be familiar with him.


I checked out The Amazing Atheist. Hmmm.... I kind of like this guy.

I picked this one first. The title is "It's Only Sexist When Men Do It":
(WARNING, lots of NSF work or young kids words)

It's no surprise he's video blogged negatively about RW. He did not disappoint.

This one is titled, "Don't take this the wrong way"
His take on RW is "there's this religious girl ..." Wow! He calls her religion 'from the church of radical feminist atheists'.

Brilliant! :D

I laughed with this part from the second video:

RW (inserted in TAA's video): I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable...

TAA: Who gives a ****! Who *********** cares if you are uncomfortable in a *********** elevator for twelve seconds? "Ooooohhhh... this is an awkward ride!". Lord *********** forbid! Lord forbid that there was an awkward tension between you and another human being! Lord knows that's exclusive to girls. Lord knows that there's never been any other situation in the history of mankind where two people shared an awkward moment together.

The only difference now, actually, is that now we spend an awkward moment together and we look for the systemic root of the problem! We're going to solve the problem of awkward moments with strangers in elevators! That's a *********** pandemic!

ETA: min 9:30 approximately.
 
Last edited:
I'm wading into this REALLY late but I've opened a related thread in general skepticism section. After all the furore, I can't help but feel that many self proclaimed skeptics have been.. well... much less than skeptical on this issue. In fact, they've been positivly dogmatic. Without dragging us off topic too much, I'd be grateful if fellow skeptics would take a peek at this;

goo.gl/raSxB

There's a related thread in the other forum; if you'd share your input. I'd be delighted!

Oh, sorry the link isn't hyperlinked - new user and ergo cannot do fancy things like link! Just copy and paste into your browser...
 
Brilliant! :D
I didn't find TAA's musings half as brilliant as you, Dani. Read for example about Greg Laden's Google searches for Richard Dawkins about elevator incidents where girls and women are sexually assaulted, molested, attacked. These things happen on a daily basis, and it's advisable for women to err on the side of caution, as blauregen wrote.

Jennifer Ouellette weighed in as well (longer, but worth reading).
 
I didn't find TAA's musings half as brilliant as you, Dani. Read for example about Greg Laden's Google searches for Richard Dawkins about elevator incidents where girls and women are sexually assaulted, molested, attacked. These things happen on a daily basis, and it's advisable for women to err on the side of caution, as blauregen wrote.

Jennifer Ouellette weighed in as well (longer, but worth reading).
I'm sorry but what does that have to do with TAA's video? Doesn't date rape happen all of the time? Doesn't domestic abuse happen all the time? If women should err on the side of caution shouldn't women avoid men at all costs? What is this line of thinking? Look, RW has every right to her feelings. She also has every right to express her feelings and ask men not to hit on her in elevators and even suggest men not hit on other women. But you are seriously missing the point.

And further how are anecdotes proof that these things happen on a daily basis? Not that it matters but seriously?
 
Last edited:
»Not that it matters,« yeah. A hint: please read the thread topic. I don't know about the exact numbers in the USA, but it's a problem here in Europe, from what I've read.

Using domestic abuse as a red herring and sliding down the slippery slope to the extremely grotesque scenario of »women avoiding men at all costs« isn't helping either.

If you repeat Laden's experiment, those results aren't anecdotes. They are a tiny sample about what happens to women in elevators. Hello again, thread topic.
 
I didn't find TAA's musings half as brilliant as you, Dani. Read for example about Greg Laden's Google searches for Richard Dawkins about elevator incidents where girls and women are sexually assaulted, molested, attacked. These things happen on a daily basis, and it's advisable for women to err on the side of caution, as blauregen wrote.

Jennifer Ouellette weighed in as well (longer, but worth reading).
Ouellette has been thoroughly addressed by me here and in posts before and after.

As for Googling, elevator assaults, you can also Google 'homeopathy works' and get even more hits. The actual data was more closely looked at here: “Hotel Elevator Rape” Is Less Common Than “Man Bites Dog”

I have lost a lot of respect for Greg Laden in this discussion. His comments have been extremely unskeptical.
 
I'm sure everyone has been waiting with bated breath for my take (yes, I'm being ironic), and I think 73 pages is long enough to wait. So here goes:

1) The guy did show bad judgment, not worthy of scorn, but...
2) Certainly worthy of RW's blog video of the incident. All I got out of it was, "Guys, here's a clue, don't do this." She didn't name him, either. And she's right, thus...
3) Stef and others overreacted to RW's reaction. That said, ...
4) RW didn't need to call out Stef by name. That showed poor judgment, too, but...
5) Not to the degree that people should be raking her over the coals for it. Disagreeing with her choice, even strongly so...well, sure. But gee whiz....

In summary: Pick-up guy shows poor judgment, the object of his affection shows poor judgment, and many of us go a little overboard with it all.
 
Read for example about Greg Laden's Google searches for Richard Dawkins

Oh, my sides! The pain!

These things happen on a daily basis are completely imagined on a daily basis, and it's advisable known for women certain women to err on the side of caution freak themselves out for no good reason.

Ftfy.

If you repeat Laden's experiment

Did he hit the ENTER key on the Google search with a pipette?
 
Last edited:
Ouellette has been thoroughly addressed by me here and in posts before and after.

Thank you for pointing me to that thread. Reading through the responses you got, I'll say it saved me a lot of work.

As for Googling, elevator assaults, you can also Google 'homeopathy works' and get even more hits. The actual data was more closely looked at here: “Hotel Elevator Rape” Is Less Common Than “Man Bites Dog”

Good point about »homeopathy works«. I see now that I've grossly overestimated those cases. Still, If I was a woman, I would be sure to err on the side of safety and caution nevertheless.
 
/\/\arko;7403359Using domestic abuse as a red herring and sliding down the slippery slope to the extremely grotesque scenario of »women avoiding men at all costs« isn't helping either.[/quote said:
Thats not an argument. No slippey slope is suggested. Your logic has consequences. You are now special pleading.
 
I would be sure to err on the side of safety and caution nevertheless.
What does this even mean? Avoid elevators? Avoid bars? Avoid leaving bars and riding elevators at 4:00am because someone just might ask you to coffee?

Come on, give us something substabtive?
 
I'm sure everyone has been waiting with bated breath for my take (yes, I'm being ironic), and I think 73 pages is long enough to wait. So here goes:

1) The guy did show bad judgment, not worthy of scorn, but...
2) Certainly worthy of RW's blog video of the incident. All I got out of it was, "Guys, here's a clue, don't do this." She didn't name him, either. And she's right, thus...
3) Stef and others overreacted to RW's reaction. That said, ...
4) RW didn't need to call out Stef by name. That showed poor judgment, too, but...
5) Not to the degree that people should be raking her over the coals for it. Disagreeing with her choice, even strongly so...well, sure. But gee whiz....

In summary: Pick-up guy shows poor judgment, the object of his affection shows poor judgment, and many of us go a little overboard with it all.
Thanks, I value your opinion. Question, if anyone disagrees are they wrong?
 
Come on, give us something substabtive [sic!]?
After reading many sexist comments lately... mace? Tazer? :)

Maybe just taking the elevator (or the stairs) with somebody you know; or saying »no« to a proposition even if the guy seems nice. It's this kind of »better safe than sorry« I meant. Which discourages romance and adventure, I'm sorry to say.
 
Maybe just taking the elevator (or the stairs) with somebody you know; or saying »no« to a proposition even if the guy seems nice. It's this kind of »better safe than sorry« I meant. Which discourages romance and adventure, I'm sorry to say.
Thanks. Good response.
 
After reading many sexist comments lately... mace? Tazer? :)

Maybe just taking the elevator (or the stairs) with somebody you know; or saying »no« to a proposition even if the guy seems nice. It's this kind of »better safe than sorry« I meant. Which discourages romance and adventure, I'm sorry to say.

Sorry, I don't get your point. I see that a few posts ago you disagreed that TAA's videos were brilliant. Fine.

You think that women have every right to be extremely cautious. Granted. What is it exactly that you disagree with?
 
I'm still waiting for someone to explain what exactly in terms of danger has changed from BEFORE EG fired his magical word bullets to AFTER EG fired his magical word bullets.

How exactly did firing magical word bullets change the risk level? This is a rationalists' board, lets hear some rationality
 
What is it exactly that you disagree with?

I'll repeat the first sentence I posted in this thread: »I didn't find TAA's musings half as brilliant as you, Dani.«

I can't find any brilliance in Teroja's polemics (»Who gives a **! Who *** cares if you are uncomfortable in a **** elevator[...]« etc; TJ has his witty moments, but some abysmal ones too, his ASU non-starter comes to my mind).

They also miss the point: it's not the generic awkwardness of the shared silence/muzak most of us may feel — it's that especially creepy situation that emerges from a socially inept man (which I myself pretty much am) hitting on a woman in a confined space.

Who gives a **? Judging from the comments all over, many give a **.
 
I'm still waiting for someone to explain what exactly in terms of danger has changed from BEFORE EG fired his magical word bullets to AFTER EG fired his magical word bullets.

How exactly did firing magical word bullets change the risk level? This is a rationalists' board, lets hear some rationality

Allow me to translate:

What he said: "Do not take this the wrong way"
What he meant: "I have a long history of sexual assault"

What he said: "but I find you very interesting"
What he meant: "I have been following you around since before the conference started"

What he said: "and I would like to talk more."
What he meant: "You want it, and I'll give it to you."

What he said: "Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?"
What he meant: "If you consent to come to my room, the cops won't press charges."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom