So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's just go with 'personal reasons'.

Ok, I understand from what little I've read on this forum that your situation is not typical, to say the least. How about your experience at TAM5; can you say what the problems were there?
 
I may as well make this my very first post on JREF, though I've been lurking for a very long time. When I'm out in public, I make a very quick mental note of all men and women wearing flip-flops because I know I won't be able to rely on those people if an emergency were to occur.

I wear hiking shoes everywhere that does not require dress shoes. I do this because it is extremely practical. I do this because if something were to go down (whatever that may be), I'm in a position to be able to move from point A to point B in a quick, efficient manner, while avoiding unnecessary injury to my feet.

I can't speak for all men (see what I did there), but the men I know make this risk assessment all the time. I wouldn't wear flip-flops to go to the bar at 11pm because I think that would be an irrational thing to do.

That Watson is thinking along these same lines is a good thing, I think. That she is equating it to feminism is completely asinine.

And... welcome to the JREF!
 
There's a gender imbalance in the publishing market, both for genres like science fiction and for what is considered "serious", "literary" fiction. This isn't just because there are fewer women writing literature (is this even true?). The reason is that women writing excellent literature are less likely to be acclaimed, or even published, than their male counterparts. So when people pledge to read 50% women writers, they aren't settling for less quality in favor of social justice -- they are simply seeking out great works that have been overshadowed for social reasons.

The confounding factor for TAM is the nature of the "credentials" being asked. Obviously, those credentials go beyond being an excellent professional and speaker. They also involve how prominent those speakers are in the skeptical community -- and one of the reasons for their prominence is that they are mostly white and male. Dawkins, for example, may be a great skeptic, but a black woman in his position might not have risen to fame like he did.

So the question here is whether TAM wants to make an effort to subvert these power structures, to rise up to the task of seeking out unknown but talented people, or if it wants to reflect society as it is. I don't think anyone is suggesting that the quality of the speakers be compromised. I can only speak for myself here, but what I'd like to see is an attempt to find equal or better talent that has been kept hidden for reasons other than their competence.

Sounds like someone can't get her book published/diatribe read, and has come to the conclusion that it's down to the all powerful patriarchy keeping her down.
 
It was a woman who made it, actually. You sexist pig. :D

I apologize for my informal use of language. The female who made the video has won the internet.

Who knows a good informal, gender neutral term for describing someone? 'Person' is so dry.
 
You think "guy" is a male-only term? You sexist pig. :D

Zing! :)

This does kind of bring up something else I've been thinking about. I've found myself on numerous occasions being taken aback when I find out the poster I've been following is not the gender I thought they were. It's kind of like seeing a person for the first time only after ever hearing his/her voice.

I can't say if that 'means' anything, but I do think it points out that we are all 'hard-wired' with certain cognitive biases and are usually genuinely surprised when those biases are contradicted.

I've seen innumerable topics brought up during this discussion. Game Theory, Theory of Mind, Meta Cognition, Statistical Analysis, Numerous Cognitive Biases, Mating Behaviors, Evolutionary Psychology, Logical Fallacies, Gender Socialization, ad infinitum...

I guess that's why this is all so very interesting to me. The whole 'elevator incident' is basically a series of escalating events where the chance for missteps and misunderstanding is escalated at each step, which many of the factors listed above in constant rotation.

That's what makes me so frustrated about blanket statements of 'sexism.' It ignores everything else, every other possibility or combination there-of for a simple, dogmatic invective.

It seems to me that when so much should be considered, it heightens the need for a skeptical view of things. Sure, one point can be over analyzed to the point of absurdity. But, then again, I can see actual, real utility in discussing in detail whether or not 'coffee in my room' actually means 'coffee' or 'sex'. I can understand why others get frustrated at this point, however.

I also think that to infer 'sex' out of 'coffee' is a rather dangerous and presumptuous thing to do when lacking all other evidence. I appreciate people who can see it both ways. The point was brought up before, men do this to other men all.the.time. That very statement was a complete 'ah-ha' moment for me, because it's so benign. I've done it to other men. Other men have done it to me. Like it was said, even the "don't take this the wrong way" genuflection has been included, for the very same reason.

"Don't take this the wrong way. I'm not gay. I don't want to have sex with you."

Light bulb moment for me.

I really do believe that many men who are empathizing with 'elevator guy' are taking this point of view. They see it as equality in action, but they are being told that because one of the people involved was a woman, it was not equality.

It's all very confusing.

And, yes. I get the point. One should do their best to not make anyone uncomfortable (regardless of gender) when possible. That's a conscious decision, however. I have no control over my gender and very little control over how I look. I fail to understand why I should modify my behavior simply based on those factors.

If a woman is uncomfortable of being alone with me on an elevator (regardless of reasons), that's her problem. (I'm addressing the Phil Pliat, 'potential sexual assault, here) I will have increasing levels of empathy for that other person based other circumstances; but with no other predicating factors other than gender? Sorry. That's your bag.

I do not fall into the false dichotomy of "I don't think it's unreasonable to proposition or ask a woman over for coffee in an elevator at 4am, given the context and circumstances" equating to "I believe men have the right to approach women for sex anytime, anywhere, under any circumstances."

How can you fight an accusation like that? More importantly, how do skeptical people think that they can publicly get away with that type of reasoning?

Anyway, I'm rambling.
 
Zing! :)

This does kind of bring up something else I've been thinking about. I've found myself on numerous occasions being taken aback when I find out the poster I've been following is not the gender I thought they were. It's kind of like seeing a person for the first time only after ever hearing his/her voice.

I can't say if that 'means' anything, but I do think it points out that we are all 'hard-wired' with certain cognitive biases and are usually genuinely surprised when those biases are contradicted.

I've seen innumerable topics brought up during this discussion. Game Theory, Theory of Mind, Meta Cognition, Statistical Analysis, Numerous Cognitive Biases, Mating Behaviors, Evolutionary Psychology, Logical Fallacies, Gender Socialization, ad infinitum...

I guess that's why this is all so very interesting to me. The whole 'elevator incident' is basically a series of escalating events where the chance for missteps and misunderstanding is escalated at each step, which many of the factors listed above in constant rotation.

That's what makes me so frustrated about blanket statements of 'sexism.' It ignores everything else, every other possibility or combination there-of for a simple, dogmatic invective.

It seems to me that when so much should be considered, it heightens the need for a skeptical view of things. Sure, one point can be over analyzed to the point of absurdity. But, then again, I can see actual, real utility in discussing in detail whether or not 'coffee in my room' actually means 'coffee' or 'sex'. I can understand why others get frustrated at this point, however.

I also think that to infer 'sex' out of 'coffee' is a rather dangerous and presumptuous thing to do when lacking all other evidence. I appreciate people who can see it both ways. The point was brought up before, men do this to other men all.the.time. That very statement was a complete 'ah-ha' moment for me, because it's so benign. I've done it to other men. Other men have done it to me. Like it was said, even the "don't take this the wrong way" genuflection has been included, for the very same reason.

"Don't take this the wrong way. I'm not gay. I don't want to have sex with you."

Light bulb moment for me.

I really do believe that many men who are empathizing with 'elevator guy' are taking this point of view. They see it as equality in action, but they are being told that because one of the people involved was a woman, it was not equality.

It's all very confusing.

And, yes. I get the point. One should do their best to not make anyone uncomfortable (regardless of gender) when possible. That's a conscious decision, however. I have no control over my gender and very little control over how I look. I fail to understand why I should modify my behavior simply based on those factors.

If a woman is uncomfortable of being alone with me on an elevator (regardless of reasons), that's her problem. (I'm addressing the Phil Pliat, 'potential sexual assault, here) I will have increasing levels of empathy for that other person based other circumstances; but with no other predicating factors other than gender? Sorry. That's your bag.

I do not fall into the false dichotomy of "I don't think it's unreasonable to proposition or ask a woman over for coffee in an elevator at 4am, given the context and circumstances" equating to "I believe men have the right to approach women for sex anytime, anywhere, under any circumstances."

How can you fight an accusation like that? More importantly, how do skeptical people think that they can publicly get away with that type of reasoning?

Anyway, I'm rambling.

It was a nice ramble :)

Welcome to the JREF forums!

p.s. what I meant to say was, I think you have a lot of really good points.
 
Ok, I understand from what little I've read on this forum that your situation is not typical, to say the least. How about your experience at TAM5; can you say what the problems were there?

I don't know what you find atypical about my situation - particularly my TAM situation, whatever that even means.

I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.

This is why I chalk up the EG 'incident' to social ineptitude rather than any type of malice.

Honestly, the only way I could've ducked the debates at TAM 5 would have been if I'd lied and said I was an atheist. And I don't think I should have to do that just to enjoy a party.
 
I do not fall into the false dichotomy of "I don't think it's unreasonable to proposition or ask a woman over for coffee in an elevator at 4am, given the context and circumstances" equating to "I believe men have the right to approach women for sex anytime, anywhere, under any circumstances."

How can you fight an accusation like that? More importantly, how do skeptical people think that they can publicly get away with that type of reasoning?

Anyway, I'm rambling.
How I wish more people rambled like that. :)

Good job and welcome to the party.
 
How can you fight an accusation like that? More importantly, how do skeptical people think that they can publicly get away with that type of reasoning?

Answer: a person is a "skeptic" only about certain subjects. For other subjects, they are usually non-skeptics, either because of emotional involvement or some other bias.

We each have our woo.
 
Answer: a person is a "skeptic" only about certain subjects. For other subjects, they are usually non-skeptics, either because of emotional involvement or some other bias.

We each have our woo.

Yep. Among my friends we say: We all chase our own unicorns.

Knowing what they are helps to put them in perspective.
 
I think I use the 'skeptical community', and these forums specifically, as a stand in for an actual social life, which can lead to problems. Now I can see how those with severe social ineptitude doing the same thing for a similar reason.

Sometimes it seems like I come here because I believe people actually read (or listen to) what I have to say. Skepticism, by it's very nature, means people have to pay attention and not dismiss out of hand. This can lead to the, often false, perception that people are listening to what you have to say because they care about you. For people who are so socially poor that in general life people simply don't listen because they are annoyed, dislike, or otherwise just don't care about, this type of 'attention' can be addictive.

Then when this perceived attention becomes something they feel entitled to, even greater problems arise. Some other people have already speculated on miss Watson's psychological attitude, but I'm being just general. The dismissal of their opinions or denial of engagement on the narrow topic they feel entitled to debate happens, they can get very upset.

Cognitively I'm aware that very few people care what I have to say in the skeptical community, or in general life, because of me as a person. They don't care about the person; they care about the argument. Here, it is my arguments drawing attention, care, and consideration. It isn't me. Yet I still find myself checking these forums and posting more when I'm feeling ignored and neglected in general life. Much more in fact. I lurk otherwise because I'm genuinely interested in all these subjects. However, if someone like myself who is well aware consciously of this psychological motivation still falls for it, how much more powerful can the effect be on someone truly socially devoid and less self skeptical? No wonder those people are drawn to groups, like skepticism, which place higher value on externalities than internalities

As disappointed as a lot of this elevator thing, it has led to many interesting side discussions. Plus one can see who is willing to be truly self skeptical, and who is not.

Thanks for this post Tyr. I think it was very insightful. I have long wondered what is it about skepticism that drew such people in, since there's nothing to me that screams "jerks welcome here" about skepticism. But the points you make above really make a lot of sense.

I think one of the other things that makes skepticism unlike other groups I'm involved with, where I don't see this kind of thing, is that its heavily based on internet interaction, with real life interaction like conferences more supplementing the internet community. Meanwhile, most of my other interest groups are mostly based on real life interaction with online activity supplementing the real life activity. The fact that skepticism is heavily based on online activity, which seems to more accessable to the kind of personalities you discuss above, makes it more understandable why such personalities would present themselves in skeptical communities and not, for example, the EDM (electronic dance music) community.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what you find atypical about my situation - particularly my TAM situation, whatever that even means.

I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.

This is why I chalk up the EG 'incident' to social ineptitude rather than any type of malice.

Honestly, the only way I could've ducked the debates at TAM 5 would have been if I'd lied and said I was an atheist. And I don't think I should have to do that just to enjoy a party.
You and a number of other skeptics in our community experience this dilemma. And I'm one of those people that repeats on a regular basis that theism and skepticism are incompatible. I do understand and have empathy for your issue, and FWIW, I truly believe we all have our own skeptic blind spots. Elevatorgate certainly brought that fact to the surface.

Your issue, however, is totally different from the claims that sexism is offending women at our events. I know you weren't saying it was the same. But I still think it needs to be pointed out that the two situations are not analogous.
 
Last edited:

I just listened to this episode and transcribed what I thought were the most interesting parts:

When I first got involved in the skeptic community, I saw it as a kind of safe space. I saw it as a place where people would respond calmly and rationally to issues like this and I assumed that there was just a basic understanding of humanist topics, of feminist topics, but I quickly came to realize that that didn’t exist, unfortunately. So I’ve been going around hoping to educate people a bit on the topic.

When I first got involved I didn’t call myself a feminist. I had an appreciation that feminism was a thing that happened and that it was important but I didn’t really think that I had anything to do with feminism. I didn’t think that feminist thinking was really required in our community because again I thought it was a safe space. So I would make jokes and I would be flirtatious and I didn’t really mind people flirting with me and I thought everything was fine. And then I would get these messages from women who would tell me that they were going to, say, skeptics in the pub events and things like that that were full of men. And they would tell me how uncomfortable they were both with just being in a room full of men, with being constantly hit on, with being touched inappropriately. And at first it didn’t really make sense to me because those things didn’t bother me at the time. But I acknowledged that these women felt that way and that it was having an impact on their own involvement in the skeptical community. But then as the years went on and Skepchick got more popular, The Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe got more popular I was being exposed to more and more of the behaviors these women were complaining about.

At this point in time I’ve come to fully understand, I think, exactly how powerful that is in terms of driving women away from our movement. So it is quite dismaying that it had to come to this but in a way I’m sort of grateful for both the feminists that I’ve been involved with that are also skeptics who have sort of led me along this path and I’m also sort of grateful that I’ve had some negative experiences so that I can better empathize with the women who are being driven away from the movement because I think that going through that has allowed me to sort of change my own behaviors and also to focus more on how we can change, how we can make the community more open and more welcoming to women.
 
To inject more facts into this discussion, I looked up the geder of speakers from last year's TAM (TAM 8). According to the program online (I was not there) there were 33 male speakers and 12 female speakers.

The Friendly Atheist quotes Jeff Wagg at TAM 8 saying that there was only 1 female speaker at TAM 7:
Jeff Wagg of JREF points out that they’ve actively reached out to women. Last year, 8 women were invited to speak at TAM. 2 said yes. 1 of those women had to cancel. It’s not like they’re not trying.
 
Answer: a person is a "skeptic" only about certain subjects. For other subjects, they are usually non-skeptics, either because of emotional involvement or some other bias.

We each have our woo.

Yep. Among my friends we say: We all chase our own unicorns.

Knowing what they are helps to put them in perspective.
If my world view wasn't perfectly valid I'd be inclined to agree with you. There are downsides to being an exception of the Dunning-Kruger effect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom