So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ms. Watson,

I find you to be a promising candidate for communally imbibing caffeinated beverages and possible subsequent sexual intercourse. If you are interested, please signal your willingness and we shall partake.

- Ken

There. Now can I be known as Forum Guy?
 
Skepticism is a behavior... not a title one "earns" or "loses".
I actually like Claus's wording.... unless you claim to have evidence, whatever.
I have argued with Claus about his definition of "making no claims" and he's wrong. Saying there is a god is a claim. However, there is no true skeptic just as there is no true Scotsman. We all have our blind spots. There is room for theists and deists in the skeptic community. There is room for everyone as long as they understand the principles of the scientific process and an evidence based Universe.

But theists do need to understand, their theism is not consistent with skeptical thinking. Beyond that, more power to them. Like I said, none of us are "true skeptics".
 
Ms. Watson,

I find you to be a promising candidate for communally imbibing caffeinated beverages and possible subsequent sexual intercourse. If you are interested, please signal your willingness and we shall partake.

- Ken

There. Now can I be known as Forum Guy?
Not here. Rebecca got herself banned. :)
 
I have argued with Claus about his definition of "making no claims" and he's wrong. Saying there is a god is a claim. However, there is no true skeptic just as there is no true Scotsman. We all have our blind spots. There is room for theists and deists in the skeptic community. There is room for everyone as long as they understand the principles of the scientific process and an evidence based Universe.

But theists do need to understand, their theism is not consistent with skeptical thinking. Beyond that, more power to them. Like I said, none of us are "true skeptics".
Wow, now I'm beginning to seriously wonder if their is a god. I agree. :)
 
The scientific skepticism movement used to include a lot of liberal theists. Martin Gardner, for one, was a prominent figure. James Randi didn't come out as atheist until this millennium.

True enough, but really it's then "I'm a skeptic, except about this one thing that I irrationally believe in anyway."

When we see UFO followers and Bigfoot fanciers as pure skeptics, then I'll accept theistic skeptics as pure skeptics.

It does getting annoying that even simply wanting not to call yourself an atheist gets aggressively called out. Even if you're a 'strong agnostic'.

Is there a term for someone who sees form to the universe but in no way accepts the existence of a deity? I've been flying under agnostic for awhile, but I in no way countenance the concept of a deity.

That's not a my charist, it's a eucharist.

Youa funnyguy!
 
I have argued with Claus about his definition of "making no claims" and he's wrong. Saying there is a god is a claim. However, there is no true skeptic just as there is no true Scotsman. We all have our blind spots. There is room for theists and deists in the skeptic community. There is room for everyone as long as they understand the principles of the scientific process and an evidence based Universe.

But theists do need to understand, their theism is not consistent with skeptical thinking. Beyond that, more power to them. Like I said, none of us are "true skeptics".

Some woo are bigger than others, however.
 
Evidence?

875187_T.JPG
 
I don't know what you find atypical about my situation - particularly my TAM situation, whatever that even means.

I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.

This is why I chalk up the EG 'incident' to social ineptitude rather than any type of malice.

Honestly, the only way I could've ducked the debates at TAM 5 would have been if I'd lied and said I was an atheist. And I don't think I should have to do that just to enjoy a party.

That's really unfortunate, but not at all surprising to me.

Not here. Rebecca got herself banned. :)

Are you kidding, or did she actually get banned from JREF at one point?
 
Last edited:
many pages back, it was explained that she got banned for phishing for passwords... IIRC which I may not?
 
I just came across this article:

http://icbseverywhere.com/blog/2011/07/on-sexism-objectification-and-power-and-maybe-a-new-era/

This article has been posted on many other blogs as the "go to" support blog of Rebecca, with people just gushing over it.

I think it just further goes to demonstrate the social ineptitude present in the skeptic community.

This line in particular just jumped out at me:

I was amazed that a young woman could hear the story and not find it creepy.

The author then goes on to say that any woman who would not have been creeped out by this incident must just be a naive, ignorant woman who was been fortunate enough to never experience sexism in her life, and thus is incapable of recognizing it.

Look, I don't blame Rebecca for being uncomfortable, because everyone has their own individual comfort zones. I wouldn't have been uncomfortable in that situation, but I don't think you have to be some crazy person to have felt uncomfortable in that situation. I'm not about to say that I'm "amazed" that any woman could possibly feel uncomfortable in a situation that would not have the same effect on me.

I mean, for pete's sakes. I live in a major city. If this was all it took to "creep me out" I would never be able to leave my apartment!

Yet this woman blogger (and her supporters) have the nerve to say that if I have a higher level of tolerance than them for what creeps me out - it must be because I'm so sheltered I don't know any better.

This is really my biggest problem with many women who label themselves as "feminists." They claim that they want women to have greater freedom. But really what they mean is they want women to be free to think like them.
 
Last edited:
You just have to stay away from me in the politics threads. It's a simple matter. :D

How is Arte?
Now you have me at a disadvantage. I'm not sure who Arte is. Sorry. Though to be sure I've not finished my morning coffee and I'm just dense.
 
This is really my biggest problem with many women who label themselves as "feminists." They claim that they want women to have greater freedom. But really what they mean is they want women to be free to think like them.

More specifically, they want women to be required to be as scared as they are.
But let's not miss the point -- the purpose of having women being scared in this sort of situation, is to require men to cater to it.
On another blog, men were decried of being sexist misogynists if they failed to cross to the other side of the street upon seeing a woman coming. Yes, you don't respect women unless you'll perform this simple act of obeisance to them. This was an actual dialog in blog comments.
 
The author then goes on to say that any woman who would not have been creeped out by this incident must just be a naive, ignorant woman who was been fortunate enough to never experience sexism in her life, and thus is incapable of recognizing it.
Yeah, THAT'S critical thinking.

Anyone who doesn't believe in god who has never been fortunate enough to experience god's presence in their life.

It is this nonsense that upsets me the most.

I've not had one person rise to defend RW's ad hominem of Dawkin's when she asserted that his positions was because of white power. Really, RW, how do you falsify that? How is that NOT circular reasoning? How does the premise not presume the conclusion?

I sent her a note. I sent a note to SGU. Crickets.... I've asked on many forums but no one will defend that crap so it just sits. Like a big turd in a punch bowl.
 
I most probably am getting mixed up... it's what I "do".

After checking, I can't find anything that gave me the impression she was banned for the reason I stated, and only seem to recall she left in a huff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom