So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am completely with you on this. I had only been to one TAM prior to this one as not-an-employee. I didn't have a good time at that one (TAM 5). I didn't have a good time at any of the ones I'm working, but kind of put it on the fact that I was working (even though that wasn't really the reason), and then had a godawful time at this one. And I'm never going to return. So, between you and me, SC, that's two women lost to TAM for reasons that have nothing to do with feminism.

What was your reason for not enjoying TAM9? I didn't see you at any of the sessions, and your badge hadn't been collected by Saturday morning. Did you only take part in the social side of things?
 
What was your reason for not enjoying TAM9? I didn't see you at any of the sessions, and your badge hadn't been collected by Saturday morning. Did you only take part in the social side of things?

Let's just go with 'personal reasons'.
 
I went to TAM 4 and I gotta say, it was something I will likely never forget. Loved almost every moment of it. OT I know but it had to be said.
 
the way that Watson conducts herself in this regard is extremely anti-skeptical, not to mention anti-rational.

This

and even sadder, the guys at SGU backed her up and engaged in anti skeptical, and especially heinously, anti-rationalism
 
I would be thrilled if Eugenie Scott appeared at every TAM because she's credentialed, topical and awesome. I'd be happy that she appeared because it's nice to have more women speakers.

More of that subtle sexism. I don't care one iota about the hydraulics of a speaker. All men. All women. All transexuals. It don't make me no nevermind.
 
More of that subtle sexism.

Yeah, but I've got a history of that going back to TAM 1 and the first Skepchick telethon - what now are TAM scholarships, so you got me. :)

I don't care one iota about the hydraulics of a speaker. All men. All women. All transexuals. It don't make me no nevermind.

Vive la differance. For me it's about the individual first and foremost, but diversity does play a role in who I want to see make a presentation.

In fact, watch me get sublty racist too. I love when NdG Tyson appears at TAMs because he's awesome. I'm happy because it's nice to have more black speakers.
 
This

and even sadder, the guys at SGU backed her up and engaged in anti skeptical, and especially heinously, anti-rationalism

I listened to that podcast again. It's getting worse. About two minutes into the podcast, she talks about how she has to do "tons of things" to avoid getting rapes, things that men don't have to think about. As an example she said that, when she goes out to bars, depending on how far she has to walk she makes a decision whether to wear high heels or flats, just so that she can run.

I don't suppose that it's ever occurred to her that men, as a general rule, don't wear high heels at all.
 
I listened to that podcast again. It's getting worse. About two minutes into the podcast, she talks about how she has to do "tons of things" to avoid getting rapes, things that men don't have to think about. As an example she said that, when she goes out to bars, depending on how far she has to walk she makes a decision whether to wear high heels or flats, just so that she can run.

I don't suppose that it's ever occurred to her that men, as a general rule, don't wear high heels at all.

If a person is in serious danger often enough that they need to make that sort of risk assessment, why would they ever wear high heels?

"Hmmm. The heels might put me in terrible danger, but they do make me several inches taller."

Who, honestly, would make that kind of risk assessment?
 
There's a gender imbalance in the publishing market, both for genres like science fiction and for what is considered "serious", "literary" fiction. This isn't just because there are fewer women writing literature (is this even true?). The reason is that women writing excellent literature are less likely to be acclaimed, or even published, than their male counterparts. So when people pledge to read 50% women writers, they aren't settling for less quality in favor of social justice -- they are simply seeking out great works that have been overshadowed for social reasons.

The confounding factor for TAM is the nature of the "credentials" being asked. Obviously, those credentials go beyond being an excellent professional and speaker. They also involve how prominent those speakers are in the skeptical community -- and one of the reasons for their prominence is that they are mostly white and male. Dawkins, for example, may be a great skeptic, but a black woman in his position might not have risen to fame like he did.

So the question here is whether TAM wants to make an effort to subvert these power structures, to rise up to the task of seeking out unknown but talented people, or if it wants to reflect society as it is. I don't think anyone is suggesting that the quality of the speakers be compromised. I can only speak for myself here, but what I'd like to see is an attempt to find equal or better talent that has been kept hidden for reasons other than their competence.
 
...

The confounding factor for TAM is the nature of the "credentials" being asked. Obviously, those credentials go beyond being an excellent professional and speaker. They also involve how prominent those speakers are in the skeptical community -- and one of the reasons for their prominence is that they are mostly white and male. Dawkins, for example, may be a great skeptic, but a black woman in his position might not have risen to fame like he did.

...

Good lord, this argument reeks. Not only is it insulting to people who are white and male (such as Dawkins), it is also insulting to women, minorities - anyone who falls outside the category 'white male'. Firstly, Dawkins has authored books because he is excellent at doing so and great in his field. Secondly, many, many of the women who were speakers at TAM have authored books as well. And thirdly, for what reason, in this scenario, was Tyson published?

Did you research any of this at all, or are you just whipping out numbers and ideas at whatever rate you feel like in order to support your argument?

Are you suggesting that the JREF bring in absolute unknowns - people who have never 'done anything' with skepticism - simply because they are of a minority race, or female? Because that is seriously messed up.

The JREF doesn't actually ask for 'credentials' to bring in speakers. They used to ask the attendees who they wanted to see. Should they bring in speakers NO ONE wants to see simply to create the sense of balance you are seeking?
 
If a person is in serious danger often enough that they need to make that sort of risk assessment, why would they ever wear high heels?

"Hmmm. The heels might put me in terrible danger, but they do make me several inches taller."

Who, honestly, would make that kind of risk assessment?

That whole part about her needing to wear flats to run struck me as entirely irrational. Like you said, if she felt she was in real danger she'd get rid of the high heels altogether, which are only designed to make her ass stick out and have men sexualize her in the first place.

She also failed to mention if she actually ever had to run in any situation while going out. I have a strong feeling she's never had to run, but fears that she may have to. I don't mind if women take precaution, but let's not say that all women are always at risk of rape every time they go out, to the point where they must decide whether or not to wear running shoes.

I have a feeling her decision to wear flats has more to do with the amount of walking and sore feet, rather than safety. I'm skeptical of her claims. If women are really that afraid to go out, then that sucks and I'll do what ever I can to make it better for them. I just don't know if that fear is justified.
 
An excellent point. If Clooney had been the one asking Rebecca for coffee, I wonder how it would've developped.

Which brings up something else that might be relevant. Many people often feel familiar with famous people who appear on broadcast media because they have read about, watched and/or listened to them for hour upon hour and believe they know something about that person. That this familiarity is all one-sided (and often based on a highly unrepresentative PR-managed image) is sometimes hard for people to grasp.

Was this relevant in the EG/Watson incident? I have no idea.
 
Good lord, this argument reeks. Not only is it insulting to people who are white and male (such as Dawkins), it is also insulting to women, minorities - anyone who falls outside the category 'white male'. Firstly, Dawkins has authored books because he is excellent at doing so and great in his field. Secondly, many, many of the women who were speakers at TAM have authored books as well. And thirdly, for what reason, in this scenario, was Tyson published?

Did you research any of this at all, or are you just whipping out numbers and ideas at whatever rate you feel like in order to support your argument?

Are you suggesting that the JREF bring in absolute unknowns - people who have never 'done anything' with skepticism - simply because they are of a minority race, or female? Because that is seriously messed up.

The JREF doesn't actually ask for 'credentials' to bring in speakers. They used to ask the attendees who they wanted to see. Should they bring in speakers NO ONE wants to see simply to create the sense of balance you are seeking?

Please refer to the paragraphs you ignored.
 
Please refer to the paragraphs you ignored.

I didn't ignore them. You were all over the place. The remaining paragraphs weren't relevant because they made false assumptions. The only accurate statement you made was "is this even true?", and I'm pretty sure the answer is "No."
 
That whole part about her needing to wear flats to run struck me as entirely irrational. Like you said, if she felt she was in real danger she'd get rid of the high heels altogether, which are only designed to make her ass stick out and have men sexualize her in the first place.

I may as well make this my very first post on JREF, though I've been lurking for a very long time. When I'm out in public, I make a very quick mental note of all men and women wearing flip-flops because I know I won't be able to rely on those people if an emergency were to occur.

I wear hiking shoes everywhere that does not require dress shoes. I do this because it is extremely practical. I do this because if something were to go down (whatever that may be), I'm in a position to be able to move from point A to point B in a quick, efficient manner, while avoiding unnecessary injury to my feet.

I can't speak for all men (see what I did there), but the men I know make this risk assessment all the time. I wouldn't wear flip-flops to go to the bar at 11pm because I think that would be an irrational thing to do.

That Watson is thinking along these same lines is a good thing, I think. That she is equating it to feminism is completely asinine.
 
Hehe. Actually, one of the things that really turns me off about skepticism is that they seem to, for whatever reason, have a lot higher percentage of people who are really socially inept.

<snip>

That's the kind of juvenile pettiness I have seen no where else but in skeptic circles. (again, amongst groups that I personally am involved in, I'm not saying skeptics have a monopoly on this kind of behavior).

It may be a minority, but it still stands out when you're not used to that sort of thing at all.



I've got a lot of interests, and a lot of those interests have big group activities/events. And even if this sort of thing doesn't happen often in skeptic circles, in all the other groups I participate with, this sort of ridiculousness never happens. And if I have to chose between investing myself in group A) socially well adjusted people who don't have members who act like they have never interacted with a live person, and group B) where a small - but noticable - percentage of people act that way, often people who tend to dominate discussions... I'm going spend my money and vacation days on group A.

I'm sorry you've had such negative experiences. I must say that I don't believe I've ever personally experienced anything like that in my years here. Maybe I've just been lucky.


There's a gender imbalance in the publishing market, both for genres like science fiction and for what is considered "serious", "literary" fiction. This isn't just because there are fewer women writing literature (is this even true?). The reason is that women writing excellent literature are less likely to be acclaimed, or even published, than their male counterparts. So when people pledge to read 50% women writers, they aren't settling for less quality in favor of social justice -- they are simply seeking out great works that have been overshadowed for social reasons.

The confounding factor for TAM is the nature of the "credentials" being asked. Obviously, those credentials go beyond being an excellent professional and speaker. They also involve how prominent those speakers are in the skeptical community -- and one of the reasons for their prominence is that they are mostly white and male. Dawkins, for example, may be a great skeptic, but a black woman in his position might not have risen to fame like he did.

So the question here is whether TAM wants to make an effort to subvert these power structures, to rise up to the task of seeking out unknown but talented people, or if it wants to reflect society as it is. I don't think anyone is suggesting that the quality of the speakers be compromised. I can only speak for myself here, but what I'd like to see is an attempt to find equal or better talent that has been kept hidden for reasons other than their competence.

I think we need to address the question of whether any of the assertions you made in your first 2 paragraphs are actually true, before we even consider paragraph 3.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom