So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, that's not how it happened, so don't get too upset about it. It's already been linked to up the thread:

I got through 2 pages before realizing I still didn't know what was going on, and had 16 more pages of slog.

Summation, please?
 
Just as a clarification...

I'm confused on the timeline. Did Dawkin's criticism come before or after Steph McGrew's criticism & Rebecca's subsequent public calling out of Steph McGrew?
 
Now you have me at a disadvantage. I'm not sure who Arte is. Sorry. Though to be sure I've not finished my morning coffee and I'm just dense.
Articulate, you said you were staying with her. She also got banned here, you must know that. Her and I were two of the more activist atheists on the forum. I miss her.
 
Articulate, you said you were staying with her. She also got banned here, you must know that. Her and I were two of the more activist atheists on the forum. I miss her.
Yep, I'm dense. :)

She's great. It was really wonderful staying with her. BTW: She is married now to Dr. Adequate. We had some great evenings talking for hours about science and philosophy.
 
Just as a clarification...

I'm confused on the timeline. Did Dawkin's criticism come before or after Steph McGrew's criticism & Rebecca's subsequent public calling out of Steph McGrew?
After. PZ responded to people who reacted to RW's ethics at the CFI conference.

PZ only noticed the complaints were about RW naming McGraf. But the complaints went well beyond naming names. RW complained that merely disagreeing with her view of EG was tantamount to misogyny by women against women. The comments in McGraf's blog reply to RW's first video were nothing close to RW's ludicrous ad hom.


Anyway... RD's comments were posted in PZ's blog. I linked to PZ's blog above and there are a dozen links each in this thread to everything else.
 
I thought someone called me 'honey' once. It turned out that she was just saying, "I'd love to spread some honey on those hot buns." It's an easy mistake to make.
 
I just came across this article:

http://icbseverywhere.com/blog/2011/07/on-sexism-objectification-and-power-and-maybe-a-new-era/

This article has been posted on many other blogs as the "go to" support blog of Rebecca, with people just gushing over it.

I think it just further goes to demonstrate the social ineptitude present in the skeptic community.

This line in particular just jumped out at me:

The author then goes on to say that any woman who would not have been creeped out by this incident must just be a naive, ignorant woman who was been fortunate enough to never experience sexism in her life, and thus is incapable of recognizing it.
Sigh....

Guess I haven't learned a darn thing traveling around the world by myself.


.... I mean, for pete's sakes. I live in a major city. If this was all it took to "creep me out" I would never be able to leave my apartment!

Yet this woman blogger (and her supporters) have the nerve to say that if I have a higher level of tolerance than them for what creeps me out - it must be because I'm so sheltered I don't know any better.

This is really my biggest problem with many women who label themselves as "feminists." They claim that they want women to have greater freedom. But really what they mean is they want women to be free to think like them.
You have put yourself intelligently into camp Linda and Ginger. :D (No sense being misunderstood.)

Informally that is. I wouldn't want to speak for Linda officially. But both of us have expressed our concern that women are perfectly capable of saying no to EG and not fearing an encounter alone with a man in a 5 star hotel elevator at 4am in Dublin.
 
Last edited:
After. PZ responded to people who reacted to RW's ethics at the CFI conference.

PZ only noticed the complaints were about RW naming McGraf. But the complaints went well beyond naming names. RW complained that merely disagreeing with her view of EG was tantamount to misogyny by women against women. The comments in McGraf's blog reply to RW's first video were nothing close to RW's ludicrous ad hom.


Anyway... RD's comments were posted in PZ's blog. I linked to PZ's blog above and there are a dozen links each in this thread to everything else.

Thanks, SG. I had read PZ's blog before, but I just couldn't remember the order of events.

So which incident was it that actually made the blogosphere erupt? Was it Steph's blog, or Rebecca's response to Steph's blog, or Dawkin's response to Rebecca?

I ignored this whole debacle initially and didn't know anything about it until curiosity finally got the better of me after seeing how much of a hoopla this had turned into, so I don't really know exactly when the powder keg went off.

Oh, but SG, please don't put me into any kind of "camp." In this heat, the only camp I want to be attending is Camp Frozen Strawberry Daquiri.
 
Last edited:
Watson was phishing for passwords? According to whom?
I don't know the details except she was mistakenly given access to the super secret mod forum and mod controls and she did bad things with her inadvertently acquired forum powers.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, SG. I had read PZ's blog before, but I just couldn't remember the order of events.

So which incident was it that actually made the blogosphere erupt? Was it Steph's blog, or Rebecca's response to Steph's blog, or Dawkin's response to Rebecca?

I ignored this whole debacle initially and didn't know anything about it until curiosity finally got the better of me after seeing how much of a hoopla this had turned into, so I don't really know exactly when the powder keg went off.

From what I've been able to tell, there was very little response to Steph's blog until after what Rebecca said about it, shortly thereafter PZ picked up on it, and then once Dawkins made himself an easy target with his response to PZ that the excitement impacted the rotating air blades.
 
....

Oh, but SG, please don't put me into any kind of "camp." In this heat, the only camp I want to be attending is Camp Frozen Strawberry Daquiri.
It was only a figure of speech. The point is you recognize it is possible to not be quite as weak and vulnerable as has been implied women must be. It has bothered me considerably that this point is really such a difficult concept for so many people in this discussion.
 
A point I wish to repeat that I have made in a couple different threads:
As a woman who has been addicted to exploring the world since I was about 12 years old, I've found myself in a handful of very dangerous places. I can probably count them on 2 hands. It happens. Especially when you are naive until you've experienced that particular mistake, then you know not to do that again.

But by far the vast majority of the places I've been, including ones people warned me about, which people tend to do a lot, never turned out to be dangerous. People are normal everywhere you go. They have families, they go to jobs, they aren't looking to rob and rape you around every corner. Crime occurs, yes, as do assaults. But these things are not the overwhelming natural state of things everywhere (with a few exceptions that evolve and devolve mostly around the political situation in certain locations)....

... My take on a liberated woman: When you are past being bothered by ignorant men, when you pay no attention to the occasional jerk, when you pay no mind whatsoever to a drunk in a hotel elevator at 4 am, you are on your way to being a liberated woman. When what you want and what you do are not inhibited or limited by these sexists, when you do what you want to do, go where you want to go, be who you want to be and men who would get in your way are no more than dust you flick off your shoulder, you are there.
 
More specifically, they want women to be required to be as scared as they are.
But let's not miss the point -- the purpose of having women being scared in this sort of situation, is to require men to cater to it.
On another blog, men were decried of being sexist misogynists if they failed to cross to the other side of the street upon seeing a woman coming. Yes, you don't respect women unless you'll perform this simple act of obeisance to them. This was an actual dialog in blog comments.

There's a comedian here who's pretty big in Boston, can't remember his name, but I remember this from one of his acts.

He says that he absolutely hates winter, because he is already a huge black men, but once he puts on his big puffy coat and ski hat, people just react with abject terror in his presence, and he has actually been criticized for walking "too close" to people and "scaring them."

He was like "White people, please, believe me. I'm not trying to rob and murder you. I'm just cold."
 
I just came across this article:

http://icbseverywhere.com/blog/2011/07/on-sexism-objectification-and-power-and-maybe-a-new-era/

This article has been posted on many other blogs as the "go to" support blog of Rebecca, with people just gushing over it.

I think it just further goes to demonstrate the social ineptitude present in the skeptic community....
This is close to what I posted above with some editing, but I posted this comment in the ICBS Blog:
As a woman who has been addicted to exploring the world since I was about 12 years old, I've found myself in a handful of very dangerous places. I can probably count them on 2 hands. It happens. Especially when you are naive until you've experienced that particular mistake, then you know not to do that again.

But by far the vast majority of the places I've been, including ones people warned me about, which people tend to do a lot, never turned out to be dangerous. People are normal everywhere you go. They have families, they go to jobs, they aren't looking to rob and rape you around every corner. Crime occurs, yes, as do assaults. But these things are not the overwhelming natural state of things in most of the world.

My take on a liberated woman: When you are past being bothered by ignorant men, when you pay no attention to the occasional jerk, when you pay no mind whatsoever to a drunk in a hotel elevator at 4 am as long as he doesn't touch you, you are on your way to being a liberated woman. When you do what you want to do, go where you want to go, be who you want to be and sexist men who would get in your way are no more than dust you flick off your shoulder, you are there.


It's no surprise a guy on an elevator in a nice hotel at 4am might "creep you out". But if you are so bothered by such a minor encounter you feel the need to publicly ask "guys, don't do that", it's time to reconsider just where you are placing your locus of control.
We'll see what kind of reply it gets after it's been posted. It's awaiting moderation but it looks like "admin" is actively posting right now and should see it soon.
 
To add to the 'honey' line of conversation, I absolutely despise being called a 'lady'. Like (to the bartender) "Get the lady a drink," or "You don't treat a lady like that."

I want to smack anyone who says that in the mouth and be all "Get back to your D&D game."

But that's just me. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom