So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.

I've often considered that if I attended TAM or a similar event, I would have the same problem. I am disappointed to find out that this is true.
 
You could say politely but firmly that you prefer not to debate it at the time.
 
You could say politely but firmly that you prefer not to debate it at the time.

And now, I probably would. It was, however, my first TAM, and I didn't know anyone and didn't know how to handle myself when attacked (and it WAS an attack - not a conversation). Instead, I just went to my room and cried a lot. Though honestly - dunno how we got to this topic.

I think I was pointing out that there are other reasons, besides feminist issues, that women stop coming to TAM.
 
And now, I probably would. It was, however, my first TAM, and I didn't know anyone and didn't know how to handle myself when attacked (and it WAS an attack - not a conversation).

I would be very interested to learn the details of this encounter.
 
I would be very interested to learn the details of this encounter.

My impression was that it was not one encounter, but many. And it is another reason I would not attend. There really should be no room for dogma in skepticism. If a genuinely curious homeopath wants to come to TAM they should feel just as welcome as anyone else. TAM and the JREF should be about education, not just a gathering of those who have figured out some magic password.
 
.. About two minutes into the podcast, she talks about how she has to do "tons of things" to avoid getting rapes, things that men don't have to think about. As an example she said that, when she goes out to bars, depending on how far she has to walk she makes a decision whether to wear high heels or flats, just so that she can run.

I don't suppose that it's ever occurred to her that men, as a general rule, don't wear high heels at all.

Us men are far too busy wearing Nike Air* so as to better chase the women down and rape them.



*Just Do It
 
Last edited:
My impression was that it was not one encounter, but many. And it is another reason I would not attend. There really should be no room for dogma in skepticism. If a genuinely curious homeopath wants to come to TAM they should feel just as welcome as anyone else. TAM and the JREF should be about education, not just a gathering of those who have figured out some magic password.

It was many. Oddly enough, Claus was the person who was really, really nice to me. I didn't have any money at that TAM, and people had volunteered to take me out for meals. Claus took me to dinner and told me he didn't care what I believed in, so long as I didn't claim to have any objective evidence. Then we ate spaghetti.
 
It was many. Oddly enough, Claus was the person who was really, really nice to me. I didn't have any money at that TAM, and people had volunteered to take me out for meals. Claus took me to dinner and told me he didn't care what I believed in, so long as I didn't claim to have any objective evidence. Then we ate spaghetti.

Evidence?
 
I don't know what you find atypical about my situation - particularly my TAM situation, whatever that even means.
Well, most other people have not been running TAM for several years, and coming back to attend it again must seem odd, at the least. The circumstances of your leaving, which I know nothing about, could also affect how you view the event. I don't know why you found TAM9 unpleasant, as you don't want to say, but it seems odd to me that you didn't, as far as I know, attend any of the sessions. For me, the main reason I go is the official events, the social side is a very strong second, but would not be sufficient on its own. However, the fact that you live locally would make a big difference to that decision. ETA: So, to say you didn't enjoy it when you didn't actually take part in the main part of the event, seems odd to me. If the social side is where there are potential problems, and you only attend the social side, then you're going to have a slightly distorted view of things.
I did not enjoy TAM 5 because in every conversation, the assumption was that I was an atheist. When I corrected the people I spoke to about their misconception, they inevitably started in on a lengthy debate, no matter what the setting. Like, I would be at a party and find myself locked in debate mode because some person I was talking to just couldn't take it that I believed something they found irrational.
Yes, I agree that would get old very quickly. At TAM8 I had a couple of conversations with people who saw atheism as the only logical result of skepticism and therefore anyone who was not an atheist was not a true skeptic. I am an atheist now, although I was brought up as Christian, but I was as skeptical about everything apart from religion as I am now, and pushing atheism at TAM is in my view divisive. Many skeptics seem to have a very distorted view, imagining all Christians to be biblical literalists. Certainly that type of attitude is opposed to reason and science, but it does not apply to all, and probably not most, Christians.

This is why I chalk up the EG 'incident' to social ineptitude rather than any type of malice.
That would be my reading of the situation too, though it doesn't excuse what EG did.
Honestly, the only way I could've ducked the debates at TAM 5 would have been if I'd lied and said I was an atheist. And I don't think I should have to do that just to enjoy a party.

I don't recall anyone asking me at either TAM I've been to, or the London ones, though the general topic did come up.
 
Last edited:
It was many. Oddly enough, Claus was the person who was really, really nice to me. I didn't have any money at that TAM, and people had volunteered to take me out for meals. Claus took me to dinner and told me he didn't care what I believed in, so long as I didn't claim to have any objective evidence. Then we ate spaghetti.

You tricked him into taking the Eucharist with you?!?!
 
You tricked him into taking the Eucharist with you?!?!

Was Eucharist harassed too, or is the guy just a freeloader?

I mean it was only pasta, but Claus isn't made of money. Eucharist should buy his own damn food.


On a more serious note...

I agree that theism and skepticism are, by definition, incompatible. However, mild religious beliefs are probably no worse that the blind spots all skeptics seem to have. Be the subject sex, race, gender or politics, I can't think of many posters here that don't have something they are completely irrational and biased about.

This poor gal simply wore an unpopular woo on her sleeve. By all means politely rebut and gently try to educate, but you won't win anyone over by preaching at them. That's kind of reverse atheism ;)
 
Thanks for this post Tyr. I think it was very insightful. I have long wondered what is it about skepticism that drew such people in, since there's nothing to me that screams "jerks welcome here" about skepticism. But the points you make above really make a lot of sense.

I think one of the other things that makes skepticism unlike other groups I'm involved with, where I don't see this kind of thing, is that its heavily based on internet interaction, with real life interaction like conferences more supplementing the internet community. Meanwhile, most of my other interest groups are mostly based on real life interaction with online activity supplementing the real life activity. The fact that skepticism is heavily based on online activity, which seems to more accessable to the kind of personalities you discuss above, makes it more understandable why such personalities would present themselves in skeptical communities and not, for example, the EDM (electronic dance music) community.

That's another good point. The interaction of the 'skeptical community' tends to be exclusively text based, on forums, blogs, and books. These are the sort of media someone who has been forced out of other social interactions tend to gravitate toward. In that regard, it is like some other groups that have higher than average social malcontents, such as hardcore gaming. This would actually be an interesting sociology investigation.

There are so many aspects. For instance, I was actually smiling and pleased that someone reference my post before I even knew what was said regarding it. That's just sad, but also intreging.
 
I also think that to infer 'sex' out of 'coffee' is a rather dangerous and presumptuous thing to do when lacking all other evidence. I appreciate people who can see it both ways. The point was brought up before, men do this to other men all.the.time. That very statement was a complete 'ah-ha' moment for me, because it's so benign. I've done it to other men. Other men have done it to me. Like it was said, even the "don't take this the wrong way" genuflection has been included, for the very same reason.

"Don't take this the wrong way. I'm not gay. I don't want to have sex with you."

Light bulb moment for me.

I was one of the people who pointed it out, but you have done it much better than I did.

I really do believe that many men who are empathizing with 'elevator guy' are taking this point of view. They see it as equality in action, but they are being told that because one of the people involved was a woman, it was not equality.

I don't know that it requires empathy or even sympathy. I think it's sufficient to look at the consequences. Late night discussions are how things get done at conferences, simply because everyone is so busy during the day they can't talk one-on-one, and when you're in a big hotel, the space you have is your room. Like you, this has happened to me many times (with men), and I've done it (with men). It's a way to get business and academic contacts which just aren't possible during the hierarchical conference day. If women don't want to do it, fine. Just say "no." When it gets sexist starts when a woman is trying to modify male behavior so that other women never have those opportunities.

Here's a story. I'm not saying that this is what actually happened, but it is at least as plausible as Watson's interpretation, or Plait's.

EG sees Watson give a talk. He finds it notable, and he wants to discuss it further. Maybe time ran out before he could say anything during the QA period and couldn't get through on the breakout session (if there was one). So he goes to the bar later and finds Watson surrounded by her entourage. He waits for an opportunity until 4 AM but doesn't get one. When she says she's tired and wants to go to bed (which does not mean much, as that's what everyone says, because it's rude to say "I'm tired of you people who are boring me"), he sees a last opportunity and goes for broke. She's already on the elevator, so he can't get a word in the hall. He thinks (quite correctly) that leaving the elevator on her floor would be creepy, so he talks to her on the elevator. The rest is history, and now he's many people's idea of a creep.
 
I agree that theism and skepticism are, by definition, incompatible.

The scientific skepticism movement used to include a lot of liberal theists. Martin Gardner, for one, was a prominent figure. James Randi didn't come out as atheist until this millennium.
 
Skepticism is a behavior... not a title one "earns" or "loses".
I actually like Claus's wording.... unless you claim to have evidence, whatever.
 
I was one of the people who pointed it out, but you have done it much better than I did.

Many thanks, Epepke. And, many apologies for not giving you attribution. I typed that up rather quickly during a break at...wait for it...a conference. :)

I have nothing to gain by this, so I hope it's taken in the spirit in which it's meant (how's that for genuflection), but your take on all of this has been more well-measured, evenly-keeled and well thought out than the vast majority of what I've been seeing elsewhere. Like I stated in my previous post, this absolutely fascinates me for all the reasons I stated. There is so much going on here that is deserving of calm, deep discussion.

I'm seeing that here with you, Skeptic Ginger and Randfan (among others whom I cannot remember). That's refreshing.

There are a few blogs out there that I also quite enjoy (ERV, Heathen-Hub, etc...), but this is by far the best discussion I've seen on the matter.
 
Uh, I'm not a Christian. All I said was that I am NOT an atheist.

It does getting annoying that even simply wanting not to call yourself an atheist gets aggressively called out. Even if you're a 'strong agnostic'.
 
Many thanks, Epepke. And, many apologies for not giving you attribution. I typed that up rather quickly during a break at...wait for it...a conference. :)

I have nothing to gain by this, so I hope it's taken in the spirit in which it's meant (how's that for genuflection), but your take on all of this has been more well-measured, evenly-keeled and well thought out than the vast majority of what I've been seeing elsewhere. Like I stated in my previous post, this absolutely fascinates me for all the reasons I stated. There is so much going on here that is deserving of calm, deep discussion.

And I was trying so hard to be obnoxious! Oh well.

There are a few blogs out there that I also quite enjoy (ERV, Heathen-Hub, etc...), but this is by far the best discussion I've seen on the matter.

Gurdur's blog on Heathen-Hub helped me a lot. It's a good summary of how complex the bruhaha has become. I've been participating in the one on rationalskepticism.org, and it isn't bad either, although I keep forgetting which is which. For example, there someone did research on actual reported rapes in elevators, finding somewhere between 2 and 4 (depending on your definitions) in the US over the past 30 years or so. None of them were anything like the Watson story. But I couldn't remember if that was here or there for a while.

In both cases, I think that there has been a progression from rather naive statements to more integrative ones, which is good. I do like this forum. Though it certainly isn't free of nutters, nor of histrionics, the culture seems to be that threads eventually settle down.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom