I don't know what you find atypical about my situation - particularly my TAM situation, whatever that even means.
Well, most other people have not been running TAM for several years, and coming back to attend it again must seem odd, at the least. The circumstances of your leaving, which I know nothing about, could also affect how you view the event. I don't know why you found TAM9 unpleasant, as you don't want to say, but it seems odd to me that you didn't, as far as I know, attend any of the sessions. For me, the main reason I go is the official events, the social side is a very strong second, but would not be sufficient on its own. However, the fact that you live locally would make a big difference to that decision. ETA: So, to say you didn't enjoy it when you didn't actually take part in the main part of the event, seems odd to me. If the social side is where there are potential problems, and you only attend the social side, then you're going to have a slightly distorted view of things.
I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.
Yes, I agree that would get old very quickly. At TAM8 I had a couple of conversations with people who saw atheism as the only logical result of skepticism and therefore anyone who was not an atheist was not a true skeptic. I am an atheist now, although I was brought up as Christian, but I was as skeptical about everything apart from religion as I am now, and pushing atheism at TAM is in my view divisive. Many skeptics seem to have a very distorted view, imagining all Christians to be biblical literalists. Certainly that type of attitude is opposed to reason and science, but it does not apply to all, and probably not most, Christians.
This is why I chalk up the EG 'incident' to social ineptitude rather than any type of malice.
That would be my reading of the situation too, though it doesn't excuse what EG did.
Honestly, the only way I could've ducked the debates at TAM 5 would have been if I'd lied and said I was an atheist. And I don't think I should have to do that just to enjoy a party.
I don't recall anyone asking me at either TAM I've been to, or the London ones, though the general topic did come up.