So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I must once again express my surprise that women are that fragile. None of the women in my life are that timid, fragile or nervous.

If I have to consciously treat women differently, specifically as if they are likely to have a heart attack at the most innocuous situation, if I have to constantly consider how 'vulnerable' a woman might feel in the most every-day situations, then, I'm afraid you're going to have to mark me down as misogynist, prejudiced, sexist, pig, because I really, really can't be that bloody condescending to anyone, regardless of gender and I really can't be bothered to worry about the delicate flower of womanhood who is so offended to be treated like I treat every other human being in the world that I have to make special note of her gender before I address her.

If it's alright with you, ladies, I'll just go on treating you like people and risk being called a sexist pig.
 
Look, I don't blame Rebecca for being uncomfortable, because everyone has their own individual comfort zones. I wouldn't have been uncomfortable in that situation, but I don't think you have to be some crazy person to have felt uncomfortable in that situation. I'm about to say that I'm "amazed" that any woman could possibly feel uncomfortable in a situation that would not have the same effect on me.

I mean, for pete's sakes. I live in a major city. If this was all it took to "creep me out" I would never be able to live my apartment!

There is something that should have occurred to me long ago. What are the social mores in Dublin? She mentioned being in a "foreign country." When I'm traveling, I have to keep in mind that mores differ, and when in Rome, well, some Italian guy is probably going to whistle at every woman he sees.

Around here (Central Florida), it's fairly common for total strangers to call each other "sweetheart" and "honey." Go 150 miles South, to Palm Beach, and it's nearly universal. Go another 60 miles South, and it's rare.

In England, sexual socialization has different rules, some of which I find a lot tougher, but I can walk up to a woman and say "Excuse me, love, but do you know how to get to such-and-such a place?" with no fear of giving offense. I wouldn't try that in New York City.

In one South American country (I think Venezuela), it's considered mandatory for men to talk to women strangers on lifts. There are a whole variety of over-the-top things that men are supposed to say, such as "blessed was the womb that gave you birth." My high-school Spanish teacher hosted someone from that country who was absolutely flipped out. She was checking her clothing and hair constantly, thinking that she had done something wrong, because she wasn't getting the interaction she was used to.

I have never been to Ireland, but from what I've seen of Irish over here, men are pretty boisterous and crude (to my mind), but so are the women, right back at them.

What is creepy does not only vary from individual to individual, but from culture to culture.
 
I most probably am getting mixed up... it's what I "do".

After checking, I can't find anything that gave me the impression she was banned for the reason I stated, and only seem to recall she left in a huff.

That was becomingadodo I think

I think Rebecca had a sock she used for a joke thread and got suspended. When returning she had mod privileges and used it for a joke (posting screen caps of a restricted area iirc)
 
There is something that should have occurred to me long ago. What are the social mores in Dublin? She mentioned being in a "foreign country." When I'm traveling, I have to keep in mind that mores differ, and when in Rome, well, some Italian guy is probably going to whistle at every woman he sees.

Around here (Central Florida), it's fairly common for total strangers to call each other "sweetheart" and "honey." Go 150 miles South, to Palm Beach, and it's nearly universal. Go another 60 miles South, and it's rare.

I get Darlin, a lot, though I have gotten honey. It's also very common, around here, to just stop and talk or wave to complete strangers. Coming from Long Island, it was a bit weird, at first, because people pretty much, keep to themselves, up North. It was mildly unnerving, at first, but I am used to it now.
BTW, I didn't realize you were Central Florida, me too, well coastal Central. I would say we should get together sometime, but the coffee is terrible! :D
 
There is something that should have occurred to me long ago. What are the social mores in Dublin? She mentioned being in a "foreign country." When I'm traveling, I have to keep in mind that mores differ, and when in Rome, well, some Italian guy is probably going to whistle at every woman he sees.

Around here (Central Florida), it's fairly common for total strangers to call each other "sweetheart" and "honey." Go 150 miles South, to Palm Beach, and it's nearly universal. Go another 60 miles South, and it's rare.

In England, sexual socialization has different rules, some of which I find a lot tougher, but I can walk up to a woman and say "Excuse me, love, but do you know how to get to such-and-such a place?" with no fear of giving offense. I wouldn't try that in New York City.

In one South American country (I think Venezuela), it's considered mandatory for men to talk to women strangers on lifts. There are a whole variety of over-the-top things that men are supposed to say, such as "blessed was the womb that gave you birth." My high-school Spanish teacher hosted someone from that country who was absolutely flipped out. She was checking her clothing and hair constantly, thinking that she had done something wrong, because she wasn't getting the interaction she was used to.

I have never been to Ireland, but from what I've seen of Irish over here, men are pretty boisterous and crude (to my mind), but so are the women, right back at them.

What is creepy does not only vary from individual to individual, but from culture to culture.

That would bring up the question of what ethnicity is EG. The conference was in Ireland but EG may not have been from there.

EG asking RW what he did at 4 in the morning is the part that seems suggestive but the actual words he used, according to RWs video, implies to me at least that he may have simply wanted to talk to her. He prefaced it with "Don't take this the wrong way" and then politely asked her to have coffee in his room. There are lots of things we don't have info on and can't know and I'm guessing that some of those things made RW feel creeped out.

ETA: Oops, I forgot to add, I've been called "Honey" on more than one occasion in a restaurant by a stranger (woman) waiting on me. It is just part of the culture in some places.
 
Last edited:
many pages back, it was explained that she got banned for phishing for passwords... IIRC which I may not?

While a mod (or after being de-modded for earlier stuff), she went in to a mod-only area and took a screen shot and posted that showing what she had done. It was all as a joke, and at the time I had assumed she did it with permission, but it turns out she had not. She had previously posted on a friend's account while staying overnight andused a sock, getting into troubl for that.

Given the previous brouhaha when Ed had used mod powers to change a poster's title under the avatar as a joke, it was pretty clear Rebecca was going to get herself suspended or banned for the misuse of her authority/site permissions.
 
Last edited:
BTW, I didn't realize you were Central Florida, me too, well coastal Central. I would say we should get together sometime, but the coffee is terrible! :D

Which coast?

There's some pretty good cider around here.
 
A bigfoot fancier that understands evidence but still entertains the notion, may indeed have something to contribute on another topic. Maybe they're really good at pointing out flaws in MIHOP 9-11 arguments.
 
While a mod (or after being de-modded for earlier stuff), she went in to a mod-only area and took a screen shot and posted that showing what she had done. It was all as a joke, and at the time I had assumed she did it with permission, but it turns out she had not. She had previously posted on a friend's account while staying overnight andused a sock, getting into troubl for that.

Given the previous brouhaha when Ed had used mod powers to change a poster's title under the avatar as a joke, it was pretty clear Rebecca was going to get herself suspended or banned for the misuse of her authority/site permissions.

Yes, I remember that now. And the title in question was something like "Resident Whiner", right? That was awful, and funny. Ah the old days.

*sheds tear*
 
More specifically, they want women to be required to be as scared as they are.

Good point, Avalon.

And what's more, women with this opinion tend to take the position that any woman who would not be scared by what scares them are that way because they are ignorant.

I think the opposite is typically true. That being a wordly woman results in one being less easily scared than someone who is more sheltered, because they have given in a given situation enough times to more accurately judge the likelihood of danger that a given situation represents.

For instance, when I go to my husband's family farm in rural Alabama, I used to get way more unsettled by things (like seeing some dangerous wild animal on the property, or being around a lot of gunfire), than people who live in the area, because they are used to these things and know enough to not be scared by them. Now I've been in most situations enough that they no longer bother me.

Conversely, when his rural family comes to visit us, they get a lot more unsettled by things that don't even phase me - like some mentally ill homeless man accosting them in the street.

Ignorance of a situation is what makes you more likely to be scared by it.
 
Last edited:
And what's more, women with this opinion tend to take the position that any woman who would not be scared by what scares them are that way because they are ignorant.
Which is ad hoc rationalization and ad hominem attack. Why ague rationally in support of your claims when you can rely on fallacy instead?
 
That would bring up the question of what ethnicity is EG. The conference was in Ireland but EG may not have been from there.

EG asking RW what he did at 4 in the morning is the part that seems suggestive but the actual words he used, according to RWs video, implies to me at least that he may have simply wanted to talk to her. He prefaced it with "Don't take this the wrong way" and then politely asked her to have coffee in his room. There are lots of things we don't have info on and can't know and I'm guessing that some of those things made RW feel creeped out.

ETA: Oops, I forgot to add, I've been called "Honey" on more than one occasion in a restaurant by a stranger (woman) waiting on me. It is just part of the culture in some places.

People use the term "hon" or honey" in healthcare a lot (at least, in my expierence in New England). It's just more familiar and endearing. I initially call all the patients I see "Sir" or "Ma'am," but if I know they well I often call them "hon" or "honey," especially if they're scared or upset. It's just something I picked up because it's so common for other healthcare workers to do so. I also call other health care workers "hon" if I know them well, and get called this in turn by patients and colleagues alike.


The thing is, even if it were universally agreed upon that what EG did was wrong, why is sexism the only possible explanation?

What if he had aspergers? What if he was just drunk? What if his mother was an elevator operator and his father was an elevator repairman, and they met on an elevator, and tell the story of their romantic meeting so often that EG was raised to believe elevators are on par with a Parisian cafe in terms of what a romantic setting it is? Okay, that one's less likely. But still, there are other possible explanations than sexism!

As someone pointed out earlier, the same faulty logic applies to thinking that even if what Dawkins said could be universally agreed upon to be wrong, white male privilage could be the only possible explanation for his statement.

Which is ad hoc rationalization and ad hominem attack. Why ague rationally in support of your claims when you can rely on fallacy instead?

Because you're making this argument while claiming to be doing so from a skeptic viewpoint? :D
 
Last edited:
Which coast?

There's some pretty good cider around here.

East coast. Would that be peach cider? I didn't know Fl was known for it's apples...

Damn, it came to me after I hit post: Cider better not be innuendo for sex!
 
I think Rebecca had a sock she used for a joke thread and got suspended. When returning she had mod privileges and used it for a joke (posting screen caps of a restricted area iirc)

Suspended for bad behavior, then returned with Mod powers. Yeah, that was a genius idea.
 
Suspended for bad behavior, then returned with Mod powers. Yeah, that was a genius idea.

Well, that's not how it happened, so don't get too upset about it. It's already been linked to up the thread:

Oddly enough, it was rebecca. :) See here for the full discussion. She also had a sock-puppet that was banned, Radial Tyre.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom